Citation Nr: 1014535 Decision Date: 04/16/10 Archive Date: 04/29/10 DOCKET NO. 07-32 937 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Portland, Oregon THE ISSUE Entitlement to service connection for residuals of a broken back. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Oregon Department of Veterans' Affairs WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Appellant ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD J. B. Freeman, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The appellant served on active duty from March 2004 to January 2006. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a September 2006 rating decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Seattle, Washington, which, in pertinent part, denied service connection for residuals of a broken back. Following the September 2007 Statement of the Case, additional evidence was received by the RO while this case was pending development of other claims and awaiting a hearing before the Board. Much of this evidence concerns the circumstances surrounding the appellant's original back injury. The RO did not readjudicate the claim and issue a Supplemental Statement of the Case in accordance with 38 C.F.R. § 19.31(b) (2009). In light of the Board's conclusion that service connection is warranted, any procedural error is moot. The Board will proceed. The appellant testified before the undersigned at a June 2009 hearing at the RO. A transcript has been associated with the file. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The appellant is service-connected for a major depressive disorder. 2. The appellant's depression at least as likely as not led to alcohol abuse. 3. The appellant fell from her barracks room while intoxicated during service, breaking the L1 vertebra, requiring surgical fusion of T12-L2, with additional residuals. CONCLUSION OF LAW The appellant's residuals of a broken back disability were incurred in active service and are not the result of willful misconduct. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1101, 1110, 1112, 1113, 1131, 1154(b), 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.301, 3.303, 3.304 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The appellant contends that she has residuals of a broken back as a result of service. For the reasons that follow, the Board concludes that service connection is warranted. Service connection may be established for a disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by active service. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1110. For the showing of chronic disease in service there is required a combination of manifestations sufficient to identify the disease entity, and sufficient observation to establish chronicity at the time. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(b). If chronicity in service is not established, a showing of continuity of symptoms after discharge is required to support the claim. Id. Service connection may be granted for any disease diagnosed after discharge, when all of the evidence establishes that the disease was incurred in service. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(d). The appellant served on active duty from March 2004 to January 2006. On the night of July 30, 2005, the appellant fell from the window of her second story barracks room, breaking her L1 vertebra, with additional soft tissue damage. The appellant was discovered by another service member and transported to the Mannheim University Clinics. She was admitted and underwent surgery to surgically fuse the T12 to L2 vertebrae. The appellant underwent a January 2006 VA examination, which describes her level of disability as she separated from service. The disability and its inservice origin are established. The Board incidentally notes some confusion regarding the date on which the accident occurred. According to the Mannheim treatment records, the appellant's treatment began in the early hours of July 31, meaning the incident occurred on the night of July 30. During the events in question, the appellant was intoxicated. The appellant had been in treatment for alcohol rehabilitation in service. She had recently failed to complete the program. The appellant eventually received a discharge from service for failure to complete the alcohol rehabilitation program. The July 31, 2005, treatment records show that the appellant was intoxicated when discovered and was still intoxicated in the view of the doctors at Mannheim as she entered surgery. The RO denied service connection on the grounds of willful misconduct. Pursuant to 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 105, 1110 and 1131, "no compensation shall be paid if the disability is the result of the person's own willful misconduct or abuse of alcohol or drugs." Willful misconduct is defined as "an act involving conscious wrongdoing or known prohibited action." It involves deliberate or intentional wrongdoing with knowledge of or wanton and reckless disregard of its probable consequences. Mere technical violation of police regulations or ordinances will not per se constitute willful misconduct. Willful misconduct will not be determinative unless it is the proximate cause of injury, disease, or death. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.1(n). Alcohol use is considered willful misconduct where one deliberately drinks a beverage to enjoy its intoxicating effects, and intoxication results proximately and immediately in disability or death. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.301(c)(2). In Allen v. Principi, the Federal Circuit Court held that veterans can only recover for an alcohol or drug abuse disability secondary to a service- connected disability if they can adequately establish that their alcohol or drug abuse disability is secondary to or is caused by their primary service-connected disorder. 237 F.3d 1368 (Fed. Cir. 2001). So compensation would only result where there is clear medical evidence establishing that the alcohol or drug abuse disability is indeed caused by a veteran's primary service-connected disability. This case primarily concerns situations where the veteran has a service-connected psychiatric disorder and is attempting to receive additional compensation, etc., for his alcohol and/or drug abuse on the premise that it is proximately due to or the result of his service-connected psychiatric disability. The converse of this, however, is not sustainable where he has abused alcohol and/or drugs and wants compensation for it as the primary condition - as opposed to the secondary residual. The RO granted service connection for major depressive disorder in an April 2009 rating decision. The appellant had been diagnosed with major depressive disorder during service. In the rating decision, the RO pointed to the diagnosis of major depressive disorder in April 2005. However, the Board's review of the service treatment records showed major depressive disorder was also diagnosed in August 2004. The appellant had undergone an August 2008 examination for psychiatric disabilities in which she was diagnosed with depression, post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and a borderline personality disorder. The examiner indicated that the appellant had been the victim of multiple sexual assaults, the first in the second grade, with additional assaults during service, leading to her depression and PTSD. The examiner indicated that these psychiatric disabilities had led to her abuse of alcohol. The appellant's representative has submitted a comprehensive argument regarding the dates of sexual assault, her alcohol rehabilitation program, and the inservice diagnosis of major depressive disorder, which is supported by the appellant's service treatment records. The first notation of a sexual assault is an August 2004 treatment note, which is unclear on its face but mentions the pre-service rape and an unexplained recent assault. Treatment notes for unrelated conditions dated in January and February 2005 show a denial by the appellant as to whether she was experiencing depression. However, on April 1, 2005, while seeking treatment for a knee problem, the appellant indicated that although she had had no depression recently, she did experience recurrent depression with sleeping difficulties. On April 8, 2005, the appellant self referred herself for alcohol treatment because her excessive drinking led to blackouts and inappropriate behavior. The diagnosis of major depressive disorder was rendered April 22, 2005, when she said that she had last taken medications for depression in 2004, but that she wanted to go back on medication because she had recently had feelings of hopelessness, loss of interest in activities, and anhedonia. The appellant reported another sexual assault in a June 2005 treatment note, indicating it had occurred one week earlier. The Board finds that the evidence supports service connection. The appellant had multiple sexual traumas, which ultimately led to diagnoses of major depressive disorder and alcohol abuse. That depression has been service-connected. Thus, a disability resulting from alcohol abuse may be service-connected as secondary where there is clear evidence establishing that the alcohol or drug abuse disability is indeed caused by her primary service-connected disability. The August 2008 examination report provides that evidence. The conclusion is reasonable based on the sequence of events. Willful misconduct is not, therefore, a bar to benefits resulting from alcohol abuse. See Allen, supra. As a result, the remaining evidence clearly shows a disability of residuals of a broken back originating during service. Service connection is warranted. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.303, supra. The Board must clarify certain issues regarding the July 30- 31, 2005, incident. The appellant contends, strenuously, that she was thrown from the window of her barracks room. Indeed, most of the material in the claims file that has been submitted in the course of the claim concerns this contention. The appellant reports that she went drinking on the night of July 30, and "blacked out," and that she woke up on the ground outside her barracks room, naked and without remembering what happened. She states that, after her surgery, a sergeant, C.R., admitted that he returned with her to her barracks room that night and had sex with her after she passed out from intoxication. Her contention is that he then threw her from the window. She further states that the window was too high for her to fall out of. The appellant has submitted a note, allegedly from C.R., to the effect that he admitted having sex with her. Many of the statements from friends and other service members concern the admission by C.R. that he had sex with the appellant on the night of the fall. This contention is only relevant to the instant appeal in that the willful misconduct determination made by the RO would be irrelevant if she had been thrown from the window. Had she been thrown out instead of falling out, the misconduct would not have been hers and service connection would be warranted. As the Board is able to conclude that willful misconduct due to alcohol abuse would not be a bar to benefits had she simply fallen, a determination that C.R. threw her from the window is not necessary. Either way, service connection would be granted. The Board must state that the appellant reported in the course of her treatment in Mannheim that she did not remember what happened that night. Her many statements afterward have blamed C.R. without establishing that she did remember. None of the statements submitted by others indicates that any of those individuals had witnessed the events or determined that C.R. had thrown the appellant from the window on the basis of a forensic analysis. None of the statements indicate that C.R. admitted throwing her from the window. The appellant filed a September 2005 complaint with the criminal investigative service of the Army regarding the incident, but there appears to have been no action taken against C.R. In short, there is no competent evidence to support this conjecture. The Board's decision here does not find, and should not be read as finding, that C.R. threw the appellant from the window of her barracks room on the night of July 30, 2005. As such, the Board finds that the evidence is at least in equipoise for the appellant's residuals of a broken back claim. Consequently, the benefit-of-the-doubt rule applies, and the claim must be granted. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b) (West 2002); Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 55 (1990). The claim has been granted; therefore, the Board finds that any error related to the Veterans Claims Assistance Act on the claim is moot. See 38 U.S.C. §§ 5103, 5103A (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. § 3.159 (2009); Mlechick v. Mansfield, 503 F.3d 1340 (Fed. Cir. 2007). ORDER Entitlement to service connection for residuals of broken back is granted. ____________________________________________ MICHELLE L. KANE Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs