Citation Nr: 1004067 Decision Date: 01/27/10 Archive Date: 02/16/10 DOCKET NO. 03-02 754 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Houston, Texas THE ISSUE Entitlement to a rating in excess of 70 percent for major depressive disorder. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Daniel G. Krasnegor, Esquire WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Appellant ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD G.A. Wasik, Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran had active duty service from January 1970 to January 1975 and from February 1976 to June 1978. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a May 2002 rating decision by a Regional Office (RO) of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). The Veteran testified at a personal hearing before the Board in Washington, D.C. in September 2003. In April 2004, the Board remanded the claim to the RO to cure a procedural defect, and in June 2005, the Board issued a decision denying the Veteran's claim. Thereafter, the Veteran appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). In October 2007, the Court set aside the Board's June 2005 decision and remanded the case to the Board for reconsideration. In July 2008, the Board again remanded the claim to the RO for action consistent with instruction from the Court. In April 2009, the claim was again before the Board when it was remanded to cure a procedural defect. In February 2009, the Veteran withdrew her request to appear for a hearing to be conducted by a Member of the Board. FINDING OF FACT The service-connected major depressive disorder is not productive of total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation or own name. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for assignment of a rating in excess of 70 percent for service-connected major depressive disorder, have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155 (West 2002); 38C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION Duty to Assist The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) and implementing regulations set forth certain notice and assistance provisions. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107; 38 C.F.R §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159 and 3.326(a). After reviewing the claims folder, the Board finds that the appellant has been notified of the applicable laws and regulations which set forth the criteria for entitlement to an increased rating for the disability adjudicated by this decision. Specifically, the discussions in May 2004 and July 2008 VCAA letters have informed the appellant of the information and evidence necessary to warrant entitlement to an increased rating for her major depressive disorder. See Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183 (2002). The requirements of 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b)(1) have been met. The Board finds that all notice required by VCAA and implementing regulations was furnished to the appellant and that no useful purpose would be served by delaying appellate review to send out additional VCAA notice letters. In this case, the RO's decision came before complete notification of the appellant's rights under the VCAA. It is arguable that the VCAA notice was not timely. See Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112 (2004). The Board finds, however, that any defect with respect to the timing of the VCAA notice in this case was harmless error for the reasons specified below. Subsequent to the rating decision on appeal, the RO did provide notice to the claimant regarding what information and evidence was needed to substantiate the claim and the appellant has had the chance to submit evidence in response to the VCAA letters. Under these circumstances, the Board finds that all notification and development action needed to render a fair decision on the claim decided herein has been accomplished and that adjudication of the claim, without directing or accomplishing any additional notification and/or development action, poses no risk of prejudice to the appellant. See, e.g., Bernard v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 384, 394 (1993). On March 3, 2006, the Court issued a decision in the consolidated appeal of Dingess/Hartman v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006), which held that the VCAA notice requirements of 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b) apply to all five elements of a service connection claim. Those five elements include: (1) veteran status; (2) existence of a disability; (3) a connection between the veteran's service and the disability; (4) degree of disability; and (5) effective date of the disability. The Court held that upon receipt of an application for a service-connection claim, 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b) require VA to review the information and the evidence presented with the claim and to provide the claimant with notice of what information and evidence not previously provided, if any, will assist in substantiating or is necessary to substantiate the elements of the claim as reasonably contemplated by the application. See Dingess/Hartman, supra. In the present appeal, the appellant was provided with notice of what types of information and evidence were needed to substantiate her claim in the VCAA letters and she was also provided with notice of the types of evidence necessary to establish an effective date or a disability evaluation for the issue on appeal in the July 2008 letter. All the VCAA requires is that the duty to notify is satisfied, and that claimants are given the opportunity to submit information and evidence in support of their claims. Once this has been accomplished, all due process concerns have been satisfied. See Bernard v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 384 (1993); Sutton v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 553 (1996); see also 38 C.F.R. § 20.1102 (harmless error). The Board also concludes VA's duty to assist has been satisfied. The Veteran's VA medical records and reports of VA examinations are in the file. The Veteran has at no time referenced outstanding records that she wanted VA to obtain or that she felt were relevant to the claim. The duty to assist includes, when appropriate, the duty to conduct a thorough and contemporaneous examination of the veteran. Green v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 121 (1991). In addition, where the evidence of record does not reflect the current state of the veteran's disability, a VA examination must be conducted. Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1991); 38 C.F.R. § 3.327(a) (2009). The RO provided the Veteran with appropriate VA examinations for the issue adjudicated by this decision. There is no objective evidence indicating that there has been a material change in the severity of the service-connected disability since the Veteran was last examined in 2009. 38 C.F.R. § 3.327(a). Furthermore, the Board finds that the VA examination reports obtained in this case are more than adequate, as they are predicated on a full reading of the medical records in the Veteran's claims file. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 310-11 (2007). The reports provide objective evidence of the current state of disability associated with the service-connected mental disorder and consider all of the pertinent evidence of record including the statements of the appellant. Accordingly, the Board finds that VA's duty to assist with respect to obtaining VA examinations or opinions concerning the issue on appeal has been met. 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c) (4). The requirements of 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c)(4) have been met. No additional pertinent evidence has been identified by the appellant as relevant to the issue decided herein for which attempts to obtain the evidence have not been made. Under the circumstances of this particular case, no further action is necessary to assist the appellant. Analysis The Veteran submitted a claim of entitlement to an increased rating for her service-connected psychiatric disorder in August 2001. At that time, the disability was evaluated as 30 percent disabling. In July 2009, the RO granted an increased rating to 70 percent, effective from August 2001. The Veteran has not indicated that she is satisfied with the 70 percent evaluation and the issue remains in appellate status. Disability evaluations are determined by comparing a veteran's present symptomatology with criteria set forth in the VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities (Rating Schedule), which is based on average impairment in earning capacity. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. Part 4. When a question arises as to which of two ratings applies under a particular diagnostic code, the higher evaluation is assigned if the disability more closely approximates the criteria for the higher rating. 38C.F.R. § 4.7. After careful consideration of the evidence, any reasonable doubt remaining is resolved in favor of the veteran. 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. The veteran's entire history is reviewed when making disability evaluations. 38 C.F.R. 4.1; Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1995). In deciding the veteran's claim, the Board has considered the determinations in Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119 (1999) and Hart v. Mansfield, 21 Vet. App. 505 (2007). In Fenderson, the Court held that evidence to be considered in the appeal of an initial assignment of a disability rating was not limited to that reflecting the then current severity of the disorder. In that decision, the Court also discussed the concept of the "staging" of ratings, finding that, in cases where an initially assigned disability evaluation has been disagreed with, it was possible for a veteran to be awarded separate percentage evaluations for separate periods based on the facts found during the appeal period. Id. at 126. Hart appears to extend Fenderson to all increased evaluation claims. Under the applicable criteria in the regulations, major depressive disorder is evaluated under a general rating formula for mental disorders. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, DC 9434. To warrant a rating in excess of 70 percent, the evidence of record must show total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation or own name. A review of the claims file demonstrates that a rating in excess of 70 percent is not warranted at any time during the appeal period. The medical evidence of record does not show that the Veteran has manifested any of the enumerated criteria for a 100 percent evaluation. The evidence of record demonstrates that the Veteran does not experience total social impairment as she maintains a relationship with her daughter, her friends and with church members. The evidence of record demonstrates that, while the service- connected mental disorder is productive of some industrial impairment, this does not rise to a level of total impairment. There is no evidence of record which demonstrates that the Veteran is unemployable solely due to her service-connected mental disorder. Employment problems have also been attributed to problems with her knees. In August 2000, the Veteran was found to be in a euthymic mood and affect. She presented with no new emotional problems. Another record dated the same month reveals the Veteran was found to be doing well with her anxiety/depression. In October 2001, the Veteran reported having a rough time the previous month which was attributed to problems with her car, financial problems and concerns about losing her memory. She denied being too depressed. On VA examination in February 2002, the Veteran reported she liked her job and liked to work with elderly people. Mental status examination revealed that she was alert, casually dressed, oriented times three and had fair memory. She denied hallucinations and delusions. She denied suicidal and homicidal ideation. Judgment appeared fair by objective questions. Affect was congruent and appropriate. The diagnosis was recurrent major depression with severe episodes. A Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) of 60-65 was assigned. A VA clinical record dated in March 2002 shows the Veteran presented with no new mental problems with the exception of concerns about memory. She enjoyed her employment. She sometimes spoke about recurrent depressions and suicidal thoughts but she had no plans. She was not found to be overtly depressed. In October 2002, the Veteran was in a bright mood and affect despite her claim of losing her job. She reported she fell asleep several times on the job. She denied being depressed. In April 2003, the Veteran was in a euthymic mood and affect. She completed her studies the previous March and was looking for a job. Her main concern was her memory. The Veteran testified before the undersigned in September 2003 that she was employed as of that month. She had been unemployed for approximately a year and six months. She was terminated from her previous employment for sleeping on the job. She did not think her mental problems were the cause of her termination. She opined that she had problems with employment in the past due to mental problems. She did not think her current job was affected by her service-connected disability. She was active in her church and intermittently attended a play or movie. She did not date. She had friends and acquaintances whom she socialized with. She did not think she had any major depressive episodes in the preceding year due to her medication. She reported recent feelings of withdrawing from people. She had memory problems. She reported being angry at times. She reported impaired judgment such as borrowing money that she shouldn't have. She preferred working the night shift as she did not like dealing with people. She had difficulties in the past dealing with coworkers. In September 2003, the Veteran did not have any new complaints except for concerns with her memory and cognitive functioning. No significant mental status changes were noted. In October 2003, the Veteran reported she had trouble being around people and would get easily irritated. She tended to stay at home and had to make herself get out at least once per day or she would not get out at all. She was trying to find a job which would not require much to do with people or that was too stressful. In February 2004, the Veteran had a bright mood and affect. She was employed and seemed to like it. She still voiced concerns about memory. No significant mental status changes were noted. In June 2004, the Veteran complained of memory problems. In October 2004, the Veteran's affect was bright and animated. She was employed and had bought a new car. No significant mental status changes were noted. In March 2005, the Veteran presented with no new emotional problems. She had recently lost her job and began work in a nursing home but had been advised to quit due to her knees. In July 2005 the Veteran's affect was bright and animated. She was working on another job monitoring inmates in a half- way house. She reported she loved the job. In May 2006, the Veteran reported she was doing all right with no significant problems or complaints. She appeared to doing okay cognitively. A VA clinical record dated in June 2006 demonstrates the Veteran was working full time in a program working with inmates. She denied any recent suicidal ideation. An assessment of memory found the results were generally adequate. It was possible that depression and anxiety had affected her performance and perception of performance on some cognitive tasks. In September 2006, the Veteran reported she felt alright. Mental status examination revealed she was alert, oriented and cooperative in no acute emotional distress. No significant mental status changes were noted. In January 2007, the Veteran was in a bright and pleasant mood. She had been sleeping alright. She was recognized as employee of the month. In April 2007, the Veteran was in a bright mood and affect. She denied new problems or complaints. She worked for the same job but had been working 8 days straight due to there being a staff shortage. Mentally she appeared to be emotionally stable. In July 2007, the Veteran denied being depressed but admitted to a lot of concerns. Her parents were not in the best of health. She was thinking of seeking a self-employment job to be near her parents. In September 2007, the Veteran voiced concerns regarding her parent's health. She also reported some issues concerning her job with inmates giving her problems. She had not been sleeping well. In November 2007, the Veteran was noted to be doing better dealing with depression and her sleep since a medication increase. She was alert, oriented and cooperative. In January 2009, the Veteran reported she had episodes, which did not last long, where she felt down and sometimes got upset. She denied suicidal ideation, homicidal ideation and audio/visual hallucinations. She was well dressed and groomed. Speech was normal rate, volume and inflection. Thought processes were goal directed and logical. Judgment and insight were fair. Cognition was grossly intact. A March 2009 clinical record shows the Veteran reported she had memory problems for two years. The medication she took for depression helped a lot but she continued to feel hopeless at times. She went through periods of depression and was currently sad but had no suicidal or homicidal ideation. She was not working but was looking for work. She was neatly attired. Conversational speech and language were intact for the purposes of the evaluation. Thinking was circumstantial. Affect was appropriate and mood was euthymic. Testing was interpreted as showing slowed information processing. The results were within normal limits for testing in other specific cognitive domains. Memory perception/construction, language and executive functions were intact. The slowed information processing was likely due to the chronic psychiatric diagnoses. In April 2009, the Veteran reported problems with memory and being angry at times. She had anxiety, anger and sleep disturbance affecting her. She denied any thoughts of harming herself. Thought processes were goal oriented. There were no delusions or hallucinations. Suicidal and homicidal ideation was not present. It was the physician's opinion that the Veteran was not a danger to self or others. The most recent VA examination was conducted in June 2009. The Veteran was unemployed. She had a close relationship with her daughter and several long term friends. She tried to speak with her friends daily and tried to socialize with them as well. She went to dinner and plays with friends but not as much as she used to. She reported she was often irritable and sometimes avoidant of others because of problems managing her anger. She tried to keep herself active in order to fight her depressive tendency to lie in bed all day. She reported problems remembering to pay bills but was able to perform activities of daily living. She was unemployed. She reported difficulty dealing with stress at her previous employment where she worked at a half-way house. One day, she became verbally aggressive on the job. She reported a history of verbal aggression but no physical aggression. She had difficulties finding a job due to problems with her knees and depression. The Veteran had moved to the Houston area one year prior to live with her mother after her father died in 2007. She had been unemployed since that time. No symptoms of impulsivity, mania, psychosis or obsessive compulsive disorder were observed. Mental status examination revealed that the Veteran was casually groomed. Her thoughts were logical and goal directed with no evidence of hallucinations or delusions. Speech was of normal rate and volume. He mood was depressed and her affect was constrained. She denied homicidal or suicidal ideation, plan or intent. She was oriented to time and place. She could not accurately complete the serial sevens or threes but was able to correctly spell a five letter word backward. The diagnosis was recurrent severe major depressive disorder. A GAF of 55 was assigned. The examiner summarized by writing that the Veteran continued to report symptoms of major depressive disorder including depressed mood, loss of interest in activities she used to enjoy, social withdrawal, sleep disturbance by sleeping too much, low energy, overeating, feelings of worthlessness, helplessness and hopelessness. She had problems with memory and occasional suicidal ideation. Her psychiatric condition did appear to impair her ability to work, but she may be able to work in a limited fashion, under certain constraints such as from home where she could make her own schedule and avoid regular interactions with co-workers. The examiner opined that the Veteran's psychiatric condition would likely result in occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms and disturbances in mood and motivation, sleep disturbances, and difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work relationships. The GAF score of 55 was based on severe psychiatric symptoms. The Board finds the above evidence demonstrates that a rating in excess of 70 percent is not warranted for the service- connected major depressive disorder. The evidence suggests, in fact, that the Veteran has been overrated, at least up until the last year. The clinical records do not document significant problems with the Veteran's social or industrial functioning up until the time of the most recent VA examination. She has consistently been able to maintain relationships with her daughter and has indicated that she socializes with friends. There are allegations made by the Veteran as to problems interacting with co-workers but these allegations are outweighed by the Veteran's other statements indicating that she enjoyed the different jobs she held during the appeal period without reference to problems with co-workers. There is no objective evidence indicating that the Veteran had problems with co-workers. As recently as January 2007, the Veteran had been recognized as an "employee of the month." The Board finds the preponderance of the evidence demonstrates that the Veteran does not have significant problems with employment due to her service- connected disability. The greatest level of impairment is that shown at the time of the June 2009 VA examination and this examiner opined that the Veteran had difficulties with employment but could still work. The evidence of record documents that the Veteran voluntarily left her last employment to move to Houston to help her mother. The examiner who conducted the most recent VA examination, in summarizing the Veteran's psychiatric status, quoted from the language used to denote a 50 percent evaluation under the General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders. This use of the exact words from the rating criteria for a 50 percent evaluation lends credence to the Board's finding that the service-connected major depressive disorder does not warrant a rating in excess of 70 percent and as stated above, the service-connected disability has in the past been overrated. The Board's inquiry is not necessarily strictly limited to the criteria found in the VA rating schedule. See Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436 (2002) [the criteria set forth in the rating formula for mental disorders do not constitute an exhaustive list of symptoms, but rather are examples of the type and degree of the symptoms, or their effects, that would justify a particular rating]. However, the Board has not identified competent evidence of symptomatology associated with the Veteran's service-connected mental disorder which would enable it to conclude that the criteria for a higher rating have been approximated. The Board finds that the GAF scores assigned during the appeal period support a finding that an increased rating is not warranted for the service-connected major depressive disorder. The Court has held that GAF scores are a scale reflecting the "psychological, social, and occupational functioning on a hypothetical continuum of mental health- illness." See Carpenter v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 240, 242 (1995); Richard v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 266 (1996) (citing the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed.), p. 32 (DSM-IV)). GAF scores ranging between 81 and 90 reflect absent or minimal symptoms (e.g., mild anxiety before an exam), good functioning in all areas, interested and involved in a wide range of activities, socially effective, generally satisfied with life, no more than everyday problems or concerns (e.g., an occasional argument with family members). GAF scores ranging between 71 and 80 reflect that if symptoms are present they are transient and expectable reactions to psychosocial stressors (e.g., difficulty concentrating after family argument; no more than slight impairment in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., temporarily falling behind in schoolwork). GAF scores ranging between 61 to 70 reflect some mild symptoms (e.g., depressed mood and mild insomnia) or some difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., occasional truancy, or theft within the household), but generally functioning pretty well, and has some meaningful interpersonal relationships. GAF scores ranging from 51 to 60 reflect more moderate symptoms (e.g., flat affect and circumstantial speech, occasional panic attacks) or moderate difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., few friends, conflicts with peers or co-workers). DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS (DSM), 32 (4th ed.) (1994) (DSM IV); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.125, 4.130. In the current case, the majority of the clinical records include GAF scores (set out in the record as being "v") in the 70's and 80's. These numbers correspond to, at most, a 30 percent evaluation under the General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders. The VA examinations resulted in the lowest GAF scores assigned which were 60-65 in June 2002 and 55 in June 2009. This level of impairment under the GAF system only represents moderate difficulty. The Board notes the examiner who conducted the most recent VA examination wrote that a GAF of 55 was assigned based on severe symptoms. However, the preponderance of the other medical evidence of record documents that this level of impairment is not representative of the Veteran's overall functioning. For these reasons and bases, the Board finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against the Veteran's claim for a disability rating higher than 70 percent for her major depressive disorder during the entire appeal period. And as the preponderance of the evidence is against her claim, the doctrine of reasonable doubt is not for application. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b); 38 C.F.R. § 4.3; Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53-56 (1990). Accordingly, the appeal is denied. The Board has considered whether the Veteran is entitled to a greater level of compensation on an extra-schedular basis. Ordinarily, the VA Schedule will apply unless there are exceptional or unusual factors which would render application of the schedule impractical. See Fisher v. Principi, 4 Vet. App. 57, 60 (1993). According to the regulation, an extraschedular disability rating is warranted based upon a finding that the case presents such an exceptional or unusual disability picture with such related factors as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization that would render impractical the application of the regular schedular standards. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1). An exceptional case is said to include such factors as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization as to render impracticable the application of the regular schedular standards. See Fanning v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 225, 229 (1993). Under Thun v. Peake, 22 Vet App 111 (2008), there is a three- step inquiry for determining whether a veteran is entitled to an extraschedular rating. First, the Board must first determine whether the evidence presents such an exceptional disability picture that the available schedular evaluations for that service-connected disability are inadequate. Second, if the schedular evaluation does not contemplate the claimant's level of disability and symptomatology and is found inadequate, the Board must determine whether the claimant's disability picture exhibits other related factors such as those provided by the regulation as "governing norms." Third, if the rating schedule is inadequate to evaluate a veteran's disability picture and that picture has attendant thereto related factors such as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization, then the case must be referred to the Under Secretary for Benefits or the Director of the Compensation and Pension Service to determine whether, to accord justice, the veteran's disability picture requires the assignment of an extraschedular rating. With respect to the first prong of Thun, the evidence in this case does not show such an exceptional disability picture that the available schedular evaluation for the service- connected major depressive disorder is inadequate. A comparison between the level of severity and symptomatology of the service-connected disability with the established criteria found in the rating schedule under Diagnostic Code 9434 shows that the rating criteria reasonably describe the Veteran's disability level and symptomatology. Higher ratings are available if additional symptomatology is demonstrated. See Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361, 363 (1993) [noting that the disability rating itself is recognition that industrial capabilities are impaired]. The Board therefore has determined that referral of this case for extra-schedular consideration pursuant to 38 C.F.R. 3.321(b)(1) is not warranted. ORDER The appeal is denied. ____________________________________________ BARBARA B. COPELAND Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs