Citation Nr: 1006239 Decision Date: 02/19/10 Archive Date: 03/02/10 DOCKET NO. 08-27 055 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Manchester, New Hampshire THE ISSUE Entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU). REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: New Hampshire State Veterans Council ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD Simone Krembs, Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from October 1964 to October 1968. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from an August 2007 rating decision of a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) that denied the claim of entitlement to a TDIU rating. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The Veteran's service-connected disabilities include posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with secondary major depressive disorder, evaluated as 50 percent disabling; a right shoulder disability, evaluated as 40 percent disabling; and a cervical spine disability, evaluated as 20 percent disabling, for a combined schedular evaluation of 80 percent. 2. The Veteran's service-connected disabilities are of such severity so as to preclude substantially gainful employment for which he would otherwise be qualified. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for the assignment of a TDIU rating have been met. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5103, 5103A, 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.159, 3.340, 3.341, 4.1-4.14, 4.16 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION Notice and Assistance Requirements The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) and implementing regulations impose obligations on VA to provide claimants with notice and assistance. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107, 5126 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a) (2009). The VCAA is not applicable where further assistance would not aid the appellant in substantiating his claim. Wensch v. Principi, 15 Vet App 362 (2001); see 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A(a)(2) (Secretary not required to provide assistance "if no reasonable possibility exists that such assistance would aid in substantiating the claim"); see also VAOPGCPREC 5-2004; 69 Fed. Reg. 59989 (2004) (holding that the notice and duty to assist provisions of the VCAA do not apply to claims that could not be substantiated through such notice and assistance). In view of the Board's favorable decision in this appeal, further assistance is unnecessary to aid the veteran in substantiating his claim. TDIU Rating In order to establish entitlement to TDIU due to service- connected disabilities, there must be impairment so severe that it is impossible for the average person to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16. In reaching such a determination, the central inquiry is whether the veteran's service-connected disabilities alone are of sufficient severity to produce unemployability. Hatlestad v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 524 (1993). Consideration may be given to the veteran's level of education, special training, and previous work experience in arriving at a conclusion, but not to his age or to the impairment caused by nonservice-connected disabilities. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.341, 4.16, 4.19; Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361 (1993). The regulatory scheme for a TDIU provides both objective and subjective criteria. Hatlestad v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 524 (1993); VAOPGCPREC 75-91 (Dec. 27, 1991), 57 Fed. Reg. 2317 (1992). The objective criteria, set forth at 38 C.F.R. § 3.340(a)(2), provide for a total rating when there is a single disability or a combination of disabilities that results in a 100 percent schedular evaluation. Subjective criteria, set forth at 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a), provide for a TDIU when, due to service-connected disability, a veteran is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation, and has a single disability rated 60 percent or more, or at least one disability rated 40 percent or more with additional disability sufficient to bring the combined evaluation to 70 percent. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16(a). In exceptional circumstances, where the veteran does not meet the aforementioned percentage requirements, a total rating may nonetheless be assigned upon a showing that the individual is unable to obtain or retain substantially gainful employment as a result of service- connected disability. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b). Here, the Veteran is service-connected for PTSD with secondary major depressive disorder, evaluated as 50 percent disabling; for a right shoulder disability, evaluated as 40 percent disabling; and for a cervical spine disability, evaluated as 20 percent disabling, for a combined schedular evaluation of 80 percent. The Veteran thus meets the percentage criteria laid out in 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). The remaining question before the Board therefore is whether the Veteran is unemployable by reason of his service- connected disabilities alone, taking into consideration his educational and occupational background. A review of the record demonstrates that from the time the Veteran filed his claim for a TDIU rating in January 2007, to July 2008, when he retired, he was employed on a full time basis as a mail handler with the United States Postal Service. In November 2006, the Veteran underwent VA psychiatric examination in conjunction with his claim for service connection for PTSD. When questioned as to his current psychiatric symptoms, the Veteran stated that he had a sleep disorder, memory loss, and loneliness. He added that he did not socialize much with his coworkers, but noted that there were a few coworkers that he did trust "on a certain level." He additionally reported other physical problems, including arthritis, a cervical spine disorder, a right shoulder disability, left foot problems, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, and a kidney problem. With regard to his social history, the Veteran stated that he was currently married to his second wife of 36 years. He described the marriage as "fantastic," and noted that he had one biological daughter, one stepdaughter, and one stepson. He described his relationship with them as "very good." With regard to his occupational history, the Veteran stated that he was currently employed on a full time basis as a mail handler at the Post Office. He stated that he had been there for 22 years. He felt that his boss was fairly happy with his performance. He acknowledged that there had been a time at work when he had gotten into a screaming match and walked out on the job, but that had not happened recently. In general, he stated that he had a hard time getting along with people, noting that he had a bad temper and did not trust people. Mental status examination revealed an anxious and depressed mood with a flattened affect. The Veteran's behavior was noted to be tense and rigid. His thought process was determined to be goal-directed and logical. There were no preoccupations, obsessions, or delusions. He denied experiencing hallucinations or illusions, and also denied experiencing suicidal or homicidal ideations. The examiner determined that there was some impairment of attention and concentration, resulting in problems with short-term memory. In addition, the Veteran reported problems with long-term memory. The examiner determined that the Veteran met the criteria for a diagnosis of PTSD, with symptoms in the moderate range. The examiner classified his symptoms as moderate, rather than severe, because the Veteran was "still functioning at work," and had a good relationship with his family. The Veteran underwent a general VA examination in July 2007. At the time of the examination, the Veteran stated that he had been working as a mail handler for the past 23 years. He noted that he had missed numerous days of work as a result of his neck, shoulder, and PTSD. Since January 1, 2007, he had missed a total of 26 days from work as a result of medical leave associated with these disabilities. The Veteran described his current right shoulder problems as manifested by a chronic dull pain that became sharp at times. He had flare ups with use and nonuse, with severe flare ups occurring three to four times weekly. He stated that he had undergone arthroscopic repair of his rotator cuff several years ago, and had been advised to undergo additional surgery, but could not currently afford to be "out" for six months. Steroid injections provided only temporary relief. His cervical spine disability was also manifested by chronic dull pain that became sharp at times. Flare ups occurred approximately twice per week. He additionally described experiencing pain, numbness, and tingling that radiated down the right upper extremity. Physical examination revealed painful range of motion of the right shoulder and cervical spine. The right shoulder disability was felt to have a mild-to-moderate effect on his activities of daily living, and a moderate effect on his ability to work as a mail handler. The cervical spine disability was felt to have a mild effect on his activities of daily living, and a mild-to-moderate effect on his work as a mail handler. The examiner opined that although the Veteran was currently working, he did have difficulty working in his trained field as a mail handler due to his cervical spine and right shoulder disabilities. However, neither disability would preclude the Veteran from obtaining gainful occupation in a field that involved sedentary employment. The Veteran underwent a VA psychiatric examination in July 2007, with the same examiner who conducted the November 2006 examination. When asked to describe his current psychiatric functioning, the Veteran stated that he had a lot of anger, noting that he got annoyed very easily. He stated that he had frequent outbursts with people, and that he argued a lot. He reported experiencing nightmares that he was unable to remember afterwards. He stated that he felt as though his psychotropic medication regimen was not helping much. With regard to his occupational functioning, the Veteran stated that he continued to work full-time as a mail handler. He noted, however, that his performance was down, and that his supervisors were complaining about the lack of work he had been doing. He had had several arguments with his supervisors, with the most recent one occurring on the Sunday before the examination. He estimated that he argued with his supervisors two to three days per month as a result of his psychiatric disability. He stated that he got about six hours of restless sleep per night. His sleep was fraught with dreams and nightmares. He stated that he generally awoke at least twice per night. His marriage continued to be "very good." He stated that he did not know what he would do without his wife. He described his relationship with his children as "good." However, he stated that he had no friends, and that he only socialized with his immediate family members once a month, and with his extended family approximately once every three months. He reported current hobbies including gardening and doing yard work. Mental status examination revealed a depressed and anxious mood with an affect that was appropriate to mood content. His behavior was notable for being very apathetic, rigid, and tense. He looked very tired. His speech was soft, slow, hesitant, and monotonous. He denied experiencing hallucinations or illusions. His thought process was determined to be goal-directed and logical. There was no evidence of any obsessions, although the Veteran was preoccupied with his failing mental health. He described experiencing paranoid delusions where he saw people driving by his house and looking at him. He then wondered why they were checking him out. He admitted experiencing suicidal ideations of a passive nature but denied experiencing homicidal ideations. There were mild problems with attention and concentration, resulting in mild short-term memory problems. He also had problems with long-term memory. Common sense reasoning and judgment as well as ethical and moral thinking were determined to be dependent upon his stress level. The examiner opined that the Veteran's PTSD symptoms were in the "serious" range, mostly because he had no friends and because he was having greater and greater difficulty on the job and isolated himself. The Veteran's global assessment of functioning (GAF) was 45. With regard to his current employment, the examiner noted that the Veteran was having greater and greater difficulties, and at some point he was either going to get fired or was going to hurt someone at work. Therefore, with respect to his current job, it was the examiner's opinion that he needed to find some other gainful employment where he perhaps could work alone, where there was less stress, and perhaps fewer hours. The examiner felt that the Veteran had deteriorated since he had seen him in November 2006. In sum, the Veteran's PTSD symptoms were of a serious nature. His symptoms were constant, and there had been no periods of remission. His symptoms seriously affected his occupational functioning, as he was currently losing two to three days of work each week. His symptoms also seriously affected his social functioning, as he isolated himself. In a November 2007 statement submitted in support of his claim, the Veteran described the current severity of his PTSD. He stated that he only seldomly spoke to his daughters on the phone, once or twice a month, at most. He stated that he felt depressed and anxious at least three to four times per week, and that he was experiencing significant trouble with both his short- and long-term memory. His memory difficulties were negatively affecting his ability to be productive at work. He continued to have difficulty with establishing and maintaining interpersonal relationships. VA treatment records dated from September 2007 to January 2008 show that the Veteran received treatment for PTSD symptoms consistent with those noted above. Records dated in September 2007 show that he reported that he was struggling with work. He went home exhausted and might fall asleep. He then had difficulty sleeping later on, and even if he was able to sleep, he awoke feeling unrefreshed. Both his PTSD and his right shoulder disability were making it difficult for him to work. He noted that he was filing paperwork for Family and Medical Leave as a result of both disabilities. The treating clinician noted that the Veteran appeared to have deteriorated since his last visit, and that he might need to take "days off" to manage his stress." In November 2007, the Veteran stated that he had recently experienced flare ups of back and shoulder pain and had had to call out of work several times. He added that he did not feel well enough to engage in activities at home. The treating clinical noted that the Veteran's fluctuating PTSD symptoms, in addition to pain associated with his neck and shoulder, had caused him to miss work on several occasions. VA treatment records dated at the end of June 2008 show that the Veteran complained of neck pain, with a recent exacerbation of pain. He stated that he was independent with his activities of daily living and with driving. He currently worked for the Post Office but noted that he was retiring later that week. He denied any functional deficits secondary to his neck pain. Prior to his retirement in July 2008, the functional limitations imposed by the Veteran's service-connected disabilities did not preclude his performance of substantially gainful employment. The record shows, however, a steady decline in the Veteran's functioning at work as the result of his service connected disabilities. While there is no medical opinion as to the combined impact of the service connected disabilities, the most recent VA psychiatric examination yielded a GAF indicative of an inability to work and an opinion that the Veteran would have to work in employment with little human contact and limited hours. Examiners who assessed the service connected physical disabilities found that these conditions limited the Veteran to sedentary employment. The record contains little, if any, evidence that the Veteran has experience in employment that would qualify him for employment that was both sedentary and isolated. Even if such employment were feasible, it is unclear whether such employment could be gainful, given the Veteran's ability to work only limited hours. Based upon the foregoing, and resolving reasonable doubt in the Veteran's favor, the Board concludes that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities alone have rendered him unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation since he left full time employment in July 2008. Accordingly, he is entitled to a TDIU. ORDER Entitlement to a TDIU rating is granted. ____________________________________________ Mark D. Hindin Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs