Citation Nr: 1003395 Decision Date: 01/22/10 Archive Date: 02/01/10 DOCKET NO. 00-07 998 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Milwaukee, Wisconsin THE ISSUE Entitlement to an increased disability rating for service- connected depression, currently evaluated 10 percent disabling. REPRESENTATION Veteran represented by: Wisconsin Department of Veterans Affairs ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD Arif Syed, Law Clerk INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from January 1980 to July 1982. This case comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal of an April 1999 rating decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Procedural history The Veteran was originally granted service connection for a psychiatric disability in a March 1998 rating decision. The RO evaluated the psychiatric disability as noncompensably (zero percent) disabling. The Veteran submitted a claim of entitlement to an increased disability rating for depression in August 1998, which was denied in the April 1999 rating decision. In March 2000, the RO received the Veteran's notice of disagreement (NOD) as to the denial of an increased disability rating. The Veteran perfected his appeal by the timely filing of a substantive appeal (VA Form 9) in April 2000. In a March 2003 rating decision, the RO proposed to terminate service connection for the psychiatric disability. In a September 2003 rating decision, the RO severed service connection for the psychiatric disability, effective December 1, 2003. The Veteran disagreed with the termination. In a March 2007 rating decision, the RO reinstated service connection for the psychiatric disability and evaluated the Veteran's disability as 10 percent disabling. In September 2007, the Board remanded the Veteran's claim of entitlement to an increased disability rating for the service-connected depression. The agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ) continued the previous denial in an October 2009 supplemental statement of the case (SSOC). The Veteran's VA claims folder has been returned to the Board for further appellate proceedings. Issues not on appeal In a May 2007 rating decision, the RO denied the Veteran's claim of entitlement to an increased disability rating for service-connected Raynaud's disease and for entitlement to service connection for a "shaving condition." To the Board's knowledge, a NOD was not filed as to either of those issues. Those matters, therefore, are not in appellate status and will be discussed no further herein. See Archbold v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 124, 130 (1996) [pursuant to 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(a), the filing of a notice of disagreement initiates appellate review in the VA administrative adjudication process, and the request for appellate review is completed by the claimant's filing of a substantive appeal after a statement of the case is issued by VA]. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The Veteran's depression disorder is manifested by impaired judgment, impaired abstract thinking, disturbances of motivation and mood, impairment of memory, anxiety, and difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. There is no evidence of obsessional rituals, speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant, near-continuous panic attacks, spatial disorientation, neglect of personal hygiene, or inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. 2. The evidence does not show that the Veteran's service- connected depression is so exceptional or unusual that referral for extraschedular consideration by designated authority is required. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The criteria for a 50 percent disability rating for depression have been met. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9435 (2009). 2. Application of extraschedular provisions for the service- connected depression is not warranted. 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b) (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran seeks entitlement to an increased disability rating for his service-connected depression. In the interest of clarity, the Board will discuss certain preliminary matters. The issue on appeal will then be analyzed and a decision rendered. Stegall concerns As alluded to above, in September 2007, the Board remanded this claim and ordered the AOJ to schedule the Veteran for an examination to determine the Veteran's most likely current psychiatric diagnosis or diagnoses. The examiner was also requested to assess the impairment resulting solely from the service-connected depression. A report was to be prepared and associated with the Veteran's VA claims folder. The Veteran's claim was then to be readjudicated. Pursuant to the Board's remand instructions, a July 2009 VA examination was conducted and an opinion rendered as to the Veteran's most likely currently psychiatric diagnoses and associated with the Veteran's claims folder. The VA examiner attributed Veteran's reported psychiatric symptoms to his service-connected depression. The Veteran's claim was readjudicated via the October 2009 SSOC. Accordingly, the Board's remand instructions have been complied with. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998) [where the remand orders of the Board are not complied with, the Board errs as a matter of law when it fails to ensure compliance]. The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 The VCAA includes an enhanced duty on the part of VA to notify a claimant as to the information and evidence necessary to substantiate a claim for VA benefits. The VCAA also redefines the obligations of VA with respect to its statutory duty to assist a claimant in the development of his claim. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103, 5103A (West 2002). The VCAA alters the legal landscape in three distinct ways: standard of review, notice, and duty to assist. The Board will now address these concepts within the context of the circumstances presented in this case. Standard of review After the evidence is assembled, it is the Board's responsibility to evaluate the entire record. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a) (West 2002). When there is an approximate balance of evidence regarding the merits of an issue material to the determination of the matter, the benefit of the doubt in resolving each issue shall be given to the claimant. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 4.3 (2009). In Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53 (1990), the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) stated that "a veteran need only demonstrate that there is an 'approximate balance of positive and negative evidence' in order to prevail." To deny a claim on its merits, the preponderance of the evidence must be against the claim. See Alemany v. Brown, 9 Vet App. 518, 519 (1996), citing Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 54. Notice The VCAA requires VA to notify the claimant and the claimant's representative, if any, of any information and any medical or lay evidence not previously provided to VA that is necessary to substantiate the claim. As part of this notice, VA is to specifically inform the claimant and the claimant's representative, if any, of which portion, if any, of the evidence is to be provided by the claimant and which part, if any, VA will attempt to obtain on behalf of the claimant. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103 (West 2002); see also Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183 (2002) [a letter from VA to appellant describing evidence potentially helpful to the appellant, but not mentioning who is responsible for obtaining such evidence, did not meet the standard erected by the VCAA]. After having carefully reviewed the record, the Board has concluded that the notice requirements of the VCAA have been satisfied with respect to the issue on appeal. The Board observes that the Veteran received a general VCAA notice letter, dated January 2007. Crucially, the RO informed the Veteran of VA's duty to assist him in the development of his claim in the above-referenced January 2007 VCAA letter. Specifically, the letter stated that VA would assist the Veteran in obtaining relevant records from any Federal agency, including those from the military, VA Medical centers, and the Social Security Administration. The Veteran was also advised in the letter that a VA examination would be scheduled if necessary to make a decision on his claim. With respect to private treatment records, the VCAA letter informed the Veteran that VA would make reasonable efforts to request such records. The January 2007 letter emphasized: "If the evidence is not in your possession, you must give us enough information about the evidence so that we can request it from the person or agency that has it. If the holder of the evidence declines to give it to us, asks for a fee to provide it, or VA otherwise cannot get the evidence, we will notify you. It is your responsibility to make sure we receive all requested records that are not in the possession of a Federal department or agency." [Emphasis as in the original]. The January 2007 VCAA letter specifically requested: "If there is any other evidence or information that you think will support your claim, please let us know. If you have any evidence in your possession that pertains to your claim, please send it to us." This complies with the "give us everything you've got" provision formerly contained in 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b) in that it informed the Veteran that he could submit or identify evidence other than what was specifically requested by the RO. [The Board observes that 38 C.F.R. § 3.159 was recently revised, effective as of May 30, 2008. See 73 Fed. Reg. 23,353-23,356 (April 30, 2008). The final rule removes the third sentence of 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b)(1), which had stated that VA will request the claimant to provide any evidence in the claimant's possession that pertains to the claim.] In short, the record indicates that the Veteran received appropriate notice under 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103 and Quartuccio. In Dingess v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006), the Court observed that each claim of entitlement to service connection consists of five elements: (1) veteran status [not at issue here]; (2) existence of a disability; (3) a connection between the veteran's service and the disability; (4) degree of disability; and (5) effective date. Because each service connection claim is comprised of five elements, the Court further held that the notice requirements of section 5103(a) apply to all five elements of each claim. Therefore, upon receipt of an application for a service connection claim, section 5103(a) and section 3.159(b) require VA to review the information and the evidence presented with the claim and to provide the claimant with notice of what information and evidence not previously provided, if any, will assist in substantiating, or is necessary to substantiate, the elements of the claim as reasonably contemplated by the application. This includes notice that a disability rating and an effective date for the award of benefits will be assigned if service connection is awarded. The Veteran was provided specific Dingess notice in the above-referenced January 2007 VCAA letter, as well as in a March 2006 letter, which detailed the evidence considered in determining a disability rating, including "nature and symptoms of the condition; severity and duration of the symptoms; and impact of the condition and symptoms on employment." The Veteran was also advised in the two letters as to examples of evidence that would be pertinent to a disability rating, such as on-going treatment records, recent Social Security determinations, and statements from employers as to job performance and time lost due to service- connected disabilities. With respect to effective date, the January 2007 and March 2006 letters instructed the Veteran that two factors were relevant in determining effective dates of increased rating claims: when the claims were received and when the evidence "shows a level of disability that supports a certain rating under the rating schedule." The letters also advised the Veteran of examples of evidence that would be pertinent to an effective date determination, such as information about continuous treatment or when treatment began, service medical records the Veteran may not have submitted, and reports of treatment while attending training in the Guard or Reserve. Accordingly, the Veteran received proper notice as to disability rating and effective date pursuant to the Court's Dingess determination. The Board recognizes that, according to Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112, 119-20 (2004), proper VCAA notice must "precede an initial unfavorable [agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ)] decision on a service connection claim." Since the VCAA was not enacted until November 2000, furnishing the Veteran with VCAA notice prior to the initial adjudication of the claim in April 1999 was clearly both a legal and a practical impossibility. Indeed, VA's General Counsel has held that the failure to do so under such circumstances does not constitute error. See VAOGCPREC 7- 2004. Crucially, the Veteran's claim was readjudicated in the October 2009 SSOC, after he was provided with the opportunity to submit additional evidence and argument in support of his claim and to respond to the VCAA notice provided in 2006 and 2007. Therefore, the essential fairness of the adjudication was not affected. See Overton v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 427, 437 (2006) [a timing error may be cured by a new VCAA notification followed by a readjudication of the claim]. The Veteran has pointed to no prejudice or due process concerns arising out of the timing of the VCAA notice. The Board has also considered the Court's decision in Vazquez-Flores v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 37 (2008), which held that for an increased compensation claim, section § 5103(a) requires, at a minimum, that VA notify the claimant that, to substantiate a claim, the claimant must provide, or ask VA to obtain, medical or lay evidence demonstrating a worsening or increase in severity of the disability and the effect that worsening has on the claimant's employment and daily life. Additionally, the claimant must be notified that, should an increase in disability be found, a disability rating will be determined by applying relevant Diagnostic Codes, which typically provide for a range in severity of a particular disability from noncompensable to as much as 100 percent (depending on the disability involved), based on the nature of the symptoms of the condition for which disability compensation is being sought, their severity and duration, and their impact upon employment and daily life. The notice must also provide examples of the types of medical and lay evidence that the claimant may submit (or ask VA to obtain) that are relevant to establishing entitlement to increased compensation, e.g., competent lay statements describing symptoms, medical and hospitalization records, medical statements, employer statements, job application rejections, and any other evidence showing an increase in the disability or exceptional circumstances relating to the disability. See Vazquez-Flores, 22 Vet. App. at 43-44. The Board observes that the Veteran was not informed of the relevant law and regulations pertaining to his increased rating claim as contemplated in the Vazquez decision. However, the evidence of record indicates that the Veteran had actual knowledge of what is necessary to substantiate his claim. In particular, the Veteran has consistently argued that his depression has worsened in severity, and has manifested in symptomatology consistent with disturbances of motivation and mood and difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. See, e.g., the Veteran's NOD dated March 2000; see also the July 2009 and October 2001 VA examination reports. In any event, the Court's decision in Vazquez-Flores was recently vacated by the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. See Vazquez-Flores v. Shinseki, 580 F.3d 1270 (Fed. Cir. 2009). In short, the record indicates the Veteran received appropriate notice pursuant to the VCAA. Duty to assist In general, the VCAA provides that VA shall make reasonable efforts to assist a claimant in obtaining evidence necessary to substantiate a claim for VA benefits, unless no reasonable possibility exists that such assistance would aid in substantiating the claim. Assistance provided by VA shall include providing a medical examination or obtaining a medical opinion when such an examination or opinion is necessary to make a decision on the claim. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 3.159 (2009). The Board finds reasonable efforts have been made to assist the Veteran in obtaining evidence necessary to substantiate his claim. There is no reasonable possibility that further assistance would aid in substantiating this claim. The pertinent evidence of record includes the Veteran's service treatment records, the Veteran's statements, as well as VA and private medical treatment records. Additionally, the Veteran was afforded VA examinations in November 1997, March 1999, October 2001, June 2009, and July 2009. The examination reports reflect that the examiners interviewed and examined the Veteran, reviewed his past medical history, documented his current medical conditions, and rendered appropriate diagnoses consistent with the remainder of the evidence of record. The Board therefore concludes that the VA examination reports are adequate for evaluation purposes. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.2 (2009); see also Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 312 (2007) [holding that when VA undertakes to provide a VA examination or obtain a VA opinion, it must ensure that the examination or opinion is adequate]. Thus, the Board finds that under the circumstances of this case, VA has satisfied the notification and duty to assist provisions of the law and that no further action pursuant to the VCAA need be undertaken on the Veteran's behalf. The Board additionally observes that all appropriate due process concerns have been satisfied. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.103 (2009). The Veteran has been accorded the opportunity to present evidence and argument in support of his claim. He has retained the services of a representative. In his April 2000 substantive appeal [VA Form 9], the Veteran declined the option of testifying at a personal hearing. Accordingly, the Board will proceed to a decision. Relevant law and regulations Disability ratings - in general Disability ratings are assigned in accordance with the VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities and are intended to represent the average impairment of earning capacity resulting from disability. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.321(a), 4.1 (2009). Separate diagnostic codes identify the various disabilities. See 38 C.F.R. Part 4. Specific rating criteria The pertinent provisions of 38 C.F.R. § 4.130 relating to rating psychiatric disabilities read as follows: 100% - Total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation or own name. 70% - Occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near-continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; impaired impulse control (such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a worklike setting); inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. 50% - Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short-and long-term memory (e.g. retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. 30% - Occupational and social impairment with occasional decrease in work efficiency and intermittent periods of inability to perform occupational tasks (although generally functioning satisfactorily, with routine behavior, self-care, and conversation normal), due to such symptoms as: depressed mood, anxiety, suspiciousness, panic attacks (weekly or less often), chronic sleep impairment, and mild memory loss (such as forgetting names, directions, recent events). 10% - Occupational and social impairment due to mild or transient symptoms which decrease work efficiency and ability to perform occupational tasks only during periods of significant stress, or; symptoms controlled by continuous medication. 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9435. Global Assessment of Functioning Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) scores are a scale reflecting the "psychological, social, and occupational functioning on a hypothetical continuum of mental health- illness." See Carpenter v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 240, 242 (1995); see also Richard v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 266, 267 (1996) [citing the American Psychiatric Association's DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL FOR MENTAL DISORDERS, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), p. 32]. GAF scores ranging between 61 to 70 reflect some mild symptoms (e.g., depressed mood and mild insomnia) or some difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., occasional truancy, or theft within the household), but generally functioning pretty well, and has some meaningful interpersonal relationships. Scores ranging from 51 to 60 reflect more moderate symptoms (e.g., flat affect and circumstantial speech, occasional panic attacks) or moderate difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., few friends, conflicts with peers or co- workers). Scores ranging from 41 to 50 reflect serious symptoms (e.g., suicidal ideation, severe obsessional rituals, frequent shoplifting) or any serious impairment in social, occupational or school functioning (e.g., no friends, unable to keep a job). Scores ranging from 31 to 40 reflect some impairment in reality testing or communication (e.g., speech is at times illogical, obscure, or irrelevant) or major impairment in several areas, such as work or school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood (e.g., depressed man avoids friends, neglects family, and is unable to work; child frequently beats up other children, is defiant at home, and is failing at school). Analysis Assignment of diagnostic code The assignment of a particular diagnostic code is "completely dependent on the facts of a particular case." Butts v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 532, 538 (1993). One diagnostic code may be more appropriate than another based on such factors as an individual's relevant medical history, the diagnosis and demonstrated symptomatology. Any change in a diagnostic code by a VA adjudicator must be specifically explained. See Pernorio v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 625, 629 (1992). In this case, the Board has considered whether another rating code is "more appropriate"" than the one used by the RO, Diagnostic Code 9435. See Tedeschi v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 411, 414 (1995). The Veteran's psychiatric disorder is currently rated under 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9435 [mood disorder, not otherwise specified] (2009). Diagnostic Code 9435 is deemed by the Board to be the most appropriate primarily because it most closely approximates the diagnosed disability in the Veteran's case (depression disorder). In any event, with the exception of eating disorders, all mental disorders including adjustment reaction disorder are rated under the same criteria in the rating schedule. Therefore, rating under another diagnostic code would not produce a different result. The Veteran and his accredited representative have not suggested that another diagnostic code is more appropriate. Accordingly, the Board concludes that the Veteran is appropriately rated under Diagnostic Code 9435. Mittleider concerns In addition to depression, for which service connection was established, the Veteran's treatment history indicates additional nonservice-connected diagnoses of PTSD, anxiety, schizoaffective disorder, mood disorder, bipolar disorder, and depressive disorder, not otherwise specified (NOS). See, e.g., VA treatment records dated October 2001, November 2001, September 2003, and November 2003. It is now well-settled that the Board is precluded from differentiating between symptomatology attributed to a nonservice-connected disability and a service-connected disability, in the absence of medical evidence which does so. See Mittleider v. West, 11 Vet. App. 181, 182 (1998), citing Mitchem v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 136, 140 (1996). As discussed above, in September 2007, the Board remanded the Veteran's claim in order for a VA psychologist to assess the impairment resulting solely from the Veteran's service-connected depression. The Veteran was provided a VA examination in July 2009. The VA examiner noted that the Veteran reported "symptoms of depression including persistently depressed mood, anhedonia, guilt, insomnia, loss of appetite, fatigue, irritability, difficulty concentrating, and past suicidal behavior." However, the VA examiner did not comment as to whether these psychiatric symptoms were attributable to the service- connected depression or to other, non service-connected psychiatric disorders. The medical evidence in the instant case therefore does not clearly differentiate between the symptomatology associated with the Veteran's service-connected depression and his non- service-connected psychiatric disabilities. It appears that such differentiation may be practically impossible. Accordingly, for the purposes of this decision, the Board will attribute all of the Veteran's psychiatric symptoms to his service-connected depression. See Mittleider, supra. The Board adds, however, that the record also indicates that the Veteran has a long history of significant polysubstance abuse. This is not service-connected. Any problems associated with the non service-connected substance abuse will not be considered in evaluating this claim. Schedular rating The Veteran's service-connected depression is currently evaluated 10 percent disabling. The 10 percent rating was assigned by the RO based on evidence of symptoms controlled by continuous medication. For the reasons expressed immediately below, the Board finds that the Veteran's symptoms more approximately warrant the assignment of a 50 percent disability rating under Diagnostic Code 9435. As noted above, to obtain a 50 percent disability rating, the record must include evidence of occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short- and long-term memory (e.g. retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. With respect to flattened affect, the July 2009 VA examiner noted that the Veteran demonstrated evidence of a restricted affect. Additionally, the examiner reported that the Veteran's "[f]acial expressions were generally flat." However, this isolated diagnosis is heavily outweighed by the remainder of the competent medical evidence of record which is devoid of a flattened affect. Specifically, a VA psychiatric treatment record dated September 2003 noted that the Veteran's "[a]ffect is appropriate to initially, somewhat angry mood, which becomes tearful, as the session progresses, and becomes quite euthymic..." The Veteran's affect has also been described as "full", "resilient at times," "normal," and "anxious." See September 2001 and August 2002 VA treatment records; November 1997 VA examination report; private treatment record dated August 2003. Since the July 2009 diagnosis has not been duplicated, and the remainder of the competent medical evidence of record is devoid any congruent evidence, flattened affect has not been demonstrated. There is no evidence of circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech. The July 2009 VA examiner noted that "[the Veteran's] speech was normal in rate and rhythm." Moreover, a VA treatment record dated September 2003 notes that the Veteran's speech was "coherent." Accordingly, circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech cannot be conceded in the instant case. The medical evidence of record does not demonstrate that the Veteran experiences panic attacks. Although the Veteran reported that he has "racing thoughts" when in the presence of others, there is no indication that he experiences panic attacks. The medical evidence of record is ambivalent concerning any difficulty in understanding complex commands. The July 2009 VA examiner noted the Veteran's report that he experiences difficulty concentrating. Further, the October 2001 VA examiner reported that the Veteran "appears somewhat confused with some degree of malconcentration." Regarding impairment of short and long-term memory, a VA treatment record dated September 2002 shows that the Veteran experiences "trouble remembering." Further, the October 2001 VA examiner reported that "[t]he [V]eteran demonstrates mild to fall off in recent and remote memory, but is able to demonstrate good retention and recall." Although the July 2009 VA examiner noted no "gross deficits in immediate, recent, or remote memory," there is evidence that the Veteran experiences some short-term memory loss. With regard to impaired judgment, the Veteran's judgment was noted to have been "somewhat compromised." See the October 2001 VA examination report. Moreover, an August 2002 VA mental health evaluation shows that the Veteran's judgment "does appear impaired." Therefore, the medical evidence of record arguably demonstrates impaired judgment. There is evidence of impaired abstract thinking. Notably, the October 2001 VA examiner reported that the Veteran's abstract thinking was "rather concrete." Impaired abstract thinking has therefore arguably been demonstrated. There is evidence of disturbances of motivation and mood. Multiple VA examination reports and VA treatment records have noted the Veteran's depressed mood. Specifically, the Veteran has reported persistently depressed mood, guilt, grief, and loneliness. See, e.g., the July 2009 VA examination report; a VA treatment record dated September 2003. Further, as noted above, the Veteran has been diagnosed with anxiety and depression, NOS. See, e.g., VA treatment records dated November 2001 and December 1999. He has attributed his anxiety to being homeless. See a VA treatment record dated August 2002. The evidence of record demonstrates that the Veteran experiences difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. Concerning social impairment, the Veteran reported that he has "episodes where he cannot control himself and wishes to stay away from people as much as possible." See the June 2009 VA examination report. The Veteran also reported to the July 2009 VA examiner that he has a "turbulent" relationship with his wife, and that "a divorce is in process." See the June 2009 VA examination report. The Veteran does not currently live with his children. Further, the Veteran has minimal involvement with his siblings, who he feels "do not take his illness seriously." See the July 2009 VA examination report. Concerning work impairment, the Veteran reported to the July 2009 VA examiner that he left his place of employment in 2006 because he became "suspicious that people were plotting against him." Consistently, he reported to the October 2001 VA examiner that he felt that people are suspicious of him. His symptoms such as loneliness and depressed mood have also caused the Veteran difficulty in establishing work relationships. Accordingly, difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships has been demonstrated. In short, although the Veteran does not have all of the symptomatology consistent with the assignment of a 50 percent rating, for example flattened affect, panic attack, or circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech, the Board finds that the impact of the Veteran's depression on his social and industrial functioning is sufficient to approximate the degree of impairment contemplated by a 50 percent rating. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.7 (2009). Criteria for the assignment of a 50 percent rating, which have arguably been met or approximated include impaired concentration, impairment of memory, impaired abstract thinking, disturbances of motivation and mood, and difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. Thus, based on the evidence of record, the Board concludes that symptomatology which warrants an increased rating of 50 percent is approximated. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.7 (2009). In sum, the medical evidence supports an increased disability evaluation, 50 percent, for the Veteran's depression. The Board also considered the assignment of a rating in excess of 50 percent. See A.B. v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 35, 38 (1993) [when a veteran is not granted the maximum benefit allowable under the Rating Schedule, the pending appeal as to that issue is not abrogated]. For the reasons expressed immediately below, the Board has determined that the evidence does not support a conclusion that the Veteran has symptoms of occupational and social impairment, which would warrant the assignment of a 70 percent or 100 percent disability rating. Multiple VA mental health evaluations have documented the Veteran's suicidal ideations. See, e.g., a VA mental health evaluation dated September 2003; July 2009 and November 1997 VA examination reports. The Veteran has also experienced impaired impulse control. A January 2004 VA psychiatric treatment record indicates that the Veteran has had homicidal thoughts towards the mother of his two children. Moreover, the Veteran was arrested for disorderly conduct in 1999. Additionally, the July 2009 VA examiner noted that symptoms of the Veteran's depression include irritability. The evidence of record shows that the Veteran experiences difficulty adapting to stressful circumstances. As indicated above, the Veteran has repeatedly indicated his difficulty in functioning at his places of employment. See, e.g., the July 2009 and October 2001 VA examination reports There is no mention of obsessive ritual in the medical evidence of record. Nor is there evidence of illogical, obscure, or irrelevant speech or near-continuous panic or depression which affects the Veteran's ability to function independently, appropriately, and effectively. There is also no evidence of spatial disorientation, and the majority of the objective evidence shows that Veteran maintains his personal appearance and hygiene. Although the medical evidence shows that the Veteran experiences difficulty in establishing social relationships, there is no indication that the Veteran is unable to establish and maintain effective relationships. Specifically, the evidence of record shows that the Veteran is married and has contact with his children, with whom he does not live. Because the Veteran demonstrates only 3 out of the 9 criteria for a 70 percent disability rating, the evidence of record does not support a conclusion that the Veteran has met the criteria for a 70 percent disability rating under 38 C.F.R. § 4.130. Finally, the record indicates that the Veteran has not suffered total occupational and social impairment as would be required for the 100 percent disability rating. The Veteran reported that he experiences auditory hallucinations, which have been persistent at times, and has heard voices telling him to commit suicide. See the July 2009 VA examination report; see also the November 1997 VA examination report. However, there is no evidence of gross impairment in thought processes or communication, grossly inappropriate behavior, intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living, disorientation as to time or place, or memory loss for names of close relatives or own name. The Board's inquiry is not necessarily strictly limited to the criteria found in the VA rating schedule. See Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436 (2002) [the criteria set forth in the rating formula for mental disorders do not constitute an exhaustive list of symptoms, but rather are examples of the type and degree of the symptoms, or their effects, that would justify a particular rating.] However, the Board has not identified any other aspects of the Veteran's service- connected depression which would enable it to conclude that the criteria for a higher rating have been approximated, and the Veteran and his representative have pointed to no such pathology. The Board notes that there are also multiple GAF scores, ranging between 35 and 65. These scores are so divergent as to be virtually useless for rating purposes. Thus, a review of the evidence indicates that symptomatology associated with the Veteran's depression most closely approximates that associated with a 50 percent evaluation. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.7 (2009). Hart consideration In Hart v. Mansfield, 21 Vet. App. 505 (2007), the Court was presented with the question of whether it is appropriate to apply staged ratings when assigning an increased rating. In answering this question in the affirmative, the Court held that staged ratings are appropriate for an increased rating claim when the factual findings show distinct time periods where the service-connected disability exhibited symptoms that would warrant different ratings. In reaching its conclusion, the Court observed that when a claim for an increased rating is granted, the effective date assigned may be up to one year prior to the date that the application for increase was received if it is factually ascertainable that an increase in disability had occurred within that timeframe. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110 (West 2002). Accordingly, the relevant focus for adjudicating an increased rating claim is on the evidence concerning the state of the disability from the time period one year before the claim was filed until VA makes a final decision on the claim. The Veteran filed his claim for an increased disability rating for his service-connected depression in August 1998. The question to be answered by the Board, therefore, is whether any different rating should be assigned for the relevant time period under consideration, August 1997 to the present. After a careful review of the record, the Board can find no evidence to support a finding that the Veteran's depression was more or less severe during the appeal period. Specifically, the November 1997 VA examiner noted Veteran's symptomatology associated with depression, short-term memory loss, anxiety, and difficulty establishing work and social relationships. The Veteran further reported feelings of loneliness, grief, anger, and guilt in September 2003. See a VA treatment record dated September 2003. Moreover, the July 2009 VA examiner noted the Veteran's report of depression, fatigue, marital discord, and stressful interaction with his children. No evidence was presented to allow for the assignment of an increased disability rating higher than 50 percent at any time during the period here under consideration. In short, a 50 percent rating is awarded from August 1997 to the present. Extraschedular consideration The Board has considered the question of whether an extraschedular rating may be appropriate for the Veteran's depression. See Bagwell v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 157 (1966). Ordinarily, the VA Rating Schedule will apply unless there are exceptional or unusual factors which would render application of the schedule impractical. See Fisher v. Principi, 4 Vet. App. 57, 60 (1993). According to the regulation, an extraschedular disability rating is warranted upon a finding that the case presents such an exceptional or unusual disability picture with such related factors as marked interference with employment or frequent period of hospitalization that would render impractical the application of the regular schedular standards. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.21(b)(1) (2009). Under Thun v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 111 (2008), there is a three-step inquiry for determining whether a veteran is entitled to an extraschedular rating. First, the Board must first determine whether the evidence presents such an exceptional disability picture that the available schedular evaluations for that service-connected disability are inadequate. Second, if the schedular evaluation does not contemplate the level of disability and symptomatology and is found to be inadequate, the Board must then determine whether the claimant's disability picture exhibits other related factors such as those provided by the regulation as "governing norms." Third, if the rating schedule is inadequate to evaluate a veteran's disability picture and that picture has attendant thereto related factors such as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization, then the case must be referred to the Under Secretary for Benefits or the Director of the Compensation and Pension Service to determine whether, to accord justice, the veteran's disability picture requires the assignment of an extraschedular rating. The Veteran has not identified any factors which may be considered to be exceptional or unusual, and the Board has been similarly unsuccessful. Although the Veteran has been hospitalized on multiple occasions, he received significant treatment for alcohol and cocaine dependence during these hospitalizations. Moreover, on two of these occasions when the Veteran was hospitalized for suicidal behavior, he later stated that the suicidal ideation was fabricated because he "was desperate to get treatment for cocaine and alcohol abuse and wants to learn to deal with his anger more appropriately." See a VA treatment record dated September 2000. The evidence of record indicates that the Veteran is currently unemployed. The Veteran stated to the July 2009 VA examiner that he stopped working as a machinist in 2006 because he "became suspicious people were plotting against him." however, the Veteran also reported to the June 2009 VA examiner that he stopped working in 2006 because of the non-use of his hands resulting from his service-connected Raynaud's disease. See the June 2009 VA examination report. There is no evidence of record to indicate that the Veteran's depression has created any unusual employment impairment, over and above that which is contemplated in the assignment of a 50 percent disability rating. See Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361, 363 (1993) [noting that the disability rating itself is recognition that industrial capabilities are impaired]. In addition, there is no evidence in the medical records of an exceptional or unusual clinical picture. Further, the record does not demonstrate any other reason why an extraschedular rating should be assigned. Accordingly, the Board therefore has determined that referral of the case for extraschedular consideration pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1) is not warranted. Conclusion In summary, for the reasons and bases expressed above, the Board finds that the evidence supports the assignment of a 50 percent disability rating for the Veteran's service-connected depression. To that extent, the appeal is allowed. ORDER Entitlement to a 50 percent disability rating for service- connected depression is granted, subject to controlling regulations applicable to the payment of monetary benefits. ____________________________________________ Barry F. Bohan Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs