Citation Nr: 1007066 Decision Date: 02/25/10 Archive Date: 03/05/10 DOCKET NO. 06-07 474 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania THE ISSUE Entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities (TDIU). REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Appellant ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD D. Schechter, Counsel INTRODUCTION The veteran had active service in the U.S. Navy from April 1969 to February 1973. The appeal comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from a January 2005 rating decision by the above Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO), which denied TDIU. In the course of appeal, in March 2008, the Veteran testified before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge at a Travel Board hearing conducted at the RO. A transcript of the hearing is contained in the claims file. The Board in October 2008 remanded the TDIU claim for additional development, and it now returns for further review. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. For the entire rating period on appeal, the Veteran's service-connected hearing loss and tinnitus have not presented such an exceptional or unusual disability picture affecting employment so as to warrant consideration of unemployability on an extraschedular basis. 2. For the entire rating period on appeal, the service- connected disabilities have not precluded substantially gainful employment so as to warrant TDIU. CONCLUSION OF LAW For the entire rating period on appeal, entitlement to TDIU is not warranted, on a schedular or extraschedular basis. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155, 5103, 5103A, 5107 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.159, 3.321(b)(1), 4.16(a),(b) (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION I. Duty to Notify and Assist The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) enhanced VA's duty to notify and assist claimants in substantiating their claims for VA benefits. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5100, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107, 5126 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a) (2009). Upon receipt of a complete or substantially complete application for benefits, VA is required to notify the claimant and his representative of any information, and any medical or lay evidence, that is necessary to substantiate the claim. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a); 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b); Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183 (2002). Proper notice from VA must inform the claimant of any information and evidence not of record (1) that is necessary to substantiate the claim; (2) that VA will seek to provide; and (3) that the claimant is expected to provide. 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b)(1) (2009). This notice must be provided prior to an initial decision on a claim by the RO. Mayfield v. Nicholson, 444 F.3d 1328 (Fed. Cir. 2006); Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112 (2004). If complete notice is not provided until after the initial adjudication, such a timing error can be cured by subsequent legally adequate VCAA notice, followed by readjudication of the claim, as in a Statement of the Case (SOC) or Supplemental Statement of the Case (SSOC). Moreover, where there is an uncured timing defect in the notice, subsequent action by the RO which provides the claimant a meaningful opportunity to participate in the processing of the claim can prevent any such defect from being prejudicial. Mayfield v. Nicholson, 499 F.3d 1317, 1323-24 (Fed. Cir. 2007); Prickett v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 370, 376 (2006). The U.S. Supreme Court has held that an error in VCAA notice should not be presumed prejudicial, and that the burden of showing harmful error rests with the party raising the issue, to be determined on a case-by-case basis. Shinseki v. Sanders, 129 S. Ct. 1696 (2009). In this case, the appellant has not demonstrated any prejudicial or harmful error in VCAA notice. A claim for TDIU is a claim for increased rating. Hurd v. West, 13 Vet. App. 449 (2000). In a claim for increased rating, the VCAA requirement is generic notice, that is, the type of evidence needed to substantiate the claim, namely, evidence demonstrating a worsening or increase in severity of the disability and the effect that worsening has on employment and earning capacity, as well as general notice regarding how disability ratings and effective dates are assigned. Vazquez-Flores v. Shinseki, 580 F.3d 1270 (Fed. Cir. 2009). The Veteran was afforded a VCAA notice letter in June 2004, prior to the appealed RO adjudication of the claim for TDIU in January 2005. The notice letter informed him of the notice and duty-to-assist provisions of the VCAA, and of the information and evidence necessary to substantiate the claim, as well as informing of the respective roles of the Veteran and VA in developing the claim and obtaining evidence, with the ultimate responsibility for ensuring that relevant evidence is obtained being on the Veteran. The letter also provided the Veteran with general notice of the evidence required to satisfy the claim. He was also afforded notice of how disability ratings and effective dates are assigned, by notice letters afforded him in November 2006 and January 2007 addressing then pending and underlying claims for service connection for hepatitis C (a request to reopen) and HIV, and in April 2007 addressing an underlying claim for service connection for PTSD, by which letters the RO was then complying with the requirements of Dingess v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). The Veteran was thereafter afforded further readjudication of the claim in a February 2009 SSOC. VA's duty to assist the Veteran in the development of the claim includes assisting him in the procurement of service medical records and pertinent treatment records and providing an examination when necessary. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. The Board finds that the RO appropriately assisted the Veteran in obtaining indicated treatment and evaluation records, and associated all records obtained with the claims folder. Service treatment records were previously obtained and associated with the claims file. The RO also informed the Veteran, including in the appealed rating action and by an SOC and SSOCs, of records obtained, and thus by implication of records not obtained, in furtherance of his claim. Although the Board recognizes that the underlying service- connected disabilities of hearing loss and tinnitus may change in severity over time, judicial efficiency precludes continuous updating of the evidentiary record so as to assure that no more recent disease progression as pertaining to the Veteran's TDIU claim is missing from the claims file. Such continual updating, with the associated requirement of RO review of the new evidence prior to Board adjudication, pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 19.37, would ultimately preclude the Board from workable efficiency in adjudication of claims before it. Such a consequence would necessarily deprive the Veteran, and indeed all veterans, of the benefit of the Board's expedient review and adjudication. In addition, the Veteran has not submitted any statement indicating that his hearing loss and tinnitus have increased in severity since the most recent VA examination in July 2004, upon which the RO based its January 2005 decision granting service connection for those disorders and assigning the initial ratings for them - ratings that remain in place currently. VA's duty to assist the Veteran by providing examinations when necessary was adequately fulfilled. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. While it is true that the noted July 2004 VA examination was not benefited by a review of the claims file, for the limited purposes of the TDIU adjudication herein there is no reasonable possibility that a further VA audiology examination benefited by such a review would further the claim. The VA examiner provided an apparently accurate assessment of the level of hearing loss and tinnitus disability, including based on the Veteran's reported history of those disorders. There is no indication that these disorders were of greater severity then than found on that examination or that they are of materially - for purposes of this TDIU claim based solely on those two service-connected disabilities (as the only service-connected disabilities whose severity is herein considered for the TDIU claim) - of greater severity now, or that the testing and evaluation conducted at that examination would somehow have been different based on the past medical and other records as contained in the claims file. Indeed, nothing in the past or more recent records contradicts or casts doubt upon the validity of the findings of the July 2004 VA examiner. Accordingly, the Board finds that the July 2004 examination, taken together with records of VA, private, and service treatment, and statements and testimony by the Veteran, as well as other evidence of record, are adequate for the Board's adjudication herein. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. The VA examination, taken as a whole, addressed both the medical findings upon examination and the Veteran's history, and presented findings and conclusions consistent with his medical history and sufficiently addressing the criteria for rating the disorders in question to allow the Board to adjudicate the claim based on informed medical findings and medical judgment. The Board accordingly concludes that additional medical evaluation would amount to no more than a fishing expedition. Hence, further examination would constitute an unreasonable delay and expenditure of scarce VA resources. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.303 (2009); Counts v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 473, 478- 9 (1994) and Gobber v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 470, 472 (1992) (VA's statutory duty to assist is not a license for a "fishing expedition"). The Board further finds that the requirements of the Board's October 2008 remand have been substantially fulfilled. The RO had already adjudicated the claims for service connection for PTSD and hepatitis C by a June 2007 rating action (the Board in October 2008 believed those claims had not yet been adjudicated because a copy of the June 2007 rating action had not yet been associated with the claims file), and the RO subsequently by a February 2009 rating action adjudicated the Veteran's claim for service connection for PTSD. The RO thereafter by a February 2009 SSOC readjudicated the claim for TDIU. Only substantial, and not strict, compliance with the terms of a Board remand is required pursuant to Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268 (1998). D'Aries v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 97 (2008). No further statement has been received by the Veteran indicating the existence of additional pertinent evidence not requested. The case presents no reasonable possibility that additional evidentiary requests would further the appealed claim. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A(a)(2); 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. Hence, no further notice or assistance to the appellant is required to fulfill VA's duty to assist the appellant in the development of the claim. Smith v. Gober, 14 Vet. App. 227 (2000), aff'd 281 F.3d 1384 (Fed. Cir. 2002); Dela Cruz v. Principi, 15 Vet. App. 143 (2001); see also Quartuccio, supra. In summary, with regard to the TDIU claim herein adjudicated, the Board finds that any error in notice and development assistance cannot "reasonably affect the outcome of the case," and hence will not affect "the essential fairness of the [adjudication]" for the ratings assigned for the rating period in question, for the appealed claim. ATD Corp. v. Lydall, Inc., 159 F.3d 534, 549 (Fed. Cir. 1998); Mayfield v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 103 (2005). The Veteran was duly afforded the opportunity to produce additional evidence to support his claim. Thus, the Board determines that the evidentiary record is adequate, and the only significant medical question remaining pertaining to the Veteran's claim for TDIU - that of objective or corroborating evidence of greater service-connected disability - was in this case, based on development already undertaken, the responsibility of the Veteran. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.303. In view of the foregoing, the Board finds that all notification and development actions needed to render a decision on the Veteran's claim on appeal herein adjudicated have been accomplished. II. Claim for TDIU A TDIU rating may be assigned where the schedular rating is less than total, when the disabled person is, in the judgment of the rating agency, unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service- connected disabilities, provided that if there is only one such disability it must be ratable at 60 percent or more, and if there are two or more disabilities at least one disability must be ratable at 40 percent or more and the combined rating must be at least 70 percent or more. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). A veteran's age is not for consideration in making the determination. 38 C.F.R. § 4.19. To establish a total disability rating based on individual unemployability on the regular basis, there must be an impairment so severe that it is impossible for the average person to follow a substantially gainful occupation. 38 C.F.R. § 3.340. In reaching such a determination, the central inquiry is whether the Veteran's service-connected disabilities alone are of sufficient severity to produce unemployability. Hatlestad v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 524, 529 (1993). For a veteran to prevail on a claim for a total compensation rating based on individual unemployability, the record must reflect some factor which takes the case outside the norm. The sole fact that a veteran is unemployed or has difficulty obtaining employment is not enough. A high rating in itself is recognition that the impairment makes it difficult to obtain or keep employment, but the ultimate question is whether the Veteran is capable of performing the physical and mental acts required by employment, not whether the Veteran can find employment. Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361 (1993). Factors to be considered are the Veteran's education, employment history and vocational attainment (without consideration of his advanced age or of the effects of non-service-connected disabilities). See Ferraro v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 326, 332 (1991). In exceptional circumstances, even where the Veteran does not meet the schedular percentage requirements under 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a), TDIU may still be assigned on an extraschedular basis, upon a showing that the Veteran is unable to obtain or retain substantially gainful employment due to service- connected disabilities. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.321(b)(1), 4.16(b). However, where such an exceptional case is indicated, the Board is to refer the case to the Director of the VA Compensation and Pension Service for extraschedular consideration. Id. Under 38 C.F.R. § 3.321, an extraschedular evaluation may be assigned in exceptional cases where the schedular evaluations are found to be inadequate. The governing norm in such cases, for individual disabilities, is a finding that the case presents such an exceptional or unusual disability picture with such related factors as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization as to render impractical the application of the regular schedular standards. 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1). The Board is also not precluded from concluding, on its own, that referral for extraschedular consideration is not warranted. See Bagwell v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 337, 339 (1996) (BVA may affirm an RO conclusion that a claim does not meet the criteria for submission pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1) or reach such a conclusion on its own). Medical evidence is generally required to establish a medical diagnosis or to address other medical questions, and lay assertions do not constitute competent evidence for these purposes. Espiritu v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 492, 494 (1992). However, lay statements may serve to support claims by supporting the occurrence of lay-observable events or the presence of disability or symptoms of disability subject to lay observation. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(a); Jandreau v. Nicholson, 492 F.3d 1372, 1376 (Fed Cir. 2007); see Buchanan v. Nicholson, 451 F.3d 1331, 1336 (Fed. Cir. 2006) (addressing lay evidence as potentially competent to support presence of disability even where not corroborated by contemporaneous medical evidence). See also Davidson v. Shinseki, 581 F.3d 1313 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 14, 2009) ("in some cases, lay evidence will be competent and credible evidence of etiology"). In this case, the Veteran's only service-connected disabilities are tinnitus, service connected and rated 10 percent disabling from January 17, 2003, and bilateral hearing loss, service connected and rated noncompensably disabling from that same date. The Veteran has not contended, either by submitted statements or by hearing testimony, and the evidentiary record does not otherwise show, that these two service-connected disabilities, either separately or together, are preclusive of substantially gainful employment. The Veteran was afforded a VA audiology examination in July 2004, and that examiner noted that the veteran's principal complaint was hearing loss, for which he wore hearing aids. He denied vertigo symptoms, though he did report the presence of constant tinnitus. On the authorized audiological evaluation, pure tone thresholds, in decibels, were as follows: HERTZ 500 1000 2000 3000 4000 Average 1000 - 4000 RIGHT 15 25 50 65 70 53 LEFT 15 25 50 55 55 46 Speech audiometry revealed speech recognition ability of 88 percent in the right ear and of 88 percent in the left ear. The examiner assessed severe high frequency sensorineural hearing loss in the right ear, and moderately severe to severe sensorineural hearing loss in the left ear. The tinnitus was matched with a four kilohertz tone at five decibels. The examiner assessed that the Veteran would continue to benefit from hearing amplification, and that medical intervention was not indicated. The Veteran's tinnitus is currently assigned a 10 percent evaluation, and his hearing loss is assigned a noncompensable evaluation. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.87, Diagnostic Code 6260 (applicable regulation and code for rating tinnitus); Smith v. Nicholson, 451 F.3d 1344 (Fed. Cir. 2006) (applicable case law for rating tinnitus); 38 C.F.R. § 4.85, Tables VI and VIa, Diagnostic Code 6100 (applicable regulations and code for hearing loss). Those ratings are not the subject of the current appeal, and hence the Board is without jurisdiction to review them. The Veteran has not indicated any special circumstances which would cause the regular schedular standards not to be applicable in rating these two disorders, and the record does not otherwise show any special circumstances with regard to these two disorders. He has also not indicated an increase in severity of these two disorders since the July 2004 VA examination, and there is otherwise no indication that the findings upon that examination are not indicative of the degree of disability presented as a result of the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus. The weight of the evidentiary record is against tinnitus or hearing loss being present which is disabling in a manner rendering inapplicable the regular schedular standards for those disorders, or disabling in a manner preclusive of substantially gainful employment so as to represent disability from these disorders not represented by the Rating Schedule. Hence, upon consideration of 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1), the Board finds that neither of these exceptions apply in this case to render inapplicable the regular schedular requirements for a claim for TDIU under 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). The Court has held that, "if the criteria reasonably describe the claimant's disability evel and symptomatology, then the claimant's disability picture is contemplated by the rating schedule, the assigned schedular evaluation is, therefore, adequate, and no referral is required." Thun v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 111, 115 (2008). Therefore, the Board has concluded that referral of this case for extra-schedular consideration is not in order. Thus, because the Veteran does not meet the regular schedular standards with a combined service-connected disability rating of only 10 percent, TDIU is not warranted in this case. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). The Board has duly considered the question of TDIU over some lesser time interval, but finds no basis for that in the present case. The Veteran was service connected for PTSD at a 50 percent level from December 30, 1996, at a 100 percent level from November 24, 2003 (based on hospitalization under 38 C.F.R. § 4.29), and then again at the 50 percent level from April 1, 2004. However, service connection for that disorder was found to have been improper, and hence service connection was severed effective from April 1, 2006. He submitted his claim for TDIU in April 2004, and hence the TDIU claim, which is a type of claim for increased rating, must be considered for an interval over which service connection for PTSD was still in effect. (Because a TDIU claim is a claim for increased compensation, the effective date rules for increased compensation apply to a TDIU claim. See Hurd, supra.) We acknowledge that the severance decision focused not on whether the original decision was clearly erroneous, but on whether all the evidence "establishes that [service connection] is clearly erroneous." Stallworth v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 482 (2006). Nonetheless, the Board will not grant TDIU on the basis of PTSD for any interval prior to the April 1, 2006, effective date of service connection severance for PTSD, now that service connection for PTSD has been found to have been erroneous, because to do so would further compound that error. While VA has not sought the return of any disability benefits paid out for the Veteran's PTSD during the interval of erroneous service connection, VA is not obligated to commit further error now on the basis of that prior error of service connection where, as here, that error of service connection has been corrected. The Board notes that in the course of appeal the Veteran had pending a claim for restoration of service connection for PTSD, which the Board denied in its October 2008 decision, and which was not appealed to the Court. The Veteran also had pending claims for service connection for hepatitis C (a request to reopen that claim) and for HIV-related illness, but these service connection claims were denied by a June 2007 rating action. That rating action was not appealed. The Veteran was also denied service connection for PTSD by a February 2009 rating action denying a new PTSD claim, and that determination was also not appealed. Accordingly, while the Veteran may have been potentially supported on a severity-of-combined-disabilities evidentiary basis in his contentions of unemployability due to PTSD, hepatitis C, and HIV-related illness, that question of severity-of-combined disabilities for those claimed disabilities is not addressed herein because those claims for service connection were denied, and hence those disorders are not for consideration in the Veteran's claim for TDIU. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16. ORDER Entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities is denied. __________________________ ANDREW J. MULLEN Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs