Citation Nr: 20044237 Decision Date: 07/01/20 Archive Date: 07/01/20 DOCKET NO. 08-29 506 DATE: July 1, 2020 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for a sleep disability, to include sleep apnea is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran had active service from December 1988 to December 1998. The Veteran appeals the denial of service connection for a sleep disability, to include sleep apnea. When this issue was last before the Board in April 2019, it was determined that further development was needed. To that end, in going through the record, the Board saw that the Veteran had served under both his current name and a former name (initials W.L.M., III). The Veteran’s service treatment records have not been obtained, and VA has found that such records are unavailable. It was noted that in a May 2012 Request for Information, the request listed the Veteran’s current name and acknowledged the other name the Veteran served under before changing his name to the current one when it asked for medical/dental records pertaining to the Veteran. The July 2012 response stated that “there are no [service treatment records] at Code 13 for this person.” As it was unclear whether “this person” included both names under which the Veteran served, the Board found that clarification was needed, where both names should be included, and the response should state that both names were searched. In a December 2019 request for information, it was found that “THERE ARE NO AIR FORCE PERSONNEL OR MEDICAL RECORDS AT CODE 13 FOR THIS PERSON.” The Board again notes that it is unclear whether “this person” included both names under which the Veteran served. A Court or Board remand confers upon the Appellant the right to compliance with that order. Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998). As the remand directives of April 2019 were not completely followed, the AOJ is again requested to comply with the Board's remand directives as stated below. The Board also notes that during the December 2019 VA examination, the VA examiner stated that: Review of the C file again notes no AD medical records in the C file as noted previously on DBQ sleep apnea 5/1/17. The Veteran did complain of a one month history of insomnia on 9/6/02 (which is nearly 4 years AFTER release from AD). However, no more information regarding the complaint (insomnia) is described in these records. The differential diagnosis of insomnia is very broad and sleep apnea is less likely as not the chief complaint of insomnia overall. The Veteran stated on 9/20/06 snoring and problem sleeping since service. However, there are no AD records to support this and the Sep 2002 note of one month of sleep problems (ie. insomnia) does not corroborate this. Several buddy statements noted. Witnessed accounts of observed sleeping are not an adequate predictor of sleep apnea. A diagnosis of sleep apnea requires a sleep study. Finally, as noted on the DBQ Sleep apnea MO 5/1/17 and again noted at this time, using UPTODATE to review the medical literature, a cause and effect relationship between sleep apnea and inhalation of volcanic ash has not been established. The Veteran was diagnosed with sleep [apnea] in Oct 2015, nearly 17 years after AD service and advancing age is a risk factor for the development of sleep apnea. The Board notes that Veteran argues that the VA opinion is inadequate because the rationale for the unfavorable opinion was that there is no documentation of the ongoing complaints reported by the Veteran. It is argued that the Veteran is competent to attest to the ongoing nature of his claimed obstructive sleep apnea. The Board agrees. The Veteran is competent to establish the presence of observable symptomatology and when they began to occur, and there is no evidence these statements are not credible. See Layno v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 465, 469. Therefore, upon remand, the examiner is instructed to specifically consider the Veteran’s lay statements regarding the onset and continuity of his symptoms. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Request the Veteran’s service treatment and dental records, where both his current name (initials S.A.) and his former name, (initials W.L.M, II) are part of the request and response. The request should include that the response must state that both names were searched. 2. Obtain an addendum opinion as to the etiology of the Veteran's sleep apnea disability. The electronic claims file must be made available to the examiner for review. Following a review of the record, the examiner is asked to provide an opinion as to whether it is at least as likely as not (a 50 percent probability or greater) that the Veteran’s claimed sleep disability, to include sleep apnea, had its onset during active service from December 1988 to December 1998 or is otherwise related to active service, to include as due to inhaling volcanic ash following the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo. The examiner should discuss why or why not the lay witness accounts of in-service symptoms, which should be accepted as true although not documented, did not represent the onset of sleep apnea, including whether it is medically possible to diagnose an onset of sleep apnea prior to sleep study being performed. In doing so, the examiner is advised that: • The Veteran served on active duty from December 1988 to December 1998 • VA treatment records from September 2002 document the Veteran’s complaints of insomnia for one month. • The October 2004 private medical record in which the Veteran reported that “my sleep is completely disturbed (5-7 hours sleepless).” • The September 2006 report that his sleeping problems first had their onset during active service in March 1991. • The November 2006 statement that the Veteran developed sleeping problems due to his breathing of volcanic ash from Mount Pinatubo while stationed at Clark Air Base. • The August 2007 statement in which the Veteran described the volcano eruption that took place in 1990 or 1991 and that after about three to four weeks of breathing in volcanic ash, he began to suffer from upper respiratory issues, such as sinus infections, upper respiratory infections, and problems sleeping. He wrote that these problems had continued to plague him since that time to the present time. The Veteran had a medical professional crossout “NonConcur,” which would indicate that the medical professional concurred with the Veteran’s statement that, “Upper Respiratory/Sleep –Is it possible for the injuries above to have occurred while this member was on Active Duty?” • The October 2007 and June 2008 buddy statements which recalled that the Veteran’s upper respiratory and breathing problems began during active service. • September 2007 and October 2007 lay statements from the Veteran’s mother, brother, and sister who all reported that the Veteran’s upper respiratory and breathing problems did not exist prior to active service and began during active service. • The October 2015statement in which the Veteran reported sleep problems for the past 22 years at the time of his diagnosis of mild obstructive sleep apnea following a diagnostic polysomnogram. For purposes of the opinion, the examiner must discuss and consider the Veteran's competent lay statements and assume such statements are credible for the purposes of the opinion. The VA examiner should provide a complete rationale for any opinions provided. The examiner must reconcile any opinion with the service treatment and personnel records, any post-service diagnoses, lay statements and testimony of the Veteran. If he or she rejects the lay evidence, an explanation must be provided, and the examiner should note that the mere passage of time without treatment is not a sufficient basis for finding that no relationship between a current disability and service exists. If additional examination is required in order to enter an opinion on the matter requested above, such an examination should be scheduled. 3. Thereafter, consider all of the evidence of record and readjudicate the issue on appeal. If any benefit sought remains denied, issue a supplemental statement of the case to the Veteran and his representative. T. MAINELLI Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board T.S. Willie The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.