Citation Nr: 20032444 Decision Date: 05/08/20 Archive Date: 05/08/20 DOCKET NO. 16-44 807 DATE: May 8, 2020 ORDER As new and material evidence to reopen a claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea has been received, to this limited extent, the appeal is granted. FINDING OF FACT 1. A January 2005 rating decision denied service connection for sleep apnea. Although notified of the denial in a January 2005 letter, the Veteran did not initiate an appeal, and no pertinent exception to finality applies. 2. New evidence associated with the claims file since the January rating decision, when considered by itself or along with evidence previously assembled, is not duplicative or cumulative of the other evidence previously of record, relates to an unestablished fact necessary to substantiate the claim for service connection for sleep apnea, and raises a reasonable possibility of substantiating the claim. CONCLUSION OF LAW 1. The January 2005 rating decision that denied service connection for sleep apnea is final. 38 U.S.C. § 7105(c); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.104, 20.302, 20.1103. 2. As new and material evidence has been received, the criteria for reopening the claim for service connection for sleep apnea are met. 38 U.S.C. § 5108; 38 C.F.R. § 3.156. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Navy from July 1981 to February 1995. This appeal to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) arose from a June 2014 rating decision in which a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) declined to reopen a previously denied claim for service connection for sleep apnea. The Veteran filed a notice of disagreement (NOD) in June 2014. Following the receipt of additional evidence, a statement of the case (SOC) (reflecting that the RO reopened the service connection claim but denied the claim on the merits) was issued in August 2016, and the Veteran filed a substantive appeal (via a VA Form 9, Appeal to the Board of Veterans Appeals) in September 2016. In July 2019, the Veteran and his wife testified during a Board video-conference hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge. A transcript of that hearing is of record. Regardless of the RO's actions, as explained below, the service connection claim for sleep apnea was previously considered and denied, and the Board has a legal duty under 38 U.S.C. §§ 5108 and 7104 to address the question of whether new and material evidence has been received to reopen the previously denied claim. That matter goes to the Board's jurisdiction to reach the underlying claim and adjudicate the claim on a de novo basis. See Barnett v. Brown, 83 F.3d 1380, 1383 (Fed. Cir. 1996). As the Board must first decide whether new and material evidence to reopen the claim has been received—and, given the favorable disposition of the request to reopen—the Veteran is not prejudiced by the Board characterizing the sleep apnea disability claim as encompassing both a request to reopen the previously denied claim and the underlying service connection claim. Request to Reopen Under the legal authority in effect at the time of the prior denial and currently, service connection may be granted for a disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by service. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110,1131; 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(a). Service connection may also be granted for any disease diagnosed after discharge, when all the evidence, including that pertinent to service, establishes that the disease was incurred in service. 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(d). The Veteran’s initial claim for service connection for sleep apnea was denied in a January 2005 rating decision. The pertinent evidence then of record consisted of his service treatment records (which document no complaint specific to, or finding or diagnosis of, sleep apnea) and private medical records (reflecting a diagnosis of sleep apnea in 1997, two years after release from active duty). The RO denied the claim on the basis that the condition did not manifest in service. Although notified of the denial in January 2005, the Veteran did not appeal the denial. Moreover, no new and material evidence was received within the one-year appeal period from the date of the notice of the denial, and no additional service records, warranting reconsideration of the claim, have been received. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(b), (c). Therefore, the RO's January 2005 denial of the claim is final as to the evidence then of record and is not subject to revision on the same factual basis. See 38 U.S.C. § 7105; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.104, 20.302, 20.1103. However, under pertinent legal authority, VA may reopen and review a claim that has been previously denied if new and material evidence is submitted by or on behalf of the Veteran. 38 U.S.C. § 5108; 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(a). In this case, the Veteran filed a request to reopen his previously denied claim for service connection for sleep apnea in June 2013. For requests to reopen filed on and after August 29, 2001, 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(a) defines "new" evidence as evidence not previously submitted to agency decision makers and "material" evidence as evidence that, by itself or when considered with previous evidence of record, relates to an unestablished fact necessary to substantiate the claim. New and material evidence can be neither cumulative nor redundant of the evidence of record at the time of the last final denial of the claim sought to be reopened and must raise a reasonable possibility of substantiating the claim. 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(a). In determining whether new and material evidence has been received, VA must initially decide whether evidence received since the prior final denial is, in fact, new. This analysis is undertaken by comparing the newly received evidence with the evidence previously of record. After evidence is determined to be new, the next question is whether it is material. The threshold for determining whether new and material evidence raises a reasonable possibility of substantiating a claim is low. See Shade v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 110, 117 (2010). Moreover, in determining whether this low threshold is met, consideration need not be limited to whether the newly submitted evidence relates specifically to the reason why the claim was last denied, but also whether the evidence could reasonably substantiate the claim were the claim to be reopened, either by triggering the VA's duty to assist or through consideration of an alternative theory of entitlement. Id. at 118. The provisions of 38 U.S.C. § 5108 require a review of all evidence submitted by or on behalf of a claimant since the last final denial on any basis to determine whether a claim must be reopened. See Evans v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 273, 282-83 (1996). Here, the last final denial of the claim is the January 2005 rating decision. Furthermore, for purposes of the "new and material" analysis, the credibility of the evidence is presumed. Justus v. Principi, 3 Vet. App. 510, 512-13 (1992). Pertinent evidence added to the claims file since January 2005 rating decision includes several VA 21-4138, Statements in Support of Claim (which reflect the Veteran’s assertions of an in-service throat surgery at Subic Bay Naval Hospital to clear his airways and correct his breathing), a June 2013 buddy statement from a fellow service member (which recounts the Veteran’s excessive snoring during service), a June 2013 buddy statement from a post-service co-worker (which describes the Veteran’s daytime fatigue and drowsiness shortly after service), and the transcript of the April 2019 Board hearing (which reflects the Veteran’s and his wife’s testimony that his sleep apnea symptoms began shortly after the Veteran’s in-service surgery). The Board finds that the above-described evidence, when considered in light of the evidence previously of record, provides a basis for reopening the previously denied claim. This evidence is "new" in that it was not before the RO at the time of the January 2005 denial, and is not duplicative or cumulative of the evidence previously of record. Moreover, this evidence is "material" in that it relates to unestablished facts necessary to substantiate the claim for service connection—namely, whether the Veteran’s current sleep apnea disability had its onset during active duty service. Thus, given the low standard of Shade, and when presumed credible, this evidence raises a reasonable possibility of substantiating the claim in that it triggers the duty to obtain an examination and medical etiology opinion. Under these circumstances, the Board concludes that the criteria for reopening the claim for service connection for sleep apnea are met. See 38 U.S.C. § 5108; 38 C.F.R. § 3.156. REASONS FOR REMAND The Board’s review of the claims file reveals that further agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ) action on the claim for service connection on the merits, prior to appellate consideration, is warranted. In May 2016, the Veteran underwent VA examination to obtain a medical opinion addressing the etiology of his sleep apnea. The VA examiner opined that the Veteran’s claimed condition was less likely than not incurred in or caused by service because the earliest clinical note of sleep apnea was in 1997, two years after military service. The VA examiner also stated that to suggest any relationship between the Veteran’s sleep apnea and military service would be purely speculation. However, in rendering the requested opinion, the VA examiner did not consider and discuss lay evidence which describes symptoms tending to suggest the in-service onset of sleep apnea, or evidence pertaining to the Veteran’s alleged in-service throat surgery. As mentioned above, a fellow service member stated that the Veteran had excessive snoring during service, and a former co-worker asserted that the Veteran had daytime fatigue and drowsiness shortly after service. Also, during the subsequent Board hearing, the Veteran and his wife testified that he began experiencing sleep apnea symptoms shortly after in-service throat surgery. Moreover, the Veteran’s post-service private treatment notes reference a prior hospitalization and surgery for throat problems. See May 1996 and June 1997 Private Treatment Notes. Given the above, the Board finds that the medical evidence currently of record is insufficient to resolve the service connection claim on appeal, and that a remand of this matter to obtain an adequate medical etiology opinion is warranted. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303 (2007) (holding that once VA undertakes the effort to provide an examination or obtain a medical opinion, it must ensure that one is provided or obtained that is adequate for purposes of the determination being made). Prior to undertaking action responsive to the above, to ensure that all due process requirements are met, and that the record is complete, the AOJ should undertake appropriate action to obtain and associate with the claims file all outstanding, pertinent records. As for service treatment records, the claims file currently includes treatment records dated from November 1980 to December 1994. As mentioned above, the Veteran asserted that he underwent throat surgery at Subic Bay Naval Hospital. However, the AOJ only requested hospital records for 1991. Therefore, the AOJ should attempt to obtain all outstanding records of evaluation and/or treatment of the Veteran at Subic Bay Naval hospital from July 1981 to February 1995, following the current procedures prescribed in 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c). The AOJ should also give the Veteran another opportunity to provide information and/or evidence pertinent to the claim on appeal (to include regarding any private (non-VA) treatment), explaining that he has a full one-year period to respond. See 38 U.S.C. § 5103(b)(1); 38 U.S.C. § 5103(b)(3) (clarifying that VA may decide a claim before the expiration of the one-year notice period). Thereafter, the AOJ should attempt to obtain any additional evidence for which the Veteran provides sufficient information and, if necessary, authorization, following the current procedures prescribed in 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. The actions identified herein are consistent with the duties imposed by the Veterans Claim Assistance Act of 2000 (VCAA). See 38 U.S.C. §§ 5103, 5103a; 38 C.F.R. § 3.129. However, identification of specific actions requested on remand does not relieve the AOJ of the responsibility to ensure full compliance with the VCAA and its implementing regulation. Hence, in addition to the actions requested above, the AOJ should also undertake any other development and/or notification action deemed warranted prior to adjudicating the service connection claim on appeal, on the merits. The matter is hereby REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain all outstanding records of evaluation and/or treatment of the Veteran at Subic Bay Naval hospital from July 1981 to February 1995. Follow the procedures set forth in 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c) with respect to requesting records from Federal facilities. All records/responses received should be associated with the claims file. 2. Send to the Veteran and his representative a letter requesting that the Veteran provide sufficient information concerning, and, if necessary, authorization to enable VA to obtain, any additional evidence pertinent to the claim on appeal that is not currently of record, to include any private (non-VA) medical records. Clearly explain to the Veteran that he has a full one-year period to respond (although VA may decide the claim within a one-year period). 3. If the Veteran responds, assist him in obtaining any additional evidence identified, following the current procedures set forth in 38 C.F.R. § 3.159. All records/responses received should be associated with the claims file. If any records sought are not obtained, notify the Veteran of the records that were not obtained, explain the efforts taken to obtain them, and describe further action to be taken. 4. After all records and/or responses received from each contacted entity have been associated with the claims file, , arrange to obtain, from an appropriate physician (), an addendum opinion addressing the etiology of the Veteran’s sleep apnea, based on claims file review (if possible). Only arrange for the Veteran to undergo VA examination, by an appropriate physician, if one is deemed necessary in the judgment of the physician designated to provide the addendum opinion. The contents of the entire electronic claims file, to include a complete copy of this REMAND, must be made available to the designated physician, and the addendum opinion should reflect consideration of the Veteran’s documented medical history and assertions. After review of the Veteran’s documented medical history and all lay assertions (and any examination of the Veteran), the physician should provide an opinion, consistent with sound medical principles, as to whether it is at least as likely as not (i.e., a 50 percent or greater probability) that the Veteran’s sleep apnea had its onset during active service, or is otherwise medically-related to service, to include symptoms described as occurring therein (such as excessive snoring) and/or shortly after service (to include daytime fatigue and drowsiness), or in-service throat surgery. In addressing the above, the physician must consider and discuss all relevant medical and other objective evidence, to include any in- and/or post-service medical evidence of, or referencing, in-service throat surgery. The physician must also consider and discuss all lay assertions by the Veteran, his wife, his fellow service member, and his former co-worker, which reflect assertions as to the nature, onset, and continuity of the Veteran’s symptoms, such as snoring, daytime fatigue, and drowsiness. The physician is advised that the Veteran is competent to report his symptoms and history, and that the other laypersons are competent to report their observations of the Veteran; as such, the lay assertions in this regard must be considered in formulating the requested opinion. If lay assertions in any regard are discounted, the physician should clearly so state, and explain why. Complete clearly stated rationale for the conclusions reached must be provided. 5. To help avoid future remand, ensure that all requested actions have been accomplished (to the extent possible) in compliance with this REMAND. If any action is not undertaken, or is taken in a deficient manner, appropriate corrective action should be undertaken. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998). 6. After completing the requested actions above, and any additional action(s) deemed warranted, adjudicate the service connection claim on appeal, on the merits, considering all pertinent evidence (to include all evidence added to the electronic claims file since the last adjudication) and legal authority. JACQUELINE E. MONROE Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board B. Spann, Associate Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.