Citation Nr: 18100447 Decision Date: 04/13/18 Archive Date: 04/13/18 DOCKET NO. 14-19 966 DATE: April 13, 2018 ISSUES DECIDED: 0 ISSUES REMANDED: 1 REMANDED ISSUE The issue of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded for additional development. The Veteran served on active duty from January 1979 to January 1999. In January 2018, the Veteran and his wife testified before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge. A transcript of the proceeding is of record. Post-service treatment records demonstrate that the Veteran was diagnosed with sleep apnea following a sleep study performed in July 2012. The requirement for a current disability has been met. Accordingly, the question remains whether the disability is related to service or had onset therein. Service treatment records (STRs) indicate that the Veteran sustained a nasal septum fracture in April 1997. In June 1997, he underwent a tonsillectomy with uvuloplasty on account of reported heroic snoring. It was specifically indicated that there had been no witnessed apneic events, but the snoring kept the Veteran’s wife awake. In November 1998, two months prior to separation from service, the Veteran underwent a pre-discharge examination. It was stated that since surgery, the Veteran had not had continuing problems with snoring. It was again indicated that the Veteran had never had any sleep apnea symptoms and did not have such symptoms at the time of the examination. In August 2012, the Veteran filed a claim for service connection for sleep apnea secondary to nasal septum condition. In November 2012, he underwent a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) examination. It was noted that the Veteran complained of snoring in service and underwent surgery. His snoring improved but eventually became worse and 3 or 4 years previously, the Veteran’s wife noted his breathing would stop and he finally underwent a sleep study that revealed sleep apnea. As to whether the Veteran’s sleep apnea was caused by or aggravated by his service-connected nasal septum fracture, the examiner opined this was less likely than not. It was explained that the Veteran did not have any residuals from the nasal septum fracture, it did not cause any daytime or nighttime problems and a nexus between it and sleep apnea could not be made. Following denial of service connection in December 2012, the Veteran submitted a Central Nervous System Disability Benefits Questionnaire in March 2013 completed by a private doctor. Dr. M. stated that although a sleep study was not performed until after retirement, in light of the Veteran’s heroic snoring in service and surgical intervention, that it was more likely than not that he had the condition of sleep apnea since at least 1997. Notably, Dr. M. did not provide a rationale as to why sleep apnea was likely present due to heroic snoring in the absence of apneic events. In an April 2014 statement, the Veteran clarified that he was no longer claiming that his sleep apnea is secondary to his in-service nasal fracture and instead, based on Dr. M’s opinion, believed that sleep apnea had onset during service. At his hearing before the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) in January 2018, the Veteran testified that he began snoring in the early 1990s. He indicated that after his nasal septum injury, he asked whether it would make his snoring worse and was reportedly told “no.” He discussed his snoring problem with the doctor and it was recommended his uvula be removed. He indicated believing his condition was life threatening in service and that although the surgery initially improved the snoring, it became worse again when he healed and he would snore himself awake and be gasping for air. Following the hearing, the Veteran submitted another private opinion. Dr. A. stated that the Veteran had experienced symptoms of sleep apnea since 1997. The doctor indicated that since then the Veteran had loud snoring, apneas that caused his wife to wake him from sleep and gasping at the end of apneas along with significant daytime fatigue. Based on this understanding, the doctor indicated that he would have diagnosed the Veteran with sleep apnea and referred him for a sleep study in 1997. Unfortunately, the private opinions of record lack probative value as they are based on an understanding that the Veteran experienced apneic events along with snoring during service. This is directly contradicted by the STRs and the indication at the November 2012 VA examination that apneic episodes began 3 to 4 years prior to that examination. Currently, the claims file does not include an opinion regarding direct service connection that is supported by adequate rationale. As the Board cannot make its own independent medical determinations and is prohibited from exercising independent judgment to resolve medical questions, the claim must be remanded for an addendum opinion addressing whether it is at least as likely as not that sleep apnea had onset in service or is directly related thereto based on a full review of the claims file. The matter is REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain an addendum opinion from an appropriate clinician regarding whether the Veteran’s sleep apnea is at least as likely as not related to service or had onset therein. The claims file should be made available to and be reviewed by the clinician in conjunction with the examination. Based on a review of the evidence, an opinion is sought as to whether it is at least as likely as not (50 percent probability or greater) the Veteran has sleep apnea that began in service, was caused by service, or is otherwise related to service. In providing the requested opinion, the examiner is advised that the term “at least as likely as not” does not mean within the realm of possibility. Rather, it means that the weight of medical evidence both for and against a conclusion is so evenly divided that it is medically sound to find in favor of causation as to find against causation. A complete rationale must be provided for any opinion expressed. 2. Thereafter, the Veteran’s claim should be readjudicated. If the benefit sought on appeal is not granted, the Veteran and his representative should be furnished a supplemental statement of the case and be given an appropriate period to respond thereto before the case is returned to the Board. Nathan Kroes Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD C. Boyd Iwanowski, Counsel