Citation Nr: 1017597 Decision Date: 05/12/10 Archive Date: 05/26/10 DOCKET NO. 09-18 679A ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Columbia, South Carolina THE ISSUES 1. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than April 20, 2007, for the award of a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder. 2. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than July 1, 2007, for the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Disabled American Veterans WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Appellant ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD A. P. Simpson, Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from April 1991 to February 1994. This case comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from July 2007 and November 2008 rating decisions of the Columbia, South Carolina, Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). In the June 2007 decision, the RO granted a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder, effective April 20, 2007. In the November 2008 rating decision, the RO granted a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability, effective July 1, 2007. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. In a March 2006 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for depression and assigned a 50 percent evaluation, effective July 27, 2004. The Veteran submitted a notice of disagreement as to the 50 percent evaluation assigned, and a statement of the case was issued in August 2006. The Veteran did not perfect an appeal. Thus, the March 2006 rating decision became final. 2. On April 20, 2007, the Veteran submitted an informal claim for an increased rating for depression. 3. Between August 2006 and April 20, 2007, there was no formal claim, informal claim, or written intent to file a claim for increase for depression nor was there evidence within one year prior to the April 2007 claim that the Veteran's service-connected psychiatric disorder met the criteria for a 70 percent evaluation. 4. The credible evidence establishes that prior to July 1, 2007, the Veteran was engaged in substantial gainful employment. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The criteria for an effective date earlier than April 20, 2007, for the award of a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5103, 5103A, 5107, 5110, 7105 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.157, 3.400, 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9400 (2009). 2. The criteria for an effective date earlier than July 1, 2007, for the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5103, 5103A, 5107, 5110, 7105 (West 2002 & Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.157, 3.400, 4.16 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION Duties to Notify and Assist The requirements of the Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) have been met. As to the claim for entitlement to an earlier effective date for the award of a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder, this claim stems from a claim for increase, which the RO increased the Veteran's disability evaluation from 50 percent to 70 percent. The Veteran has stated that he is satisfied with the 70 percent evaluation. See VA Form 21-4138, Statement in Support of Claim, received in November 2008. This means that the notice requirements of 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a) have been met since the Veteran's claim was successfully granted an increased rating. See Hartman v. Nicholson, 483 F.3d 1311 (Fed. Cir. 2007). The RO properly issued a statement of the case in June 2009 addressing the effective-date issue. As to the claim for entitlement to an earlier effective date for the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability, this claim stems from the Veteran having submitted a VA Form 21-8940, Veteran's Application for Increased Compensation Based Upon Unemployability, which claim was granted in the January 2009 rating decision. This means that the notice requirements of 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a) have been met since the Veteran's claim was successfully granted. See Hartman v. Nicholson, 483 F.3d 1311 (Fed. Cir. 2007). The RO properly issued a statement of the case in June 2009 addressing the effective-date issue. As to the duty to assist, VA has obtained VA treatment records from 2006 to 2009. The Veteran has submitted a psychotherapy progress report from his private psychologist. The Veteran was provided with a video conference before the undersigned Acting Veterans Law Judge. A transcript of that hearing has been associated with the claims file. VA did not provide the Veteran with examinations in connection with the claims for earlier effective dates, as they do not meet the statutory requirements for entitlement to a VA examination or medical opinion. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A(d)(2)(A)-(C) (West 2002); see also 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c)(4)(A)-(C) (2009). (VA provided the Veteran with examinations in connection with his claim for increase for major depressive disorder and his claim for entitlement to a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability.) In sum, there is no evidence of any VA error in assisting the appellant that reasonably affects the fairness of these adjudications. The Board concludes the Veteran was provided the opportunity to meaningfully participate in the adjudication of his claims and did in fact participate. Washington v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 191 (2007). Hence, there is no error or issue that precludes the Board from addressing the merits of this appeal. Analysis The Veteran argues that he warrants effective dates going back to 2004 for both the 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder and the total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability. At a March 2010 hearing before the undersigned, the Veteran testified that he last worked in 2004 as an administrator for a nursing home. He described having severe problems with his ability to focus and back pain at that time. The Veteran stated he had used up all of his leave and personal time because of these disabilities. He stated he had been on bed rest for two years answering phones in connection with his job from home. The Veteran testified that he was unable to focus and maintain focus, which is when he started seeking psychiatric help. He described himself as becoming reclusive. The Veteran stated he had been seeing a therapist, who had provided a statement showing "the characteristics for 100 percent." He argued his 70 percent evaluation and the total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability should go back to July 2004. Governing regulations provide that a decision of a duly constituted rating agency or other agency of original jurisdiction shall be final and binding on all VA field offices as to conclusions based on evidence on file at the time VA issues written notification in accordance with 38 U.S.C.A. § 5104 (West 2002). 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 20.1103 (2009). The assignment of effective dates of awards is generally governed by 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110 and 38 C.F.R. § 3.400. Unless specifically provided otherwise, the effective date of an award based on a claim for increase (which includes a claim for total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability) shall be fixed in accordance with the facts found, but shall not be earlier than the date of receipt of application therefor. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110(a). The implementing regulation states that the effective date for a claim for increase will be the date of claim or date entitlement arose, whichever is later. 38 C.F.R. § 3.400. An effective date for a claim for increase may be granted prior to the date of claim if it is ascertainable that an increase in disability had occurred within one year from the date of claim. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5110(b)(2); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.400(o)(1) and (2) (2009); see Harper v. Brown, 10 Vet. App. 125, 126 (1997). Under 38 C.F.R. 3.157(b) (2009), once a claim for compensation has been allowed, receipt of a VA outpatient or hospital examination or admission to a VA hospital will be accepted as an informal claim for increased benefits. See Servello v. Derwinski, 3 Vet. App. 196, 199 (1992). The date on the VA outpatient or hospital examination will be accepted as the date of claim. 38 C.F.R. 3.157(b). When all the evidence is assembled, VA is responsible for determining whether the evidence supports the claim or is in relative equipoise, with the veteran prevailing in either event, or whether a preponderance of the evidence is against a claim, in which case, the claim is denied. Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49 (1990). The Board has carefully reviewed the evidence of record and finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against the grant of (1) an effective date earlier than April 20, 2007, for the award of a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder and (2) an effective date earlier than July 1, 2007, for a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability. The reasons follow. 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder The Board notes that when the RO granted service connection for the psychiatric disorder in the March 2006 rating decision, it characterized the disability as "depression." In the July 2007 rating decision, the RO recharacterized the service-connected disability as major depressive disorder. It does not impact the Veteran's disability evaluation, as both diagnoses have the same criteria. Under 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434, the criteria for a 70 percent evaluation are as follows: Occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near-continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; impaired impulse control (such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a worklike setting); inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. The Veteran's allegation that the 70 percent evaluation should go back to 2004 is legally precluded. In a March 2006 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for depression and assigned a 50 percent evaluation, effective July 27, 2004. The Veteran submitted a timely notice of disagreement as to the 50 percent evaluation, arguing he warranted a 70 percent evaluation. See VA Form 21-4138, Statement in Support of Claim, received in March 2006. The RO issued a statement of the case in August 2006. At that time, it considered VA treatment records up until August 17, 2006, pertaining to treatment for the psychiatric disorder. The Veteran never submitted a substantive appeal by the end of the appeal period, which would have been in March 2007. See 38 C.F.R. § 20.302(b) (2009). Thus, the March 2006 rating decision is final, see 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(c); 38 C.F.R. § 20.1103 (2009), and is a legal bar to an effective date going back to July 2004 for the 70 percent evaluation. The Veteran next submitted a claim for increase on April 20, 2007. See VA Form 21-4138. This is the first claim for increase received after the March 2006 rating decision. While VA treatment records pertaining to treatment for the service-connected disability are claims for increase, see 38 C.F.R. § 3.157(b), the VA treatment records pertaining to treatment for the Veteran's psychiatric disorder were considered at the time of the August 2006 statement of the case. There are no VA treatment records pertaining to treatment for the psychiatric disorder between August 2006 and April 2007. Thus, in this case, the date of claim is April 20, 2007. The earliest effective date in a claim for increase can be up to one year prior to April 20, 2007, if it is factually ascertainable that an increase in the service- connected disability was shown during that time period. The Board has thoroughly reviewed the VA treatment records dated within one year prior to the April 20, 2007, claim for increase. None of these records establish a basis to award a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder. For example, May 2006 and August 2006 VA outpatient treatment reports show that the Veteran's appearance was described as neat and clean (the same examiner reported the clinical findings in these treatment records). This is evidence against a finding of neglect of personal appearance and hygiene. The Veteran was oriented to person, place, time and situation. This is evidence against spatial disorientation. The Veteran's speech was of normal rate, tone, and was spontaneous. His thought processes were linear and goal directed, and thought content was appropriate. This is evidence against speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant. Suicidal and homicidal ideations were absent. The examiner described the Veteran's mood as euthymic, and stated he was cooperative. She also stated he had good eye contact. Impulse control was found to be "good," which is evidence against impaired impulse control. The examiner stated the Veteran had no hallucinations. Concentration was good, as was insight and judgment. Irritability was absent. There was no report that the Veteran had near-continuous panic/depression affecting his ability to function. In May 2006, the examiner found that Veteran's depression and anxiety symptoms had "improved." In August 2006, the same examiner stated that the Veteran was "stable from a psych[iatric] perspective." The Board is aware that the symptoms listed under the 70 percent evaluation are examples of the types and degree of symptoms that would warrant a 70 percent evaluation, and that the Veteran need not have these particular symptoms in order to warrant a 70 percent evaluation. See Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436 (2002). However, the criteria described under the 70 percent evaluation indicate a more serious disability than the Veteran demonstrated prior to April 20, 2007. None of the evidence within one year of the April 2007 claim for increase meets the criteria for a 70 percent evaluation. In November 2008, the Veteran submitted a private "Psychotherapy Progress Report" addressing treatment the Veteran had received from November 2005 to February 2006. As correctly stated by the RO in the June 2009 statement of the case, such document refers to symptoms the Veteran exhibited more than one year prior to his April 2007 claim for increase. Thus, they do not assist the Veteran in obtaining an earlier effective date for the 70 percent evaluation. Based upon the descriptions of the Veteran's symptoms in the VA treatment records within one year prior to his April 2007 claim for increase, the Board finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against a finding that he met the criteria for a 70 percent evaluation for the service-connected major depressive disorder prior to April 20, 2007. The benefit-of- the-doubt rule is not for application. See Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 55 (1990); 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107. Total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability On December 11, 2007, the Veteran submitted a VA Form 21- 8940, Veteran's Application for Increased Compensation Based Upon Unemployability, in which he stated he had been working at the same assisted living facility (RCCH) as an administrator nurse from January 1995 to the present and had worked 70 hours per week during that time period. He indicated he had earned $75,000 in the past 12 months. As to the most he had ever made, the Veteran wrote $110,000, which he stated was from 1995 to 2000. His highest gross earnings per month was $6,000. When asked to indicate his current monthly earned income, if presently working, the Veteran wrote, "5000.00" When asked the date which his disability affected his full-time employment, he wrote, "March 3, 2000." When asked the date he had last worked full time and when he became too disabled to work, the Veteran wrote "March 2000." In April 2008, the Veteran submitted another completed VA Form 21-8940. There, he stated he had been working at RCCH as an administrator nurse from January 1995 to June 2007 and had worked 75 hours per week. He indicated he had earned $135,000 in the past 12 months. As to the most he had ever made, the Veteran wrote $145,000, which he stated was in 2006. His highest gross earnings per month was $12,000. When asked to indicate his current monthly earned income, if presently working, the Veteran wrote, "0." When asked the date which his disability affected his full-time employment, he wrote "July 30, 2002." (It is difficult to read the exact year because the Veteran wrote over the last number.) When asked the date he had last worked full time, the Veteran wrote, "June 30, 2008." (It is unclear whether the 2008 date was an error.) When asked when he became too disabled to work, the Veteran wrote "June 15, 2007." In cases where the schedular rating is less than 100 percent, a total disability rating may be assigned when the individual is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as the result of service-connected disability, without regard to advancing age. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16 (2009). A total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability may be assigned, when the disabled person is, in the judgment of the rating agency, unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities, provided that, if there is only one such disability, this disability shall be ratable at 60 percent or more, and that, if there are two or more disabilities, there shall be at least one disability ratable at 40 percent or more, and sufficient additional disability to bring the combined rating to 70 percent or more. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). The 60 percent evaluation may be met when the veteran's disabilities are from common etiology. Id. at (a)(2). When an RO is considering a rating increase claim from a claimant whose schedular rating meets the minimum criteria of section 4.16(a) and there is evidence of current service- connected unemployability in the claimant's claims file or under VA control, evaluation of that rating increase must also include an evaluation of a reasonably-raised claim for a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability, and VA is required to adjudicate that claim. Norris v. West, 12 Vet. App. 413, 418 (1999); see also Roberson v. Principi, 251 F.3d 1378, 1384 (Fed. Cir. 2001). The Veteran met criteria for consideration of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability under 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) as of July 27, 2004 (the date that the Veteran was awarded service connection for major depressive disorder and assigned a 50 percent evaluation). At that time, he had a combined evaluation of 60 percent based upon his back and psychiatric disorder having a common etiology (the psychiatric disorder was granted as being due to the back disorder). The Board has reviewed the evidence of record from that date to determine if there was evidence of service-connected unemployability and finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against a finding that the Veteran was unable to obtain and sustain gainful employment solely due to service- connected disabilities prior to July 1, 2007. For example, in a May 2005 VA examination report, the examiner wrote, "The [V]eteran is currently employed." In the February 2006 VA examination report, the examiner wrote, "This [V]eteran owns his own business. He owns a community care home." In the May 2007 VA examination report, the examiner stated the Veteran was self employed and the owner of a community care home. More importantly, in an August 2007 VA outpatient treatment report (which post dates July 1, 2007), the examiner noted the Veteran was working for the community care home (the wording does not indicate past tense, but present tense). In a December 2007 application for individual unemployability, the Veteran himself indicated he was still working at the community care home. The Board finds that there is entirely a lack of credible evidence prior to July 1, 2007, that the Veteran was unable to work due to service-connected disability or disabilities. To the extent that the Veteran has alleged and testified, under oath, that he stopped working prior to July 2007, the Board completely rejects these allegations, as it finds that the Veteran is not a credible historian. He has provided conflicting statements as to when he stopped working. He also has provided exaggerated and inaccurate statements in the past, which has caused the Board to conclude that the Veteran's demonstrates a lack of credibility when he is seeking compensation benefits with VA. For example, in March 1994, when the Veteran filed his original claim for service connection for the low back disability, he claimed that a sofa fell on his back and he was rushed to the emergency room. See VA Form 21-2545, Report of Medical Examination for Disability Evaluation. At the March 1994 VA examination, the examiner stated the Veteran reported that a sofa fell on his back and that while lying down on the ground as a result of severe pain, another sofa fell on his cervical spine, and he was unconscious for two hours. However, the service treatment records do not remotely support the Veteran's version of the event. In a March 1992 physical therapy consultation, the examiner wrote that the Veteran was moving furniture and strained his back. This same history was reported in an April 1992 physical therapy consultation. In the report of medical examination at discharge from service in February 1994 (approximately one month prior to the Veteran completing the VA Form 21-2545), when listing the summary of defects, there was no report of loss of consciousness. In fact, the examiner wrote that the Veteran had denied any "disturbances of consciousness." In the report of medical history completed by the Veteran at that time (February 1994), he checked "no" to the question of whether he had ever been a patient in a hospital. See item # 19. He had the knowledge to report undergoing physical therapy, see item # 21, which is entirely consistent with the service treatment records, but somehow neglected to report his medical history involving him going to the emergency room and having two hours of unconsciousness. The Board finds that the March 1994 statements that a sofa fell on his back and the statement that another sofa fell on his cervical spine, which resulted in unconsciousness, are not credible. In connection with the current claim, the Veteran has provided varying dates as to when he stopped working, ranging from 2004 to 2007, which shows that the Veteran's credibility should continue to be doubted in connection with a claim for monetary benefits before VA. Moreover, the South Carolina Department of Health & Environmental Control website showing that the Veteran is the report of contact for a care facility (the website indicates that it was updated as of April 2010). However, whether the Veteran is currently working is not the issue before the Board. The issue is whether there evidence of service-connected unemployability prior to July 1, 2007. The Board concludes that there is no credible evidence of service-connected unemployability prior to July 1, 2007. As laid out above, the Veteran provided different information in the VA Form 21-8940 he submitted in December 2007 than in the one he submitted in April 2008. In the December 2007 form, he stated he had become too disabled to work as of March 2000; however, he also indicated he was employed as of the date of his submission. See item # 16 (showing dates of employment from January 1995 to "present"). He indicated he had made $75,000 in the last year and was currently making $5,000 per month. This document would indicate the Veteran had substantial gainful employment as of December 2007. However, in his April 2008 application, he wrote his last day of work was in June 2007 and that his monthly salary was zero, which would contradict his December 2007 application. This also contradicts an August 2007 VA outpatient treatment report showing that the examiner wrote that the Veteran "works as a Health Care Administrator." That would indicate the Veteran was working in August 2007. While the August 2007 treatment record is consistent with the December 2007 application, it contradicts the April 2008 application, wherein he stated he stopped working in June 2007. To add to this, at the March 2010 hearing before the undersigned, the Veteran testified he had last worked in June 2004, an entirely different date than he had presented before. In reading through the Veteran's testimony (that he stopped working in June 2004), it completely contradicts the information he provided in both VA Forms 21-8940 showing that he was employed full time from 2004 until 2007. See VA Forms 21-8940, dated December 2007 and April 2008. Showing further inconsistent statements by the Veteran, in the December 2007 application, he stated the most he had earned in one year was $110,000 from 1995 to 2000, but in the April 2007 application, he stated that the most he had earned in one year was $145,000 in 2006. The December 2007 application was signed by the Veteran in December 2007, which post dates the 2006 year where he earned $145,000. When multiple facts pertaining to the same issue change, the Board can only conclude that the person who has provided the varying facts is not credible. As a result of the Board finding that the Veteran is not credible, it accords his allegations of having stopped working prior to July 1, 2007, no probative value. Stated differently, there is no objective evidence that the Veteran stopped working prior to July 1, 2007. Thus, even if there was a claim for a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability pending as of July 1, 2007, and as early as July 2004, the Board finds no basis to award such benefit prior to July 1, 2007. In fact, it concludes that the Veteran had substantial gainful employment until at least July 1, 2007, which prohibits the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability prior to that date. As noted above, in November 2008, the Veteran submitted a private "Psychotherapy Progress Report" addressing treatment he had received from November 2005 to February 2006 for his service-connected psychiatric disorder. In the summary, the psychologist stated, "[The Veteran] reported that due to back problems and depression, he has been unable to work." The Veteran alleges that this is evidence of his inability to work prior to July 2007. The Board does not find that such statement is objective evidence that the Veteran was unable to work prior to July 2007. The psychologist did not say that he found the Veteran was unable to work, but rather merely reported what the Veteran had stated to him. The Board rejects any factual history provided by the Veteran as not credible. In other words, this evidences provides no basis for the award of an earlier effective date. Lastly, the Board notes that throughout the appeal, the Veteran has made allegations of working only a few hours a week at various times from 2004 to 2007 due to his psychiatric disorder or his back disorder to support his allegation of not being able to work. In Faust v. West, 13 Vet. App. 342, 356 (2000), the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims defined "substantially gainful employment" as an occupation that provides an annual income that exceeds the poverty threshold for one person, irrespective of the number of hours or days that the veteran actually works. Based on the salaries the Veteran has reported he received since 2004, there can be no argument that he was not engaged in substantial gainful employment prior to July 1, 2007. Accordingly, for all the reasons stated above, the Board finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against an effective date earlier than July 1, 2007, for the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability, and the benefit-of-the-doubt rule is not for application. See Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 55; 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107. ORDER Entitlement to an effective date earlier than April 20, 2007, for the award of a 70 percent evaluation for major depressive disorder is denied. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than July 1, 2007, for the award of a total rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities is denied. _____________________________________________ A. C. MACKENZIE Acting Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs