Citation Nr: 1104875 Decision Date: 02/07/11 Archive Date: 02/14/11 DOCKET NO. 09-09 370 ) DATE ) ) On appeal from the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office in Togus, Maine THE ISSUE Entitlement to an effective date earlier than August 16, 2006, for the grant of service connection for sleep apnea, to include as due to clear and unmistakable error (CUE). REPRESENTATION Veteran represented by: Penny E. Gronbeck WITNESS AT HEARING ON APPEAL Veteran ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD T.R. Bodger INTRODUCTION The Veteran served on active duty from November 1981 to November 1985 and from December 1989 to December 1993. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a November 2007 rating decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) from Togus, Maine. In August 2009, the Veteran testified before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge during a travel board hearing. A copy of the proceeding has been associated with the claims file. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. A June 1994 rating decision denied the Veteran's claim of service connection for sleep apnea; he was informed of his appellate rights and did not appeal; and the decision became final. 2. The RO did not commit an error to which reasonable minds could not differ by not favorably considering a July 1992 in- service consultation examination showing a diagnosis of sleep apnea, or by not favorably weighing the evidence before the RO at the time of the June 1994 decision. 3. The November 2007 rating decision granted service connection for sleep apnea and assigned an effective date of August 16, 2006, the date of receipt of the Veteran's petition to reopen his claim. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW The June 1994 rating decision, which denied the Veteran's original service connection claim, did not involve clear and unmistakable error, and an effective date earlier than August 16, 2006 is not assignable for the grant of service connection for sleep apnea. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5109A, 5110 (West 2002); 38 C.F.R. § 3.105(a), 3.400(r) (2010). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION I. Duty to Notify and Assist Upon receipt of a substantially complete application for benefits, VA must notify the claimant what information or evidence is needed in order to substantiate the claim and it must assist the claimant by making reasonable efforts to get the evidence needed. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103(a), 5103A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b); see Quartuccio v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 183, 187 (2002). The notice required must be provided to the claimant before the initial unfavorable decision on a claim for VA benefits, and it must (1) inform the claimant about the information and evidence not of record that is necessary to substantiate the claim; (2) inform the claimant about the information and evidence that VA will seek to provide; and (3) inform the claimant about the information and evidence the claimant is expected to provide. 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5103(a); 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(b) (1); Pelegrini v. Principi, 18 Vet. App. 112, 120 (2004). The United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has held that the duties of notify and assist do not apply to a claim based on a previous decision having been the result of CUE. See Livesay v. Principi, 15 Vet. App. 165 (2001) (en banc). The Court found that an attempt to obtain benefits based on an allegation of CUE "is fundamentally different from any other kind of action in the VA adjudicative process." Livesay, 15 Vet. App. at 178. As such, an allegation of CUE does not represent a "claim" but rather is a collateral attack on a final decision. The provisions of the VCAA, and its implementing regulation, are not, therefore, applicable to the adjudication of the issue of CUE in a prior, final decision. II. Clear and Unmistakable Error The Veteran contends that he is entitled to an effective date of January 1994, the date of his initial service connection claim for sleep apnea, because he alleged that the RO committed CUE in the June 1994 rating decision. A rating decision becomes final if the Veteran does not timely perfect an appeal of the decision. 38 U.S.C.A. § 7105; 38 C.F.R. § 20.200, 20.302. There are only two exceptions to the rule of finality of VA decisions, i.e., challenges based on CUE in a prior, final decision (38 U.S.C.A. §§ 5109A, 7111), and reopened claims based on new and material evidence (38 U.S.C.A. § 5108). Cook v. Principi, 318 F.3d 1334, 1339 (Fed. Cir. 2002). A claim of CUE is a collateral attack on an otherwise final rating decision by a VA regional office. Smith v. Brown, 35 F.3d 1516, 1527 (Fed. Cir. 1994). As such, there is a presumption of validity that attaches to a final decision. When such a decision is collaterally attacked the presumption becomes even stronger. Fugo v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 40, 43-44 (1997). Pursuant to 38 U.S.C.A. § 5109A (a), a rating decision is subject to revision on the grounds of CUE. The Court established a three-pronged test to determine whether CUE is present in a prior, final determination: (1) either the correct facts, as they were known at the time, were not before the adjudicator, or the statutory/regulatory provisions extant at that time were not correctly applied; (2) the error must be "undebatable" and of the sort "which if it has been made, would have manifestly changed the outcome at the time it was made"; and (3) a determination that there was CUE must be based on the record and law that existed at the time of the adjudication in question. Damrel v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 242, 245 (1994), citing Russell v. Principi, 3 Vet. App. 310, 313-14 (1992) (en banc). CUE is a very specific and rare kind of "error." It is the kind of error that compels the conclusion that the result would have been different but for the error. Even when the premise of error is accepted, if it is not absolutely clear that a different result would have ensued, the error complained of cannot be ipso facto clear and unmistakable. Fugo, 6 Vet. App. at 43-44. Disagreements about how the facts were weighed or evaluated and failures of the duty to assist cannot be CUE. 38 C.F.R. § 20.140(d) (2) and (3). If the evidence establishes an undebatable, outcome determinative error, the prior decision must be reversed or revised. 38 U.S.C. § 5109A (a). The decision constituting the reversal or revision "has the same effect as if the decision had been made on the date of the prior decision." 38 U.S.C. § 5109A (b). By way of procedural background, the RO initially denied the Veteran's claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea in a June 1994 rating decision, because the Veteran had no anatomic diagnosis although excessive snoring by history was noted. The Veteran was notified of the decision in a June 1994 letter, and the Veteran did not timely appeal. The decision became final. On August 16, 2006, the Veteran filed a claim of service connection for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and asserted that his sleep apnea was secondary to his PTSD. In a January 2007 rating decision, the RO denied the Veteran's secondary service connection claim. In June 2007, the Veteran filed a petition to reopen his direct service connection claim. In November 2007, the RO reopened the Veteran's claim and granted service connection for sleep apnea, effective August 16, 2006. In November 2008, the Veteran asserted that he was entitled to an earlier effective date. In a June 2008 rating decision, the RO denied the Veteran's claim for an earlier effective date finding that the claim was reopened on August 16, 2006, the date the Veteran submitted his petition to reopen. On August 2008, the Veteran filed a notice of disagreement, appealing the effective date assigned in the November 2007 rating decision and asserting that the August 16, 2006 effective date should be revised based upon CUE committed in the June 1994 rating decision. See 38 U.S.C.A. § 5109A; 38 C.F.R. § 3.105(a). The Veteran and his representative assert that the correct facts as they were known at the time were not before the RO in June 1994. Specifically, they argue that the June 1994 rating decision incorrectly provided that the Veteran was not diagnosed with sleep apnea. In the June 1994 rating decision, the RO stated that the Veteran was evaluated in service and found to have excessive snoring by history but that a VA examination found no anatomic diagnosis. The Veteran points to an in-service, July 1992 consultation report where he sought treatment from ENT for bad snoring. He was diagnosed with obstructive apnea and recommended to undergo an oral surgery evaluation. In an August 1992 oral surgery evaluation, the Veteran's sleep apnea diagnosis was reaffirmed and the examiner recommended oral surgery. There are no further records indicating continued complaints or treatment for this condition. Further, an October 1993 examination report shows no diagnosis for a sleep disorder and in the accompanying medical history, the Veteran expressly denied experiencing sleep problems. Aside from the March 1994 VA examination, which did not show a current diagnosis, the next treatment record showing complaints of difficulty sleeping and fatigue is dated in June 2002. However, there was no further diagnosis of sleep apnea until February 2004 when the Veteran underwent a diagnostic sleep study. In the June 1994 rating decision, the RO indicated that the Veteran's service treatment records from December 1989 to December 1993 as well as the March 1994 VA examination were reviewed. It is presumed that the RO reviewed all of these service treatment records, to include the July 1992 consultation sheet. However, even assuming that the RO did not review this July 1992 consultation sheet, the Veteran's CUE claim cannot prevail. Specifically, the RO also relied on a March 1994 VA examination report. During this examination, the examiner indicated that he reviewed the Veteran's second period of service from 1989 to 1993, when the Veteran asserted that his snoring became excessive and caused him problems. In relating the Veteran's medical history, the examiner noted that the Veteran had excessive snoring in service for which he was evaluated and an uvuloplasty was recommended but not performed. On examination, the examiner found that the Veteran's head, face, neck, nose, sinus, mouth and throat were all negative and his respiratory system was clear. The Veteran was diagnosed with excessive snoring by history with no anatomic diagnosis. As such, the examiner found that the Veteran did not have a current sleeping disability at the time of his March 1994 examination. Based upon the facts known at the time of the June 1994 rating decision, to include the July 1992 consultation sheet, it is not clear that the RO's failure to acknowledge this specific treatment note would have manifestly changed the outcome at the time the initial decision was made as the March 1994 VA examiner did not find that the Veteran suffered from a current sleep disability. See Damrel, 6 Vet. App. at 245; Fugo, 6 Vet. App. at 43-44; see also, Degmetich v. Brown, 104 F.3d 1328, 1332 (1997)(holding that interpretation of sections 1110 and 1131 of the statute as requiring the existence of a present disability for VA compensation purposes cannot be considered arbitrary). It appears that the Veteran is also asserting that the March 1994 VA examination was inadequate and the RO erred in relying upon it in the adjudication of the Veteran's claim. Specifically, the Veteran asserts that the examination was inadequate as the examiner did not provide a more extensive sleep study in light of his in-service sleep problems. However, the March 1994 VA examination report noted that the examiner reviewed the Veteran's service treatment records for his second period of service, which purportedly included the July 1992 consultation report as well as the October 1993 examination and medical history reports showing that no sleep problems existed at that time. While the examiner did not specifically cite to the July 1992 report, he noted the Veteran's history of excessive snoring. After such a review as well as a physical examination, the examiner assessed the Veteran with excessive snoring by history but found no anatomic diagnosis of sleep problems at that time. In support of his conclusion, the examiner pointed to the negative results on examination to include his head, face, neck, nose, sinus, mouth and throat. It appears that the VA examiner did consider the service treatment records, including the July 1992 consultation report which provides that the Veteran was diagnosed with obstructive apnea as well as the October 1993 examination report and medical history. The examiner appears to have been apprised of all the relevant facts as they were known to him at that time. The examiner took the Veteran's oral history and reviewed his service treatment records. While he did not specifically note the Veteran's in-service diagnosis of obstructive apnea, he noted the Veteran's history of excessive snoring and the recommended surgery which are provided in the July 1992 report and August 1992 oral surgery evaluation. The VA examination is based upon the facts as they were known at time of the examination and adequately reasoned. Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 311 (2007); Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008). With respect to the allegations that the RO erred by relying upon the March 1994 VA examination, the Board finds that this examination is thorough and well-reasoned. Allegations that the RO improperly weighed and evaluated the evidence of record at that time of adjudication can never rise to the stringent definition of clear and unmistakable error. Russell, 3 Vet. App. at 313. To the extent the Veteran and his representative assert that the VA examiner was incorrect in his findings, the Board may not reject medical opinions based on its own medical judgment. Obert v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 30 (1993); see also Colvin v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 171 (1991), overruled on other grounds by Hodge v. West, 155 F.3d 1356 (Fed. Cir. 1998). In light of the foregoing, the Board finds that there was no error of fact or law that would compel the conclusion to be manifestly different but for the error in this case. The Board notes that the "benefit of the doubt rule" is not applicable in CUE cases. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1411(a) and (b). III. Earlier Effective Date The Board also looks to the Veteran's August 16, 2006 petition to reopen his service connection claim to determine whether he is entitled to an earlier effective date. The proper effective date for new and material evidence other than service department records received after a final disallowance is the date of receipt of the claim to reopen or date entitlement arouse, whichever is later. 38 U.S.C.A. § 5110(i); 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(q) (2), 3.400(r). After submitting his August 16, 2006 petition to reopen, the Veteran submitted statements from himself as well as third party statements indicating his sleep problems. He also submitted a duplicate copy of the July 1992 consultation sheet indicating a diagnosis of obstructive apnea. Following the submission of this evidence, the Veteran was afforded VA examinations in December 2006 and September 2007 where the examiners assessed the Veteran with sleep apnea. In the December 2006 examination report, the examiner opined that the Veteran's sleep apnea was not related to his PTSD. However, in the September 2007 examination report, the examiner opined that the Veteran's sleep apnea was more likely than not related to his service. Based upon this new evidence, the RO granted service connection in November 2007 and assigned an effective date of August 16, 2006, the date of his original petition to reopen. Based upon the foregoing, the effective date of a claim received after a final disallowance is the date of receipt of the new claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is the later. 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(q) (2). The Veteran's claim to reopen was received on August 16, 2006. He did not submit new or material evidence sufficient to reopen his service connection claim prior to August 16, 2006. Accordingly, the assignment of an effective date of August 16, 2006 was proper, and entitlement to an earlier effective date for the grant of service connection for the Veteran's sleep apnea on a direct basis or CUE grounds is not warranted. ORDER The claim for an effective date earlier than August 16, 2006, for the grant of service connection for sleep apnea is denied. ____________________________________________ KATHLEEN K. GALLAGHER Veterans Law Judge, Board of Veterans' Appeals Department of Veterans Affairs