Citation Nr: 1000565 Decision Date: 01/05/10 Archive Date: 01/15/10 DOCKET NO. 00-22 502A ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in North Little Rock, Arkansas THE ISSUES 1. Entitlement to service connection for depression, to include as due to service-connected disorders. 2. Entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Amber Morgan, Esq. ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD M. Katz, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from March 1982 to September 1983. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from an April 2000 rating decision by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office in North Little Rock, Arkansas (RO) and Board remand. By a November 3, 2005 decision, the Board denied the Veteran's claims to reopen the issue of entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur and for entitlement to service connection for depression. The Veteran appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). Based on an October 2007 Memorandum Decision, the Court vacated and remanded this appeal for further development. The issue of entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur is addressed in the remand portion of the decision below, and is remanded to the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in North Little Rock, Arkansas. FINDING OF FACT The evidence of record demonstrates that depression is related to active duty service. CONCLUSION OF LAW Depression was incurred in or aggravated by active military service. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1131, 5103A, 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 3.303 (2008). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION VA has certain notice and assistance requirements. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5100, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5106, 5107, 5126 (West 2002 & Supp. 2007); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326 (2008). Without deciding whether the notice and development requirements have been satisfied in the present case, the Board is not precluded from adjudicating the issue of entitlement to service connection for depression. This is so because the Board is taking action favorable to the Veteran by granting this claim. As such, this decision poses no risk of prejudice to the Veteran. See, e.g., Bernard v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 384 (1993); see also Pelegrini v. Principi, 17 Vet. App. 412 (2004); VAOPGCPREC 16-92, 57 Fed. Reg. 49,747 (1992). Service connection may be granted for disability due to a disease or injury which was incurred in or aggravated by active service. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1131; 38 C.F.R. § 3.303. In addition, service connection may be granted for any disease diagnosed after discharge, when all the evidence, including that pertinent to service, establishes that the disease was incurred in service. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(d). In order to establish service connection for a claimed disorder, the following must be shown: (1) medical evidence of a current disability; (2) medical, or in certain circumstances, lay evidence of in-service incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury; and (3) medical evidence of a nexus between the claimed in-service disease or injury and the current disability. Hickson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 247, 253 (1999); see also Pond v. West, 12 Vet App. 341, 346 (1999). Service connection may be established on a secondary basis for a disability which is shown to be proximately due to or the result of a service connected disease or injury. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(a) (2008). Establishing service connection on a secondary basis requires evidence sufficient to show (1) that a current disability exists and (2) that the current disability was either (a) caused by or (b) aggravated by a service-connected disability. Id.; Allen v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 439 (1995) (en banc) (additional disability resulting from aggravation of a nonservice-connected disorder by a service-connected disorder is also compensable under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310). The determination as to whether these requirements are met is based on an analysis of all the evidence of record and the evaluation of its credibility and probative value. See Baldwin v. West, 13 Vet. App. 1, 8 (1999). The Veteran is seeking service connection for depression, also claimed as secondary to his service-connected tinnitus and left ear hearing loss. In numerous statements the Veteran reported that his depressive symptoms began during service. He also alleged that his depression was the result of his service-connected tinnitus or left ear hearing loss. By a July 1999 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for tinnitus and granted a 10 percent evaluation, effective January 5, 1999. By that same rating decision, the RO granted service connection for left ear hearing loss and granted a noncompensable evaluation, effective January 5, 1999. The Veteran's service treatment records reveal one complaint of depression during service. A February 1982 examination report reveals that the Veteran's psychiatric status was normal. In a report of medical history, completed at that time, the Veteran denied a history of frequent trouble sleeping, depression or excessive worry, loss of memory or amnesia, and nervous trouble of any sort. The Veteran was enrolled in alcohol rehabilitation in June 1983. An undated report of mental status evaluation reveals that the Veteran's behavior was normal, he was fully alert and fully oriented, his mood or affect was unremarkable, his thinking process was clear, his thought content was normal, and his memory was good. The physician reported that the Veteran had the mental capacity to understand and participate in proceedings, was mentally responsible, and met the retention requirements of Chapter 3. An August 1983 Chapter examination noted the Veteran's psychiatric status to be normal. However, in a report of medical history, completed at that time, the Veteran reported frequent trouble sleeping, depression and excessive worry, and loss or memory or amnesia. An undated service personnel record reflects that the Veteran received a court martial for having been absent without leave and for disobeying an order. The Veteran spoke about discharge instead of rehabilitation, noting that rehabilitation had previously failed. The record reveals that the Veteran had a history of poor performance and lacking motivation, and that he could not recover and become a functional soldier. The record concluded that "chapter action" would be initiated immediately. Social Security Administration records reflect that the Veteran was found to be disabled on the basis of organic mental disorders, affective disorders, and substance addiction disorders. VA treatment records from August 2000 through October 2008 reveal complaints of and treatment for various psychiatric disorders, including depression. The treatment records also reveal that the Veteran attended group therapy and participated in a homeless veteran program, substance abuse rehabilitation, and vocational rehabilitation. An August 2000 treatment record notes the Veteran's complaints of substance abuse and depression or mania. Other August 2000 records reveals diagnoses of depression, major depression, alcohol abuse, cocaine abuse, and nicotine dependence. A September 2000 treatment record indicates a history of major depressive disorder. From September 2000 through October 2000, the Veteran was admitted to a domiciliary with diagnoses of major depressive disorder, poly-substance abuse, and chronic right thigh pain. From October 2000 through November 2000, the Veteran participated in substance abuse rehabilitation, and maintained diagnoses of alcohol dependence and cocaine dependence. The Veteran participated in a domiciliary rehabilitation program from November 2000 through March 2001. Treatment records reflect diagnoses of major depressive disorder, cocaine dependence, alcohol dependence, and nicotine dependence. A December 2000 treatment record notes the Veteran's complaints of auditory and visual hallucinations and paranoia. The diagnoses were dysthymic disorder, schizotypal personality disorder, cocaine dependence, and alcohol dependence. In January 2001, the Veteran reported a history of depression, personality disorder, substance abuse, and homelessness. Another January 2001 treatment record reflects that a depression screen was positive. The diagnoses were major depressive disorder, cocaine dependence, alcohol dependence, and nicotine dependence. In February 2001, the Veteran reported a history of substance abuse since the age of 15. A March 2001 depression screen was positive, and the diagnoses were major depressive disorder, cocaine dependence, alcohol dependence, and nicotine dependence. The Veteran participated in a Transitional Residence Program from March 2001 through July 2001. Treatment records note diagnoses of manic depressive disorder, cocaine dependence, and alcohol dependence. A January 2002 treatment record notes a diagnosis of depression, and a depression screen was positive. Another January 2002 treatment record reflects the Veteran's complaints of depression, fleeting suicidal thoughts, anxiety, poor sleep, nightmares, low self esteem, poor concentration, limited energy, helplessness and hopelessness, visual hallucinations, and paranoia. The diagnoses were substance induced mood disorder, cocaine abuse, and alcohol dependence. A February 2002 treatment record reveals the Veteran's complaints of difficulty sleeping and some paranoid feelings. The diagnosis was depression not otherwise specified. Another February 2002 treatment record notes the Veteran's complaints of low self esteem, mood swings, negative thinking, depression, a history of suicide attempts, and a history of alcohol and substance abuse. The diagnosis was depression, not otherwise specified. In November 2002, the Veteran complained of homelessness, unemployment, substance abuse, and depression. A February 2004 treatment record reflects a diagnosis of depression and a history of bipolar disorder. A March 2006 treatment record reflects diagnoses of cocaine dependence, alcohol dependence, nicotine dependence, cannabis dependence, substance-induced mood disorder, and rule out adjustment disorder. Treatment records from 2007 reflect diagnoses of depressive disorder, not otherwise specified; generalized anxiety disorder; anxiety and confusion; alcohol dependence; cocaine dependence; cannabis dependence; nicotine dependence; and substance-induced mood disorder. A September 2008 discharge summary reveals diagnoses of substance abuse mood disorder, alcohol dependence, and cocaine abuse. A May 2001 private psychiatric evaluation report by D.H., M.D. notes the Veteran's complaints of being constantly depressed. The physician reported that the Veteran had a longstanding drug problem involving alcohol and cocaine. The Veteran endorsed depression, auditory and visual hallucinations, sleep disturbance, occasional suicidal ideation, and paranoia. He noted that he made a suicide attempt when in service, but that he could not remember the means by which he tried it. Mental status examination revealed the Veteran to be fully oriented, but not alert. He stumbled through most of the interview. He reported that he heard voices and had visions, and that he felt paranoid from time to time. Memory was poor for both remote and recent events. Judgment and insight were very limited. The diagnoses were major depression, characterized by chronic depressive affect, poor sleep, and some suicidal ideation; and substance-induced persisting dementia, characterized by severe memory impairment, inability to concentrate, difficulty carrying out tasks. In August 2003, the Veteran underwent a VA mental disorders examination. His claims file was not available for review at the time of the examination. The Veteran complained of feeling disappointed and moderately depressed. He noted a history of incarceration, substance abuse, and being institutionalized. He stated that he gained 50 pounds in the prior 6 months and that he had difficulty sleeping, dimunition in libido, and occasional suicidal and homicidal ideation. Mental status examination revealed the Veteran to have an euthymic mood and affect appropriate to content. There was no significant anxiety or dysphoria noted, and the Veteran was "quite affable." Speech was normal, thought processes were normal, and memory was normal. The Veteran was fully oriented, and he did not report hallucinations or delusions. Insight and judgment were adequate. The diagnosis was depressive disorder, not otherwise specified. After conducting an examination of the Veteran, but not reviewing the Veteran's claims file, the VA examiner concluded that he did "not find any evidence that the veteran has had a psychological diability [sic] secondary to his hearing loss." The Veteran submitted medical treatise information in support of his claim. Specifically, he submitted one article on tinnitus which indicates that tinnitus "may be associated with psy-chological distress, and particularly, with depression and anxiety." He also submitted an article regarding the impact of chronic tinnitus on demanding cognitive tasks. An October 2005 private medical treatment letter indicates that the Veteran "does appear to have a mental illness that does require long term treatment and monitoring" and that the Veteran "verbalized his belief that his tinnitus has caused the development of his mental illness." An undated letter from R.L., M.D., a VA physician, reflects that the Veteran "clearly has a diagnosis of Major Depression Disorder" and that a clear "causalty" could not be provided for the diagnosis, but that the Veteran's "significant hearing disorder of Tinnitus has been an aggravating co-occurring disorder making depression symptoms more difficult to treat . . . ." and that "[i]n that context, the two disorders are related." In January 2007, the Veteran underwent a private psychological evaluation by J.M., Ph.D. The Veteran complained of anxiety, depression, hearing loss, tinnitus, and organic brain syndrome. He noted difficulty sleeping due to worry and that he was chronically upset about the constant ringing in his ears. He also reported intense mood swings, fair energy, and variable appetite. He noted many instances of feeling suicidal with a history of some attempts and a history of substance abuse. The Veteran was administered the Dementia Rating Scale - 2. His performance was reported as poor which confirmed cognitive limitations. The physician reported that his scores were only slightly higher than those associated with dementia. The Veteran also completed the Beck Depression Scale, and his score indicated a marked depressive state. The diagnoses were anxiety disorder, not otherwise specified; depressive disorder, not otherwise specified; rule out bipolar disorder; cognitive disorder, not otherwise specified; and rule out mild mental retardation. In a February 2007 letter, J.M., RNP reported that she received numerous telephone calls from the Veteran complaining about the ringing in his ears and that he has reported that he could not sleep due to the ringing in his ears. J.M. stated that "typical behavior for chronic tinnitus is depression, insomnia, anxiety and mood swings" and that the Veteran has "many if not all of the symptoms." J.M. further reported that "[r]esearch has also shown that depression can lead to signs of dementia" and that the Veteran "has obvious signs and symptoms of dementia due to the inadequate treatment of tinnitus." However, J.M. qualified her opinion, noting that she was "not an expert in this field . . . ." In a June 2007 lay statement, M.B. reported that the Veteran's psychological and emotional problems were secondary to and a direct result of his hearing loss and tinnitus. The remainder of the statement speaks to the severity of the Veteran's psychological problems. In an August 2007 letter, I.K., M.D., a VA physician, reflects a diagnosis of major depressive disorder and notes that the Veteran was treated with antidepressant and sleep medication. Dr. I.K. noted that one of the Veteran's "main medical problems is . . . tinnitus" and that "[a]t least a portion of [the Veteran's] psychiatric difficulties appear to be directly attributable to the tinnitus." Dr. I.K. further reported that the tinnitus "has caused him to have difficulties with insomnia, anxiety, depression and irritability." Dr. I.K. concluded that it was "unclear how much of his emotional difficulties are secondary to the tinnitus, but . . . a large portion certainly would be directly attributable to this physical condition." In a March 2008 letter, Dr. I.K. stated that "the tinnitus may at least be a part of the etiology of [the Veteran's] depressive symptoms." In June 2009, the Veteran underwent a VA mental disorders examination. The report notes the Veteran's complaints of depression and isolation, and that he was marginally functioning. He also noted daily lack of interest, depressed mood, insomnia, poor appetite, feeling like a failure, no spirit, poor concentration, feeling slowed down, and thinking he would be better off dead. He indicated that he would not kill himself. Mental status examination revealed the Veteran to be appropriately dressed with disheveled clothes and poor hygiene. Psychomotor activity was lethargic, speech was slow and mumbled, mood was depressed, and affect was normal. The Veteran was easily distracted with a short attention span. He was fully oriented, and his thought process and thought content were unremarkable except for suicidal ideation. The Veteran denied delusions and hallucinations. Judgment, insight, and memory were normal. The diagnoses were recurrent major depression, cocaine dependence in remission, and alcohol dependence in remission. After reviewing the Veteran's claims file and conducting an interview of the Veteran, the VA examiner concluded that "it is at least as likely as not that some portion of his depressive illness was caused by or a result of his military service." The VA examiner also noted that he could not "resolve the issue of whether his depression was due to or aggravated by his service connected left ear hearing loss or tinnitus without resorting to mere speculation." The Board finds that the competent evidence of record supports a finding of service connection for depression. There are current diagnoses of depression of record. Degmetich v. Brown, 104 F.3d 1328, 1333 (1997) (holding that the existence of a current disability is the cornerstone of a claim for VA disability compensation). In addition, the Veteran's service treatment records reflect a complaint of depression during service. See Hickson, 12 Vet. App. at 253 (holding that service connection requires medical, or in certain circumstances, lay evidence of inservice incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury). Moreover, the only medical opinion of record addressing the issue of whether the Veteran's depression is directly related to service is the June 2009 VA opinion, which concluded that "it is at least as likely as not that some portion of his depressive illness was caused by or a result of his military service." Although the August 2003 VA examiner found that the Veteran's depression was not related to his hearing loss, the VA examiner did not provide an opinion as to whether the Veteran's depression was directly related to service. In this, and in other cases, only independent medical evidence may be considered to support Board findings. The Board may not base a decision on its own unsubstantiated medical conclusions. Colvin v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 171, 175 (1991). Accordingly, as the only medical evidence of record speaking to the relationship between the Veteran's current depression and his active duty service indicates that his depression is related to service, service connection for depression is warranted. Thus, as the evidence reveals a complaint of depression during service, a current diagnosis of depression, and a medical nexus opinion that the Veteran's depression is related to service, service connection for depression is warranted. ORDER Service connection for depression is granted. REMAND As noted in the Board's April 2008 remand, the Veteran's original claim for entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur was denied by a December 1984 rating decision. The December 1984 rating decision was sent to the Veteran at a Bayland Street address in Houston, Texas. The record reflects that the Veteran's October 1983 claim for listed a Plum Creek address in Houston, Texas as his then-current address. Although there is one computer printout in the Veteran's claims file noting a Bayland Street address, there is no correspondence from the Veteran or his representative indicating that the Veteran resided at a Bayland Street address. The Veteran now claims that he has never lived at the Bayland Street address, that he did not receive notice of the December 1984 rating decision, and that his claim for service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur should be treated as a claim for service connection and not as a claim to reopen a previously denied claim. In its April 2008 remand, the Board directed the RO to conduct factual development to determine whether the Bayland Street address that the December 1984 rating decision was sent to could be shown to have been the Veteran's address of record at the time that the December 1984 rating decision was mailed to him. The remand further instructed that, if the Bayland Street address could not be shown to have been the Veteran's address of record at that time, the RO must send the Veteran a revised and proper VCAA notice and readjudicate the Veteran's claim on the merits with consideration of all of the evidence of record. Although the RO conducted factual development, including two internet searches of a "DebtorDiscovery" website, the RO was unable to produce any evidence whatsoever that the Veteran lived at the Bayland Street address in December 1984, or that he ever lived at the Bayland Street address. As the RO was unable to show that the Veteran's address of record at the time of the December 1984 rating decision was the Bayland Street address, the Veteran's claim is, in fact, an original claim for service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur and not a claim to reopen the issue of service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur. However, the RO did not send the Veteran a revised and proper VCAA notice and readjudicate his claim for entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur on the merits with consideration of all of the evidence of record. Indeed, the August 2009 supplemental statement of the case reflects that the RO again concluded that new and material evidence had not been submitted to reopen the Veteran's claim of entitlement to service connection for residuals of a right femur disorder, despite the Board's April 2008 remand instructions. The Court has held that RO compliance with a remand is not discretionary, and that if the RO fails to comply with the terms of a remand, another remand for corrective action is required. Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268 (1998). Accordingly, as the RO did not send the Veteran revised and proper VCAA notice and adjudicate his claim of entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur on the merits with consideration of all of the evidence of record in compliance with the April 2008 Board remand, a remand is again required for full compliance. Accordingly, the case is remanded for the following action: 1. The RO must provide notice to the Veteran of what information or evidence is needed in order to substantiate his claim for entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur, and it must assist the Veteran by making reasonable efforts to get the evidence needed. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5100, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5106, 5107, 5126; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326. The RO must also provide notice as required by Dingess/Hartman v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). 2. As the RO has been unable to produce evidence showing that the Bayland Street address was the Veteran's address of record at the time of the December 1984 rating decision, the RO must readjudicate the Veteran's claim for entitlement to service connection for residuals of a fractured right femur on the merits, considering all of the evidence currently of record. If the claim remains denied, a supplemental statement of the case must be provided to the Veteran and his representative. After the Veteran and his representative have had an opportunity to respond, the appeal must be returned to the Board for appellate review. No action is required by the Veteran until he receives further notice; however, he may present additional evidence or argument while the case is in remand status at the RO. Kutscherousky v. West, 12 Vet. App. 369 (1999). ______________________________________________ JOY A. MCDONALD Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs