Citation Nr: 1032862 Decision Date: 09/01/10 Archive Date: 09/13/10 DOCKET NO. 06-28 553 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Columbia, South Carolina THE ISSUES 1. Entitlement to service connection for major depressive disorder, to include as due to service-connected low back disability. 2. Entitlement to a disability rating in excess of 40 percent for a low back disability. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: The American Legion ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD K. Haddock, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran had active military service from May 1975 to April 1992. This case comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from April 2005 and March 2006 rating decisions by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Columbia, South Carolina. The issue of entitlement to an increased disability rating for a low back disability is addressed in the REMAND following the order section of this decision. FINDING OF FACT The Veteran has not major depressive disorder at any time during the pendency of this claim. CONCLUSION OF LAW Major depressive disorder was not incurred in or aggravated by active service and is not proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disability. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1110 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 3.310 (2006); 38 C.F.R. § 3.303 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION Duties to Notify and Assist The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA), codified in pertinent part at 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103, 5103A (West 2002 & Supp. 2009), and the pertinent implementing regulation, codified at 38 C.F.R. § 3.159 (2009), provide that VA will assist a claimant in obtaining evidence necessary to substantiate a claim but is not required to provide assistance to a claimant if there is no reasonable possibility that such assistance would aid in substantiating the claim. They also require VA to notify the claimant and the claimant's representative, if any, of any information, and any medical or lay evidence, not previously provided to the Secretary that is necessary to substantiate the claim. As part of the notice, VA is to specifically inform the claimant and the claimant's representative, if any, of which portion, if any, of the evidence is to be provided by the claimant and which part, if any, VA will attempt to obtain on behalf of the claimant. Although the regulation previously required VA to request that the claimant provide any evidence in the claimant's possession that pertains to the claim, the regulation has been amended to eliminate that requirement for claims pending before VA on or after May 30, 2008. The Board also notes that the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has held that the plain language of 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103(a) requires that notice to a claimant pursuant to the VCAA be provided "at the time" that, or "immediately after," VA receives a complete or substantially complete application for VA-administered benefits. Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112, 119 (2004). The timing requirement enunciated in Pelegrini applies equally to the initial-disability-rating and effective-date elements of a service-connection claim. Dingess v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). The record reflects that the Veteran was mailed a letter in February 2006 advising him of what the evidence must show and of the respective duties of VA and the claimant in obtaining evidence. In April 2006 the Veteran was mailed a letter providing him with appropriate notice with respect to the disability-rating and effective-date elements of his claim. Although the Veteran was not provided adequate notice until after the initial adjudication of the claim, the Board finds that there is no prejudice to the Veteran in proceeding with the issuance of a final decision. See Bernard v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 384, 394 (1993). In this regard, the Board notes that following the provision of the required notice and the completion of all indicated development the claim was readjudicated. There is no indication or reason to believe that the ultimate decision on the merits of the claim would have been different had complete VCAA notice been provided at an earlier time. See Overton v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 427, 437 (2006) (A timing error may be cured by a new VCAA notification followed by a readjudication of the claim). The Board also finds the Veteran has been afforded adequate assistance in response to his claim. The Veteran's service treatment records (STRs) and service personnel records (SPRs) are on file. VA Medical Center treatment records have been obtained. The Veteran was afforded appropriate VA examinations in July 2006 and January 2007. Neither the Veteran nor his representative has identified any outstanding evidence, to include medical records, which could be obtained to substantiate the claim. The Board is also unaware of any such evidence. In sum, the Board is satisfied that any procedural errors in the RO's development and consideration of the claim were insignificant and non prejudicial to the Veteran. Accordingly, the Board will address the merits of the claim. Legal Criteria Service connection may be granted for disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by active military service. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1110, 1131; 38 C.F.R. § 3.303. Service connection may be granted for disability which is proximately due to or the result of service-connected disability. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(a). Additional disability resulting from the aggravation of a nonservice-connected disability by a service- connected disability is also compensable under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(a). Allen v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 439, 448 (1995) (en banc). During the pendency of this claim, 38 C.F.R. § 3.310 was amended, effective October 10, 2006. The amendments to this section are not liberalizing. Therefore, the Board will apply the former version of the regulation. Except as otherwise provided by law, a claimant has the responsibility to present and support a claim for benefits under laws administered by the Secretary. The Secretary shall consider all information and lay and medical evidence of record in a case before the Secretary with respect to benefits under laws administered by the Secretary. When there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence regarding any issue material to the determination of a matter, the Secretary shall give the benefit of the doubt to the claimant. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107; 38 C.F.R. § 3.102; see also Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53 (1990). To deny a claim on its merits, the evidence must preponderate against the claim. Alemany v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 518, 519 (1996), citing Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 54. Analysis The Veteran's STRs are negative for any complaints of or treatment for depression while in active service. Additionally, at his February 1992 separation examination, the Veteran checked "no" on the questionnaire in response to the question of whether he had experienced depression or excessive worry. Also of record, are medical records from the Veteran's post-separation service in the Army National Guard. At an Army National Guard examination in November 2000, the Veteran again checked "no" on the questionnaire in response to the question of whether he had experienced any depression or excessive worry. A review of the Veteran's VA Medical Center treatment records shows that the Veteran has sought periodic mental health counseling at the VA Medical Center and that he has been diagnosed with major depressive disorder by his VA case manager. In July 2006, the Veteran was afforded a VA psychiatric examination. After examination of the Veteran was complete, it was recommended by the examiner that the Veteran undergo a complete psychological and neuropsychological evaluation to assess both the Veteran's cognitive functioning and his differential diagnosis. After reviewing the Veteran's August 2006 psychological test results, the VA examiner reported that the Veteran exaggerated his symptoms and generally did not provide any data to support his claim of experiencing depression. The examiner also reported that the Veteran had not presented any symptoms of depression during the initial July 2006 evaluation and she reported that she could not find evidence of any service-connected psychiatric disorder for the Veteran. The Veteran was afforded another VA psychiatric examination in January 2007. After a thorough review of the claims files and an examination of the Veteran, the VA examiner reported that the only Axis I diagnosis she could make was that of malingering. The examiner reported that the Veteran was a very poor historian, was very evasive, and was able to recall his medication and what they were prescribed for, but was unable to immediately repeat words or know the number of pennies in a dollar. The examiner reported that these abilities were inconsistent with each other. The VA examiner also reported that the Veteran had consistently been inconsistent through his report of symptoms in that the Veteran exaggerated his symptoms and reported symptoms that were not consistent with psychiatric illness. The examiner reported that the Veteran appeared to be trying to make himself cry by rubbing his eyes with his jacket and attempting to appear sad. The examiner reported that the Veteran was not very successful in his endeavor. The examiner also reported that the Veteran became particularly agitated with questions he was unsure how to answer and there was no evidence to suggest that the Veteran had a major mental illness, with the exception of malingering in order to attempt to obtain funding. The examiner opined that to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, the Veteran was not suffering from a primary Axis I mental illness. However, the examiner did note that the Veteran abused alcohol. The examiner also reported that there was no evidence to support a service-connected psychiatric disability claim. The examiner noted that even though the Veteran did have some VA Medical Center treatment notes that indicated a diagnosis of major depression, the approach by an individual treating provider is often different than that of an evaluator. In this regard, the VA examiner noted that an evaluator uses further questioning to attempt to clarify a diagnosis as opposed to a treating physician, who may assume that prior diagnoses have been correct and just continue with the same treatment and diagnoses without challenging it. The VA examiner reported that both she and the other psychiatrist she conferred with on this case had forensic psychiatry experience and training in addition to the fact that the examiner herself is board certified in forensic psychiatry. The examiner reported that this experience aided her in evaluating things more objectively and in looking for evidence that was inconsistent with mental illness rather than accepting a patient's symptoms as they are reported, which is what is frequently done by treating providers in order to achieve therapeutic alliance. Additionally, the VA examiner noted that clinical treatment notes do not provide an adequate description of symptoms to support a diagnosis of major depressive disorder. She reported that during disability evaluations, it is imperative that the patient be evaluated utilizing DSM-IV criteria for mental illness objectively, rather than working to develop a therapeutic alliance with the patient. Greater weight may be placed on one physician's opinion than another's depending on factors such as the reasoning employed by the physicians and whether (and the extent to which) they reviewed prior clinical records and other evidence. Gabrielson v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 36, 40 (1994). Additionally, while the findings of a physician are medical conclusions that the Board cannot ignore or disregard, Willis v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 66 (1991); the Board is free to assess medical evidence and is not obligated to accept a physician's opinion. Wilson v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 614 (1992). The Board finds the opinion provided by the January 2007 VA examiner to be more probative than the diagnosis provided by the Veteran's VA Medical Center mental health case manager. In this regard, the VA examiner clearly states that she used the DSM-IV criteria in her evaluation of the Veteran's symptoms. It is unclear as to whether the Veteran's mental health case manager did the same. Additionally, the VA examiner pointed out clear instances of inconsistencies in the Veteran's reported symptoms and clearly outlined her reasons for believing that the Veteran did not actually have an Axis I diagnosis of a mental disability. Moreover, there is no indication from the record that the Veteran's diagnosis of major depressive disorder by his VA Medical Center mental health counselor was adequately based on the DSM-IV criteria. In addition, as pointed out by the January 2007 VA examiner, as a forensic psychiatrist, she sees things more objectively and looks for evidence that was inconsistent with mental illness rather than accepting a patient's symptoms as they are reported, which is what is frequently done by treating providers in order to achieve therapeutic alliance. Accordingly, the Board has concluded that the preponderance of the evidence is against this claim. Therefore, entitlement to service connection for major depressive disorder is not warranted. ORDER Entitlement service connection for major depressive disorder is denied. REMAND The Board finds that additional development is required before the Veteran's claim of entitlement to an increased disability rating for his low back disability is decided. The Veteran was last afforded a VA examination of his spine in February 2006. In a September 2008 statement from the Veteran's representative, it was reported that the Veteran's low back disability had increased in severity since his last VA examination. A review of the VA Medical Center treatment records on file shows that the Veteran does receive periodic treatment at the VA Medical Center for back problems. However, the information provided in the VA Medical Center treatment notes is not sufficient for the purposes of determining the current level of all impairment resulting from the Veteran's service-connected low back disability. Therefore, the Veteran should be afforded a VA examination to determine the current level of severity of all impairment resulting from his service-connected low back disability. Additionally, current treatment records should be obtained before a decision is rendered with regard to this issue. Accordingly, this case is remanded to the RO or the Appeals Management Center (AMC), in Washington, D.C., for the following actions: 1. The RO or the AMC should undertake appropriate development to obtain any pertinent evidence identified, but not provided by the Veteran, to include VA Medical Center treatment records. If it is unable to obtain any such evidence, it should so inform the Veteran and his representative and request them to submit the outstanding evidence. 2. Then, the Veteran should be afforded a VA examination by an examiner with appropriate expertise to determine the current level of severity of all impairment resulting from the Veteran's service-connected low back disability. The claims files must be made available to and reviewed by the examiner. Any indicated studies should be performed. The RO or the AMC should ensure that the examiner provides all information required for rating purposes. All manifestations of the Veteran's low back disability should be identified, to include any symptoms of radiculopathy and any periods of medically prescribed bed rest. In addition, the examiner should provide an opinion concerning the current degree of industrial impairment resulting from the Veteran's service-connected low back disability, to include whether it is sufficient by itself to render the Veteran unemployable. The rationale for all opinions expressed must be provided. 3. The RO or the AMC should undertake any other development it determines to be warranted. 4. Then, the RO or the AMC should readjudicate the Veteran's claim based on a de novo review of the record. If the benefit sought on appeal is not granted to the Veteran's satisfaction, a Supplemental Statement of the Case should be furnished to the Veteran and his representative, and they should be afforded the requisite opportunity to respond. Thereafter, if indicated, the case should be returned to the Board for further appellate action. By this remand, the Board intimates no opinion as to any final outcome warranted. The Veteran need take no action until he is otherwise notified, but he may furnish additional evidence and/or argument during the appropriate time frame. See Kutscherousky v. West, 12 Vet. App. 369 (1999). This REMAND must be afforded expeditious treatment. The law requires that all claims that are remanded by the Board or the Court for additional development or other appropriate action must be handled in an expeditious manner. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5109B, 7112 (West Supp. 2009). ______________________________________________ Shane A. Durkin Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs