Citation Nr: 20006879 Decision Date: 01/28/20 Archive Date: 01/28/20 DOCKET NO. 08-39 226 DATE: January 28, 2020 REMANDED Entitlement to an initial compensable rating prior to February 21, 2003, for service-connected valvular heart disease is remanded. Entitlement to a rating in excess of 20 percent for service-connected kyphoscoliosis with lumbosacral strain and degenerative arthritis of the spine (lumbar spine disability) is remanded. Entitlement to an initial rating in excess of 10 percent for service-connected right lower extremity radiculopathy is remanded. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than May 8, 2017, for the award of service connection for right lower extremity radiculopathy is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty from September 1978 to June 1992, and from March 1995 to July 1995. In April 2018, the Board issued a decision that awarded a 30 percent disability rating to the Veteran’s service-connected valvular heart disease, effective February 21, 2003, but denied an initial compensable rating for the period prior to February 21, 2003. The Board also remanded the Veteran’s claim for a rating in excess of 30 percent from January 23, 2015, for his service-connected valvular heart disease, and his claim for a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU) due to service-connected disabilities. Insofar as the Board denied entitlement to an initial compensable rating for the period prior to February 21, 2003, the Veteran appealed the Board’s decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). Subsequently, the parties to the action submitted a Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR) which was adopted by the Court in an Order issued in April 2019. In the JMPR, the parties agreed that the Board’s decision with respect to the assignment of a 30 percent disability rating to the Veteran’s service-connected valvular heart disease, effective February 21, 2003, should not be disturbed. As for the Veteran’s claims of entitlement to a rating in excess of 30 percent from January 23, 2015, for his service-connected valvular heart disease; and his claim of entitlement to a TDIU, the Board notes that those issues are still pending at the agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ) and will not be discussed herein. 1. Entitlement to an initial compensable rating prior to February 21, 2003, for service-connected valvular heart disease is remanded. In the April 2019 JMPR, the parties noted that VA revised the criteria for evaluating disabilities of the heart during the period under review and that, while the new criteria specifically accounts for valvular heart disease, Diagnostic Code 7000 under the old criteria was specifically captioned rheumatic heart disease. Because the Veteran’s service-connected valvular heart disease was not shown to be etiologically related to rheumatic fever, the parties noted that Diagnostic Code 7000 was applicable only by analogy, and it was not expected that the Veteran’s non-rheumatic heart disease would perfectly mesh with the old criteria. The parties then agreed that the Board’s analysis was inadequate as it failed to consider whether the analogous criteria of the older version of Diagnostic Code reasonably approximated the Veteran’s heart valve dysfunction so as to permit the award of a compensable rating. Where pertinent statutes or regulations change while a claim is pending, the Board must consider the claim in light of both the former and revised schedular rating criteria to determine whether the disability warrants and increased evaluation. VA’s General Counsel has determined that amended rating criteria, if favorable to the claim, may be applied only for periods from and after the effective date of the regulatory change. The Veteran does, however, get the benefit of having both the old and new regulations considered for the applicable periods after the effective date of the change. See VAOPGCPREC 3-00. The relevant schedular criteria for rating diseases of the heart were amended effective January 12, 1998. See 62 Fed. Reg. 65207, 65219 (Dec. 11, 1997). As such, the claim must also be considered under the criteria that were in effect prior to January 12, 1998. In an October 2016 rating decision, the AOJ assigned an effective date of June 29, 1995, for the award of service connection for the Veteran’s service-connected valvular heart disease. In doing so, the AOJ assigned an initial compensable rating under Diagnostic Code 7000; however, in assigning the initial compensable rating, there is no indication that the AOJ considered the application of the former criteria for rating diseases of the heart. Moreover, the April 2017 Statement of the Case (SOC) also fails to identify or apply the former criteria. On remand, the AOJ should readjudicate the issue on appeal, with consideration in the first instance of the both the old and new rating criteria for rating diseases of the heart, ensuring not to apply the new criteria retrospectively (i.e., prior to January 12, 1998). 2. Entitlement to a rating in excess of 20 percent for service-connected lumbar spine disability is remanded. In March 2019, the Veteran underwent a VA examination to address the current nature and severity of his service-connected lumbar spine disability. In addition to other clinical findings, the examiner noted his reports of flare-ups and functional loss. The Veteran also stated that he could not bend forward all the way without it causing pain. Although the examiner noted that the Veteran’s functional ability was significantly limited following repeated use and during flare ups due to pain, fatigue, weakness, and lack of endurance, the examiner then estimated that his functional loss in terms of range of motion would was the same as the range of motion demonstrated during the examination. Given that the examiner earlier indicated that the Veteran was not experiencing a flare-up at the time of the examination, but that he experienced significant limitations following repeated use and during flare ups due to pain, fatigue, weakness, and lack of endurance, the examiner’s conclusion that his range of motion would essentially stay the same following repeated use or during flare ups is contradictory with the other findings contained in the examination report. Furthermore, in an August 2019 correspondence, the Veteran’s attorney argued that the March 2019 VA examination report was inadequate as it failed to reflect consideration of his lay statement concerning the severity, frequency, duration, or functional loss associated with his flare ups. Thus, given the inconsistent findings contained within the March 2019 VA examination report, and to ensure compliance with the Court’s holding in Sharp v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 26, 34-35 (2017), the Veteran should be scheduled for a new VA examination to assess the current nature and severity of his service-connected lumbar spine disability. On remand, the AOJ should associate with the record any outstanding VA treatment records that are not currently associated with the claims file. Additionally, the Veteran should be given the opportunity to identify any outstanding pertinent records. 3. Entitlement to an initial rating in excess of 10 percent for service-connected right lower extremity radiculopathy is remanded. With regard to his claim for an initial rating in excess of 10 percent for service-connected right lower extremity radiculopathy, this issue is inextricably intertwined with his claim for an increased rating for his service-connected lumbar spine disability, as well as his claim for an effective date earlier than May 8, 2017, for the award of service connection for right lower extremity radiculopathy. See Parker v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 116 (1994); Harris v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 180, 183 (1991). As such, the Board will defer consideration of that issue at this time. 4. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than May 8, 2017, for the award of service connection for right lower extremity radiculopathy is remanded. Following a July 2017 rating decision that denied the Veteran’s claim for an increased rating for his service-connected lumbar spine disability, and awarded service connection for the Veteran’s right lower extremity radiculopathy and assigned an initial 10 percent disability rating, effective May 8, 2017, the Veteran filed a notice of disagreement in February 2018 as to the ratings assigned to his service-connected lumbar spine disability and right lower extremity radiculopathy, as well as the effective date assigned for the award of service connection for his right lower extremity radiculopathy. In July 2019, the AOJ issued a SOC that addressed the Veteran’s claims for increased ratings, but it did not address his claim for an earlier effective date and, to date, the AOJ has yet to issue a SOC that addressed this issue. Thus, a remand is required for the AOJ to issue a SOC. 38 C.F.R. § 20.200 (2019); Manlincon v. West, 12 Vet. App. 238, 240-41 (1999). The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Send the Veteran and his attorney an SOC that addresses the issue of entitlement to an effective date earlier than May 8, 2017, for the award of service connection for right lower extremity radiculopathy. If the Veteran perfects an appeal by submitting a timely VA Form 9, the issue should be returned to the Board for further appellate consideration. 2. Associate any outstanding VA treatment records with the Veteran’s claims file. 3. Give the Veteran the opportunity to identify any outstanding pertinent evidence that has not already been associated with the claims file. The AOJ should then attempt to obtain those records if he provides the appropriate authorization. 4. After completing the above development, the Veteran should be scheduled for an appropriate VA examination by a competent medical professional to determine the current nature and severity of his service-connected lumbar spine disability and right lower extremity radiculopathy. The entire record must be made available to and be reviewed by the examiner. The examiner should take a history from the Veteran as to the progression of his service-connected disabilities, and any indicated evaluations, studies, and tests should be conducted. The examiner must address each of the following inquiries: a) The examiner should describe all pertinent orthopedic and neurologic manifestations associated with the Veteran’s service-connected lumbar spine disability and radiculopathy. b) The examiner should test for pain in active motion, passive motion, weight-bearing, and nonweight-bearing. If such testing cannot be conducted, the examiner should explain why this is so. c) The examiner should ask the Veteran to report any range of motion loss during flare-ups or following repeated use. The Veteran should be asked to identify: (1) the frequency of flare-ups; (2) the duration of flare-ups; (3) any precipitating factors; and (4) any alleviating factors. Even if the Veteran is not experiencing a flare-up at the time of the examination, the examiner must elicit relevant information as to his flare-ups and ask him to describe the additional functional loss, if any, he suffers during flare-ups or following repeated use. d) If the examination does not occur during a flare-up, based upon the evidence of record, and the information elicited on examination, please state whether it is at least as likely as not (50 percent probability or greater) that, during a flare-up, limitation of flexion is limited to 30 degrees or less (the measurement required for the next higher rating). e) With regard to the right lower extremity radiculopathy, the examiner should indicate whether there is complete or incomplete paralysis of the affected nerve(s) and, if so, the examiner should describe the severity of the impairment as mild, moderate, moderately severe, or severe with marked muscular atrophy. f) The examiner should also address the impact that the Veteran’s service-connected lumbar spine disability and right lower extremity radiculopathy have on activities of daily living, including employment. If the examiner cannot provide the above-requested opinion without resorting to speculation, he or she should state whether all procurable medical evidence had been considered, to specifically include the Veteran’s description as to the severity, frequency, and duration of flare-ups and his description as to the extent of functional loss during a flare-up and after repetitive use over time; whether the inability is due to the limits of medical community or the limits of the examiner’s medical knowledge; and whether there is additional evidence, which if obtained, would permit the opinion to be provided. See Sharp v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 26, 33 (2017). 5. Thereafter, and after any further development deemed necessary, the issues on appeal should be readjudicated. With regard to the initial rating assigned to the Veteran’s valvular heart disease, consider both the former (pre- January 12, 1998) and current (post- January 12, 1998) criteria for evaluating disabilities of the spine. For all times prior to January 12, 1998, only the former diagnostic criteria for evaluating disabilities of the heart are applicable. For all times from January 12, 1998, to the present, both the former and current diagnostic criteria are applicable. The more favorable criteria should be applied. If the benefits sought on appeal are denied, in whole or in part, issue the Veteran and his attorney a Supplemental Statement of the Case. Irvin Cannaday Acting Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board James R. Springer, Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential, and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.