Citation Nr: 1014865 Decision Date: 04/19/10 Archive Date: 04/30/10 DOCKET NO. 96-27 534 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Winston- Salem, North Carolina THE ISSUE Entitlement to an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for depressive disorder, for the period between May 1, 1994 and July 30, 2001. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Sean A. Ravin, Attorney WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Appellant ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD M. Zawadzki, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from April 1974 to April 1994, with three years and two months of prior active service. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a June 1995 rating decision issued by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, in which the RO, in pertinent part, granted service connection and assigned an initial 10 percent rating for depressive disorder with complaint of fatigue, effective May 1, 1994. In June 1996, the Veteran testified during a hearing before hearing officer at the RO (RO hearing). A transcript of that hearing is of record. In an October 1996 decision, the RO granted a higher, 30 percent, initial rating for depressive disorder with fatigue, effective May 1, 1994. In March 2000, the Board remanded the claim for an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for further development. In July 2002, the Board denied the claim for a higher initial evaluation for depressive disorder. The Veteran appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). In a July 2003 Joint Motion for Remand, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs (VA) and the Veteran, through her representative, moved that July 2002 decision be vacated and remanded. The Court granted the motion by Order in July 2003. In February 2004, the Board remanded the claim for further development. In a January 2005 rating decision, the RO granted a 50 percent rating for depressive disorder, effective November 22, 2004. In a November 2005 decision, the Board denied an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for depressive disorder, for the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001, granted a 50 percent evaluation for the period from July 31, 2001 to November 21, 2004, and granted a 70 percent evaluation from November 22, 2004. The Veteran appealed that portion of the November 2005 decision which denied an initial rating in excess of 30 percent for the period prior to July 31, 2001, to the Court. In a February 2007 Joint Motion for Remand, the Secretary of VA and the Veteran, through her representative, moved that the portion of the November 2005 decision which denied an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for depressive disorder, for the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001, be vacated and remanded. The Court granted the motion by Order in February 2007. In a November 2007 decision, the Board denied an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001. The Veteran appealed the November 2007 Board decision to the Court. In a March 2009 Joint Motion for Remand, the Secretary of VA and the Veteran, through her representative, moved that the November 2007 decision be vacated and remanded. The Court granted the motion by Order in March 2009. In June 2009, the Board remanded the claim for further development. That development has been completed. Because the Veteran has disagreed with the initial rating assigned following the grant of service connection for depressive disorder, the Board has characterized the issue on appeal in light of Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119, 126 (1999) (distinguishing initial rating claims from claims for increased ratings for already service-connected disability). Further, despite the higher initial rating established for depressive disorder in the October 1996 rating decision, the Veteran has not been awarded the highest possible rating. As a result, she is presumed to be seeking the maximum possible benefit and her claim remains in appellate status. A.B. v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 35 (1993). The Board notes that, in argument submitted in March 2010, the Veteran's attorney asserted that she is entitled to an initial evaluation greater than 30 percent, to include a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities (TDIU), for service- connected depressive disorder, for the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001. In the March 2000 remand, the Board noted that, in his January 2000 Informal Hearing Presentation, the Veteran's representative had raised a claim for a TDIU, which was referred to the RO for appropriate action. This matter was again referred to the RO in the November 2005 Board decision. In an August 2007 rating decision, the RO denied a TDIU. In a July 2008 rating decision, the RO continued to deny the claim for a TDIU. The March 2010 claim for a TDIU for the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001 has not been adjudicated by the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ). Therefore, the Board does not have jurisdiction over this claim and it is referred to the AOJ for appropriate action. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. All notification and development action needed to fairly adjudicate the claim on appeal has been accomplished. 2. From May 1, 1994 through July 30, 2001, depressive disorder was not manifested by more than definite impairment; there was no considerably impaired ability to establish or maintain effective or favorable relationships with people, by reason of psychoneurotic symptoms the reliability, flexibility and efficiency levels were not so reduced as to result in considerable industrial impairment. 3. Under the revised rating criteria, effective November 7, 1006, the evidence reflects that from November 7, 1996 through July 30, 2001, depressive disorder was not manifested by occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short- and long-term memory (e.g., retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; and difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for an initial evaluation greater than 30 percent for depressive disorder for the period from May 1, 1994 through July 30, 2001, have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.1, 4.3, 4.7, 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9411 (1996); 38 C.F.R. § 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9411 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) describes VA's duty to notify and assist claimants in substantiating a claim for VA benefits. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5100, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107, 5126 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a) (2009). The Board notes that the claim for a higher initial rating for the service-connected depressive disorder is a downstream issue, which was initiated by a notice of disagreement. The Court has held that, as in this case, once a notice of disagreement from a decision establishing service connection and assigning the rating and effective date has been filed the notice requirements of 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5104 and 7105 control as to the further communications with the appellant, including as to what "evidence [is] necessary to establish a more favorable decision with respect to downstream elements...." Goodwin v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 128, 137 (2008). In any event, the Veteran was notified of the general provisions of the VCAA by the RO in correspondence dated in March 2004, March 2005, and March 2006. These letters notified the Veteran of VA's responsibilities in obtaining information to assist the Veteran in completing her claim for a higher initial rating, identified the Veteran's duties in obtaining information and evidence to substantiate her claim, and provided other pertinent information regarding VCAA. Thereafter, the claim was reviewed and a supplemental statement of the case was issued in August 2009. See 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a), Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183 (2002), Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112 (2004). See also Mayfield v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 103, 110 (2005), reversed on other grounds, 444 F.3d 1328 (Fed. Cir. 2006); Mayfield v. Nicholson (Mayfield II), 20 Vet. App. 537 (2006); Kent v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 1 (2006), Mayfield v. Nicholson (Mayfield III), 499 F.3d 1317 (Fed. Cir. 2007). During the pendency of the appeal, the Court, in Dingess/Hartman v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006), has held that the VCAA notice requirements apply to all elements of a claim. The Board notes that the Veteran has not been provided specific notice regarding the assignment of disability ratings and effective dates in regard to her claim for a higher initial rating for depressive disorder; however, such omission is not shown to prejudice the appellant. Because the Board's decision herein denies the claim for a higher initial rating, no disability rating or effective date is being, or will be, assigned. Accordingly, there is no possibility of prejudice to the Veteran under the notice requirements of Dingess/Hartman. The Veteran has been made aware of the information and evidence necessary to substantiate her claim and has been provided opportunities to submit such evidence. A review of the claims file shows that VA has conducted reasonable efforts to assist her in obtaining evidence necessary to substantiate her claim during the course of this appeal. Her service treatment records, VA and private treatment records, vocational rehabilitation records, and Social Security Administration (SSA) records have been obtained and associated with the claims file. The Veteran has also been provided with VA examinations to assess the nature of her disability. Furthermore, the Veteran has not identified any additional, relevant evidence that has not been requested or obtained. The Veteran has been notified of the evidence and information necessary to substantiate her claim, and she has been notified of VA's efforts to assist her. See Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183 (2002). As a result of the development that has been undertaken, there is no reasonable possibility that further assistance will aid in substantiating her claim. Law and Regulations Disability evaluations are determined by the application of VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities, which assigns ratings based on average impairment of earning capacity resulting from a service-connected disability. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. Part 4. Where there is a question as to which of two ratings shall be applied, the higher rating will be assigned if the disability picture more nearly approximates the criteria required for that rating. Otherwise, the lower rating will be assigned. 38 C.F.R. § 4.7. After careful consideration of the evidence, any reasonable doubt remaining is resolved in favor of the veteran. 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. The veteran's entire history is to be considered when making disability evaluations. See generally 38 C.F.R. § 4.1; Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1995). Where an increase in the level of a service-connected disability is at issue, the primary concern is the present level of disability. Francisco v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 55 (1994). However, where, the question for consideration is entitlement to a higher initial rating since the grant of service connection, evaluation of the medical evidence since the grant of service connection to consider the appropriateness of "staged rating" (assignment of different ratings for distinct periods of time, based on the facts found) is required. Fenderson, 12 Vet. App. at 126. Where the law or regulations governing a claim are changed while the claim is pending, the version most favorable to the claimant applies (from the effective date of the change), absent congressional intent to the contrary. Karnas v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 308, 312-13 (1991); 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110(g) (West 2002). In deciding such a case, the Board must determine whether the previous or revised version is more favorable to the veteran. However, if the revised version is more favorable, the retroactive reach of that regulation can be no earlier than the effective date of the change, and the Board must apply only the earlier version of the regulation for the period prior to the effective date of the change. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110(g) (West 2002); VAOPGCPREC 3- 2000 (2000). General Rating Formula for Psychoneurotic Disorders: Ratin g The attitudes of all contacts except the most intimate are so adversely affected as to result in virtual isolation in the community. Totally incapacitating psychoneurotic, symptoms bordering on gross repudiation of reality with disturbed thought or behavioral processes associated with almost all daily activities such as fantasy, confusion, panic and explosion of aggressive energy resulting in profound retreat from mature behavior. Demonstrably unable to obtain or retain employment 100 The ability to establish and maintain effective or favorable relationships with people is severely impaired. The psychoneurotic symptoms are of such severity and persistence that there is severe impairment in the ability to obtain or retain employment 70 The ability to establish or maintain effective or favorable relationships with people is considerably impaired. By reason of psychoneurotic symptoms the reliability, flexibility and efficiency levels are so reduced as to result in considerable industrial impairment 50 Definite impairment in the ability to establish or maintain effective and wholesome relationships with people, and when psychoneurotic symptoms result in reduced levels of initiative, flexibility, efficiency, and reliability as to produce definite industrial impairment 30 38 C.F.R. § 4.132, Diagnostic Codes 9400-9411 (effective prior to November 7, 1996). In Hood v. Brown, 4 Vet.App. 301 (1993), the Court invited the Board to "construe" the term "definite" in a manner that would quantify the degree of impairment for purposes of meeting the statutory requirement that the Board articulate "reasons and bases" for its decision. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(d)(1) (West 2002). The VA General Counsel reviewed this matter and concluded that "definite" may be construed to mean "distinct, unambiguous, and moderately large in degree." The General Counsel held that the word "definite" represents a degree of social and industrial inadaptability that is "more than moderate but less than rather large." VAOPGCPREC 9-93 (1993). The Board is bound by this interpretation of the term "definite." 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(c) (West 2002). Effective November 7, 1996, VA amended the rating criteria applicable to mental disorders under 38 C.F.R. § 4.130. 61 Fed. Reg. 52,700 (October 8, 1996). The rating criteria for all psychiatric disorders, with the exception of eating disorders, are as follows: General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders: Ratin g Total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own name 100 Occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near-continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; impaired impulse control (such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a worklike setting); inability to establish and maintain effective relationships 70 Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short- and long-term memory (e.g., retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships 50 Occupational and social impairment with occasional decrease in work efficiency and intermittent periods of inability to perform occupational tasks (although generally functioning satisfactorily, with routine behavior, self-care, and conversation normal), due to such symptoms as: depressed mood, anxiety, suspiciousness, panic attacks (weekly or less often), chronic sleep impairment, mild memory loss (such as forgetting names, directions, recent events) 30 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Codes 9201-9440 (2009). Factual Background and Analysis As noted above, in the June 1995 rating decision, the RO granted service connection and assigned an initial 10 percent rating for depressive disorder, pursuant to Diagnostic Code 9400. In the October 1996 rating decision, the RO granted a 30 percent initial rating, pursuant to Diagnostic Code 9405. Records of VA and private treatment during the period in question reflect findings of and treatment for depression. The Veteran was afforded a VA general medical examination in March 1995. She stated that she was presently unemployed, although she had worked part-time (16 hours a week) as a loan collector, adding that she had to quit secondary to fatigue and not being able to manage her workload at home. The pertinent diagnosis was fatigue secondary to depression. On VA psychiatric examination in March 1995, the Veteran described depression with a tendency towards crying spells during and since service. She described difficulty concentrating and indicated that, despite sleeping reasonably well, she felt tired and fatigued during the day. She added that she had tried working since separation from service, but was unable to continue both because of her physical symptoms and her depression and difficulty concentrating. On examination, she appeared alert and pleasant. Verbal productivity, orientation, memory, insight, and judgment appeared adequate. The diagnosis was depressive disorder, not otherwise specified. During an April 1995 admission assessment at the Albermarle Mental Health Center (AMHC), the Veteran stated that she was so stressed that she could not hold down her part-time job. She indicated that, until recently, she had worked for a bank on the weekends. She stated that her four children lived with her. On examination, thought processes were intact and there were no hallucinations or delusional thinking. She was oriented with good recent and remote memory and judgment appeared good. Her affect matched her conversation and, at times, she became teary. The social worker commented that it was evident that she was depressed, adding that, at times she would not seem to understand the questions posed to her as though she had disassociated for that moment. The Axis I diagnosis was major depression, single episode, severe without psychotic features (principal/primary), and rule out dysthymia, late onset, primary type. During VA treatment in May 1995, the Veteran described herself as feeling sad, with feelings of worthlessness and helplessness. She indicated that she slept little, but was in bed a lot, adding that she got up multiple times to check that the door was locked, her children were alright, the stove was off, etc. She stated that she lived with her adult daughter and three other children, and that her family was supportive. She admitted to suicidal ideation, but was unsure of intentions. She stated that symptoms had worsened since coming off Zoloft, adding that she was more tearful. On mental status examination, mood was sad and irritable and affect was congruent. Speech was slightly soft with normal rhythm and thoughts were goal-directed with some near delusional guilt and repeated checking. There were no auditory hallucinations or paranoia. Memory and concentration seemed intact. Judgment was OK by test, but impaired by history. The physician assigned a Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) score of 55. A June 1995 record of treatment from AMHC reflects that the Veteran had not previously come in as requested because of an increase in her depressive symptoms. She was given new medication. In her July 1995 notice of disagreement, the Veteran asserted that she was unable to work due to her depressive disorder, adding that she attended outpatient therapy and had to take medication daily. A July 1995 record of VA treatment reflects that the Veteran had been on Prozac for approximately two weeks and, prior to that, was on Zoloft for about a month, which she stopped because of headaches. She added that, prior to that, she took Amitriptyline for two weeks, but had constipation. She reported that the medication made her feel in control of her anxiety, adding that she no longer cried uncontrollably, and had not lost her temper for about a month. On mental status examination, she was crying and had depressed mood, but denied suicidal or homicidal thoughts, plan, or intent. The Axis I diagnosis was major depression. A December 1995 report of contact reflects that the Veteran had to withdraw from school during the fall quarter for both financial and medical reasons. Specifically, she reported that her right arm began to cause her some problems, and she missed classes due to pain and medical treatment. She added that she was getting behind in paying her bills, so she took a part-time job as a messenger in an effort to catch up on her bills, and that her work schedule caused her to miss mental health therapy with resulting problems. During treatment in February 1996, the Veteran complained of crying spells and feeling helpless. She described a sad mood, and stated that she was not able to sleep for more than three hours. Affect was restricted. There was no evidence of a formal thought disorder, delusion or paranoia. She denied suicidal ideation and her insight was fair. The diagnoses were major recurrent depression without psychosis, and dysthymia. In her June 1996 Form 9, the Veteran stated that her state of health, prior to being put on medication, severely limited her earning capacity, as she was experiencing loss of energy, crying spells, loss of concentration, and an inability to tolerate frustrations at home and relate to her children. She reported that she was prescribed anti-depressants in April 1995, but continued to have problems concentrating, and subsequently dropped out of college. A June 1996 letter from College of the Albermarle verifies that the Veteran enrolled in classes for the 1995 fall quarter, but withdrew and did not complete the quarter. During the June 1996 RO hearing, the Veteran testified that she had to withdraw from classes due to her nervous condition, depression, and difficulty concentrating and retaining material. She also reported that she was working as a courier, about 15 to 20 hours per week, and that she had been at this job for approximately seven or eight months. She added that, during her employment at the bank, she was very emotional and cried a lot. She stated that she thought she was crying because of her mother, with whom she was very close, who had passed away the prior month. During VA treatment in August 1996, the Veteran denied suicidal ideations, homicidal ideations, and hallucinations. The physician noted that Nortriptyline caused constipation and Zoloft caused severe headaches, but she had done well on Prozac, although she still had some mild depression. There were no findings of delusions or psychosis. Insight and judgment were fair. Affect was tentative and euthymic. During treatment in September 1996, the Veteran's mood was described as "doing well" and it was noted that she was working as a courier. The Axis I diagnoses were major depressive disorder, recurrent, improved; dysthymic disorder, early onset; and obsessive-compulsive disorder. During VA treatment in February 1997, the Veteran reported that she quit her five-day-a-week job because of its stresses and demands, but stated that she was applying for a job on Saturdays (only at the Post Office), and was planning to go to school. In July 1997, the Veteran was described as doing well on Prozac, and her symptoms of depressed mood, crying spells, sleeplessness, and checking had all been eliminated. While she still checked and rechecked locks of the front door and her car, as well as the whereabouts of her purse, this was much improved. There was no evidence of thought disorder or impaired memory or cognition. She had euthymic mood and affect. In January 1998, she had goal-directed thinking with no lethality or psychosis. Mood and affect were again described as euthymic. The Veteran underwent VA examination again in January 1998. She stated that she slept a lot and was easily upset, irritable, had a lack of interest, poor concentration and episodes of crying. She frequently checked her purse and other things to make sure they were present. She reported that she worked as a courier from August 1995 to December 1996. She indicated that she was presently on Prozac, and described her symptoms as greatly improved. On examination, she was alert and cooperative, with no bizarre motor movements or tics. Mood was somewhat tense, and affect was appropriate. There were no delusions, ideas of reference, or suspiciousness. Recent and remote memory were good. Insight, judgment, and intellectual capacity appeared adequate. The diagnoses were dysthymic disorder and obsessive compulsive traits. A GAF score of 70 was assigned. During VA treatment in May 1998, the Veteran denied crying spells, lethality, psychosis, sleep or appetite disturbances, or checking symptoms. She was described as compliant with her medications, and the physician commented that she continued to do very well. Mental status examination was stable, with goal-directed thoughts. The Axis I diagnoses were major depressive disorder, recurrent with psychosis, now in remission, dysthymic disorder, and obsessive compulsive disorder, mild. During VA treatment in August 1998, the Veteran described herself as less depressed. While she described increased irritability and headaches lately, she commented that this was in the context of trying to stop drinking coffee. Mood was euthymic and affect was full range. Speech was normal rate and tone, and there were no hallucinations or suicidal or homicidal ideations. She described a compulsion to check things, i.e., her purse, car, and door locks. Insight and judgment were fair. The Axis I diagnosis was major depression, recurrent, and the physician assigned a GAF score of 60. In January 1999, the Veteran reported that she had stopped taking Prozac since the previous September because she was feeling good, although she described herself as feeling depressed since December. She added that she had quit her job. She denied suicidal or homicidal ideations. Mood was depressed with constricted affect. Speech was coherent and relevant, with normal rate and tone. Thoughts were well-organized, with no delusions or hallucinations elicited. Insight and judgment were not impaired. The assessment was major depression, recurrent, moderate, and Prozac was restarted. During orthopedic treatment in January 2000, the Veteran reported that she was currently going to school for speech pathology and worked at night. In a statement received in December 2000, the Veteran indicated that she was unable to work upon separation from service, adding that she was having pains, headaches, and crying spells. During VA fee basis psychiatric examination in February 2001, the Veteran reported that she was most concerned about the anxiety she felt whenever her pocketbook was not in view, adding that she had to have it with her at all times, and she went into panic if she could not see it. She also indicated that she got very anxious thinking about whether the doors in her house and car were locked, stating that the doubt and anxiety forced her to drive home to check the door. She described several jobs since discharge from service, including selling security systems, drawing blood, and working for W.F. She stated that the job at W.F. turned out to be very stressful, and she quit after 18 months. She reported that she was taking child care classes at a community college. She added that she had stopped taking Prozac and going to her psychological appointments, because she was feeling better. On examination, she was alert and oriented, and denied feeling depressed. She denied suicidal thoughts, but described panic attacks whenever she was not in possession of her pocketbook or when she thought she had not locked doors. Affect and thought processes were appropriate, and there were no inappropriate behaviors or evidence of memory deficit. The Axis I diagnoses were major depressive disorder, recurrent, in remission, and obsessive compulsive disorder as manifested by the obsession that she must have her pocketbook with her at all times and the compulsion to check the doors repetitively. The examiner assigned a GAF score of 66, indicating that the Veteran had some moderate symptoms and impairment of social and occupational adaptability. He noted that the Veteran's GAF score from 1987 to 1994 was estimated to have been 48. The examiner commented that the Veteran's depression was currently in remission, but there was a good indication that she was acutely depressed from 1987 to 1994, following her discharge from the Army. The aforementioned evidence reflects that the medical evidence provides no basis for assignment of an initial rating in excess of 30 percent for depressive disorder during the period in question. As noted above, the regulations under which the Veteran's depressive disorder was evaluated during the period from, May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001 were revised effective November 7, 1996. The provisions of the revised regulations can only be applied to any evidence of record received on or after the effective date of the revised regulations. Prior to that time, only the old regulations are for application. To warrant the next higher disability rating, 50 percent, under the rating criteria in effect prior to November 7, 1996, the evidence would have to show that the Veteran's ability to establish or maintain effective or favorable relationships with people was considerably impaired; and that by reason of psychoneurotic symptoms her reliability, flexibility and efficiency levels were so reduced as to result in considerable industrial impairment. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (effective prior to November 7, 1996). While, during the period in question, depressive disorder has been manifested by depression, crying spells, sleep impairment, poor concentration, fatigue, irritability, and disturbances of mood, the medical evidence simply does not establish considerable or severe impairment. In this regard, while the Axis I diagnosis in April 1995 was major depression, single episode, severe without psychotic features, the Axis I diagnosis in September 1996 included major depressive disorder, recurrent, improved and, during treatment in July 1997, the Veteran described herself as "doing well" adding that her symptoms of depressed mood, crying spells, sleeplessness, and checking had all been eliminated. During treatment in May 1998, major depressive disorder was described as in remission and, in August 1998, the Veteran described herself as less depressed. In January 1999, the Veteran herself indicated that she had stopped taking Prozac the prior September because she was feeling good and the Axis I diagnosis was major depression, recurrent, moderate. On VA examination in February 2001, the Veteran reported that she had stopped taking Prozac and going to her psychological appointments because she was feeling better, and the Axis I diagnosis was major depressive disorder, recurrent, in remission. The VA examiner specifically commented that the Veteran had some moderate symptoms and impairment of social and occupational adaptability. As noted above, VA's General Counsel clarified that the term "definite" in the rating criteria represented a degree of impairment which was "more than moderate." As such, a finding "considerable" impairment would require medical evidence that the Veteran's depressive disorder was even greater than "more than moderate." Nevertheless, during the period in question, the Veteran's diagnosed depressive disorder was described as improved, in remission, and moderate. In addition, while she and her attorney have consistently argued that depressive disorder resulted in occupational impairment during the period in question, the evidence of record simply does not demonstrate that any such impairment was more than definite. In this regard, occupational information, printed in August 2009, reflects that the Veteran was employed by a bank (N.B.) in collections from October 1994 to February 1995, as an ATM servicer/armed courier (for W.F.) from August 1995 to December 1996, and as a medical technician at the Hampton VA Hospital from March to July 1999. A copy of the Veteran's resume in her VA vocational rehabilitation file indicates that she worked as a phlebotomist from April to November 1998. SSA records reflect that, in addition to the employment indicated above, the Veteran worked as an assistant in an after school program from 1999 to 2000, two hours per day, five days per week. Thus, she was clearly able to obtain employment during the period in question. Her attorney has argued that she was unable to maintain employment due to her service-connected disability; however, the evidence of record indicates that her periods of unemployability from May 1, 1994 to July 31, 2001 were not solely attributable to depressive disorder. In this regard, during the March 1995 VA psychiatric examination, the Veteran stated that she was unable to continue working since separation from service, but was unable to continue working both because of her physical symptoms and her depression and difficulty concentrating. A September 1995 vocational rehabilitation counseling record reflects that, after separation from military service in April 1994, the Veteran took approximately five months off to spend time with her family, and then worked for approximately five months in collections. While she reported that that she left her job because of anxiety, depression, and headaches, she resumed employment six months later, and remained employed for over a year. An undated vocational rehabilitation counseling record reflects that the Veteran quit her job in December 1996 for several reasons, including the fact that her children had previously been cared for by her mother, but her mother passed away in May 1996, as well as the fact that the job required her to carry a weapon, which was felt to be inappropriate due to her physical limitations and psychological disability. Further, the conclusion that depressive disorder did not result in considerable or severe industrial impairment is bolstered by a June 1995 vocational evaluation report, which includes an opinion that the Veteran had extremely high potential for success in occupations requiring precision and dependability, with strong potential to meet increasing job demands. The evaluator opined that she appeared basically able to work with others or alone; however, the stability of her mental health would be a large factor in job success. The evaluator also opined that it was reasonable to expect her to succeed in technical training at the community college level, adding that the stability of her mental health was the critical issue in her rehabilitation. While, in a September 1995 report, a vocational rehabilitation counselor opined that the Veteran did not have marketable skills from her military service jobs and her length of employment in post- military jobs and resulting stress indicated that she was largely unemployable at the present time, significantly, in a form completed in December 1996, a physician from the VA mental health clinic discussed the Veteran's feasibility for training, describing her as intelligent, motivated, and disciplined. Her diagnoses were listed as major depression in partial remission, dysthymia, and obsessive-compulsive symptoms. He opined that she seemed entirely appropriate for training. The physician stated that the Veteran had very good potential to gain and retain employment, adding that she was an independent, self-motivated person. In addition to her periods of employment from 1995 to 2000, the record reflects that the Veteran attended school during the period in question. While she testified in June 1996 that she had withdrawn from classes because of her nervous condition, a December 1995 report of contact reflects that the Veteran had to withdraw from school during the fall quarter for both financial and medical reasons, to include problems with her right arm. Further, the vocational rehabilitation records reflect that the Veteran resumed school in 1997, and continued her studies until at least the fall 2000 semester. Notably, a July 1998 transcript from Elizabeth City State University verifies that the Veteran took 39 credit hours from the summer of 1997 through the summer of 1998. An April 1999 letter from Hampton University indicated that she had completed a full year of study. An October 1999 report of training indicates that the Veteran had dropped several classes, and was training half-time in the fall of 1999. VA Forms 28-1905 (Authorization and Certification of Entrance or Reentrance into Rehabilitation and Certification of Status) reflects that the Veteran attended Hampton University 3/4 time during the spring 2000 semester, and half-time during the Fall 2000 semester. During the February 2001 VA examination, the Veteran reported that she was taking childcare classes at a community college. Also, the evidence of record does not demonstrate that the Veteran had considerable or severe impairment in her ability to establish or maintain effective relationships with people or was isolated in the community. The record contains no evidence of how the Veteran interacted with coworkers or other members of the public during the period in question, but, during the June 1996 hearing, she testified to having a very close relationship to her mother. She also appears to have been able to successfully function as a caregiver for her children, despite at one point indicating that she could not relate to them. Overall, neither the Veteran's personal testimony nor the cumulative medical evidence reflects that she was unable to establish and maintain relationships with other people. Therefore, an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent, pursuant to the rating criteria in effect prior to November 7, 1996, is not warranted. The conclusion that an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent is not warranted is bolstered by the GAF scores assigned during the period in question. A GAF score of 55 was assigned in May 1995, the GAF score was 70 on VA examination in January 1998, and the GAF scores were 60 and 66 in August 1998 and February 2001, respectively. According to the Fourth Edition of the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV), a GAF score ranging from 61 to 70 is indicative of some mild symptoms (e.g., depressed mood and mild insomnia) OR some difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., occasional truancy, or theft within the household), but generally functioning pretty well, has some meaningful interpersonal relationships. A GAF score from 51 to 60 is indicative of moderate symptoms (e.g., flat affect and circumstantial speech, occasional panic attacks) OR moderate difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning (e.g., few friends, conflicts with peers or co- workers). While a GAF score ranging from 51 to 60 may be indicative of moderate difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning, the 30 percent rating currently assigned pursuant to the rating criteria in effect prior to November 7, 1996 contemplates definite impairment which is "more than moderate." Based on the foregoing, the Board finds that an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent is not warranted under the rating criteria in effect prior to November 7, 1996. To warrant the next higher disability rating, 50 percent, under the revised rating criteria, the evidence would have to show occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short- and long-term memory (e.g., retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships. However, since November 1996, the evidence fails to show that the Veteran displayed flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of memory; impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; or difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434. Rather, the Veteran's speech was consistently described as normal. Despite her affect being described as restricted in February 1996 and constricted in January 1999, affect was described as euthymic in August 1996, July 1997, and January 1998 and full range in August 1999. Furthermore, memory and judgment were described as good, adequate, and not impaired. Although, during the February 2001 VA examination the Veteran reported panic attacks when she thought she was not in possession of her pocketbook or when she thought she had not locked doors, there is no medical evidence of panic attacks more than once a week due to service-connected depressive disorder. The Board has considered the fact that the Veteran has described ritual checking in regard to her pocketbook and doors; however, there is no medical evidence during the period in question which reflects that her service-connected depressive disorder is manifested by obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities. Furthermore, while she admitted to suicidal ideation in May 1995, the Veteran has, since, consistently denied suicidal ideation. In addition, while a GAF score of 60 was assigned in August 1998, GAF scores of 66 and 70 were assigned in January 1998 and February 2001, respectively. As indicated above, such scores are indicative of only mild symptoms or some difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning, consistent with the 30 percent rating currently assigned. While the VA examiner who assigned the GAF score of 66 commented that there were some moderate symptoms and impairment of social and occupational adaptability, as indicated above, there is simply no medical evidence of flattened affect, circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech, panic attacks more than once a week, difficulty in understanding complex commands, impairment of short- and long-term memory, impaired judgment, or impaired abstract thinking, as contemplated in a 50 percent rating pursuant to the revised rating criteria. Based on the foregoing, the Board finds that an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent is not warranted under the revised rating criteria. The above determinations are based upon consideration of pertinent provisions of VA's rating schedule. Additionally, the Board finds that there is no showing that, at any point from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001, depressive disorder has reflected so exceptional or so unusual a disability picture as to warrant the assignment of any higher evaluation on an extra-schedular basis. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b). As discussed above, the Veteran has been periodically employed from October 1994 to 2000. The Board acknowledges that the Veteran has described periods of unemployment or related that she had quit her job due to the symptoms related to her service-connected depression. However, according to the VA General Counsel, "the mere assertion or evidence that a disability interferes with employment would not in all cases require consideration of section 3.321(b)(1)." VAOGCPREC 6-96 at 6. The General Counsel noted that the "rating schedule is itself based upon the average impairment of earning capacity due to diseases, and application of the schedule clearly recognizes that the rated disabilities interfere with employment." Thus, the General Counsel concluded that "the fact that a disability interferes with employment generally would not constitute an 'exceptional or unusual' circumstance rendering application of the rating schedule impractical." Instead, the General Counsel stated that consideration of an extra-schedular rating under 3.321(b)(1) was only warranted "where there is evidence that the disability picture presented by the veteran would, in that average case, produce impairment of earning capacity beyond that reflected" in the rating schedule or where evidence shows that the veteran's "service-connected disability affects employability in ways not contemplated by the rating schedule." Id. at 6. In this case, there is no evidence that the disability picture presented by the Veteran produced impairment of earning capacity beyond that reflected in the rating schedule (as set forth in 38 C.F.R. §4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 and 38 C.F.R. §4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434); or that the Veteran's "service-connected disability affected her employability in ways not contemplated by the rating schedule." The Veteran's level of industrial impairment from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001 was assigned a 30 percent evaluation under both the old and revised regulations for the level of occupational impairment caused by her service-connected disability. The rating schedule, and specifically the 30 percent rating, contemplates that there would be some interference with employment, which in fact occurred in the Veteran's case. Moreover, the record reflects that the Veteran left her employment in for reasons both related and unrelated her service-connected depressive disorder as, during the March 1995 VA psychiatric examination, she stated that she was unable to continue working since separation from service both because of her physical symptoms and her depression and difficulty concentrating, and, the vocational rehabilitation records reflect that she quit her job in December 1996 for several reasons, including the fact that her children had previously been cared for by her mother, but her mother passed away in May 1996, as well as the fact that the job required her to carry a weapon, which was felt to be inappropriate due to her physical limitations and psychological disability. There is simply no evidence to show that the Veteran's service-connected disability affected her employability in ways not contemplated by the rating schedule. For instance, if the Veteran's medications caused severe side effects which caused her not be able to work, this would be a result not contemplated by the rating schedule. In this case, although there were some initial side effects from her anti-depressive medications, such as headaches from Zoloft, and constipation, initially thought to have been caused by Amitriptyline and Nortriptyline, neither of these symptoms was alleged to have caused any interference with the Veteran's employability. The Board also notes that the Veteran was not hospitalized for any period of time secondary to her depressive disorder; and at no time during the period in question were any delusional or hallucinatory elements observed which prevented her from working. In light of the foregoing, the criteria for invoking the procedures set forth in 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b)(1) have not been met. See Bagwell v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 337, 338-9 (1996); Floyd v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 88, 96 (1996); Shipwash v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 218, 227 (1995). For all the foregoing reasons, there is no basis for staged rating of depressive disorder, pursuant to Fenderson, during the period from May 1, 1994 to July 30, 2001, and the claim for higher initial rating must be denied. In reaching these conclusions, the Board has considered the applicability of the benefit-of-the doubt doctrine; however, as the preponderance of the evidence is against assignment of any higher rating, that doctrine is not applicable. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b); 38 C.F.R. § 3.102; Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53-56 (1990). ORDER Entitlement to an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for depressive disorder, for the period between May 1, 1994 and July 30, 2001, is denied. ____________________________________________ RENÉE M. PELLETIER Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs