Citation Nr: 20031733 Decision Date: 05/06/20 Archive Date: 05/06/20 DOCKET NO. 18-49 895A DATE: May 6, 2020 ORDER The claim for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is denied. FINDING OF FACT OSA was not first manifested on active duty, is not otherwise shown to be the result is not the result of active service, or to be related to a service-connected disability. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for entitlement to service connection for OSA are not met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 1131, 5107(b) (2012); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.303, 3.310, 3.317 (2019). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served in the U.S. Marine Corps on active service from December 1977 to June 2007. Service personnel records show that he served in the southwest Asia (SWA) theater of operations in 1990 and 1991. He is thus recognized as a Persian Gulf Veteran. This appeal comes before the Board of Veterans Appeals (Board) from a February 2012 rating decision by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). The Veteran asserts that his OSA had its onset during active service or is otherwise the result of has active service. In the alternative, he argues that his OSA is the result of his service-connected CAD and hypertension. Unfortunately, the evidence does not support the Veteran’s claims. Under the relevant laws and regulations, service connection may be granted for a disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by active service. 38 U.S.C. § 1110. Generally, the evidence must show: (1) the existence of a present disability; (2) in-service incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury; and (3) a causal relationship between the present disability and the disease or injury incurred or aggravated during service. Shedden v. Principi, 391 F.3d 1163, 1166-67 (Fed. Cir. 2004). Private medical records establish that obstructive sleep apnea was first diagnosed following a September 2011 polysomnography (PSG), or sleep study. Additionally, sleep problems were noted in service. The Veteran reported symptoms of disrupted sleep during active service. Service treatment records (STRs) show the Veteran reported difficulty sleeping in 1995, noted as insomnia. Thereafter, in 1998, 2001, 2002 and 2007, including on his February 2007 discharge physical, the Veteran reported jerking of his upper and lower extremities during sleep, observed by his spouse and barracks-mates, but of which he was unaware and which did not wake him up. However, on his discharge physical, the examining physician noted that a 2002 sleep study was negative. Finally, after his discharge examination but prior to his discharge in June 2007, STRs in May 2007 show the Veteran reported and was treated for symptoms of sleep disruption including daytime tiredness and sleepiness, nighttime awakenings, and shaking in his sleep. It was noted he had ongoing sleep disorders and needed sleep studies. Service Connection as a Consequence of SWA Service For those that served in Persian Gulf War Veterans with qualifying service in the SWA theater of operations may receive service connection on a presumptive basis for a qualifying chronic disability that manifested during service or to a compensable degree after service and before December 31, 2021, due to an undiagnosed illness or a medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illness. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 1117, 1118; 38 C.F.R. § 3.317. Sleep disturbances are among the symptoms listed as among the signs or symptoms which may be manifestations of undiagnosed illness or may be included in medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illness. 38 C.F.R. § 3.317. Notwithstanding, the medical evidence shows the Veteran’s symptoms of sleep disturbance have been accounted for as part of diagnosed conditions. Symptoms of chronic sleep impairment, to include insomnia, are service connected as part of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), in a February 2008 rating decision, effective in June 2007. And, during the pendency of this appeal, symptoms of shaking and jerking at night have been diagnosed and service connected as essential tremors and restless leg syndrome in a February 2019 rating decision, effective in June 2007. These conditions, found to be present in service, also account for the complaints of fatigue and sleepiness in service; complaints of snoring are addressed below in connection with direct service connection. There are no other symptoms of the Veteran’s reported sleep disturbance that are not diagnosed. OSA is not among the medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illnesses defined in the criteria. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.317(a). As there are no symptoms of sleep disturbance that are undiagnosed, and OSA is not identified as a medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illness in the criteria, there are no undiagnosed symptoms or disorders that may be considered for service connection under 38 C.F.R. § 3.317. Accordingly, presumptive service-connection for symptoms of sleep disturbances and/or OSA as an undiagnosed illness is not warranted. Direct Service Connection As also described above, there is no dispute that the Veteran reported and was observed to exhibit symptoms of disrupted sleep during active service. STRs show the Veteran reported difficulty sleeping in 1995, which was noted to be insomnia, and he reported in his February 2007 discharge physical, that he had trouble sleeping and sometimes shook during his sleep beginning after his return from SWA. The examining physician noted that a 2002 sleep study was negative. STRs further evidence that, after the Veteran’s discharge examination but prior to his discharge in June 2007, he reported and was treated for daytime tiredness and sleepiness, nighttime awakenings, and shaking in his sleep. It was noted he had ongoing sleep disorders and should undergo sleep studies. Post service testing was in fact accomplished; in November 2008 the Veteran and his wife described disturbed sleep, with jerking and shaking. He was in good shape physically, with stable weight. His wife reported he snored and had frequent pauses in his breathing. The doctor suspected OSA, and a PSG was performed. However, such did not show any significant sleep apnea, and such was not diagnosed. The PSG did not meet the diagnostic criteria. In January 2012, the Veteran underwent VA examination at which time the VA examiner acknowledged the diagnosis of OSA and opined it is less likely than not that OSA was incurred in or caused by active service. As rationale, the VA examiner explained that STRs did not establish a diagnosis of sleep apnea during active military service, and that OSA first developed in 2011. Subsequently, the Veteran submitted three medical statements in support of his claim. In a 2012 statement, Ms. JG, a nurse practitioner, stated that there was no way to rule out the existence of OSA during the Veteran’s active service. As rationale, she explained the Veteran had manifested ongoing symptoms of OSA throughout active service until his diagnosis in 2011. She identified these symptoms as body movements during sleep, cramping/movement in his legs, and drowsiness. She then explained that the onset of OSA is insidious and chronic, and often goes unnoticed, undiagnosed and/or underestimated for years. In 2012, Ms. VO, another nurse practitioner, stated she agreed the Veteran’s OSA “may have been going on for years.” As rationale, she pointed to the Veteran’s diagnosis with periodic limb movements at the same time he was diagnosed with OSA. Yet, she further qualified her statement by asserting there is no way to determine in favor or against. The third opinion was proffered by Dr. BS-H in February 2014, who opined “It is also possible” that there is a 50/50 probability the Veteran’s OSA “could have been caused” during active duty. She provided no rationale for her opinion. In September 2014, the VA conducted a records review examination, to include the above opinions. After review of the record, the 2014 VA examiner opined it is less likely than not that OSA was incurred in or caused by active service, and it is less likely than not that OSA was caused by exposure to environmental hazards in SWA. As rationale, the VA examiner explained that shaking during sleep is not a symptom of OSA, observing also that the shaking had not been shown to wake the Veteran from sleep. Rather, the medical evidence showed the Veteran woke up refreshed and did not manifest daytime somnolence. In addition, the VA examiner observed, there was no evidence the Veteran had been exposed to environmental hazards causing sleep apnea. The VA examiner further explained that there was no evidence of OSA during active service or prior to 2011, when it was initially diagnosed. The Veteran’s separation examination in 2007 and polysomnograms conducted in 2002 and 2008 were negative for OSA. Moreover, a 2010 VA cardiology consult in 2010 showed no mention of sleep apnea or any relationship of such symptoms to cardiac follow-up and a 2012 neurology evaluation by Ms. VO concluded there was no way to determine that OSA diagnosed in 2011 was present during active service. After the 2014 VA examination, the Veteran submitted a fourth medical statement, dated in 2014, from Dr. WJL. Dr. WJL opined it is as likely as not that the OSA diagnosed in 2011 began while he was active duty military. As rationale, the physician explained that the Veteran had been treated at his facility for OSA and, by history, his symptoms began many years ago. Dr. WJL also stated, however, that this opinion was unprovable. It is noted that Dr. WJL was part of the team that conducted the negative 2008 sleep study. In analyzing the evidence before it as to the theory of direct service connection, the results of the 2002 and 2008 sleep studies are crucial. Both are shown in the medical evidence to be negative for OSA. In other words, the medical evidence does not establish a diagnosis of OSA until 2011—over four years after the Veteran’s discharge from active service. Two of the four medical opinion supporting a finding that the Veteran’s OSA is the result of or had its onset during active service use conditional language. VO stated the Veteran’s OSA “may have been” going on for years. Dr. BS-H stated “it is possible” that there is a 50/50 probability the Veteran’s OSA “could have” been caused by his active duty. Language such as “may have,” “possible” and “could have” is equivocal and causes the opinions offered to be speculative rather than definite in nature. Moreover VO did not give a precise time period for the onset of the diagnosed OSA and then stated there is no way to determine when the Veteran’s diagnosed OSA may have begun, increasing the speculative nature of her opinion. Because these opinions are speculative in nature, they cannot be of probative weight. Obert v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 30, 33 (1993). Finally, Dr. BS-H provides no rationale for her opinion which, in addition to the speculative nature of the opinion overall, weighs against its probative weight. The rationale for the third opinion supporting the onset of OSA during active service, from JG is that the Veteran manifested symptoms of OSA throughout active service until his diagnosis with OSA in 2011. However, the symptoms JG identified were body movements during sleep, cramping/movement in the Veteran’s legs, and drowsiness. Yet, the 2014 VA examiner stated that shaking is not a symptom of OSA; the private doctor who satted there was no OSA in 2008, and eventually diagnosed such in 2011, also stated such symptoms were not accounted for by OSA in reporting the PSG results. Furthermore, the Veteran’s symptoms of tremors, shaking, and jerking have been diagnosed and separately service-connected as essential tremors and restless leg syndrome. These symptoms described as related to OSA cannot then be counted as symptoms of OSA. In a similar manner, symptoms of drowsiness, without further explanation, cannot be accepted as marking the onset of OSA during active service, particularly when other explanations for sleepiness are offered, to include insomnia and the physical tics he stated kept him from restful sleep. JG’s observation that the onset of the Veteran’s specific OSA was during active service is based on observations of symptoms that are ultimately determined to be symptoms of other, separately service-connected disorders, thus this opinion loses its probative value as to the onset of OSA. The fourth statement supporting the onset of OSA during active service, from Dr. WJL, also offers the opinion that the Veteran’s OSA began during the Veteran’s active service. As rationale, he explained that he treated the Veteran for OSA and, by history, his symptoms began many years ago. Evidence does not show that Dr. WJL began treating the Veteran in 2008, which is after the Veteran had been discharged. Thus it appears that the physician’s opinion is based on a history as reported by the Veteran and his spouse. As has been explained above, the symptoms of sleep disturbance reported and observed during active service, i.e., shaking and jerking of the Veteran’s upper and lower extremities, nighttime limb and body movement, and difficulty sleeping, and daytime tiredness or drowsiness, were ultimately diagnosed as other disorders or as associated with other disorders and separately service-connected. Moreover, the medical evidence establishes that the Veteran’s OSA did not have its onset during active service. This is clearly documented in the 2002 and 2008 sleep studies, which are negative for OSA. The 2008 test, in particular, is important because it was done at the behest of Dr. WJL and he specifically found no OSA and that other explanation for reported symptoms was required. Dr. WJL based his rationale on the report of inservice symptoms ultimately found to be diagnosed as or associated with other disorders, essential tremors and restless leg disorder, and PTSD, now separately service-connected. His initial findings in 2008 support such. This and the documented fact that OSA was not diagnosed until 2011 weigh against the probative value of his opinion. This leaves the opinion of the VA examiner in 2014 which, as noted above, considered three of the private opinions in its rationale. The 2014 VA examiner demonstrated review of the entire record, including STRs over the period of the Veteran’s two decades of active service and throughout the pendency of this appeal until 2014, including the negative 2002 and 2008 sleep studies, and the 2011 positive sleep study. As such, the 2014 VA examiner had a more complete and accurate set of records to review. Hence the Board finds the opinion of the 2014 VA examiner to have great probative weight. The Veteran and his witness, his spouse, have attested that the Veteran’s symptoms of OSA began during active service after the Veteran’s return from SWA. The Veteran and his witness are competent to report their observations concerning his difficulty sleeping and awakenings, daytime tiredness, shaking and jerking jerk in his sleep during active service and after discharge, with snoring and pauses in breathing, to his diagnosis of OSA in 2011. Such symptoms are lay-observable. Nevertheless, the Veteran and his witness are not medical professionals, qualified to identify and diagnose symptoms of OSA and to relate such symptoms and diagnosis medically to active service. In other words, the Veteran and his witness know that the Veteran exhibited symptoms of sleep disturbance, but they do not know the etiology of those symptoms of sleep disturbance. See Layno v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 465, 469 (1994); Jandreau v. Nicholson, 492 F.3d 1372 (Fed. Cir. 2007). There are no other medical statements, findings, or opinions tending to establish the Veteran’s OSA is the result of active service, including exposure to environmental hazards in SWA. The weight of the evidence is against the claim; there is no doubt to be resolved. Service connection on a direct basis is not warranted. Secondary Service Connection In addition, a disability that is proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disease or injury shall be service connected. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. The Veteran is service-connected for CAD and hypertension, effective in June 2007. He alleges OSA is related to such. In their statements, JG, VO, and Dr. BS-H. addressed a potential relationship between the claimed OSA and CAD. JG explained that historical symptoms such as cardiovascular disease and hypertension are clearly associated with OSA and, in sum, may exacerbate pre-existing CAD. However, statements indicate OSA may cause CAD or hypertension, not vice-versa. VO stated that OSA is, and has been, correlated with high blood pressure, increased risk for CAD, and also for stroke and that the Veteran’s OSA could have exacerbated his CAD. Again, this is an argument the OSA is a primary condition, not the reverse as the Veteran alleges. Dr BS-H stated there is a causal relationship between the Veteran’s OSA diagnosis and his hypertension and his resultant CAD. No rationale for the conclusory statement is offered, and hence no probative value is warranted. In contrast, the 2014 VA examiner opined that the claimed OSA is less likely than not proximately due to or the result of the Veteran’s service-connected CAD or hypertension. As rationale, the VA examiner explained that STRs showed cardiac disease preceded the diagnosis of OSA. Specifically, STRs dated in 2002 showed the Veteran complained of chest pain for the past 15 years, and hypertension was being evaluated in 2003. VA cardiology treatment records in 2010 made no mention of OSA or any relationship of symptoms of OSA to cardiac follow-up. OSA was not diagnosed until 2011. The VA examiner further explained that whether OSA causes heart disease is still unclear. A preponderance of the literature does not support a causal relationship between OSA and heart disease. See 2014 VA Examination for OSA. As above noted, the 2014 VA examination was conducted with review of the record, to include STRs. Here also, it is important to note that the 2014 VA opinion is also based on review of medical literature and on all possible ways in which the claimed OSA could be the result of active service, incidents of active service, or of service-connected disorders. The Board thus finds the 2014 VA examiner’s opinion to have the greater weight. The above medical record thus presents no competent medical evidence of record establishing the diagnosed OSA is the result of the service-connected CAD and/or hypertension. There are no other medical statements, opinions or findings tending to establish the diagnosed OSA is the result of the Veteran’s service-connected CAD and/or hypertension. The Veteran has argued that his OSA is the result of his service connected CAD and hypertension. However, the Veteran lacks the medical expertise to determine his claimed OSA is the result of his service-connected CAD or hypertension. See Jandreau, supra. Service connection for OSA on a secondary basis is not warranted. In sum, there is no basis, as a Gulf War-related condition, on a direct basis, or a secondary basis, on which to relate currently diagnosed OSA to service. In-service complaints have been associated with non-OSA diagnoses, and repeated testing showed no OSA until several years after service. The weight of the evidence is against the claim; there is no doubt to be resolved. Service connection for OSA is not warranted. WILLIAM H. DONNELLY Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board L.J. Bakke, Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.