Citation Nr: 1006136 Decision Date: 02/19/10 Archive Date: 03/02/10 DOCKET NO. 06-14 162 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in St. Paul, Minnesota THE ISSUE Entitlement to waiver of the recovery of an overpayment of VA nonservice-connected pension benefits in the amount of $28,512. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: The American Legion ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD Linda E. Mosakowski, Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from July 1974 to December 1975. This matter comes to the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Committee on Waiver and Compromises (Committee) in St. Paul, Minnesota, that denied entitlement to a waiver of the recovery of an overpayment of VA nonservice-connected pension benefits in the amount of $28,512. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. In March 2002, service connection was granted for the Veteran's tinnitus and hearing impairment of the left ear, with the assignment of a 10 percent disability rating, and nonservice-connected pension was granted. Both benefits were effective from January 9, 2002. Since the pension benefit payment was $796 per month and the service connection compensation payment was $64 per month, the Veteran elected to receive pension benefits rather than compensation payments. The Veteran had no income from the Social Security Administration (SSA) at that time. 2. The Veteran was granted disability benefits from the SSA effective from April 1, 2002, in the monthly amount of $732. 3. The Veteran failed to notify VA when his countable income was increased by the SSA disability benefit payments. 4. From April 2002 until May 2005, the Veteran received pension payments that had not been adjusted for the SSA disability payments. 5. In a March 2005 letter, VA notified the Veteran that evidence received from the SSA showed that his income had changed as of April 1, 2002, and VA proposed to reduce his benefits payments as a result of including the SSA disability payments in countable income. 6. In June 2005, the Debt Management Center at the RO notified the Veteran that an overpayment in the amount of $28,512 had been created and provided him with information about how to seek a waiver of recovery of that overpayment debt. 7. The Veteran filed a timely request for a waiver of recovery of the overpayment debt in July 2005. 8. There was no fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith on the part of the Veteran in the creation of the pension overpayment in the amount of $28,512. 9. The Veteran bears all fault in the creation of the overpayment and he did not change position in reliance on receiving the April 2002 to May 2005 pension benefits to which he was not entitled. 8. Collecting the overpayment from the Veteran would neither create undue hardship to him or his family nor defeat the purpose for which nonservice-connected pension benefits were intended; rather, to waive recovery of the overpayment would unjustly enrich the Veteran. CONCLUSION OF LAW Recovery of the overpayment of VA nonservice-connected pension benefits in the amount of $28,512 does not violate the standard of equity and good conscience. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1506, 1521, 5302 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 1.962, 1.963, 1.965, 3.159, 3.271, 3.272, 3.277, 3.660 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION I. Duties to notify and to assist The obligations to notify and to assist claimants concerning the information and evidence needed to substantiate a claim for VA benefits that are found in 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103 and 5103A (and the implementing regulations) do not apply to requests to waive the recovery of an overpayment. Barger v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 132 (2002). The statute governing waiver claims, however, has its own notice provisions. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5302. In a waiver claim, the payee must be notified of his right to apply for a waiver and be provided with a description of the procedures for submitting the application. The Veteran was sent proper notice of the overpayment debt in June 2005. That notice included an enclosure explaining the procedures for filing a waiver of collection of the overpayment debt. Thus, the notice requirements were met. II. Waiver of collection of an overpayment debt A. Factual Background In March 2002, service connection was granted for the Veteran's tinnitus and hearing impairment of the left ear, with the assignment of a 10 percent disability rating, and nonservice-connected pension was granted. Both benefits were effective from January 9, 2002. Since the pension benefit payment was $796 per month and the service connection compensation payment was $64 per month, the Veteran elected to receive pension benefits rather than compensation benefits. The Veteran had no income from the Social Security Administration (SSA) at that time. In July 2004, the SSA notified the Veteran that he had been awarded Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits. The letter explained to the Veteran that he was being sent a check for $2,166, for the period between December 2001 and March 2002 and no further payments would be sent to him at that time because he had too much income after March 2002. Since SSI is paid to help disabled individuals who have little income, such payments are considered "public welfare" and are therefore excluded from countable income for purposes of calculating the VA pension benefits. 38 C.F.R. § 3.272(a). The Veteran was also granted Disability Compensation benefits from the SSA effective from April 1, 2002, in the monthly amount of $732. Disability benefits are considered compensation paid by the SSA and are therefore included in countable income. 38 C.F.R. § 3.271(g). The Veteran failed to notify VA when his countable income was increased by the monthly SSA Disability Compensation benefit payments. From April 2002 until May 2005, the Veteran received pension payments that had not been adjusted for the SSA Disability Compensation payments that should have been included in countable income. In a March 2005 letter, VA notified the Veteran that evidence received from the SSA showed that his income had changed as of April 1, 2002, and VA proposed to reduce his benefits payments as a result of including the SSA disability payments in countable income. In June 2005, the Debt Management Center at the RO notified the Veteran that an overpayment in the amount of $28,512 had been created and provided him with information about how to seek a waiver of recovery of that overpayment debt. The Veteran filed a timely request for a waiver of recovery of the overpayment debt in July 2005. That request was denied by the Committee in September 2005 and the Veteran appealed. After the November 2005 statement of the case was issued, the Veteran perfected his appeal. B. Entitlement to a waiver of collection of an overpayment Nonservice-connected pension is payable to a Veteran of wartime at rates prescribed by law, reduced by the amount of the Veteran's annual income. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1521. For pension purposes, payments of any kind from any source will be counted as income during the 12-month annualization period in which received, unless specifically excluded under the provisions of 38 C.F.R. § 3.272. 38 C.F.R. § 3.271(a). Compensation paid by the Social Security Administration for a disability is explicitly included in countable income. 38 C.F.R. § 3.271(g). Supplemental Security Income paid by the SSA is excluded from countable income. 38 C.F.R. § 3.272(a). A person who is receiving pension benefits is required to report to VA in writing any material change or expected change in net worth, in his or her income or that of a spouse or dependent child, or in another circumstance that affects the payment of benefits. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1506(3); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.277(b), 3.660. An overpayment is created when a payee has received monetary benefits to which he or she is not entitled. 38 C.F.R. § 1.962. Here, the Veteran received monthly pension payments from April to November 2002 in the amount of $796, when he should have received $64 per month. Similar monthly overpayments were made until May 2005. The total overpayment is in the amount of $28,512. Overpayments created by the retroactive discontinuance of pension benefits will be subject to recovery unless waived. 38 C.F.R. § 3.660(a)(3). Recovery of the overpayment of any VA benefits must be waived if: (1) the application for relief is filed in a timely manner; (2) there is no indication of fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith on the part of the person having an interest in the waiver; and (3) recovery of the indebtedness from the payee who received such benefits would be against equity and good conscience. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5302(a), (c). An application for waiver generally is timely if it is made within 180 days from the date of VA's notification to the payee of the indebtedness. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5302(a); 38 C.F.R. § 1.963(b)(2). Here, the Veteran was notified of the overpayment indebtedness in June 2005 and he filed his application for a waiver the following month. Thus, the Veteran's application was timely filed. As for the second requirement, the statute prohibits a waiver if there is an indication of fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith on the part of the appellant. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5302(c). The regulations provide that it is not necessary that the debtor undertakes conduct with actual fraudulent intent if such conduct is undertaken with intent to seek an unfair advantage, with knowledge of the likely consequences, and the result of that conduct is a loss to the government. 38 C.F.R. § 1.965(b)(1). In this regard, a waiver is not warranted if a material fact is misrepresented, or there is unfair dealing or deceptive dealing. 38 C.F.R. § 1.965(b)(1). But this record contains no evidence of fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith on the part of the Veteran. To be sure, the Veteran failed to notify VA when he began receiving monthly Disability Compensation benefits from the SSA. But there is no evidence to indicate that those omissions were undertaken with the intent to seek an unfair advantage of the government, rather than a mistake. With respect to the third requirement, the "equity and good conscience" standard is applied when the facts and circumstances in a particular case indicate a need for reasonableness and moderation in the exercise of the government's rights. 38 C.F.R. § 1.965(a). It means arriving at a fair decision between the obligor (the Veteran) and the government. 38 C.F.R. § 1.965(a). In making such a decision, the following factors (which are not an all- inclusive list) must be considered: (1) fault of the debtor; (2) balancing of faults; (3) changing position to one's detriment; (4) undue hardship; (5) defeat of the purpose for which benefits were intended; and (6) unjust enrichment. 38 C.F.R. § 1.965(a) (order of factors changed to facilitate the following discussion). Although the Veteran only makes arguments with respect to undue hardship and fault in the creation of the debt, all factors will be addressed. The Veteran is at fault in the creation of the debt. The law requires him to notify VA when his income changes. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1506(3) (a person who is receiving pension benefits is required to report to VA in writing any material change in his or her income); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.277(b), 3.660. In the March 2002 letter notifying him of his entitlement to VA pension benefits, the Veteran was notified that it was his responsibility to notify VA if his income changed. That letter specifically identified Social Security Benefits as the type of income changes that required the Veteran to notify VA. Moreover, VA enclosed with that letter VA Form 21-8768 (Disability Pension Award Attachment-Important Information) that also explained that the Veteran's pension payments depended upon his income level and that the Veteran was required to report all income to VA. The enclosure also explained that it was important that he contact VA whenever there was a change in any condition affecting his entitlement to benefit. The Veteran did not report the receipt of SSA Disability Compensation benefits. As a result, he received benefits to which he was not entitled. Had the Veteran properly reported his income, no debt would have been incurred. Thus, the debt is the fault of the Veteran. The Veteran asserts that the creation of the debt was not his fault. First, he explains that since he was sent a letter from the SSA about Supplemental Security Income (that is not includable in countable income for VA pension purposes), and was never sent a letter from SSA about Disability Compensation benefits, he mistakenly believed that the monthly benefits he was receiving from the SSA were SSI benefits. September 2005 Notice of Disagreement; see also January 2006 Substantive Appeal. As a lay person, the Veteran is competent to present evidence of what he believed and what letters he received. 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(a)(2) (lay evidence can be provided by a person who has no specialized education, training, or experience, but who knows the facts or circumstances and conveys those matters that can be observed and described by a lay person). But just because evidence is competent does not mean that it is credible. In determining the weight to be assigned to evidence, credibility can be affected by inconsistent statements, internal inconsistency of statements, inconsistency with other evidence of record, facial implausibility, bad character, interest, bias, self-interest, malingering, desire for monetary gain, and witness demeanor. Caluza v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 498, 511, 512 (1995), aff'd per curiam, 78 F.3d 604 (Fed. Cir. 1996). It is the responsibility of the Board to weigh the evidence and determine where to give credit and where to withhold the same and in so doing, the Board may accept some evidence and reject other evidence. Evans v. West, 12 Vet. App. 22, 30 (1998). Here, the Veteran's statements about how the creation of his debt is not his fault are not credible. It is plausible that a lay person generally may not know the differences between Supplemental Security Income benefits and Disability Compensation benefits paid by the SSA. But from the evidence in the record, it is not plausible that this particular Veteran did not know that the monthly benefits he was receiving from SSA were Disability Compensation benefits that he needed to report to VA. First, the July 2004 letter from the SSA upon which the Veteran is relying as his only correspondence from the SSA, clearly advised him that his Supplemental Security Income benefits would be sent in a check for $2,166, and that no further Supplemental Security Income benefits would be sent to him at that time. The second page of that letter explained that any SSI benefits were determined on the basis of his income, including his VA pension benefits, his one- time payment from VA for retroactive benefits, unearned income that was received in March and April 2002, and his Social Security benefits of $757 per month for June 2004 through September 2004. The SSA explained further that because of that income, the Veteran was not eligible to receive SSI benefits after April 2002. Yet, notwithstanding the explanations in that letter, the Veteran claims that when he began receiving monthly checks, he believed that the monthly amounts were SSI benefits, not Disability Compensation benefits from the SSA. Second, it is not plausible that the Veteran did not know that he had been granted Disability Compensation benefits from the SSA. The Veteran had filed a claim for those benefits, which was granted by the SSA, effective from April 2002. It is not plausible that by June 2005, when the overpayment notice was sent, that the Veteran had never checked on the status of his Disability Compensation benefits claim. Moreover, by asserting that the only letter he had ever received from the SSA was the SSI benefits letter of July 2004, the Veteran is implying that he never received any of the annual notices from that agency that his monthly Disability Compensation benefits had been increased due to an increase in the cost of living. Thus, his argument is based on a claim that more than one letter from the SSA to him concerning Disability Compensation benefits never arrived- only the letter discussing SSI benefits excludable from VA's countable income was received by the Veteran. Finally, in the March 2002 letter from VA explaining how the Veteran's pension benefits would be calculated, VA instructed the Veteran to submit to VA information about all of his annual income and VA would determine which of it was to be excluded from countable income. The Veteran did not follow those instructions. Instead, he failed to report to VA any income at all from the SSA. As a result, the creation of an overpayment is the fault of the Veteran. In the alternative, the Veteran argues in a May 2005 VA Form 21-4138 (Statement in Support of Claim) that he did advise VA of his Social Security income and he included with that statement the first page of the July 2004 SSA letter. See also January 2006 Substantive Appeal (I immediately reported the July 2004 SSA notice to VA and was told this didn't count against my pension benefit). But the claims folder does not contain any correspondence from the Veteran about Social Security benefits until May 2005, after VA had notified him that his pension benefits would be reduced by the amount of his SSA Disability Compensation benefits. There are no VA Forms 21-0516-1 (Improved Pension Eligibility Verification Report) in the claims folder reporting the Veteran's income and net worth. The absence of any communication to or from the Veteran in the claims folder on this matter undercuts the Veteran's credibility in stating that he had reported the income from the SSA. There is a presumption of regularity under which it is presumed that government officials "have properly discharged their official duties." United States v. Chemical Foundation, Inc., 272 U.S. 1, 14-15 (1926). His credibility concerning his notice to VA of his SSA benefits is also lessened by an inconsistent statement that he made in his September 2005 notice of disagreement. In that document, the Veteran stated that he had received the July 2004 letter from the SSA about his SSI benefits, which are excluded from countable income for VA pension purposes. He argued in that document that since he received no other notice from the SSA, he felt he had taken all necessary action with VA. That statement implies that he felt that no action with VA was necessary because the SSI benefits were excluded from countable income. Finally, the Veteran argues that the recovery of the debt should be waived because he did not intentionally cause the overpayment. September 2006 Substantive Appeal. But even if the Veteran were actually confused about the type of benefits he was receiving monthly from the SSA, his failure to report that income caused the overpayment. Even if a genuine mistake had been made, the fault would still lie with the Veteran, who made the asserted mistake. The Veteran was required to notify VA of any changes in his income. When he began receiving monthly benefits from the SSA, he failed to report that income. As a result, the creation of the overpayment debt is the fault of the Veteran. The government, on the other hand, has no fault in the creation of the debt. Once VA was made aware that the Veteran was receiving Disability Compensation from the SSA, the Veteran was contacted about a potential overpayment and further payments were stopped after the Veteran was given 60 days to request a hearing on the matter. Thus, the relative fault of the parties lies entirely on the Veteran. There is no evidence in the record that the Veteran changed his position in reliance on receiving the nonservice- connected pension benefits during the period when he was not entitled to receive those benefits. The Veteran argues that to collect the debt would create financial hardship. July 2005 VA Form 5855 (Financial Status Report). Using the financial data supplied by the Veteran in July 2005, with adjustments for expenses that do not occur monthly (propane, auto insurance, and trailer taxes), the Veteran's monthly expenses total $666 and his monthly Disability Compensation benefits from the SSA total $778. Thus, even if the entire VA benefit were withheld until the overpayment debt were collected, the Veteran still would have $112 per month above his monthly expenses. He also owns a car, a motorcycle, and a trailer/boat/camper worth a total of $3,350. And the Veteran has submitted no additional evidence since the payments were withheld in June 2005 showing that actual financial hardship has arisen. Since this factor concerns whether collection would deprive the debtor of basic necessities, the record does not establish undue hardship in this case. As for whether recovering the overpayment would defeat of the purpose for which the benefits were intended, since he was a wartime Veteran, when he had income below the specified level, VA was authorized to pay him benefits so that his income would be increased to meet that specified level. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1521. This particular Veteran has income that is almost at that specified level-with a shortfall of approximately $66 per month. Since the information in the record shows that the Veteran is more than able to meet the basic necessities of life, collecting the debt would not defeat the purpose for which the pension benefits were intended. The last factor to be considered is unjust enrichment. The Veteran accepted pension benefits at a time when he was not entitled to them, so he was definitely enriched by the overpayment. As to whether that enrichment would be unjust, the Veteran has not shown any reason why he should not be required to repay the $28,512 to which he was not entitled. As noted above, he merely points out that creation of the overpayment was not intentional. Having raised no equitable reason for waiver that is supported by the record, to permit the Veteran to retain the benefits to which he was not entitled would be unjust enrichment. Since the evidence in the record with respect to the factors to be considered and the arguments of the Veteran fail to show that recovery would violate the standard of equity and good conscience, the recovery of the overpayment will not be waived. Nor is this determination affected by the benefit of the doubt doctrine. When there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence about a claim, reasonable doubt should be resolved in the claimant's favor. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b); 38 C.F.R. § 3.102. But as discussed above, the Veteran's positive evidence as to why the creation of the debt was not his fault is not credible and the evidence submitted as to his financial hardship establishes that factor against the claim. When the credibility of the evidence is taken into account, the evidence against the claim is much greater than that in favor, so that there is no reasonable doubt to resolve. Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49 (1990) (benefit of the doubt rule inapplicable when the preponderance of the evidence is against the claim). ORDER Waiver of the recovery of the overpayment of VA nonservice- connected pension benefits in the amount of $28,512, is denied. ____________________________________________ S. L. Kennedy Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs