Citation Nr: 20031971 Decision Date: 05/06/20 Archive Date: 05/06/20 DOCKET NO. 15-08 994A DATE: May 6, 2020 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran had active duty for training from March to August 1991, and active service from January 2004 to May 2005, and January 2006 to May 2007. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) on appeal from a September 2013 rating decision by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) that denied the Veteran service connection for his OSA. The Veteran is service connected for, inter alia, an anxiety disorder and fibromyalgia. In April 2019, a Veterans Law Judge (VLJ) other than the undersigned VLJ issued a decision remanding this matter to the RO for further development. The April 2019 VLJ observed, in pertinent parts, as follows: In the February 2019 VA examination, the examiner opined that the Veteran’s [OSA was] less likely than not proximately due to or [a] result of the Veteran’s service-connected condition. The examiner explained that[,] per the Mayo Clinic, [OSA] occurs when the muscles in the back of the throat relax too much to allow normal breathing. When the muscles relax, the airway narrows or closes. The brain senses this impaired breathing and briefly rouses the person to reopen the airway. As such, the examiner opined that the Veteran’s [OSA was] less likely than not proximately due to or the result of anxiety disorder and/or fibromyalgia. The Board acknowledges that[, in his Substantive Appeal,] the Veteran cit[ed] a statement [by] the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain. The Veteran [included in his Substantive Appeal an excerpt of this statement, indicating] that, among patients with chronic pain, more than 50 percent experience sleep disturbances[,] and some even report that as many as 78 to 88 percent of the patients with chronic pain report sleep trouble. However, for patients with fibromyalgia[,] obstructive sleep apnea is significantly more common with observed rates of 46 to 80 percent. Based on the foregoing, the April 2019 VLJ concluded that “a remand [was] warranted[,] as an addendum opinion [was] needed to address aggravation.” Therefore, the April 2019 VLJ directing as follows: [Upon remand,] the examiner must state whether it is at least as likely as not (a [50] percent probability or greater) that the Veteran’s [OSA] was (a) caused by or has been (b) aggravated (worsened beyond the natural progress of the disorder) by his service-connected fibromyalgia and/or anxiety disorder. The examiner must address the statement cited from the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain [an excerpt from which was included in the Veteran’s Substantive Appeal]. In December 2019, a VA examiner (other than the February 2019 VA examiner who rendered the opinion quoted by the April 2019 VLJ in her Remand order) rendered an addendum opinion. The December 2019 VA examiner stated: [OSA] is a physical obstruction in the airway. Obstructive sleep apnea happens when breathing is either stopped or reduced during sleep because of a narrowing or blockage of the upper airway. Medical literature does not support that fibromyalgia/anxiety increase the physical obstruction, therefore, do not aggravate sleep apnea. The December 2019 VA examiner did not expressly address “the statement cited from the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain [that was noted in the Substantive Appeal].” Further, she did not address the issue of “whether it is at least as likely as not . . . that the Veteran’s [OSA] was . . . caused by . . . his service-connected fibromyalgia and/or anxiety disorder.” In April 2020, the RO issued a Supplemental Statement of the Case (SSOC) continuing denial of service connection for the Veteran’s OSA and returned this matter to the Board. The Board acknowledges that the direct secondary causation theory of entitlement has already been addressed in the opinion rendered by the February 2019 VA examiner and quoted in the April 2019 VLJ’s decision. Accordingly, the Board is without a basis to conclude that the December 2019 VA examiner’s election not to address the direct secondary causation theory of entitlement caused the RO’s failure to substantially comply with the April 2019 VLJ’s remand order when the RO last adjudicated this matter in the April 2020 SSOC based on the findings rendered by the February 2019 and December 2019 VA examiners. However, the record makes it abundantly clear that neither the February 2019 nor the December 2019 VA examiner expressly addressed the excerpt included in the Substantive Appeal and attributed to a statement from the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain. The excerpt reads as follows: An estimated 28 million Americans have sleep complaints due to chronic pain syndromes. Among patients with chronic pain, more than 50% experience sleep disturbances. Some reports say as many as 70% - 88% patients with chronic pain report sleep trouble. Sleep disturbance shows an independent and linear correlation with pain severity, even after controlling for health measures and sleep habits. Sleep complaints portend worse outcome among those with chronic pain. In patients with fibromyalgia, complaints of poor sleep quality and fatigue are more prominent than pain. . . . Among patients with fibromyalgia, a poor night’s sleep predicts more pain the next day, and more pain predicts greater sleep impairment that night. Patients with fibromyalgia frequently experience nonrestorative sleep and alpha-wave intrusions are commonly observed during polysomnography. The prevalence of insomnia, restless leg syndrome (RLS), and hypersomnia are higher among patients with fibromyalgia than within the general population. Similarly, OSA is significantly more common, with observable rates of 46% - 80% reported among patients with fibromyalgia. The above-quoted excerpt was not accompanied by a citation to the statement of the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain from which it was derived. Further, while the excerpt included markings suggesting that the statement from which it was derived had footnotes to certain studies that the statement relied upon, these footnotes were similarly not included in the excerpt. Therefore, at this juncture, the Board is without a basis to find that the statement from which the excerpt was derived could qualify as a reliable study or as “medical literature.” Rather, at this juncture, the excerpt qualifies as the Veteran’s lay statement included in his Substantive Appeal, although the Veteran’s future submission of the entire statement from which the excerpt was derived (or a citation to the publication) might requalify the statement into a medical treatise evidence. However, at this juncture, the Board is without a basis to conclude that the December 2019 VA examiner’s statement “[m]edical literature does not support that fibromyalgia/anxiety increase the physical obstruction, therefore, do not aggravate sleep apnea” reflected her assessment of the statement of the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain from which the excerpt included in the Substantive Appeal was derived. The probative value of a medical treatise evidence is determined on a case-by-case basis because such evidence may constitute competent medical evidence. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(a)(1). However, in order to qualify as probative, the treatise evidence must provide more than just generic statements that are not relevant to a veteran’s particular circumstances. Wallin v. West, 11 Vet. App. 509, 514 (1998). Here, the content of the excerpt included in the Substantive Appeal suggests that the entire statement from which the excerpt was derived was a generic statement not reflective of the Veteran’s particular circumstances. However, given that the statement from which the except was derived has not been associated with the claims file, the Board is presently not in a position to determine whether the statement is or is not directly relevant to the circumstances at bar. Moreover, the Board is mindful that, to provide a competent opinion as to the scientific AGENTvalidity and content of a medical treatise evidence, a VA examiner is entitled to be provided with the treatise at issue, not a de facto lay statement replicating two paragraphs from the treatise that the litigant finds most favorable to his/her claim. The foregoing, however, does not alter the fact that the December 2019 VA examiner did not address the excerpt included in the Substantive Appeal, as she was expressly directed in the April 2019 VLJ’s Remand order. Generally, a post-remand VA examination does not require a further remand for an addendum medical opinion if the examination is in substantial compliance with the remand directive. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268 (1998). In this case, however, the December 2019 VA examiner’s opinion was not in substantial compliance with the April 2019 VLJ’s Remand order; rather, it facially failed to comply with it. Therefore, the RO’s issuance of the SSOC without an appropriate addendum opinion violated the holding of Stegall. Accordingly, while the Board regrets further delay, a remand is required before a decision may be rendered as to the Veteran’s claim seeking service connection for OSA. In conclusion, the Board takes this opportunity to observe that, because – in the Board and RO’s record – the Veteran’s representative was erroneously designated as the Appellant in this matter (with the representative’s name slightly misspelled), some of VA mailed communications, to include the mailing of the April 2019 VLJ’s decision, were erroneously addressed and forwarded only to the Veteran’s representative, without being copied to the Veteran. However, the record also reflects that, in April 2020, an RO representative contacted the Veteran personally by means of a telephonic communication, verified that the Veteran had no additional evidence to submit, informed him that this matter was being returned to the Board for further adjudication, and obtained his express consent to have this matter certified to the Board. Therefore, the instant Remand order is proper and does not violate the Veteran’s due process rights. Further, given that this matter is being remanded to the RO for further adjudication, the Veteran would be availed to an opportunity to make additional submissions and/or inquire about the documents associated with the claims file in the past that might be of interest to the Veteran. The Board has also notified the administrative staff of the error in the mailing record, which has been corrected to ensure that all mailed communications would be sent to both the Veteran and his representative. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Direct the Veteran to submit a full and complete copy of the statement, including footnoted material, from which the except that was included in the Substantive Appeal and attributed to the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Chronic Pain (AOSACP) was derived. In alternative, direct the Veteran to submit a citation to the academic publication containing the AOSACP statement, provided that such a citation enables VA to access the publication on a reputable publicly accessible website, and to download the statement in full in order to associate an electronic copy of the statement with the claims file. Provide the Veteran with ample time to submit a full and complete copy of the AOSACP statement or an appropriate citation. 2. In the event the Veteran submits a full and complete copy of the AOSACP statement or an appropriate citation: a. Request the Veteran to identify any outstanding post service private and VA treatment records relevant to his claim for service connection for OSA. b. Provide the Veteran with the necessary authorization forms, attempt to obtain all identified records, and document all negative responses received. c. In the event the Veteran, being afforded ample time to submit a full and complete copy of the AOSACP statement or an appropriate citation, fails to submit such a copy of the statement or such a citation, dispense with the tasks detailed infra in Step 3 and proceed to Step 4. 3. In the event the Veteran submits a full and complete copy of the AOSACP statement or an appropriate citation, forward the Veteran’s claims file to the VA examiner who conducted his February 2019 examination or, if this examiner is not available, to the VA examiner who provided the addendum December 2019 opinion, or if this examiner is also not available, to an appropriate VA examiner. The VA examiner is requested to: a. Opine as to whether the AOSACP statement qualifies as a peer-reviewed or otherwise-reliable academic medical study. b. Opine whether the AOSACP statement is supported or contradicted by peer-reviewed or otherwise academically acclaimed medical studies, and provide the titles and citations of these studies. c. Opine whether it is as likely as not (a 50 percent probability or greater) that the Veteran’s OSA was aggravated beyond its natural progression by the Veteran’s service-connected fibromyalgia or his service-connected anxiety disorder. d. In the event the VA examiner finds that it is as likely as not that the Veteran’s OSA was aggravated by his service-connected fibromyalgia and/or anxiety disorder, opine on the degree of aggravation of the Veteran’s OSA beyond its natural progression that is attributable to his fibromyalgia and/or anxiety disorder. 4. After completing the foregoing and any other development necessary, readjudicate the Veteran’s claim for service connection for OSA addressing, separately: a. The presumptive theory of entitlement raised by the Veteran in light of his service during the Gulf War era. b. The direct primary causation theory of entitlement. c. The direct secondary causation theory of entitlement asserted by the Veteran on the grounds that his OSA was caused by his service-connected anxiety disorder and/or his service-connected fibromyalgia. d. The secondary aggravation theory of entitlement asserted by the Veteran on the grounds that his OSA was aggravated by his service connected anxiety disorder and/or his service-connected fibromyalgia. 5. If any benefit sought on appeal remains denied, an SSOC should be furnished to the Veteran and his representative, and he should be afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond. 6. While the law requires that all claims remanded by the Board for additional development must be handled in an expeditious manner, 38 U.S.C. §§ 5109B, 7112, in light of the COVID-19 public health measures undertaken by the Federal government, the U.S. States, and municipalities, reasonable accommodations should be made to comply with these measures and to ensure the safety of all parties affected by this Remand order. Cf. Veterans Legal Advocacy Group v. Wilkie, No. 20 2346, 2020 U.S. App. Vet. Claims LEXIS 753 (Vet. App. Apr. 28, 2020). The Veteran has the right to submit additional evidence and argument on the matters the Board has remanded. Kutscherousky v. West, 12 Vet. App. 369 (1999). Cynthia M. Bruce Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board Anna Kapellan The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.