Citation Nr: 19133333 Decision Date: 04/29/19 Archive Date: 04/29/19 DOCKET NO. 15-15 348 DATE: April 29, 2019 ORDER Entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is denied. FINDING OF FACT The preponderance of evidence is against a finding that the Veteran’s current obstructive sleep apnea is the result of disease or injury in service; or proximately due to, or aggravated by, his service-connected disabilities, to include post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with major depressive disorder and alcohol dependence. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for service connection for sleep apnea have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 5107 (2012); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.303, 3.304., 3.310 (2018). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION Service connection will be granted for a disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by active service. 38 U.S.C. § 1110; 38 C.F.R. § 3.303. Establishing service connection generally requires evidence of (1) a current disability; (2) an in-service incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury; and (3) a nexus between the claimed in-service disease or injury and the current disability. Shedden v. Principi, 381 F.3d 1163, 1167 (Fed. Cir. 2004). Service connection may also be granted when a claimed disability is found to be proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disability, or when any increase in severity (aggravation) of a nonservice-connected disease or injury is found to be proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disability. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. When there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence regarding any issue material to the determination of a matter, VA shall give the benefit of the doubt to the claimant. 38 U.S.C. § 5107(b); 38 C.F.R. § 3.102. The record establishes the Veteran has obstructive sleep apnea; therefore, the current disability requirement for his service connection claim has been met. The Veteran claims his sleep apnea is secondary to his service-connected PTSD with major depressive disorder and alcohol dependence [hereinafter “service-connected psychiatric disability”]. There are several opinions addressing the theory of secondary service connection; however, the Board finds the preponderance of evidence is against the Veteran’s claim. In April 2014, the Veteran submitted an opinion from his treating physician, A.A., M.D., to support his claim. A.A., M.D., noted an association between sleep disturbances and psychiatric disorders is well recognized in the medical community because multiple studies have shown a high prevalence of sleep disturbances in patients with psychiatric disorders. He specifically referenced two studies, which found that up to 70 percent of active duty members who carry a diagnosis of PTSD are at risk for obstructive sleep apnea. A.A., M.D., conceded there is not conclusive evidence establishing which causes the other and acknowledged there are studies that suggest sleep apnea can worsen PTSD. Yet, A.A., M.D., concluded that it is at least as likely as not the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disability contributed to or aggravated his sleep apnea because he had no manifestations of sleep apnea prior to his PTSD diagnosis and continued suffer from sleep apnea after successful treatment for PTSD. The Board finds the rationale provided by A.A., M.D., lacks probative value because it is somewhat inconsistent with his own statements regarding the current state of medical knowledge regarding the association between sleep disturbances and psychiatric disorders. A.A., M.D., statements regarding the association between sleep disturbances and psychiatric disorders appear to suggest that sleep apnea may aggravate psychiatric disorders, but they provide no indication that the converse is true. In August 2014, the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) obtained an opinion regarding the Veteran’s claim. The August 2014 VA examiner determined the Veteran’s sleep apnea is less likely than not proximately due to his service-connected psychiatric disorder. The August 2014 VA examiner referenced the opinion provided by A.A., M.D., to highlight that there are no studies that show PTSD causes sleep apnea. The August 2014 VA examiner acknowledged a correlation between PTSD and sleep apnea and explained there are studies suggesting sleep-disordered breathing is a risk factor for the development of PTSD and PTSD symptoms improve with sleep apnea treatment, as well as PTSD being associated with a decreased quality of sleep apnea treatment. While the August 2014 VA examiner’s opinion is probative with respect to the issue of causation, the Board finds it lacks the probative value to make a fully informed decision on the Veteran’s claim because it does not address aggravation in the context of secondary service connection. In July 2018, A.A., M.D., provided an addendum to his initial opinion in which he cited the Board’s decision in another case to provide support for his opinion that the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disorder has aggravated his sleep apnea; however, Board decisions are not binding precedent and are limited to the facts and circumstances present in individual cases. A.A., M.D., also noted the opinion a July 2011 VA examiner’s report and suggested the examiner concluded “it is more likely than not the Veteran’s sleep apnea is aggravated by his PTSD;” however, the July 2011 VA examiner did not provide an opinion in this regard and simply stated the Veteran’s “sleep problems began with PTSD and worsened with depression” without mention of the specific diagnosis of sleep apnea. As a result of the deficiencies in the previously noted opinions, the Board requested an opinion regarding the Veteran’s claim from a specialist with the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 20.901(a). In October 2018, the Board received the requested opinion, which was co-authored by two physicians due to the overlap in specialties resulting from the Veteran’s claim. The opinion indicates there is no reliable or credible literature that suggests psychiatric disorders, like PTSD, cause, aggravate, or worsen sleep apnea. The authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion acknowledged the high prevalence of sleep apnea in individuals with psychiatric disorders, but they explained that just because two conditions are found together, or are correlated, does not mean that one condition caused, aggravated, or worsened another. The authors noted it is hypothesized that sleep apnea may predate many anxiety disorders, leading to a higher prevalence of sleep disturbances in patients with such disorders. The authors also addressed the rationale provided by A.A., M.D., regarding a potential relationship between sleep apnea and PTSD in the Veteran’s case due to the order in which the conditions manifest. For clarity, the Board again notes A.A., M.D., reasoned the Veteran’s PTSD at least as likely as not contributed to or aggravated his sleep apnea because he had no manifestations of sleep apnea prior to his PTSD diagnosis and continued suffer from sleep apnea after successful treatment for PTSD. The authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion indicated this is an inadequate rationale to support a link between the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disability and sleep apnea because the temporal relationship between two conditions provides no substantive evidence that one caused or affects the other. The authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion noted research shows sleep apnea is much more common among older adults like the Veteran. They further noted obesity is one of the strongest risk factors for obstructive sleep apnea, explaining the Veteran was obese at the time of his sleep apnea diagnosis at the age of 60. They explained the use of an “association” or “correlation” to establish a cause-and-effect relationship between the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disability and sleep apnea is illegitimate and misleading because there are several other variables that must be considered. The authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion also addressed the reliance of A.A., M.D., on the July 2011 VA examiner’s report in his July 2018 addendum to bolster the credibility of his initial opinion and explained it appears to be an example of his attempt to twist an association between two conditions to establish a cause-and-effect relationship that does not exist. While acknowledging the importance of the field of psychological studies and counseling, the authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion indicated the July 2011 VA examiner, a psychologist, is not medically qualified to provide an opinion regarding the disease process of obstructive sleep apnea because psychologist are not trained in pathophysiology. They further noted sleep disturbances are not the same as a diagnosis of sleep apnea, the condition for which the Veteran seeks service connection. Ultimately, the authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion concluded that it is less likely than not the Veteran’s sleep apnea is the result of disease or injury in service because the condition was diagnosed 35 years after his separation from service with no evidence, subjective or objective, indicating it was incurred in service. They further concluded it is less likely than not the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disorder caused his sleep apnea, explaining the condition results from a physiological obstruction of the airways during sleep and not from the sleep disorders, to include insomnia, parainsomnia, or arousals, such as nightmares, terror, and panic, that are associated with psychological disorders like PTSD. They further explained that it is for this same reason that the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disorder cannot have aggravated his sleep apnea, noting that, from a pathophysiological standpoint, psychiatric disorders, such as PTSD, do not contribute to or affect the process that causes sleep apnea. The authors of the October 2018 VHA opinion fully acknowledged medical literature establishes psychiatric disorders and sleep apnea often coexist, but they reiterated this does not establish a cause-and-effect relationship between the two. The Board finds the October 2018 VHA opinion to be the most probative evidence of record regarding the Veteran’s claim. It thoroughly addresses the theory of entitlement put forth by the Veteran. The authors considered an accurate factual history of the claimed disability and provided a detailed, well-reasoned rationale to support their conclusions that is consistent with the current state of medical knowledge as outlined by all the experts who have provided opinions regarding the Veteran’s claim, to include A.A., M.D. The Board acknowledges there is a high prevalence of sleep disturbances among individuals with psychiatric disorders. Although there is evidence that suggests sleep apnea may negatively affect psychiatric manifestations, it does not appear there is any credible or reliable evidence that psychiatric disorders cause or aggravate sleep apnea, as thoroughly explained in the October 2018 VHA opinion. In sum, the Board finds the preponderance of evidence is against a finding that the Veteran’s current obstructive sleep apnea is the result of disease or injury in service; or proximately due to, or aggravated by, his service-connected PTSD with major depressive disorder and alcohol dependence. As the preponderance of evidence is against a finding of nexus to either service or a service-connected disability, the benefit-of-the-doubt rule does not apply, and the Veteran’s claim must be denied. See Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49 (1990). M. HYLAND Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals ATTORNEY FOR THE BOARD L. S. Kyle, Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential, and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.