Citation Nr: 19130619 Decision Date: 04/18/19 Archive Date: 04/18/19 DOCKET NO. 18-03 116 DATE: April 18, 2019 ORDER Entitlement to special monthly compensation (SMC) in excess of the amount paid pursuant to 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114(l) and 1114(p) based on aid and attendance at a rate equal to § 1114(m), plus § 1114(k), is denied. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Due to service-connected residuals of stroke, to include hemiparesis of both the upper and lower extremities of the right side, along with depressive disorder, hemisensory impairment, aphasia, apraxia, dysphagia, bowel function impairment, and voiding dysfunction, the Veteran is so helpless as to be in need of regular aid and attendance of another person. 2. The Veteran has no other service-connected disabilities, separate from his stroke residuals, that qualify him for SMC pursuant to 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114(l) through 1114(o). CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for entitlement to special monthly compensation in excess of the amount paid pursuant to 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114(l) and 1114(p) based on aid and attendance at a rate equal to § 1114(m), plus § 1114(k), have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114(k), (l), (m), (p), 5107 (2012); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.350, 3.352 (2018). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty from December 1969 to September 1972. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) on appeal from July and November 2017 rating decisions of a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in St. Paul, Minnesota, which, in pertinent part, granted SMC under 38 U.S.C. § 1114, subsection (l) and 38 CFR § 3.350(b) based on aid and attendance criteria, and under 38 U.S.C. § 1114, subsection (p) and 38 CFR § 3.350(f)(3) at the rate equal to subsection (m) for a higher level of entitlement being met. Entitlement to SMC under 38 U.S.C. § 1114, subsection (k) and 38 CFR § 3.350(a) for loss of use of a creative organ was also granted, and that particular SMC entitlement is not in dispute here. The Veteran’s attorney withdrew as representative in August 2018. As the Veteran is now unrepresented in this case, VA has a duty to construe his claims liberally. See Moody v. Principi, 360 F.3d 1306, 1310 (Fed. Cir. 2004); Szemraj v. Principi, 357 F.3d 1370, 1373 (Fed. Cir. 2004). The Veteran submitted additional evidence in support of his claim after the most recent Statement of the Case (SOC) of November 2017, along with a waiver of review of such evidence by the agency of original jurisdiction. As such, the Board may properly consider such evidence at this time. See 38 C.F.R. §§ 19.37, 20.800, 20.1304(c); Disabled American Veterans v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs, 327 F.3d 1339 (Fed. Cir. 2003). Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) The Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA) and implementing regulations impose obligations on VA to provide claimants with notice and assistance. 38 U.S.C. §§ 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107 (2012); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.156(a), 3.159, 3.326(a) (2018). The Veteran in this case has not referred to any deficiencies in either the duties to notify or assist; therefore, the Board may proceed to the merits of the claim. See Scott v. McDonald, 789 F.3d 1375, 1381 (Fed. Cir. 2015, cert. denied, U.S.C. Oct. 3, 2016) (holding that “the Board’s obligation to read filings in a liberal manner does not require the Board….to search the record and address procedural arguments when the [appellant] fails to raise them before the Board”); Dickens v. McDonald, 814 F.3d 1359, 1361 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (applying Scott to an appellant’s failure to raise a duty to assist argument before the Board). The Board has reviewed all of the evidence in the Veteran’s claims file. Although the Board has an obligation to provide adequate reasons and bases supporting this decision, there is no requirement that the evidence submitted by the Veteran or obtained on his behalf be discussed in detail. Rather, the Board’s analysis below will focus specifically on what evidence is needed to substantiate the claim and what the evidence in the claims file shows, or fails to show, with respect to the claim. See Gonzales v. West, 218 F.3d 1378, 1380-81 (Fed. Cir. 2000) and Timberlake v. Gober, 14 Vet. App. 122, 128-130 (2000). Entitlement to Special Monthly Compensation (SMC) Special monthly compensation (SMC) is a monetary benefit that is paid for service-connected disabilities which result in impairment of the senses, loss or loss of use (of the extremities, creative organ, breast, or buttocks), or which render the Veteran housebound or in need of the regular aid and attendance of another person. 38 U.S.C. § 1114; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.350, 3.352. SMC is authorized under subsections (k) through (s), with the rate amounts increasing the later in the alphabet the letter appears (except for the “s” rate). SMC at the “k” and “r” rates are paid in addition to any other SMC rates, with certain monetary limits. Id. The rate of SMC “varies according to the nature of the veteran’s service-connected disabilities.” Moreira v. Principi, 3 Vet. App. 522, 524 (1992). While schedular rates of compensation are predicated on the average reduction in earning capacity, special monthly compensation benefits are meant to provide additional compensation based on noneconomic factors such as personal inconvenience, social inadaptability, or the profound nature of the disability. VAOPGPREC 5-89 (Mar. 23, 1989). The Veteran currently receives special monthly compensation (SMC) under 38 U.S.C. 1114, subsection (l) and 38 CFR 3.350(b) on account of being so helpless as to be in need of regular aid and attendance while not hospitalized at U.S. government expense, from April 21, 2014. He also receives SMC under 38 U.S.C. 1114, subsection (p) and 38 CFR 3.350(f)(4) at the rate equal to subsection (m) on account of entitlement to the rate equal to subsection (l) with additional disability, depressive disorder, independently ratable at 100 percent, again from April 21, 2014. In addition, the Veteran receives SMC under 38 U.S.C. 1114, subsection (k) and 38 CFR 3.350(a) on account of loss of use of a creative organ from April 21, 2014. Hereinafter, in this Board decision, the particular subsection from 38 U.S.C. 1114 that justifies a particular award of SMC will be noted with the subsection paragraph, e.g., SMC(k), for ease of reading and reference. Here, the Veteran has not disagreed with his SMC(k) award for loss of a creative organ, and as it remains payable regardless of the determination of the other categories of SMC under consideration, the Board need not discuss the Veteran’s SMC(k) further in this decision. By way of medical background, the Veteran underwent a triple bypass heart operation in April 2014 in a VA medical center. The Veteran suffered a stroke in the course of this operation, and in the course of claims and appeals at the regional office level, the Veteran is now service connected for residuals of that stroke, to include hemiparesis of both the upper and lower extremities of the right side, along with hemisensory impairment, aphasia, apraxia, dysphagia, bowel function impairment, and voiding dysfunction, all as due to the stroke suffered in April 2014. In addition, the Veteran is now also service connected for depressive disorder due to his stroke residuals. The Veteran has not contested any medical evidence that led to the current award of SMC ratings. As relevant to the Veteran’s claim, SMC at the “l” rate is payable when the Veteran, due to service-connected disability, has suffered the anatomical loss or loss of use of both feet or one hand and one foot, or is blind in both eyes, or is permanently bedridden or so helpless as to be in need of regular aid and attendance. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(l); 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(b). The Veteran was awarded his current levels of SMC as noted above in a November 2017 rating decision, which noted the award of SMC(l) was based on the residuals of the stroke, when combined equals a 100 percent disability for which medical evidence demonstrated the requirement of aid and attendance of another individual. This rating decision also determined that additional SMC(p) was entitled at a rate equal to subsection (m) on the account of the SMC(l) with additional disability, namely the depressive disorder, independently rated at 100 percent since April 21, 2014. The Veteran seeks a rate of SMC in excess of this amount, up to and including the rate of SMC(r)(2) because of his asserted daily need for in-home care by a licensed care provider. See August 2017 notice of disagreement. SMC In Excess of 38 U.S.C. § 1114(l) – Legal Criteria As set forth under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(m), SMC is warranted if the Veteran, as a result of service-connected disability, has suffered the anatomical loss or loss of use of both hands, or of both legs at a level, or with complications, preventing natural knee action with prosthesis in place, or of one arm and one leg at levels, or with complications, preventing natural elbow and knee action with prosthesis in place, or has suffered blindness in both eyes having only light perception, or has suffered blindness in both eyes, rendering such Veteran so helpless as to be in need of regular aid and attendance. SMC at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n) level is warranted if the Veteran, as the result of service-connected disability, has suffered the anatomical loss of use of both arms at levels, or with complications, preventing elbow action with prostheses in place, has suffered the anatomical loss of both legs so near the hip as to prevent the use of prosthetic appliances. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n). SMC at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n) level is also warranted if the Veteran’s service-connected disability has caused him to suffer anatomical loss of one arm and one leg so near the shoulder and hip as to prevent the use of prosthetic appliances, or to suffer blindness without light perception in both eyes. SMC at 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o) level is warranted if the Veteran, as the result of service-connected disability, has suffered disability under conditions which would entitle such Veteran to two or more of the rates provided in one or more of § 1114(l) through § 1114(n), no condition being considered twice in the determination, or if the Veteran has suffered bilateral deafness (and the hearing impairment in either one or both ears in service connected) rated at 60 percent or more disabling and the Veteran has also suffered service-connected total blindness with 5/200 visual acuity or less, or if the Veteran has suffered service-connected total deafness in one ear or bilateral deafness (and the hearing impairment in either one or both ears is service connected) rated at 40 percent or more disabling and the Veteran has also suffered service-connected blindness having only light perception or less, or if the Veteran has suffered the anatomical loss of both arms so near the shoulder as to prevent the use of prosthetic appliances, he or she shall receive compensation at the rate found in § 1114(o). 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o). Determinations for entitlement under § 1114(o) must be based upon separate and distinct disabilities. That requires, for example, that where a Veteran who had suffered the loss or loss of use of two extremities is being considered for the maximum rate on account of helplessness requiring regular aid and attendance, the latter must be based on need resulting from pathology other than that of the extremities. 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(e). If the loss of use of two extremities or being permanently bedridden leaves the person helpless, increase is not in order on account of this helplessness. Under no circumstances will the combination of “being permanently bedridden” and “being so helpless as to require regular aid and attendance” without separate and distinct anatomical loss, or loss of use, of two extremities be taken as entitling the Veteran to the maximum benefit. The fact, however, that two separate and distinct entitling disabilities, such as loss of use of both hands and both feet, result from a common etiological agent, for example, one injury or rheumatoid arthritis, will not preclude maximum entitlement. 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(e). Next, 38 U.S.C. § 1114(p) provides for “intermediate” SMC rates between the different subsections, with the maximum SMC not exceeding that prescribed at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o) rate. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(p); 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(f). A Veteran receiving the maximum rate under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o) or (p) who is in need of regular aid and attendance or a higher level of care is entitled to an additional allowance during periods that he or she is not hospitalized at the United States Government’s expense. Determination of this need is subject to the criteria of 38 C.F.R. § 3.352. In addition to regular levels of compensation for aid and attendance as authorized by 38 U.S.C. § 1114(l), 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r) provides for a higher level of benefit called “special aid and attendance” in certain circumstances. A veteran receiving the maximum rate under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o), who is in need of regular aid and attendance or a higher level of care, is entitled to an additional allowance during periods he or she is not hospitalized at United States Government expense. 38 U.S.C. 1114(r)(1)-(2). A still higher level aid and attendance allowance is authorized by 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r)(2), and is payable in lieu of the regular aid and attendance allowance authorized by 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r)(1). 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(h)(3). Determinations as to need for aid and attendance must be based on actual requirement of personal assistance from others. In making such determinations, consideration is given to such conditions as: inability of claimant to dress or undress herself or to keep herself ordinarily clean and presentable; frequent need of adjustment of any special prosthetic or orthopedic appliances which by reason of the particular disability cannot be done without aid; inability of claimant to feed herself through loss of coordination of upper extremities or through extreme weakness; inability to attend to the wants of nature; or incapacity, physical or mental, which requires care or assistance on a regular basis to protect the claimant from hazards or dangers incident to his or her daily environment. “Bedridden” will be a proper basis for the determination and is defined as that condition which, through its essential character, actually requires that the claimant remain in bed. It is not required that all of the disabling conditions enumerated above be found to exist before a favorable rating may be made. The particular personal functions which the Veteran is unable to perform should be considered in connection with his/her condition as a whole. It is only necessary that the evidence establish that the Veteran is so helpless as to need regular aid and attendance, not that there be a constant need. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352. A Veteran is entitled to the higher level aid and attendance allowance authorized by 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r)(2) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(h) in lieu of the regular aid and attendance allowance when all of the following conditions are met: (i) the Veteran is entitled to the compensation authorized under 38 U.S.C. 1114(o), or the maximum rate of compensation authorized under 38 U.S.C. 1114(p); (ii) the Veteran meets the requirements for entitlement to the regular aid and attendance allowance § 3.352(a); (iii) the Veteran needs a “higher level of care” (as defined in § 3.352(b)(2)) than is required to establish entitlement to the regular aid and attendance allowance, and in the absence of the provision of such higher level of care the Veteran would require hospitalization, nursing home care, or other residential institutional care. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352(b)(1)(i-iii). Need for a higher level of care shall be considered to be necessary for personal health-care services provided on a daily basis in the Veteran’s home by a person who is licensed to provide such services or who provides such services under the regular supervision of a licensed health-care professional. Personal health-care services include (but are not limited to) such services as physical therapy, administration of injections, placement of indwelling catheters, and the changing of sterile dressings, or like functions which require professional health-care training or the regular supervision of a trained health-care professional to perform. A licensed health-care professional includes (but is not limited to) a doctor of medicine or osteopathy, a registered nurse, a licensed practical nurse, or a physical therapist licensed to practice by a state or political subdivision. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352(b)(2). The term “under the regular supervision of a licensed health-care professional” means that an unlicensed person performing personal health-care services is following a regimen of personal health-care services prescribed by a health-care professional, and that the health-care professional consults with the unlicensed person providing the health-care services at least once each month to monitor the prescribed regimen. The consultation need not be in person; a telephone call will suffice. A person performing personal health-care services who is a relative or other member of the Veteran’s household is not exempted from the requirement that he or she be a licensed health-care professional or be providing such care under the regular supervision of a licensed health-care professional. The performance of the necessary aid and attendance service by a relative of the beneficiary or other member of his or her household will not prevent the granting of the additional allowance. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352(b)(2-4), (c). The requirements for establishing the need for a higher level of care are to be strictly construed. The higher level aid- and-attendance allowance is to be granted only when the Veteran’s need is clearly established and the amount of services required by the Veteran on a daily basis is substantial. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352(b)(5). A Veteran who has a service-connected disability rated as 100 percent disabling and (1) has an additional service-connected disability or disabilities independently rated at 60 percent or more, or (2) by reason of such service-connected disability or disabilities is permanently housebound, shall receive SMC under the provisions of 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s). 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(h)(3)(i). SMC In Excess of 38 U.S.C. § 1114(l) – Evidence and Analysis The Board notes, as already discussed above, that the Veteran receives SMC(l) on the account of being so helpless as to be in need of regular aid and attendance, and also SMC(p) at the rate equal to subsection (m) on account of entitlement to the rate equal to subsection (l) with additional disability. Since the Veteran’s compensation is already equivalent to SMC(m), the Board will discuss entitlement to SMC greater than subsection(m), i.e., subsection (n) and subsection (o). SMC at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n) level is warranted if the Veteran, as the result of service-connected disability, has suffered the anatomical loss of use of both arms at levels, or with complications, preventing elbow action with prostheses in place, has suffered the anatomical loss of both legs so near the hip as to prevent the use of prosthetic appliances. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n). SMC at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(n) level is also warranted if the Veteran’s service-connected disability has caused him to suffer anatomical loss of one arm and one leg so near the shoulder and hip as to prevent the use of prosthetic appliances, or to suffer blindness without light perception in both eyes. Because the medical evidence indicates that the Veteran has not suffered anatomical loss of both arms, or of both legs, or the anatomical loss of one arm and one leg so near the shoulder and hip, the Board finds that the Veteran is not eligible for SMC(n). The question then before the Board is whether the Veteran, who is in receipt of SMC(l) and SMC(p) payable at the rate of SMC(m) for the need of regular aid and attendance plus additional disability, qualifies to receive the maximum rate of SMC(o) by establishing that he has suffered disability under conditions which would entitle the Veteran to two or more of the rates provided in one or more of § 1114(l) through § 1114(n), no condition being considered twice in the determination. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o) (emphasis added). Determinations for entitlement under § 1114(o) must be based upon separate and distinct disabilities. That requires, for example, that where a Veteran who had suffered the loss or loss of use of two extremities is being considered for the maximum rate on account of helplessness requiring regular aid and attendance, the latter must be based on need resulting from pathology other than that of the extremities. 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(e). Here, the Board notes the award of SMC(l) with aid and attendance is predicated on the Veteran’s service-connected disabilities related to the stroke he suffered in April 2014 and the residuals thereafter, to include hemiparesis of both the upper and lower extremities of the right side, along with hemisensory impairment, aphasia, apraxia, dysphagia, bowel function impairment, and voiding dysfunction. The Veteran received a VA medical examination in January 2019, where the examiner, Dr. R.M., who is also a physician who sees the Veteran on a regular basis, noted the Veteran continues to have extensive disability as a result of his April 2014 stroke and its residuals. The examiner noted right sided hemiparesis with significant expressive aphasia and frequent headaches. The examiner also made note of chronic pain issues as well related to his right side hemiparesis, with some right side facial droop noted as well. The examiner also noted the Veteran remains very depressed since his stroke and is unable to do almost any of the physical things he and his spouse used to do. The Veteran asserts he is qualified for SMC(r)(2) because of the requirement for a qualified home health care provider, but in order to reach the threshold of SMC(r)(1) or (2), the Veteran must meet three requirements. A Veteran is entitled to the higher level aid and attendance allowance authorized by 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r)(2) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(h) in lieu of the regular aid and attendance allowance when all of the following conditions are met: (i) the Veteran is entitled to the compensation authorized under 38 U.S.C. 1114(o); (ii) the Veteran meets the requirements for entitlement to the regular aid and attendance allowance § 3.352(a); (iii) the Veteran needs a “higher level of care” (as defined in § 3.352(b)(2)) than is required to establish entitlement to the regular aid and attendance allowance, and in the absence of the provision of such higher level of care the Veteran would require hospitalization, nursing home care, or other residential institutional care. 38 C.F.R. § 3.352(b)(1)(i-iii). The Veteran has already established his requirement for regular aid and attendance pursuant to SMC(l), as discussed previously. However, the Veteran does not meet the first requirement, that of qualifying for SMC at the 38 U.S.C. § 1114(o) level. In order to establish SMC(o), the Veteran must first establish he is entitled to two or more ratings between subsection (l) and subsection (n), which are based on separate and distinct disabilities. (Emphasis added.) The Board notes, and the Veteran has not asserted otherwise, that his service-connected disabilities for which he receives SMC are related to the April 2014 stroke and subsequent residuals, to include the depressive disorder. So, even though the Veteran receives SMC(l) and also SMC(p) payable at a rate equivalent to subsection (m), those SMC entitlements are all derived from the same condition, the residuals of the April 2014 stroke. “Determinations must be based upon separate and distinct disabilities. This requires, for example, that where a veteran who had suffered the loss or loss of use of two extremities is being considered for the maximum rate on account of helplessness requiring regular aid and attendance, the latter must be based on need resulting from pathology other than that of the extremities.” 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(e)(3). Additionally, a Veteran who is already in receipt of SMC(l) cannot establish entitlement to a second award of SMC(l) based on the need for aid and attendance unless the Veteran’s need for aid and attendance arises from a disability other than that for which the Veteran is already in receipt of SMC(l). Breniser v. Shinseki, 25 Vet. App. 64, 77-78 (2011) (emphasis in the original). As noted, the Veteran’s entitlements to SMC(l) and SMC(p), payable at a rate equivalent to subsection (m), all derive from the Veteran’s residuals of his April 2014 stroke, to include his depressive disorder. Without a second disability qualifying under SMC(l), (m), or (n) that is not related to the Veteran’s stroke residuals, he is unable to qualify for SMC(o) pursuant to regulation. In other words, the Veteran is in receipt of SMC(l) and (p) for his stroke residuals, and he also requires aid and attendance based on his stroke residuals. The need for aid and attendance would independently satisfy the criteria for SMC at the (l) rate. However, because the need for aid and attendance does not arise from a disability separate and distinct from the disability for which he is already receiving SMC(l), he is not entitled to a higher SMC payment at the (o) rate. Breniser, 25 Vet. App. at 76. (Emphasis added). Because the Veteran does not qualify for SMC(o), the Veteran’s claim for a higher level of SMC fails, and the Board need not reach the further analysis of 38 U.S.C. § 1114(r)(2) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.352 regarding the determination requirements of special aid and attendance benefits. The Veteran does not contend, and the medical evidence does not indicate, that the Veteran’s requirement for aid and attendance translates into a claim that he is housebound in fact, pursuant to 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s). Also, SMC(l), already awarded, is the greater benefit, and as such, SMC(s) will not be discussed. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(t) provides for a higher level of SMC if a Veteran is in need of regular aid and attendance for the residuals of traumatic brain injury (TBI). Service connection for a TBI has not been established, and this section is inapplicable. Accordingly, entitlement to special monthly compensation (SMC) in excess of the amount paid pursuant to 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114(l) and 1114(p) based on aid and attendance at a rate equal to § 1114(m), plus § 1114(k), is denied as a matter of law. Where the law is dispositive, the claim must be denied on the basis of absence of legal merit. Sabonis v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 426, 430 (1994). Neither the Veteran nor his representative has raised any other issues, nor have any other issues been reasonably raised by the record. See Doucette v. Shulkin, 28 Vet. App. 366, 369 (2017) (confirming that the Board is not required to address issues unless they are specifically raised by the claimant or reasonably raised by the evidence of record). MICHAEL A. PAPPAS Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD J. Setter, Associate Counsel