Citation Nr: 1035707 Decision Date: 09/21/10 Archive Date: 09/28/10 DOCKET NO. 05-17 718 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional (RO) Office in Albuquerque, New Mexico THE ISSUES 1. Entitlement to service connection for hepatitis C. 2. Entitlement to service connection for depression, secondary to hepatitis C. REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: Vietnam Veterans of America ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD J.B. Freeman, Associate Counsel INTRODUCTION The appellant served on active duty from July 1973 to May 1974, with additional service with the Army National Guard. This matter is before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on remand from the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). In a November 2009 Order, the Court endorsed a joint motion for remand, vacated the Board decision that denied the hepatitis C claim and remanded the depression claim, and remanded the matter for compliance with the instructions in the joint motion. In June 2008, this matter came before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from an April 2004 rating decision of the RO in St. Louis, Missouri, which declined reopening of the hepatitis C claim and denied depression on the merits. Evidence has been received subsequent to the final consideration of the claim by the RO. The appellant, through his representative, has waived RO consideration of that evidence. The Board may consider the appeal. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1304 (2009). The appellant filed a December 2009 petition to reopen a claim for service connection for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The petition has been raised by the record, but has not been adjudicated by the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ). Therefore, the Board does not have jurisdiction over it, and it is referred to the AOJ for appropriate action. The issue of service connection for hepatitis C is addressed in the REMAND portion of the decision below and is REMANDED to the RO via the Appeals Management Center (AMC), in Washington, DC. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. In April 2004 and May 2005 rating decisions, the RO denied service connection for depression. 2. The appellant was informed of these decisions and of his procedural and appellate rights in April 16, 2004, and May 23, 2005, letters. 3. The RO issued a Statement of the Case, which was sent to the appellant on August 8, 2008. 4. The appellant's Substantive Appeal as to the claim of service connection for depression was received on October 14, 2009, and was not timely. 5. VA did not waive the timeliness of the Substantive Appeal. 6. The appellant did not timely request an extension of the time limit for filing a Substantive Appeal. CONCLUSION OF LAW The appellant has not submitted a timely Substantive Appeal with regard to the August 2008 Statement of the Case, nor has he submitted a timely request for extension of the time limit for filing the substantive appeal. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 7105, 7108 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.109, 20.202, 20.302, 20.303 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The Board has thoroughly reviewed all the evidence in the appellant's claims folders. Although the Board has an obligation to provide reasons and bases supporting this decision, there is no need to discuss, in detail, the evidence submitted by the appellant or on his behalf. See Gonzales v. West, 218 F.3d 1378, 1380-81 (Fed. Cir. 2000) (the Board must review the entire record, but does not have to discuss each piece of evidence). The analysis below focuses on the most salient and relevant evidence and on what this evidence shows, or fails to show, on the claim. The appellant must not assume that the Board has overlooked pieces of evidence that are not explicitly discussed herein. See Timberlake v. Gober, 14 Vet. App. 122 (2000) (the law requires only that the Board address its reasons for rejecting evidence favorable to the appellant). The Board must assess the credibility and weight of all evidence, including the medical evidence, to determine its probative value, accounting for evidence which it finds to be persuasive or unpersuasive, and providing reasons for rejecting any evidence favorable to the claimant. Equal weight is not accorded to each piece of evidence contained in the record; every item of evidence does not have the same probative value. When all the evidence is assembled, VA is responsible for determining whether the evidence supports the claim or is in relative equipoise, with the appellant prevailing in either event, or whether a preponderance of the evidence is against a claim, in which case, the claim is denied. Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49 (1990). I. Timeliness of Appeal The Board's authority to review an adverse RO decision is initiated upon a claimant's submission of a Notice of Disagreement (NOD) and completed by a substantive appeal after a Statement of the Case (SOC) has been furnished. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(a); 38 C.F.R. § 20.200. It is well-established judicial doctrine that any statutory tribunal must ensure that it has jurisdiction over each issue before adjudicating the merits and that, once apparent, a potential jurisdictional defect may be raised by the court, tribunal or any party, sua sponte, at any stage in the proceedings. Barnett v. Brown, 83 F.3d 1380, 1383 (Fed. Cir. 1996). The present issue, service connection for depression, has been returned to the Board by the November 2009 U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) Order endorsing the joint motion for remand. The joint motion for remand found that the depression issue was inextricably intertwined with the hepatitis C issue. The joint motion for remand failed to mention that the Board did not issue a final decision on the issue of service connection for depression. The Court held that when an appellant files a timely NOD and no SOC is issued, the Board should remand, rather than refer, the issue to the RO for the issuance of an SOC. Manlincon v. West, 12 Vet. App. 238, 240-41 (1999). In June 2008, the Board remanded the claim for depression under Manlincon, for issuance of a SOC. The Board did not decide the claim or conclude that a perfected appeal existed. The Court's jurisdiction extends only to those claims which have been the subject of a final Board decision. When the Board remands, no final decision is made as to that issue. The Board is not clear what the Court's jurisdiction was to remand the depression claim; however, because it has been the subject of the November 2009 Order, the Board will consider whether jurisdiction exists for the Board to address the claim. The Board remanded the depression claim in June 2008 for issuance of a Statement of the Case. The threshold question is whether the appellant has submitted a timely substantive appeal following the SOC. As noted above, appellate review is initiated by an NOD and completed by a substantive appeal after an SOC is furnished by the RO. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(a); 38 C.F.R. § 20.200. Proper completion and filing of a substantive appeal are the last actions a claimant needs to take to perfect an appeal. 38 C.F.R. § 20.202. The NOD and the substantive appeal must be filed with the VA office that entered the determination with which disagreement has been expressed. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(b)(1); 38 C.F.R. § 20.300. After an NOD is filed, an SOC is to be prepared unless the benefit being sought is granted in full. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(d)(1). The SOC is to be forwarded to the claimant at his or her most recent address of record, with a copy provided to the claimant's representative. 38 C.F.R. § 19.30(a). Thereafter, a claimant must file a substantive appeal. A substantive appeal consists of a properly completed VA Form 9 or correspondence containing the necessary information. 38 C.F.R. § 20.202. The substantive appeal must be filed within 60 days from the date the SOC is mailed or within the remainder of the one- year time period from the date of mailing of notice of the initial determination being appealed, whichever ends later. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(d)(3); 38 C.F.R. § 20.302(b). Except as provided in 38 C.F.R. § 20.302, the filing of additional evidence after the receipt of notice of an adverse determination does not extend the time limit for initiating or completing an appeal from that determination. 38 C.F.R. § 20.304. Except in the case of simultaneously contested claims, if (i) a claimant submits additional evidence within one year of the date of mailing of the notification of the determination being appealed, and (ii) that evidence requires, in accordance with 38 C.F.R. § 19.31, that the claimant be furnished a supplemental statement of the case, then the time to submit a substantive appeal shall end not sooner than 60 days after such supplemental statement of the case is mailed to the appellant, even if the 60- day period extends beyond the expiration of the one-year appeal period. 38 C.F.R. § 20.302(b)(2). In an April 2004 rating decision, the RO denied service connection for depression and hepatitis C. The appellant was informed of this decision and of his procedural and appellate rights in an April 16, 2004 letter. The appellant submitted a May 2004 NOD in which he expressed his disagreement with the denials of service connection for depression and hepatitis. In addition, the appellant submitted additional evidence pertinent to the depression claim. An April 2005 SOC was issued on the hepatitis C claim. The appellant submitted a Form 9, received on May 17 or 18, 2005, which perfected the hepatitis C appeal and stated that the depression claim was also an appeal item. A May 2005 rating decision was issued, continuing the depression claim denial. The appellant was informed of this decision and of his procedural and appellate rights in a May 23, 2005, letter. The RO did not further process the depression claim. The appellant's representative prepared a May 2008 Informal Hearing Presentation in which he argued that the appellant should receive a SOC for the depression claim and that the Board should remand under Manlincon. The Board did so in June 2008, while also denying the appellant's hepatitis C claim. The RO then issued an August 2008 SOC on the depression claim. The appellant was provided notice of the SOC and his appellate and procedural rights in an August 8, 2008, letter. Under the circumstances described above, the appellant must have perfected his appeal to the Board within sixty days following notice of the SOC, October 8, 2008, as such date would have been later than the alternative deadline of one- year following notice of the April 2004 or May 2005 RO denial. As described below, he did not do so. An IRIS computer log of contact with the appellant has been printed out and associated with the claims file. The appellant had contacted the RO in November 2005, both times to check on the status of his appeal. The next contact was on August 8, 2008, when the SOC was released. A second entry, also from August 8, 2008, indicates that the award was returned, reviewed for accuracy and sent back to authorization. The log indicates that the next contact was on April 1, 2009, indicating that his benefits have been cut off, due to an EVR not submitted. On April 2, 2009, the appellant contacted the RO again, indicating that he was homeless and that the EVR had been submitted. Of note, a January 2003 contact log entry indicates that the appellant was homeless and that his mailing address was solely for mail. The log also reflects a July 30, 2009, entry indicating that the claims file had been received back from the Office of General Counsel, where it had been pending the appeal of the June 2008 Board decision to the Court. A review of the file showed that no reply had been received to the August 2008 SOC. The file would be returned to the RO and EP 338 cancelled. The log reflects that the appellant called on September 23, 2009, "to check on the status of his claim for appeals." The entry state that the appeals were still being processed by a Decision Review Officer. The appellant filed a petition to reopen the depression claim, along with original claims for a back condition, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia, a bilateral foot condition and a liver condition on October 15, 2009. A set of facsimile records were received in November 2009, which include a Substantive Appeal VA Form 9, signed by the appellant on October 14, 2009. An October 16, 2009, report of contact indicates that the appellant called to check on his appeal. He claimed that he never received his SOC. The person filing the report stated that the VA computer system showed a SOC sent out in August and that the appeal had been closed. A request to pull his file and take appropriate action was entered. This report of contact also appears on the IRIS contact log. The appellant was sent an October 26, 2009, letter under the guidelines of the Veterans Claims Assistance Act, which listed, among others, the depression claim as one to reopen a previously denied claim. The letter indicates that he had been previously denied and had failed to appeal the issue. The record reflects that the appellant has been using a single address to receive his mail throughout the course of his hepatitis C and depression claims. None of his mail has ever been returned from that address. The Board notified the appellant and his representative in a June 2010 letter that his substantive appeal was untimely, and provided the pertinent laws and regulations to them at that time. The Board notified the appellant and his representative that they had 60 days to request a hearing or to submit evidence and argument concerning the timeliness of his substantive appeal. The appellant responded in June 2010 with his argument and some copies of the documents discussed above. He did not request a hearing. Therefore, the appellant has been accorded all due process. The appellant argues that he never received the SOC sent in August 2008. However, there is a "presumption of regularity" under which it is presumed that government officials have properly discharged their official duties. See Ashley v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 307, 308-09 (1992). Unless rebutted by clear evidence to the contrary, VA is entitled to the benefit of this presumption. Id.; see also Mindenhall v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 271 (1994) (applying the presumption to procedures at the RO). The mailing of the Statement of the Case falls under the presumption of regularity for business documents. The Board acknowledges the recent decision of the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) in Percy v. Shinseki, 23 Vet. App. 37 (2009) which held that the 60- day period in which to file a substantive appeal is not jurisdictional, and thus VA may waive any issue of timeliness in the filing of a substantive appeal. In that case, by treating a disability rating matter as if it were part of the claimant's timely filed substantive appeal for more than five years, VA had waived any objections it might have had to the timeliness of the appeal with respect to the matter. In this case, VA did not waive any issue of timeliness. The contact log, as set forth above, shows that the appellant was not informed that his Form 9 was timely. At most, a September 2009 entry indicates that he was told that appeal was being processed by a Decision Review Officer. No Form 8 was issued showing that the depression claim had been appealed. The October 2009 notice letter informed the appellant that the depression claim had not been appealed and was final. Accordingly, the Board concludes that this case may be distinguished from Percy. The Board further notes that there are no communications prior to or following the expiration of the appeal period which could be construed as a request for extension of time to file a substantive appeal. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105(d)(3); 38 C.F.R. § 20.303. Neither the appellant nor his representative have indicated that his failure to timely file a substantive appeal was due to good cause. The appellant was properly provided notice of his appellate rights. There is no excuse for his failure to file a timely appeal. Absent a timely substantive appeal, an appeal was not perfected on the denial of service connection for depression, and the Board is without jurisdiction to adjudicate the claim. Consequently, the benefit-of-the-doubt rule does not apply, and the appeal must be dismissed. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b) (West 2002); Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 55 (1990). II. Due Process The Board has determined the appellant did not submit a timely substantive appeal with regard to the rating decision currently on appeal. As such, the Board is declining jurisdiction to consider the merits of the claim. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a) (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 20.101 (2009). Thus, VA is not required to take any further action to assist the claimant under the Veterans Claims Assistance Act. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5103A(a) (West 2002); In this case, the appellant was properly notified of the jurisdictional problem, and he was afforded the procedural safeguards of notice and the opportunity to be heard on the question of timeliness in a June 2010 letter, to which he responded with argument and evidence. The Board concludes that due process safeguards have been satisfied. ORDER The appeal of entitlement to service connection for depression, secondary to hepatitis C, is dismissed. REMAND The hepatitis C claim must be remanded for an adequate VA examination and medical opinion. The joint motion for remand concluded that VA's duty to assist had not been satisfied by the VA examination relied on by the Board in June 2008. Specifically, VA guidance on hepatitis C indicates that transmission of hepatitis C by air-gun injectors was "biologically plausible" but there was no scientific evidence of this actually happening. Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) Fast letter 04-13 (June 29, 2004). Thus, a "full discussion of all modes of transmission, and a rationale as to why the examiner believes the air-gun was the source of the veteran's Hepatitis C" was necessary in adjudicating any service connection claim for hepatitis C. The appellant had been seen for a December 2004 VA examination to develop medical evidence for this claim. The examiner indicated in the report that the infection was at least as likely as not from other more common causes, than from an air-gun injection. The examiner noted that he had never seen air-guns listed among the modes of transmission for hepatitis C. The joint motion for remand found this to be inadequate. The Board remands for an adequate VA examination and opinion which considers the air-gun injection as a biologically plausible mode of transmission and a full discussion of all modes of transmission in determining whether the appellant's hepatitis C is at least as likely as not due to service. The Board notes that the joint motion for remand also instructed that VA obtain the appellant's treatment records for periods of incarceration from the Kansas Department of Corrections. The appellant submitted these records on his own in May 2010. Accordingly, the case is REMANDED for the following action: 1. Schedule the appellant for a VA examination to determine whether his hepatitis C is as likely as not etiologically related to inservice air-gun injection inoculations. The entire claims folder and a copy of this REMAND must be made available to the physician. All indicated studies should be conducted, and the results reviewed before the final opinion. The opinion should discuss the appellant's air-gun injection during service as a mode of transmission and provide a full discussion of all modes of transmission, with a rationale as to whether the hepatitis C is at least as likely as not related to service. It would be helpful if the examiners would use the following language, as may be appropriate: "more likely than not" (meaning likelihood greater than 50%), "at least as likely as not" (meaning likelihood of at least 50%), or "less likely than not" or "unlikely" (meaning that there is a less than 50% likelihood). The term "at least as likely as not" does not mean "within the realm of medical possibility." Rather, it means that the weight of medical evidence both for and against a conclusion is so evenly divided that it is as medically sound to find in favor of that conclusion as it is to find against it. The examiners should provide a complete rationale for any opinion provided. 2. Then, the RO should readjudicate the claim on the merits. If the benefits sought are not granted, the appellant and his representative should be furnished a SSOC and afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond before the record is returned to the Board for further review. The appellant has the right to submit additional evidence and argument on the matter or matters the Board has remanded. Kutscherousky v. West, 12 Vet. App. 369 (1999). This claim must be afforded expeditious treatment. The law requires that all claims that are remanded by the Board of Veterans' Appeals or by the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims for additional development or other appropriate action must be handled in an expeditious manner. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5109B, 7112 (West Supp. 2009). ______________________________________________ K. PARAKKAL Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs