Citation Nr: 1008080 Decision Date: 03/04/10 Archive Date: 03/11/10 DOCKET NO. 08-10 876 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Muskogee, Oklahoma THE ISSUE Entitlement to a total disability evaluation based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities (TDIU). REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: The American Legion WITNESSES AT HEARING ON APPEAL The Veteran and his spouse ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD Terrence Griffin, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from May 1983 to April 1987. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a November 2007 rating decision of the Muskogee, Oklahoma, Regional Office (RO) of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), which denied the appellant's claim of entitlement to TDIU. The Veteran submitted a Notice of Disagreement in December 2007 and timely perfected his appeal in April 2008. In June 2009, the Veteran testified before the undersigned Acting Veterans Law Judge, who was designated by the Chairman to conduct the hearings pursuant to 38 U.S.C.A. § 7102(b) (West 2002 & Supp. 2009) and who participated in this decision. A transcript of this proceeding has been associated with the claims file. FINDING OF FACT The competent medical evidence of record supports a finding that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities render him unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities have been met. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16, 4.19 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The appellant seeks entitlement to TDIU. In the interest of clarity, the Board will first discuss certain preliminary matters. The issue on appeal will then be analyzed and a decision rendered. I. The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) The Board has given consideration to the VCAA. The VCAA includes an enhanced duty on the part of VA to notify a claimant as to the information and evidence necessary to substantiate a claim for VA benefits. The VCAA also redefines the obligations of VA with respect to its statutory duty to assist claimants in the development of their claims. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103, 5103A (West 2002). The Board is granting the Veteran's claim of entitlement to TDIU. Accordingly, any failure to provide complete notice or assistance under the VCAA in the development of this claim has been rendered moot and no further discussion is therefore necessary. II. The Merits of the Claim In general, after the evidence has been assembled, it is the Board's responsibility to evaluate the entire record. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a) (West 2002). When there is an approximate balance of evidence regarding the merits of an issue material to the determination of the matter, the benefit of the doubt in resolving each such issue shall be given to the claimant. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 3.102 (2009). In Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53 (1990), the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) stated that "a veteran need only demonstrate that there is an 'approximate balance of positive and negative evidence' in order to prevail." To deny a claim on its merits, the preponderance of the evidence must be against the claim. See Alemany v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 518, 519 (1996), citing Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 54. Relevant Law and Regulations It is the established policy of VA that all veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (2009). A finding of total disability is appropriate "when there is present any impairment of mind or body which is sufficient to render it impossible for the average person to follow a substantially gainful occupation." See 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340(a)(1), 4.15 (2009). "Substantially gainful employment" is that employment "which is ordinarily followed by the nondisabled to earn their livelihood with earnings common to the particular occupation in the community where the veteran resides." See Moore v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 356, 358 (1991). "Marginal employment shall not be considered substantially gainful employment." See 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) (2009). The Court noted the following standard announced by the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit in Timmerman v. Weinberger, 510 F.2d 439, 442 (8th Cir. 1975): It is clear that the claimant need not be a total 'basket case' before the courts find that there is an inability to engage in substantial gainful activity. The question must be looked at in a practical manner, and mere theoretical ability to engage in substantial gainful employment is not a sufficient basis to deny benefits. The test is whether a particular job is realistically within the physical and mental capabilities of the claimant. A claim for a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability "presupposes that the rating for the [service-connected] condition is less than 100%, and only asks for TDIU because of 'subjective' factors that the 'objective' rating does not consider." See Vettese v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 31, 34-35 (1994). In Hatlestad v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 164 (1991), the Court referred to apparent conflicts in the regulations pertaining to individual unemployability benefits. Specifically, the Court indicated there was a need to discuss whether the standard delineated in the controlling regulations was an "objective" one based on the average industrial impairment or a "subjective" one based upon the Veteran's actual industrial impairment. In a pertinent precedent decision, the VA General Counsel concluded that the controlling VA regulations generally provide that veterans who, in light of their individual circumstances, but without regard to age, are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation as the result of service-connected disability shall be rated totally disabled, without regard to whether an average person would be rendered unemployable by the circumstances. Thus, the criteria include a subjective standard. It was also determined that "unemployability" is synonymous with inability to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation. See VAOPGCPREC 75-91. In determining whether unemployability exists, consideration may be given to the Veteran's level of education, special training and previous work experience, but not to his age or to any impairment caused by non service-connected disabilities. See 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.341, 4.16, 4.19 (2009). Schedular Basis A total disability rating for compensation may be assigned, where the schedular rating is less than total, when the disabled person is, in the judgment of the rating agency, unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities, provided that, if there is only one such disability, this disability shall be ratable at 60 percent or more. If there are two or more disabilities, there shall be at least one disability ratable at 40 percent or more and the combined rating must be 70 percent or more. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) (2009). Extraschedular Basis Pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b), when a claimant is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities, but fails to meet the percentage requirements for eligibility for a total rating set forth in 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a), such case shall be submitted for extraschedular consideration in accordance with 38 C.F.R. § 3.321. As has been discussed in the law and regulations section above, TDIU may be awarded on either a schedular basis or an extraschedular basis. As explained below, in this case only the schedular basis need be considered. Analysis The Veteran is currently service connected for: a major depressive disorder (50 percent disabling); the residuals of a right clavicle fracture (30 percent disabling); cariomyopathy (30 percent disabling); tinnitus (10 percent disabling); hypertension (10 percent disabling); and for hearing loss (noncompensable). Accordingly, the Veteran meets the criteria for schedular consideration of TDIU. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) (2009). For reasons stated immediately below, the Board finds that the evidence of record demonstrates that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities render him unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation. The Veteran has testified that he is incapable of sustaining employment due to his service-connected depression and the residuals of his right clavicle fracture. See Board Hearing Transcript, p. 6, June 17, 2009. The Veteran reported working in a manufacturing plant from May 1995 until October 2007, when he ceased working. He was placed on short-term disability leave from April 2007 until October 2007, when he became entitled to a retirement pension. The evidence of record, including an August 2007 VA psychological examination, indicates that the Veteran ceased working in April 2007, as a result of surgery related to a non-service connected disorder. Nevertheless, the record further reflects that since August 2007, his depression symptoms have increased. For example, during his August 2007 VA examination, aside from passive suicidal ideation and a depressed affect, the Veteran's mental status examination was normal and no cognitive or mental impairments were noted. Conversely, a January 2008 private psychological examination found the Veteran to be: severely depressed; to have "significant thinking and concentration problems"; to demonstrate resentment and hostility towards others; to be withdrawn and isolated; and to have poor judgment. The private psychologist that conducted this examination, supplemented this examination report in a May 2009 medical opinion, opining that the Veteran was "permanently disabled and unable to work...more likely than not...[because of] his service connected Depression." See Private Treatment Record, D.O.B., Ph. D., May 21, 2009. The conclusion of the Veteran's private psychologist (D.O.B., M.D.) is further supported by the lay statements of the Veteran and his spouse. The Veteran testified that his service-connected shoulder disorder hindered his ability to work effectively at his former manufacturing job, and because of a work related accident his former employer required monthly depression counseling. See Board Hearing Transcript, pp. 5-6, June 17, 2009. The Veteran's spouse provided similar testimony concerning the impact the Veteran's depression symptoms had on his employment and also detailed the negative effect the Veteran's depression symptoms had on their marital relationship. Id. at p. 8. The Board finds this lay testimony, to the extent it relates to symptoms and the perception of the impact these symptoms had on the Veteran's employment, to be competent and credible. See Savage v. Gober, 10 Vet. App. 495-97 (1997). Although both the August 2007 VA examination and the private psychologist's May 2009 medical opinion diagnose the Veteran with depression, the January 2009 private psychological examination and the May 2009 private psychologist's medical opinion also diagnose a cognitive disorder, not otherwise specified. This suggests some of the noted mental and psychological symptoms that prevent the Veteran from working might be attributable to the non-service connected cognitive disorder. However, the Board is unable to discern to what extent the Veteran's service-connected disabilities and his nonservice-connected cognitive disorder independently impact his ability to work. Consequently, the Board must conclude that the Veteran's inability to work is solely attributable to his service-connected disabilities. See Howell v. Nicholson, 19 Vet.App. 535, 540 (2006); see also Mittleider v. West, 11 Vet .App. 181, 182 (1998) (application of benefit of the doubt doctrine requires Secretary to attribute inseparable disabilities to claimant's service-connected disability). It is also noted that the currently assigned 50 percent disability rating for depression anticipates considerable occupational impairment; and, while the Veteran does not currently meet the criteria for a 100 percent schedular rating for depression, such a rating involves a social component, in addition to an occupational component. In the present matter, the evidence demonstrates that the Veteran has continued relationships with his family such that he is not totally socially impaired. Additionally, the Veteran currently does not have any symptoms listed in the criteria for the assignment of a 100 percent rating. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). Thus, a schedular 100 percent rating for service-connected depression is not warranted. The question, however, with a TDIU is different in that it is a determination of whether the Veteran is precluded from working on account of his service-connected disabilities. There is no social component in this determination. The evidence demonstrates that the Veteran is unemployable based on his service-connected disabilities, to include depression. The lay statements of the Veteran and his wife make this clear. Furthermore, the Veteran's private psychologist clearly opined that the Veteran's total unemployability was more than likely caused by service-connected depression. Based on the above analysis, the Board concludes that a grant of TDIU is warranted under 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). In conclusion, for the reasons and bases expressed above, the Board finds that the Veteran's claim for TDIU is warranted on a schedular basis. The benefit sought on appeal is accordingly granted. ORDER Entitlement to TDIU is granted, subject to the laws and regulations governing the award of monetary benefits. ____________________________________________ K. A. KENNERLY Acting Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs