Citation Nr: 1024490 Decision Date: 06/30/10 Archive Date: 07/08/10 DOCKET NO. 01-02 575A ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania THE ISSUES 1. Entitlement to an initial compensable rating for major depression from April 15, 1981, to March 13, 1994. 2. Entitlement to an initial rating in excess of 50 percent for major depression from March 14, 1994. 3. Entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU) due to service-connected disability. REPRESENTATION Veteran represented by: Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States WITNESSES AT HEARING ON APPEAL Veteran and her spouse ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD Heather J. Harter, Counsel INTRODUCTION The veteran had active service from April 1979 to April 1981. This matter came to the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from rating decisions of the RO in Cleveland, Ohio. In a September 1999 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for major depression and assigned an initial noncompensable rating for the period from April 15, 1981, to March 13, 1994, and a 50 percent rating from March 14, 1994. The RO denied the Veteran's claim for a TDIU in September 2000. In February 2002, the veteran and her husband testified before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge at a hearing held at the RO. The Board remanded the appeal for further procedural and evidentiary development in June 2003 and again in November 2008. Such development has been accomplished and the matter has been returned to the Board for further appellate review. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. From April 15, 1981 to March 13, 1994, the evidence of record does not demonstrate social and industrial impairment which can be attributed to the Veteran's service-connected major depression. 2. From March 13, 1994, to November 6, 1996, the Veteran's major depression is shown to have resulted in considerable social and industrial impairment. 3. From November 7, 1996 to the present, the Veteran's major depression is shown to have resulted in considerable social and industrial impairment; it is also shown to result in occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity. 4. The Veteran has been awarded service connection for major depression, rated as 50 percent disabling. 5. The Veteran's employment background includes two years as a legal secretary, and very sporadic part-time work since that time. Her educational background includes an Associates Degree. 6. The medical evidence shows the Veteran is unemployable due to her personality disorder and substance abuse problems. 7. The Veteran's service-connected disability alone does not render her unable to obtain or retain employment. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. From April 15, 1981 to March 13, 1994, the criteria for the award of a compensable disability rating for major depression have not been met. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5107 (West 1991); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.130, 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995). 2. From March 14, 1994, to November 6, 1996, a disability rating greater than 50 percent for major depression is not warranted. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5107 (West 1991); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.130, 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995). 3. From November 7, 1996 to the present, a disability rating greater than 50 percent for major depression is not warranted under either the older or the newer regulatory criteria, as neither set of criteria supports a more favorable analysis of the Veteran's situation. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5107 (West 1991); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.130, 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995); 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155, 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.126, 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). 4. A total disability rating for compensation based upon individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities is not warranted. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1155, 5107 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.321, 3.340, 3.341, 4.16 (2009). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran contends she is totally disabled and rendered unemployable by her service-connected major depression. She is seeking a 100 percent disability rating and/or a grant of a total disability rating based upon unemployability due to service-connected disability for the entire period of time at issue. Duties to notify and assist When an application for benefits is received, VA has certain notice and assistance requirements under the law. See 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a). First, proper notice must be provided to a claimant before the initial VA decision on a claim for benefits and must: (1) inform the claimant about the information and evidence not of record necessary to substantiate the claim; (2) inform the claimant about the information and evidence that VA will seek to provide; and (3) inform the claimant about the information and evidence the claimant is expected to provide. This information was provided in letters of March 2003 and May 2004, prior to the most recent adjudications of this appeal. The VA is also required to inform the Veteran of how the VA assigns disability ratings and effective dates. See Dingess/Hartman v. Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 473 (2006). A letter containing this information was provided to the Veteran in March 2009. The Veteran's service treatment records, VA medical records, VA vocational rehabilitation records, and copies of her Social Security records have been obtained. She has submitted a treatment workbook showing her efforts at psychological self-understanding for review. She and her former husband provided sworn testimony during a hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge. She and her representative have presented written arguments in support of her claims. The veteran has been provided with VA medical examinations. Concerning this, when VA undertakes to provide a VA examination or obtain a VA opinion, it must ensure that the examination or opinion is adequate. Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 312 (2007). The Board finds that the VA examinations obtained in this case are adequate, as they were predicated on a review of the claims file and all pertinent evidence of record as well as on clinical examinations, and provide medical information needed to address the rating criteria relevant to this case. In particular, the report of the most recent March 2009 VA examination reflects extensive review of the Veteran's historical medical records over the past thirty years, and thorough analysis of the various psychiatric diagnoses which have been rendered over the years. The examiner was provided with and discussed the different rating criteria applicable to each rating period. The report reflects well-supported conclusions and clear explanations. The conclusions were based upon the Veteran's prior medical history and her disability was described in sufficient detail so that the Board's evaluation of the Veteran's major depression can be fully informed. See Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 120 (2007). We are satisfied that all relevant and obtainable evidence has been obtained. All relevant records and contentions have been carefully reviewed. Thus, the Board concludes that VA has satisfied its duties to notify and assist. Standard of review Once the evidence has been assembled, it is the Board's responsibility to evaluate the record. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7104(a). When there is an approximate balance of evidence regarding the merits of an issue material to the determination of the matter, the benefit of the doubt in resolving each such issue shall be given to the claimant. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107; 38 C.F.R. § 3.102. In Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 53 (1990), the Court stated that "a veteran need only demonstrate that there is an 'approximate balance of positive and negative evidence' in order to prevail." To deny a claim on its merits, the evidence must preponderate against the claim. Alemany v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 518, 519 (1996), citing Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 54. Analysis Increased disability ratings Because the veteran has perfected an appeal as to the assignment of the initial rating for major depression following the initial award of service connection, the VA is required to evaluate all the evidence of record reflecting the period of time between the effective date of the initial grant of service connection until the present. Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119 (1999). Since the Veteran's service connection grant was implemented effective in April 1981, this exercise involves a lengthy period of time and a large number of medical records. It is important to note at the outset that the Board's task here is that of reviewing the evidence of record and applying the appropriate laws and regulations to determine the appropriate disability rating to be assigned to the impairment resulting from the Veteran's service-connected major depression. In so doing, we note that the Veteran has multiple psychiatric diagnoses of record and that psychiatric symptoms can often result from multiple psychiatric disabilities. The United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has recognized the complexity of these cases involving multiple diagnoses, noting that for psychiatric conditions, multiple diagnoses may represent subjective differences of opinions of examiners. Clemons v. Shinseki, 23 Vet. App. 1 (2009). However, in this case, service connection has been granted for major depression only. Thus, the issue before the Board now is that of the appropriate disability rating to be assigned to her major depression. Because the Clemons case involved a claim for entitlement to service connection, viewing the disability at issue as broadly as possible was appropriate. Here, service connection has already been granted, and thus, our task is that of identifying the level of impairment resulting from the service-connected disability, to the extent possible. To accomplish this task, we rely upon medical experts to attribute the Veteran's various symptoms either to her service-connected major depression, or to her nonservice-connected disabilities, as this is a task requiring medical expertise which the Board does not possess. Colvin v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 171 (1991). Disability ratings are determined by applying the criteria set forth in VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities, which is based on the average impairment of earning capacity. Individual disabilities are assigned separate diagnostic codes. 38 U.S.C.A. § 1155 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 4.1 (2002). If a veteran has an unlisted disability, it will be rated under a disease or injury closely related by functions affected, symptomatology, and anatomical location. 38 C.F.R. § 4.20; see 38 C.F.R. § 4.27 (providing specific means of listing diagnostic code for unlisted disease or injury). If two evaluations are potentially applicable, the higher evaluation will be assigned if the disability picture more nearly approximates the criteria required for that rating; otherwise, the lower rating will be assigned. 38 C.F.R. § 4.7. If there is disagreement with the initial rating assigned following a grant of service connection, separate ratings can be assigned for separate periods of time, based on the facts found. Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119, 126 (1999). See AB v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 35, 38 (1993) (on a claim for an original or an increased rating, it is presumed that the veteran seeks the maximum benefit allowed by law and regulation, and it follows that such a claim remains in controversy when less than the maximum available benefit is awarded). Reasonable doubt as to the degree of disability will be resolved in the veteran's favor. 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. Pertinent regulations do not require that all cases show all findings specified by the Rating Schedule, but that findings sufficiently characteristic to identify the disease and the resulting disability and above all, coordination of rating with impairment of function will be expected in all cases. 38 C.F.R. § 4.21. Therefore, the Board has considered the potential application of various other provisions of the regulations governing VA benefits, whether or not they were raised by the veteran, as well as the entire history of the veteran's disability in reaching its decision. Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589, 595 (1991). Congenital or developmental defects such as personality disorders are not diseases or injuries for the purposes of service connection. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(c), 4.9. See Winn v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 510, 516 (1996), and cases cited therein. As service connection is precluded for personality disorders, it follows that VA compensation may not be paid for impairment resulting from personality disorders. With regard to substance abuse problems in general, governing law precludes the payment of VA compensation for disability which is the "result of the person's own willful misconduct or abuse of alcohol or drugs." 38 U.S.C.A. § 1110. Revised VA regulations codified in 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, regarding the evaluation of neuropsychiatric disabilities became effective November 7, 1996, before the promulgation of a final decision on the veteran's claim for entitlement to an increased rating for major depression. 61 Fed.Reg. 52695 (1996). When a law or regulation changes after a claim has been filed or reopened, but before the administrative or judicial appeal process has been concluded, the version most favorable to an appellant applies unless Congress provided otherwise or permitted the Secretary to do otherwise and the Secretary does so. Marcoux v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 289 (1996); Karnas v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 308 (1991). However, the new regulations cannot be applied prior to their effective date. A legal opinion promulgated by the VA Office of the General Counsel held that whether the amended criteria for the evaluation of mental disorders are more beneficial to claimants than the prior provisions should be determined on a case by case basis. VA O.G.C. Prec. 11-97 (Mar. 25, 1997). Thus, for the time period subsequent to November 7, 1996, a comparison of the old regulatory criteria as applied to the facts of the veteran's case with the new regulatory criteria as applied to the facts is required by law. Prior to November 1996, governing regulation provided that the severity of a psychiatric disability would be measured by actual symptomatology, as it affects social and industrial adaptability. 38 C.F.R. § 4.130 (1995). The criteria provided for evaluating impairment resulting from psychoneurotic disorders were as follows: There are neurotic symptoms which may somewhat adversely affect relationships with others but which do not cause impairment of working ability. [0 percent] Less than criteria for the 30 percent, with emotional tension or other evidence of anxiety productive of mild social and industrial impairment. [10 percent] Definite impairment in the ability to establish or maintain effective and wholesome relationships with people. The psychoneurotic symptoms result in such reduction in initiative, flexibility, efficiency and reliability levels as to produce definite industrial impairment. [30 percent] Ability to establish or maintain effective or favorable relationships with people is considerably impaired. By reason of psychoneurotic symptoms the reliability, flexibility, and efficiency levels are so reduced as to result in considerable industrial impairment. [50 percent] Ability to establish and maintain effective or favorable relationships with people is severely impaired. The psychoneurotic symptoms are of such severity and persistence that there is severe impairment in the ability to obtain or retain employment. [70 percent] The attitudes of all contacts except the most intimate are so adversely affected as to result in virtual isolation in the community. Totally incapacitating psychoneurotic symptoms bordering on gross repudiation of reality with disturbed thought or behavioral processes associated with almost all daily activities such a fantasy, confusion, panic, and explosions of aggressive energy resulting in profound retreat from mature behavior. Demonstrably unable to maintain or retain employment. [100 percent] 38 C.F.R. § 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995). Under the amended regulatory rating criteria, depression, along with other anxiety disorders, is rated under a "General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders". 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). As amended, the regulation reads: A mental condition has been formally diagnosed, but symptoms are not severe enough either to interfere with occupational and social functioning or to require continuous medication. [0 percent] Occupational and social impairment due to mild or transient symptoms which decrease work efficiency and ability to perform occupational tasks only during periods of significant stress, or; symptoms controlled by continuous medication. [10 percent] Occupational and social impairment with occasional decrease in work efficiency and intermittent periods of inability to perform occupational tasks (although generally functioning satisfactorily, with routine behavior, self-care, and conversation normal), due to such symptoms as: depressed mood, anxiety, suspiciousness, panic attacks (weekly or less often), chronic sleep impairment, mild memory loss (such as forgetting names, directions, recent events). [30 percent] Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short-and long-term memory (e.g., retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships. [50 percent] Occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near- continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately, and effectively; impaired impulse control (such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a worklike setting); inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. [70 percent] Total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own name. [100 percent] 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). The psychiatric symptoms discussed above are not exclusive; they are examples of typical symptoms for the listed percentage ratings. See Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436 (2002). In addition, other related regulations were amended in November 1996. According to the amended rating criteria, when evaluating a mental disorder, the rating agency shall consider the frequency, severity, and duration of psychiatric symptoms, the length of remissions, and the veteran's capacity for adjustment during periods of remission. The rating agency shall assign an evaluation based on all the evidence of record that bears on occupational and social impairment rather than solely on the examiner's assessment of the level of disability at the moment of the examination. 38 C.F.R. § 4.126(a) (2009). However, when evaluating the level of disability from a mental disorder, the rating agency will consider the extent of social impairment, but shall not assign an evaluation solely on the basis of social impairment. 38 C.F.R. § 4.126(b) (2009). All diagnoses of mental disorders must conform to the psychiatric standards set forth in the DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDER, Fourth Edition, The American Psychiatric Association (1994), (DSM-IV). 38 C.F.R. § 4.125 (2009). April 15, 1981 to March 13, 1994 The claims file contains little information pertaining to the Veteran's mental health status during this time period, as it does not appear that she sought regular medical treatment. The report of a VA psychiatric examination conducted in June 1981 reflects the examiner's conclusion that "the most likely diagnosis appears to be that of personality disorder, with possibly passive aggressive features." At the time, she was living with her parents, receiving unemployment, and hoping to go to school, although she was uncertain as to what type of school she desired. The Veteran earned an Associates degree in Secretarial Science in May 1983, and apparently worked as a legal secretary for approximately two years. The report of a February 1994 phone call with the Social Security Administration reflects the veteran's report that she was not seeing any health care provider for mental problems and was not taking medication at that time. She had not seen her previous mental health care provider since 1984, and had not been hospitalized since her inservice hospitalization at Bethesda Naval Hospital. A report provided by the Veteran's family doctor to the Social Security Administration in March 1994 reflects that she had last been seen in October 1992, that he had never prescribed any medication for an emotional condition and that there was no information in the Veteran's chart about depression, schizophrenia, or a personality disorder. During a follow-up phone call the same month, the doctor explained that he had suggested sending the Veteran to a mental health center several times, but that she refused to go. He never made a diagnosis of a mental disorder as he felt that was not his field. He also noted that the Veteran acted strange in his office, and that although she dressed appropriately, she did not appear well kept. In light of the near-total absence of medical or other evidence reflecting the Veteran's level of functioning from April 1981 until March 1994, the Board can only find that the criteria for a compensable disability rating have not been met. That she was able to attend school and maintain a job for at least two years is shown in the record, but the record contains little else contemporaneous with this period of time. The Board acknowledges the evidence from the Veteran's family doctor, that she acted strange and had been referred to a mental health center, but this statement does not provide a basis for 1) attributing these symptoms to major depression, versus her personality disorder or substance abuse problems (for which monetary compensation may not be paid, as explained above), or 2) assigning a particular percentage level of impairment. Absent evidence demonstrating that the Veteran manifested social and industrial impairment which could be reasonably attributed to major depression between April 1981 and March 1994, the Board is constrained to hold that the preponderance of the evidence is against the claim for a compensable disability rating under the provisions of 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.130, 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995), for this period of time. March 13, 1994 to November 6, 1996 The report of a March 1994 psychological examination conducted pursuant to the Veteran's Social Security claim reflects diagnoses of "rule out schizophrenia, undifferentiated type, and schizotypal personality disorder." The examiner noted that the Veteran's prognosis was very poor without treatment and opined that she was not capable of handling personal funds. The examiner also noted that the Veteran participated in behaviors that were potentially and actually harmful to her. The report reflects multiple instances of inappropriate communication, statements of tangentiality, difficulty concentrating, and derealization on the part of the Veteran during the clinical interview. The report of a March 1994 functional capacity assessment conducted pursuant to the Veteran's Social Security claim reflects poor maturity, very poor social interactions, and very poor ability to make decisions. It is these reports which provide the basis for the RO's award of a 50 percent disability rating from March 1994 to November 1996. It would appear that the Veteran was not employed during this period, although the evidence is inconclusive as to her employment status. During a 1997 Board hearing she testified that she had worked at a car wash briefly in 1994, but no further information is contained in any of the voluminous records which comprise the veteran's VA claims file. Upon review, the Board again notes the limited evidence reflecting these two and a half years, as two reports dated in March 1994 comprise the only evidence illustrating the Veteran's level of functioning during this time period. Our task is rendered more difficult, as neither of these reports contains a diagnosis of depression, but rather the authors attribute the Veteran's functional problems to possible schizophrenia and a personality disorder. Neither of these two disorders is considered to be service-connected for purposes of VA compensation. However, the evidence is clear that the Veteran was impaired in her ability to establish relationships with people and she reduced levels of reliability, flexibility and efficiency are certainly reflected in the two March 1994 reports. The evidence available, however, does not support a finding that her ability to establish and maintain effective or favorable relationships with people was severely impaired as a result of her service-connected disability during this time. Similarly, it is not shown that her psychoneurotic symptoms were of such severity and persistence that there was severe impairment in her ability to obtain or retain employment as a result of her service-connected disability from March 1994 to November 1996, as is required under the applicable criteria for an award of a 70 percent or higher disability rating. The Board therefore holds that the preponderance of the evidence is against a disability rating greater than 50 percent for service-connected major depression from March 1994 to November 1996. November 7, 1996 to the present As noted above, when a law or regulation changes after a claim has been filed or reopened, but before the administrative or judicial appeal process has been concluded, the version most favorable to an appellant applies. Thus, for the time period subsequent to November 7, 1996, a comparison of the old regulatory criteria as applied to the facts of the veteran's case with the new regulatory criteria as applied to the facts is required by law. In this case, it appears that the RO initially assigned the 50 percent disability rating under the newer criteria. However, it is the responsibility of the Board to perform the comparison required by law, so as to ensure that the Veteran is given the highest disability rating allowable by law, under whichever criteria are more favorable to her throughout the appeal period after the regulatory change was implemented. The Veteran briefly sought medical care from the VA healthcare system in April 1998. However, a May 1998 therapy note shows that she was "not desiring therapy at this time. . . Remains strongly fixated on claim determination." The report of a March 1999 VA examination reflects diagnoses of major depression with anxiety, alcohol dependence, cannabis abuse, and a histrionic personality disorder. A Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) Score of 55 was assigned. The VA examiner rendered the opinion that the Veteran's major depression, alcohol dependence, and cannabis abuse were the direct result of an incident during service, when the Veteran was sexually assaulted by an officer. The examiner commented in a June 1999 addendum that if the Veteran had been able to tell anyone about the assault and seek treatment at the time or soon after, her symptoms could have been controlled. It was essentially this report upon which the September 1999 grant of service connection for major depression was based. A June 1999 VA special psychological examination reflects that the Veteran was married in March 1998, but that the marriage was rocky. She had been working as a phone operator in January 1999 but was fired due to rudeness. The examiner opined that the examination itself was 'retraumatizing' to the Veteran, and noted that the interview was painful and unpleasant, because the Veteran was emotionally unstable, yelling, crying, and conveying her anger for one hour and a half. Following the clinical interview and psychological testing, the examiner rendered diagnosis of major depression with paranoid and anxious features, alcohol dependence in partial remission, sexual abuse of an adult based upon an alleged sexual assault, and a borderline personality disorder. The examiner specifically noted that the Veteran had inability to retain a job, manifested by a recent termination, but opined that "after medication and some achievement of emotional stability, perhaps the issue of retraining could be considered." A GAF Score of 43 was assigned. During an August 2000 VA examination, the veteran reported that she had worked as a salesperson, but not for more than a few months at a time. She remained married although she reported having some prior separations. She was not seeking psychiatric treatment, although she stated that her family doctor had given her some Prozac. She only took it when she was very angry with her husband, however. The examiner rendered a diagnosis of "a very severe borderline personality disorder, at times accompanied with pretty severe depression." The examiner assigned a GAF Score of 55 to 60, and explained that this means "she is expected to have serious difficulty functioning in her job, basically due to her personality disorder." During a February 2002 hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge, the Veteran testified that she was not taking any medication, but that she expected to begin regular psychiatric treatment at the VA in the near future. She also stated that she had done some seasonal part time work at Christmastime. With regard to her mental state, she testified that she was quick to anger and slow to get over her outrage. Her former husband testified that he felt her mental state was unstable, that she was easily frustrated and small irritations always grew into major confrontations. He stated that he was always on pins and needles when they would go out in public, and often avoided social situations, worried about an outburst from her. VA medical records reflect that the Veteran began psychiatric treatment in June 2002. She was assigned diagnoses of adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features, prolonged posttraumatic stress disorder, and depressive disorder. She attended individual therapy and group therapy, and began taking psychotropic medication, as well. She also entered the VA vocational rehabilitation system, and began taking computer classes under the auspices of that program. She also participated in a community work adjustment program. Both situations deteriorated over time, however, due to the Veteran's anger control problems, as she used inappropriate language, and became overly agitated on the job, yelling at customers and at her supervisor. According to vocational rehabilitation records, she disrupted her computer class to the point where other students requested to change to another class. Her case notes reflect instances of yelling at her case worker as well. After the last of these instances, the case worker recommended that the Veteran undergo weekly psychotherapy with a clinician versed in the treatment of personality disorders. The case worker, himself a neurorehabilitation psychologist, identified the Veteran's personality disorder as the source of her inability to work with others. The final report in her VA vocational rehabilitation file reflects that she was eventually deemed unfeasible for employment; it was recommended that she focus on independent living skills and her emotional health, reducing as much stress as possible from her life. The Veteran's marriage was dissolved in January 2003. A March 2003 joint letter from the Veteran's treating VA psychologist and psychiatrist outlines her psychosocial stressors at the time, which included the end of the marriage and conflicts on the job in her VA-sponsored community readjustment program. She was experiencing depression, anxiety, sleep disturbance, anger management problems, and interpersonal conflicts. Her diagnoses at that time included dysthymia, mixed adjustment disorder, and borderline personality disorder. Her GAF was 45. The Veteran submitted a copy of a December 2003 mental functional capacity assessment completed by her VA treating psychologist, apparently in support of an application for food stamps and/or housing assistance. The report shows that a psychologist deemed the Veteran to be unemployable, although the psychologist indicated that the Veteran's mental functional limitations were expected to last between 30 days and nine months. Evidence submitted by the Veteran shows that she filed for bankruptcy in 2004. The Veteran's VA treating psychologist submitted a statement for the record in June 2004, showing that the Veteran was participating in a program for substance abuse involving alcohol and cocaine, and anxiety and anger management skills classes. She was taking medication. She was complaining of anxiety, depression and occasional suicidal thoughts. She reported racing thoughts and trouble concentrating. She had a low tolerance for stress and a history of interpersonal conflicts and problematic behaviors. Her pertinent diagnoses were recurrent major depression, alcohol abuse in partial remission, and borderline personality disorder. The psychologist assigned a GAF Score of 50. A VA clinical social worker submitted a June 2004 statement for the record, reflects that during the previous year the Veteran had displayed symptoms of a mood disorder, including depressive moods, a sense of hopelessness, a limited sense of insight caused by lowered expectations, an inability to resolve basic issues concerning her life, and a poor sense of planning her daily activities. He also indicated that her quality of life has been negatively impacted by these symptoms, and that she was attempting to resolve these issues through a variety of treatment modalities. The Veteran's VA outpatient treatment reports reflect her group and individual therapy from 2002 through 2006. Additionally, the Veteran has submitted several workbooks and worksheets she completed in her journey toward mental wellness during this time period. She discontinued taking all psychotropic medication in February 2006, with the approval of her treating VA psychiatrist. She apparently ceased psychiatric and psychological treatment with VA later in 2006. A letter from a psychologist with the Southwestern Pennsylvania Human Services Agency received in August 2007 indicates that he had been treating the Veteran for the previous year for PTSD, with panic attacks, hypervigilant behaviors, night terrors, and impairment with concentration, maintaining a schedule, distractibility, occupational tasks, response to authority, awareness of hazards, and travel in unfamiliar places. The psychologist indicated that the Veteran was having financial difficulty because "she still has significant occupational impairment." A February 2008 report of an evaluation performed on behalf of the Pennsylvania Office of Vocational Rehabilitation is of record. Following extensive testing and a clinical interview with the Veteran, the examining psychologist reached the conclusion that the Veteran was unemployable at that time due to her psychiatric disabilities and compromised emotional status. The psychologist rendered diagnostic impressions of bipolar I disorder, rule out schizoaffective disorder; polysubstance dependence of unknown status; reported PTSD; and a personality disorder, not otherwise specified. The psychologist reported that the results from the clinical interview and personality assessment revealed extreme levels of continuing emotional turmoil associated with her disorders. The Veteran scored very high on one particular test designed to measure levels of sociopathy. At the time of the evaluation, she was experiencing severe mood swings, clinical depression, anxiety, social isolation, and agitation. The psychologist recommended in the strongest terms that the Veteran initiate psychiatric treatment, to include pharmacotherapy, as soon as possible, and indicated that she would benefit from a day treatment or partial hospitalization program. The psychologist summarized that not only was the Veteran not a candidate for vocational services at that time, she was "a most severely disabled young woman suffering from a severe bipolar disorder, or perhaps, a schizoaffective disorder." An April 2008 statement from a counselor with the Southwestern Pennsylvania Human Services Agency reflects that the veteran had been assessed as "alcohol dependent," and had attended substance abuse treatment from January through April 2008. During a March 2009 VA examination, the Veteran reported that she was not receiving medical care for major depression at that time, but that she was considering whether to resume regular treatment. She also reported that she had worked for a couple of months in 2005 at U Haul for twenty hours a week, but left because they had asked her to work more hours, which she found to be too stressful. Pursuant to the Board's most recent remand, the Veteran underwent a VA examination in March 2009. The examination was extremely thorough, including psychological testing, a clinical interview, and a comprehensive review of the medical records in the Veteran's claims file, as shown by the extensive report prepared by the examiner. The examiner systematically reviewed all of the various diagnoses assigned to the Veteran's disabilities over the years by different providers, and concluded that the diagnoses which were substantiated over time and which conformed to the DSM-IV, were that of recurrent major depressive disorder, which the examiner characterized as mild to moderate; alcohol abuse, cannabis abuse, history of cocaine abuse, and a borderline personality disorder. The examiner specified that the substance abuse diagnoses and the personality disorder were unrelated to the Veteran's military service and unrelated to her major depression. The examiner assigned a "current GAF due solely to service-connected condition" of 65, and an "overall GAF secondary to all conditions" of 50. The examiner provided the following summary regarding these conclusions: It is this examiner's opinion that in addition to her [service connected] depression, she fulfills diagnostic criteria for substance abuse and her personality disorder. These are not secondary to her service-connected depression nor are they part of her depression. It appears quite clear that her ongoing substance abuse and characterological issues are the primary factor that affects her ability to obtain or maintain employment. She has been through a vocational rehabilitation program in the past, but was unable to complete it due to interpersonal difficulties. It also appears that her substance abuse is not being adequately addressed. Given the ongoing substance abuse and her characterological issues, it is unlikely that she would be able to maintain employment. Her service-connected condition of depression alone [does] not prevent her from engaging in a substantially gainful occupation. Her service- connected depression does not affect her ability to complete ordinary activities or activities of daily living or functioning. In sum, throughout the time period at issue, from November 1996 to the present, the Veteran has struggled with several major life events, including marriage, divorce, and bankruptcy. She attempted to return to school; attempted to engage in serious psychotherapy; and attempted at least several jobs through the VA and on her own; all without success. She also struggled with substance abuse and financial pressures throughout. Her personality disorder, as manifested by interpersonal conflicts, difficulties with anger, and the inability to get along with other people is a recurrent theme in her medical records, and, as emphasized above, is separate from her service-connected major depression. Upon a longitudinal review of the record pertaining to the time period from November 1996 to the present, the Board finds that the preponderance of the evidence is against a disability rating greater than 50 percent, for this time period, under either the older or newer regulatory criteria. Perhaps the most salient point is that throughout the time period at issue, it appears the Veteran nonservice-connected disabilities of a personality disorder and substance abuse caused greater overall functional impairment than did her service-connected major depression. In assigning the most appropriate disability rating, then, it is the responsibility of the VA to provide compensation for only that portion of her overall impairment that results from her service- connected major depression, to the extent that the symptomatology can be separately identified. Although the various psychologists and psychiatrists who have interviewed the Veteran and authored written records now contained in the claims file have not agreed on the Veteran's exact diagnoses, they all identify some sort of personality disorder, substance abuse, and some sort of depression, as impacting upon her overall decreased ability to function in the greater world. Several of the examiners and health care providers have specifically attributed the Veteran's anti- social characteristics, and inability to maintain employment to her personality disorder. For example the August 2000 VA examiner anticipated that she would have difficulty functioning in a job due to her personality disorder. The Veteran's VA vocational rehabilitation caseworker attributed the Veteran's inability to work with others solely to her personality disorder. The March 2009 examiner provided a specific explanation that the Veteran's ongoing substance abuse and characterological issues were the primary factor affecting her ability to obtain or maintain employment. The assignment of GAF scores between 43 and 60 throughout the time period at issue represents the assessments of mental health professionals that the veteran has "serious symptoms or any serious impairment in social, occupational or school functioning," or "moderate symptoms or moderate difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning." DSM-IV. These scores by themselves reflect an overall level of impairment which fits squarely into the criteria set forth for a 50 percent disability rating under either the older regulations or the newer regulations. However, when viewed in light of the March 2009 examiner's explanation that the Veteran's assessment of functioning due solely to major depression is a score of 65 (reflecting "Some mild symptoms or some difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning, but generally functioning pretty well"), the conclusion that a higher disability rating is not warranted becomes inescapable. In light of our conclusion that neither the older nor the newer regulatory criteria provides a more favorable result for the Veteran, an exhaustive comparison of the two is not necessary. We view the medical evidence as supporting a finding that the veteran's ability to establish or maintain effective or favorable relationships with people is considerably impaired on account of her service-connected major depression. Considerable industrial impairment due to depression is also demonstrated in the record. 38 C.F.R. § 4.132, Diagnostic Code 9405 (1995). However, we find, based upon the evidence of record and especially the persuasive analysis by the May 2009 VA examiner, that any further impairment in the Veteran's social and industrial capacity, beyond what could be deemed "considerable," is not due to her depression, but rather to her nonservice- connected disabilities of a personality disorder and substance abuse. Similarly, applying the newer regulatory criteria to the Veteran's situation yields the conclusion that her service- connected major depression results in reduced reliability and productivity, difficulty in understanding complex commands, impairment of memory, impaired judgment, impaired abstract thinking, disturbances of motivation and mood, and difficulty in establishing and maintain effective work and social relationships. While the Veteran does display many of the symptoms listed in the rating criteria for a 70 percent disability rating, such as illogical, obscure, or irrelevant speech, impaired impulse control, and difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances; these symptoms have been attributed to her personality disorder and substance abuse, rather than to her major depression, by those examiners who have attributed her symptomatology to the different disabilities. Analyzed under either set of criteria, neither a 70 percent disability rating for major depression nor a 100 percent disability rating for major depression is warranted. 38 C.F.R. § 4.132 (Diagnostic Code 9405) (1995); 38 C.F.R. § 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9434 (2009). The currently-assigned 50 percent disability rating is the more nearly analogous rating best reflecting the level of impairment resulting from the Veteran's service-connected major depression. The preponderance of the evidence is against the award of a higher disability rating and the benefit sought on appeal must be denied. In reviewing this complex case, we considered awarding staged ratings to reflect the apparent increases in the Veteran's level of functioning during her marriage, and during the time period when she was receiving regular medical care for her mental health issues, but in light of our conclusion that the highest disability rating warranted during the entire period from November 1996 to the present is that of 50 percent, assigning a lower rating for any smaller period therein would not benefit the Veteran. Concomitantly, however, it is reasonable to suppose that during the most difficult periods of her life, as outlined above, during the past fourteen or so years, she likely experienced periods of decreased functioning which are not adequately recorded in the record, as she did not seek regular mental health care, and thus does not have regular documentation of the course of her disability. Thus, on balance, a 50 percent disability rating throughout the entire time period is the rating which most accurately represents her overall impairment due to major depression. Generally, evaluating a disability using either the corresponding or analogous Diagnostic Codes contained in the rating schedule is sufficient. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.20, 4.27. For exceptional cases, VA has authorized the assignment of extraschedular ratings and provided the following guidance for awarding such ratings: To accord justice, therefore, to the exceptional case where the schedular evaluations are found to be inadequate, the Under Secretary for Benefits or the Director, [C & P], upon field station submission, is authorized to approve on the basis of the criteria set forth in this paragraph an extra-schedular evaluation commensurate with the average earning capacity impairment due exclusively to the service-connected disability or disabilities. The governing norm in these exceptional cases is: A finding that the case presents such an exceptional or unusual disability picture with such related factors as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization as to render impractical the application of the regular schedular standards. 38 C.F.R. § 3.321(b). As the Court recently explained in Thun, a "determination of whether a claimant is entitled to an extraschedular rating under § 3.321(b) is a three-step inquiry." Thun v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 111, 115 (2008). If the RO or Board determines that (1) the schedular evaluation does not contemplate the claimant's level of disability and symptomatology, and (2) the disability picture exhibits other related factors such as marked interference with employment or frequent periods of hospitalization, then (3) the case must be referred to an authorized official to determine whether, to accord justice, an extraschedular rating is warranted. Neither the RO nor the Board is permitted to assign an extraschedular rating in the first instance; rather the matter must initially be referred to those officials who possess the delegated authority to assign such a rating. See Floyd v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 88, 95 (1996). Anderson v. Shinseki, 22 Vet. App. 423 (2009). In this case, there is no allegation or indication that the schedular criteria are inadequate for rating the impairment resulting from the Veteran's major depression. Indeed, as discussed above, the Board held that the criteria set forth for a noncompensable disability rating more nearly approximated the symptomatology reflected in the evidence of record for the time period from April 1981 to March 1994. The Board also held that the criteria for a 50-percent disability rating more nearly approximated the Veteran's symptomatology arising from major depression subsequent to March 1994. Thus, the Board concurs with the RO's determination that no referral for consideration of an extraschedular rating is warranted in this matter. Unemployability Initially, the Board notes that the Veteran is actually unemployed, as she has not worked regularly since the 1980s. She testified during a 1997 Board hearing that she had worked at a car wash briefly in 1994, during a 1999 VA examination, she reported that she was working as a telephone operator, at the February 2002 hearing she reported some seasonal part- time work at Christmastime, and during the March 2009 VA examination, she stated she had worked at U Haul for a couple of months in 2005. Major depression is the Veteran's sole service-connected disability. A 50 percent disability rating is assigned. The Veteran earned an Associates degree in Secretarial Science in May 1983, and apparently worked as a legal secretary for approximately two years. In 1989, she applied for VA assistance in taking classes to become a flight attendant. However, she did not attend classes and withdrew from the program. She then submitted a September 1989 statement to the VA education service indicating that she no longer intended to attend school, and requesting that the contributions she had made to her education fund during service be refunded to her. Social Security Records show that the Social Security Administration determined the Veteran is incapable of handling benefit payments due to a combination of a personality disorder, depression, and schizophrenia. That agency determined that her primary diagnosis precluding work is that of schizotypal personality disorder. She apparently does not receive Social Security Disability benefit payments; however, as her cumulative employment contributions throughout her lifetime were not sufficient to qualify for these benefits. As described above, the Veteran was unable to complete a VA vocational rehabilitation program, due to her personality disorder. She was eventually deemed unfeasible for employment; it was recommended that she focus on independent living skills and her emotional health, reducing as much stress as possible from her life. In a February 2003 letter addressed to the Veteran's case worker, who as noted above is a neurorehabilitation psychologist, the Veteran's rehabilitation counselor manager and a rehabilitation counselor-in-training, made the following assessment: It is our recommendation she apply for individual unemployability status with the Veteran's Administration (sic). We are comfortable with this recommendation due to the various attempts of [the Veteran] to work and become financially independent over the past year. She is just not emotionally stable enough to handle the stressors of competitive work at this time, and it is obviously not from lack of trying. We feel if she were granted individual unemployability it would relieve a large amount of stress, and allow [the Veteran] to focus on healing, and becoming more emotionally stable. Total disability ratings for compensation based on individual unemployability may be assigned when the combined schedular rating for the service-connected disabilities is less than 100 percent and when it is found that the service-connected disabilities are sufficient to produce unemployability without regard to advancing age, provided that, if there is only one such disability, this disability is ratable at 60 percent or more, or if there are two or more disabilities, there is at least one disability ratable at 40 percent or more and additional disabilities to bring the combined rating to 70 percent or more. Alternatively, a total disability rating for compensation based on unemployability may be assigned to a veteran who is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of his/her service-connected disabilities. The veteran's employment history, educational and vocational attainment as well as his or her particular physical disabilities are to be considered in making a determination on unemployability. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16. In determining whether the veteran is entitled to a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability, neither her nonservice-connected disabilities nor her age may be considered. Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361 (1993). The sole fact that a claimant is unemployed or has difficulty obtaining employment is not enough. A high rating in itself is a recognition that the impairment makes it difficult to obtain and keep employment. The question is whether the veteran is capable of performing the physical and mental acts required by employment, not whether the veteran can find employment. Van Hoose. As the Veteran has a single service-connected disability, which is rated as 50 percent disabling, a total disability rating is not supported on a schedular basis, as the criteria set forth above are not met. As noted, however, a total disability rating for compensation based on unemployability may alternatively be assigned to a veteran who is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of his/her service-connected disabilities. In this case, the evidence does not support the Veteran's claim that she is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of her service-connected major depression, however. The medical and other professional evidence of record is all to the effect that the Veteran is actually unemployable, due to the combination of all her psychiatric disabilities. It is noteworthy, however, that none of the experts in this area have viewed the Veteran's unemployable status as permanent in nature. Rather, they emphasize that with treatment, she should be able to maintain employment. In particular, the Veteran's treating VA psychologist in December 2003 opined that the Veteran's mental functional limitations were expected to last between 30 days and nine months, and in February 2008, the psychologist who performed a vocational assessment stated that she might be able to perform part- time, supervised work if her emotional status were to improve. The resolution of this claim, however, revolves not around whether she is actually unable to maintain employment, but whether she is unable to do so on account of her service- connected major depression, without consideration of impairment arising from her other nonservice-connected disabilities. In applying the law to the facts of this case, then, the Board finds that the Veteran is not rendered unemployable due to her service-connected major depression. In so concluding, we rely upon the opinions contained in the evidence of record, submitted by medical professionals and occupational, vocational professionals. In particular, we note the well-explained conclusion rendered by the Veteran's VA case worker, who is a neurorehabilitation psychologist, to the effect that the Veteran's personality disorder, rather than her depression precluded her from working. The other medical evidence of record, including her VA medical records and the records generated by the various Pennsylvania state agencies, only supports these conclusions. It is important at this point to distinguish the multiple medical opinions cited above from the February 2003 statement made by the Veteran's VA vocational rehabilitation case worker and the rehabilitation counselor-in-training. They recommended that the Veteran apply for a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability, as they felt she was not employable, and was financially needy. They did not, however, attribute her unemployability to her major depression; rather, they attributed her unemployability to her emotional instability. It would appear that they were not entirely familiar with the criteria for an award of a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability and may not have realized that this award must be based solely upon impairment from service-connected disability. It is especially noteworthy that this letter was addressed to the Veteran's case worker, the neurorehabilitation psychologist, who in his subsequent final report also recommended that the veteran reduce stress, but specifically attributed her inability to work to her personality disorder, and did not recommend an award of a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability due to service connected disability. In sum, the preponderance of the evidence is against the Veteran's claim for a total disability rating based upon individual unemployability due to service connected disability. The appeal is denied. ORDER An initial compensable disability rating for major depression from April 15, 1981, to March 13, 1994, is denied. A disability rating greater than 50 percent for major depression from March 14, 1994, to the present, is denied. A total disability rating based upon individual unemployability due to service connected disability is denied. ____________________________________________ STEVEN L. COHN Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs