Citation Nr: 1038274 Decision Date: 10/12/10 Archive Date: 10/22/10 DOCKET NO. 07-22 359 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Lincoln, Nebraska THE ISSUES 1. Whether there was clear and unmistakable error (CUE) in the August 1997 rating decision which denied entitlement to service connection for a right knee disability. 2. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007, for the award of service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis. (The Veteran's motion to revise a November 1999 Board decision that denied service connection for a right knee disability based on clear and unmistakable error (CUE) is the subject of a separate Board decision). REPRESENTATION Appellant represented by: John Stevens Barry, Attorney-at- Law ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD L.J. Bakke, Counsel INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from September 1986 to November 1991. This appeal arises before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from rating decisions rendered in September 2007 and May 2009 by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Lincoln, Nebraska in which service connection for right knee laxity, patellar tenonitis was granted and evaluated as 20 percent disabling effective July 30, 2007 and CUE was not found in the August 1997 rating decision in which service connection for a right knee disability was denied. The Veteran appealed the effective date assigned the grant of service connection for right knee laxity, patellar tendonitis, including whether CUE was committed in an August 1997 rating decision that initially denied the claim. In a June 2009 decision, the Board denied an effective date prior to July 30, 2007 for the award of service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis. The Veteran appealed that decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (hereinafter Court). Based on a March 2010 Joint Motion for Remand (Joint Motion), the Court vacated and remanded the Board's June 2009 decision for development in compliance with the Joint Motion. In essence, the Court remanded the Board's June 2009 decision on the issue of entitlement to an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007 for the grant of service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis, in order to allow the one year period to transpire in which the Veteran could file an appeal as to a May 2009 rating decision which denied a finding of CUE in the August 1997 rating decision that denied service connection for a right knee disability. The Veteran subsequently perfected an appeal of the CUE decision. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. In an August 1997 rating decision, the RO denied service connection for a right knee disability. 2. The August 1997 rating decision was subsumed by a November 1999 Board decision. 3. Service connection for right knee laxity, patellar tendonitis was granted in a September 2007 rating decision, and evaluated as 20 percent disabling, effective July 30, 2007. 4. A claim to reopen the previously denied claim for service connection for a right knee disability was received on July 30, 2007. 5. The evidence of record does not show a claim, formal or informal, seeking to reopen the Veteran's claim for service connection for a right knee disability prior to July 30, 2007. CONCLUSION OF LAW 1. There was no CUE in the August 1997 rating decision that denied service connection for a right knee disability. 38 C.F.R. § 3.105(a) (2009). 2. The criteria for an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007 for the grant of service connection for right knee laxity and patellar tendonitis have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5100 (West 2002 and Supp. 2009); 38 C.F.R. § 3.155(a), 3.400 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS I. Duty to Notify & Assist Concerning the claim of clear and unmistakable error (CUE) in August 1997 rating decision, the Board notes that the Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) does not apply to claims alleging CUE. Livesay v. Principi, 15 Vet. App. 165 (2001). Concerning the claim for an earlier effective date, VA has met all statutory and regulatory notice and duty to assist provisions. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5100, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5106, 5107, 5126 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326 (2009). A letter dated in August 2007 satisfied the duty to notify provisions for the issue of service connection, after which the claim was adjudicated. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.159; Kent v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 1 (2006); Overton v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 427 (2006); see also Dingess/Hartman v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). In addition, this case involves a "downstream" issue, as the initial claim for service connection was granted in the September 2007 rating decision appealed, and the current appeal arises from the Veteran's disagreement with the effective date initially assigned the service-connected right knee laxity, patellar tendonitis. In cases where a service connection has been granted and an evaluation has been assigned, the typical claim has been more than substantiated, it has been proven, thereby rendering section 5103(a) notice no longer required because the purpose that the notice was intended to serve has been fulfilled. See Dingess v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). Thus as the Veteran's claim for an effective date for service connection earlier than July 30, 2007 was appealed directly from the grant of service connection and effective date assigned, no further action under Section 5103(a) is required. Goodwin v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 128 (2008); see also Hartman v. Nicholson, 483 F.3d 1311 (Fed. Cir. 2007); Dunlap v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 112 (2007). Moreover, the Veteran has neither alleged nor demonstrated any prejudice with regard to the content or timing of the notice. See Shinseki v. Sanders, 129 S. Ct. 1696 (2009) (reversing prior case law imposing a presumption of prejudice on any notice deficiency, and clarifying that the burden of showing that an error is harmful, or prejudicial, normally falls upon the party attacking the agency's determination); see also Mayfield v. Nicholson, 444 F.3d 1328, 1333-34 (Fed. Cir. 2006). In addition, the duty to assist the Veteran has also been satisfied in this case. The RO obtained the Veteran's service medical treatment records and identified VA treatment records. VA examination was provided in August 2007. As there is no indication that any failure on the part of VA to provide additional notice or assistance reasonably affects the outcome of this case, the Board finds that any such failure is harmless. See Mayfield v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 537 (2006); see also Dingess/Hartman, 19 Vet. App. at 493. II. CUE Previous determinations which are final and binding, including degree of disability and other matters, will be accepted as correct in the absence of CUE. Where evidence establishes such error, the prior rating decision will be reversed or amended. For the purpose of authorizing benefits, the rating or other adjudicatory decision which constitutes a reversal of a prior decision on the grounds of CUE has the same effect as if the corrected decision had been made on the date of the reversed decision. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5109A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.105(a). In order for CUE to exist: (1) "[e]ither the correct facts, as they were known at the time, were not before the adjudicator (i.e., more than a simple disagreement as to how the facts were weighed or evaluated) or the statutory or regulatory provisions extant at the time were incorrectly applied;" (2) the error must be "undebatable" and of the sort "which, had it not been made, would have manifestly changed the outcome at the time it was made;" and (3) a determination that there was CUE must be based on the record and law that existed at the time of the prior adjudication in question. Damrel v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 242, 245 (1994) (quoting Russell v. Principi, 3 Vet. App. 310, 313-14 (1992) (en banc)). To establish a CUE claim the alleged error must have been outcome determinative and the error must have been based upon the evidence of record at the time of the original decision. See Cook v. Principi, 318 F.3d 1334, 1344 (Fed. Cir. 2002), cert. denied, 123 S.Ct. 2574 (2003) (citations omitted). CUE is the kind of legal or factual error that when called to the attention of later reviewers compels the conclusion, to which reasonable minds could not differ, that the result would have been manifestly different but for the error. Fugo v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 40 at 43 (1993), overruled in part by Simmons v. Principi, 17 Vet. App. 104 (2003). To reasonably raise CUE, there must be some degree of specificity as to what the alleged error is, and unless it is the kind of error that, if true, would be CUE on its face, persuasive reasons must be given as to why the result would have been manifestly different but for the error. Id. at 44. Simply to claim CUE on the basis that previous adjudications had improperly weighed and evaluated the evidence can never rise to the stringent definition of CUE. Id. Historically, in January 1997, the Veteran filed a claim for service connection for a right knee disability. The RO denied the Veteran's claim in an August 1997 rating decision, explaining that the evidence did not demonstrate that the Veteran was diagnosed with a right knee disability. The Veteran appealed this decision and, in November 1999, the Board affirmed the RO's August 1997 decision. The Board summarized the Veteran's contentions and noted that service treatment records showed treatment for a right knee disability during active service. The Board summarized the findings of VA examiners who had examined the Veteran in 1997, 1998, and 1999 and found that the medical evidence did not establish that the Veteran manifested a current right knee disability. Accordingly, absent findings of a current right knee disability, the Board held that service connection could not be granted. When a determination of the agency of original jurisdiction is affirmed by the Board, such determination is subsumed by the final appellate decision and may not thereafter be reopened and allowed except upon receipt of new and material evidence. A claim based on the same factual basis may not be considered. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5108, 7104 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 20.1104 (2009). An unappealed rating decision, reviewed on the merits by the Board, is subsumed in the Board decision and is not subject to a claim of CUE as a matter of law. Manning v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 534, 540 (2002) (citing Donovan v. West, 158 F.3d 1377, 1381-82 (Fed. Cir. 1998)); Duran v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 216, 224 (1994). The Federal Circuit clarified that a later Board decision's delayed subsuming of a RO decision occurs only when the Board decided the same issue that the RO decided and when the RO decision and the Board review were based on the same factual basis. Brown v. West, 203 F.3d 1378, 1381-82 (Fed. Cir. 2000). The Federal Circuit held that it would be inconsistent with the statutes governing the finality of Board decisions to permit a CUE challenge before the RO to an earlier RO decision after the Board had reviewed all the evidence in that RO decision and denied service connection, thus in essence affirming the RO decision. In its November 1999 decision, the Board performed a de novo review of the claim for service connection for a right knee disability. The Board affirmed the RO decision on the same claim and factual basis. Accordingly, the Board finds that the November 1999 Board decision subsumed the RO's August 1997 decision. Therefore, the August 1997 RO decision is not subject to a claim of CUE as a matter of law. To the extent that the Veteran asserts CUE in the Board's November 1999 decision, this contention is being addressed by the Board in a separate decision. Based on the foregoing, the Board concludes that the Veteran's claim of CUE in the August 1997 rating decision fails as a matter of a law. Accordingly, the claim is dismissed. III. Earlier Effective Date Except as otherwise provided, the effective date of an evaluation and award of compensation based on an original claim or a claim reopened after final disallowance, will be the date of receipt of the claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is the later. 38 C.F.R. § 3.400 (2008). The effective date of the grant of benefits based on a reopened claim shall be the date of receipt of claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is later. 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(r). The effective date of an award of service connection is based upon a variety of factors, including date of claim, date entitlement is shown, and finality of prior decisions. See, e.g., Lalonde v. West, 12 Vet. App. 377, 382 (1999) (holding that "the effective date of an award of service connection is not based on the date of the earliest medical evidence demonstrating a causal connection, but on the date that the application upon which service connection was eventually awarded was filed with VA"). The date of receipt of a claim is the date on which a claim, information, or evidence is received by VA. 38 C.F.R. § 3.1(r). A "claim" is defined broadly to include a formal or informal communication in writing requesting a determination of entitlement or evidencing a belief in entitlement to a benefit. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.1(p); see also Brannon v. West, 12 Vet. App. 32, 34-5 (1998); Servello v. Derwinski, 3 Vet. App. 196, 199 (1992). Any communication or action indicating an intent to apply for one or more benefits under the laws administered by VA, from a veteran or his representative, may be considered an informal claim. Such informal claim must identify the benefit sought. Upon receipt of an informal claim, if a formal claim has not been filed, an application form will be forwarded to the claimant for execution. If received within one year from the date it was sent to the Veteran, it will be considered filed as of the date of receipt of the informal claim. When a claim has been filed which meets the requirements of 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.151 or 3.152, an informal request for increase or reopening will be accepted as a claim. 38 C.F.R. § 3.155. A report of examination or hospitalization may be accepted as an informal claim for benefits, but only after there has been a prior allowance or disallowance of a formal claim for compensation. 38 C.F.R. § 3.157; Crawford v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 33, 35-6 (1993). The Veteran contends that an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007 for the grant of service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis should be assigned. Specifically, he argues that the award of service connection for this condition should be effective as of the date of his original claim in January 1997. As noted above, the Veteran filed his original claim seeking service connection for a right knee disorder in January 1997. The RO denied the Veteran's claim in an August 1997 rating decision, which the Veteran appealed. In November 1999, the Board issued a decision which denied the claim for service connection for a right knee disability. The Board's November 1999 decision is final. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a). As explained above, the Board's decision subsumed the August 1997 rating decision. See Duran, supra; Brown, supra. By a separate decision, the Board has denied the Veteran's motion for revision of the November 1999 Board decision that denied service connection for a right knee disability. The Board's November 1999 decision, which denied the Veteran's original claim seeking service connection for a right knee disorder, is final. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a). On July 30, 2007, the RO received the Veteran's claim to reopen the previously denied claim for service connection for a right knee disability. In September 2007, the RO issued a rating decision which granted service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis, and assigned a disability evaluation of 20 percent, effective July 30, 2007. Considering the evidence of record, summarized in pertinent part above, and in light of the applicable laws and regulations, the Veteran's claim must be denied. The provisions of 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110(a) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.400 are clear that an award of service connection "shall" be the later of the receipt of the claim to reopen or the date entitlement arose. 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(r). In this case, the earliest possible claim to reopen was received on July 30, 2007, and there are no documents that can be construed as a claim, formal or informal, prior to this date. See 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.1, 3.155 (2009). The Veteran and his representative do not point to any document that may serve as a formal or informal claim to reopen the previously denied claim for a right knee disability. Rather, in the November 2007 notice of disagreement, January 2008 substantive appeal, and August 2010 post-Court remand argument the Veteran and his representative point to arguments in support of CUE in the August 1997 rating decision which has been denied by this decision, and the November 1999 Board decision which has been denied by a separate Board decision. The record simply presents no basis upon which to assign an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007 for the grant of service connection for right knee laxity and patellar tendonitis. The preponderance of the evidence is against the claim; there is no benefit of doubt to be resolved; and an effective date earlier than July 30, 2007 for service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis is not warranted. Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49 (1990). ORDER The claim for CUE in the August 1997 rating decision which denied entitlement to service connection for a right knee disability is dismissed. An earlier effective date prior to July 30, 2007, for the award of service connection for right knee laxity with patellar tendonitis is denied. ____________________________________________ DAVID L. WIGHT Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs