Citation Nr: 20045282 Decision Date: 07/08/20 Archive Date: 07/08/20 DOCKET NO. 17-56 879 DATE: July 8, 2020 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND On initial review of this case the Board remanded the case for a medical opinion on direct service connection. See 12/19/2018 BVA Decision. The Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) arranged an examination as directed in the Board remand. For the reasons set forth below, however, the Board finds that the remand directives were not substantially complied with. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268 (1998). Entitlement to service connection for OSA is remanded. In the September 2019 examination reports (09/26/2019 C&P Exam, 1st & 3rd Entries) the examiner opined that it is not at least as likely as not that the Veteran’s OSA had onset in service or is otherwise causally connected to his active service. The Board finds two bases on which the examination was inadequate. First, the examiner provided an inadequate rationale. The examiner noted that there was no evidence of chronicity of care for OSA during active service, and that there was a 20-year gap between the Veteran’s discharge from active service and his diagnosis with OSA in 2011. Hence, a nexus with service was not established. Exam Report, 2nd Entry, P. 2. The Board notes that the absence of contemporaneous treatment, alone, is not an adequate basis for a negative nexus opinion, unless the significance of the absence of medical records of treatment is explained by the examiner. Further, the examiner did not address the evidence on which the Board found necessitated the remand in the first place, which was the Veteran’s lay evidence describing his history of symptoms. The examiner noted in the OSA DBQ (09/26/2019 C&P Exam, 1st Entry) that the Veteran reported breathing difficulty and snoring while asleep for years, but that it was not until 6 to 7 years before the examination that he was told to get himself checked. Id., P. 2. The examiner, however, did not even address the Veteran’s lay history or opine whether his reported symptoms indicated the onset of OSA. Hence, further medical analysis is needed. The second reason another remand is needed is not the fault of the examiner, as the prior remand did not mention it. A VA outpatient entry dated in February 2008 notes that the Veteran weighed 252 pounds, and that his BMI was 34.7. He was advised that the associated risks of his obesity included sleep apnea, and he was encouraged to lose weight. See 05/13/2008 Medical Treatment-Government Facility. VA’s General Counsel (GC) opined in 2017 how the issue of obesity is to be assessed. One of the primary holdings of the opinion is that obesity is not a disability for purposes of VA benefits; hence, it cannot be the subject of service connection. VAOPGCPREC No. 1-2017 (Jan. 6, 2017); see also Marcelino v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 155 (2018). The GC recognized further, however, that obesity may act as an “intermediate step” between a service-connected disability and a current disability that may be service connected on a secondary basis under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(a). The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims later held that obesity may also be a secondary or aggravating factor. See Walsh v. Wilkie, 32 Vet. App. 300 (2020). Hence, additional medical assessment is needed on whether the Veteran’s obesity was due to service-connected factors, to include the limitations, if any, caused by the Veteran’s spine disabilities and any medications prescribed to treat them; or, an inability to exercise due to the impact of service-connected disabilities. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: Send the claims file to the clinician who conducted the September 2019 OSA examination, or another, equally or higher qualified clinician. Ask the clinician to provide an addendum wherein the clinician provides the significance, if any, of the absence of documented treatment records on the issue of whether OSA had onset in active service. Further, inform the clinician that the Veteran’s lay reported symptoms of years of breathing difficulty while asleep and snoring must be considered. Hence, is it at least as likely as not (at least a 50 percent probability) that the Veteran’s reported symptoms indicated the onset of OSA? If so, then the approximate timeframe of the onset of the symptoms must be determined. If the answer to the above question is, No, ask the clinician to further address the impact, if any, of the Veteran’s obesity as follows: (a) Whether it is at least as likely as not that the service-connected spine and associated neurological disabilities, to include any medications prescribed as treatment, caused the Veteran to become obese/gain weight?; (b) If so, whether the obesity/weight gain as a result of the service-connected disabilities was a substantial factor in causing OSA?; and, (c) Whether it is at least as likely as not that OSA would not have occurred but for the obesity/weight gain caused by the service-connected disabilities? If the answer to (c) is, No, then is it at least as likely as not that obesity worsens the OSA? Advise the clinician that any worsening need not be permanent; instead, an impairment in earning capacity due to temporary flare-ups of OSA caused by a service-connected disability is sufficient. See Ward v. Wilkie, 31 Vet. App. 233 (2019). If so, in terms of a percentage, please provide a baseline of aggravation. If the clinician responds in the negative to all questions related to the Veteran’s obesity, then is it at least as likely as not that the service-connected spine and associated neurological disabilities worsen the OSA by any incremental amount, whether temporary or permanent, as long as it is considered not attributable to the natural progress of the disorder? If so, in terms of a percentage, please provide a baseline of aggravation. The clinician must provide a full explanation for all opinions provided. If the AOJ uses a clinician other than the one who provided the September 2019 opinion, and the substitute clinician advises that an examination is necessary to provide the requested opinions, then the AOJ shall arrange the examination. Eric S. Leboff Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board W. T. Snyder The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.