Citation Nr: 20045409 Decision Date: 07/08/20 Archive Date: 07/08/20 DOCKET NO. 15-36 312 DATE: July 8, 2020 ORDER Service connection for obstructive sleep apnea is denied. FINDING OF FACT The weight of the evidence fails to show that it is at least as likely as not that the Veteran’s obstructive sleep apnea was incurred in or due to service, or otherwise proximately caused or aggravated by his service-connected PTSD. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea have not been met. 38 U.S.C. § 1110; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.303, 3.310. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran honorably served on active duty from June 2001 to September 2004. In a July 2014 rating decision, the Regional Office (RO) denied his claim for service connection for an obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). The Veteran appealed. In August 2018, the Board remanded the claim for a supplemental medical opinion. In a May 2020 Supplemental Statement of the Case, the RO has affirmed its prior denial and then returned the appeal to the Board. In seeking service connection, the Veteran maintains that his OSA is secondary to his PTSD, as reflected in his May 2013 initial claim. As reflected in his July 2014 Notice of Disagreement, the Veteran states that his OSA is aggravating his PTSD symptoms due to a lack of sleep from his condition and thus service connection should be granted for a condition that is aggravating a service-connected condition. As reflected in his August 2014 correspondence, the Veteran reiterates that he should be granted service connection for sleep apnea. In his opinion, it does not matter that his OSA is not related to military service. Sleep apnea aggravates and exacerbates the symptoms of his PTSD and PTSD is doing the same to his apnea. As he knows a lot of veterans who have been granted service connection for sleep apnea, he further believes that denying him this benefit is not fair to him. As reflected in his substantive appeal (VA Form 9 received in October 2015), the Veteran states that his sleep disturbance from his PTSD causing his insomnia also severely affect his sleep apnea, as these conditions are indeed interconnected. Upon reviewing the Veteran’s contentions and all evidence of record viewed in light of pertinent laws, the Board has found that service connection for OSA must be denied in this case for the following reasons. Of preliminary note, the Board has no authority to grant service connection on an equitable basis and is bound by laws as passed by Congress, implemented by VA, and controlled by case law. The law does mandate the Board to ensure that all its decisions are fair and just. To that end, every individual case is decided based on the application of law to the factual circumstances specific to each veteran. By implication, any two given claims for service connection for OSA brought forth by two different veterans might result in a grant of the sought benefit in one case and in a denial of the same benefit in another case. The Board in reviewing a claim specifically analyzes the medical and lay evidence brought to bear in that individual case. While decisions made in other Board decisions may be considered, the Board decisions themselves are not precedential as each decision is based on the specific opinions and evidence relevant to the Veteran whose claim is being decided. In this case, the record is devoid of any suggestion that the Veteran has specialized knowledge, training, or experience in medicine, pathophysiology, epidemiology, or similar fields. As such, the Veteran is said not to possess the requisite expertise to render medical opinions. See Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008). This is especially true in his case involving the medically complex respiratory and psychiatric disabilities. Id. This is among the reasons why the Board has remanded his claim for a supplemental medical opinion which, however, turned out negative in his case and tipped the scales against a favorable disposition of this claim based on this Veteran’s particular circumstances, as explained in greater detail below. Generally, service connection shall be granted for a disability incurred in service. 38 U.S.C. § 1110. Within the meaning of section 1110, “service connection” is a term of art that connotes many factors, but essentially means that a particular injury or disease had originated in service and had caused a post-service disability, that is, a present disability as shown by the evidence to had been incurred in or coincident to service. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.303(a). This further means that “service connection” is legally complex and may not be automatically granted for every disability, even if such a disability is conceivably interconnected with service or a service-connected disability. Rather, an entitlement to service connection must be established by the evidence of record meeting very specific legal criteria. An entitlement to service connection for OSA may be established either on a so-called direct or secondary basis. Establishing an entitlement to service connection on a direct basis generally is subject to the three fundamental legal requirements that must be met with the requisite evidentiary standard of 50-percent or greater probability showing: (1) the existence of the claimed disability; (2) the relevant traumatic event in service, such as injury or disease, and (3) a causal link between the claimed disability and the etiologically relevant traumatic event in service. See Shedden v. Principi, 381 F.3d 1163 (Fed. Cir. 2004). Establishing an entitlement to service connection on a secondary basis requires the evidence to show that a service-connected disability either proximately caused or aggravated (made worse) the claimed disability. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. Of note, the direct and proximate causation as well as aggravation are unidirectional. That is, the evidence of record must show that the Veteran’s service directly caused, or his PTSD proximately caused or aggravated his OSA rather than showing that his OSA exacerbated his PTSD symptoms. The Board is not aware of any law that allows a grant of service connection for a disability based on an aggravation of rather than by a service-connected disability. In other words, to qualify for service connection on a secondary basis, it must be shown that the OSA results from the psychiatric symptomatology, not the other way around. Here, the existence of the claimed OSA is not in dispute. The conclusive diagnosis has been confirmed by the 2009 and 2013 sleep study reports, as well as the April 2014 and October 2019 VA examination reports. Likewise, the Veteran’s PTSD is service connected. What has been unclear is whether the Veteran had incurred his OSA in service or sustained any in-service trauma that might have caused his OSA, or whether his PTSD caused or aggravated his OSA. This much has been suggested by the evidence of record, as noted by the Board in its August 2018 remand order. However, a “suggestion” is not the legal standard for establishing an entitlement to service connection. Rather, every legal criterion must be met with the requisite evidentiary standard of 50-percent probability or greater. Moreover, the Veteran has been found to not possess the requisite expertise in rendering medical opinions, while the Board must meaningfully understand the nature and etiologies of his disabilities as well as the pathophysiological mechanisms between them. For these reasons, the Board may not simply defer to the Veteran’s beliefs and must rely on a medical expert’s opinion which turned out negative in this case. An October 2019 VA examination report reflects a medical opinion that it is less likely as not (meaning a probability of less than 50 percent) that the Veteran’s OSA had been incurred in or due to service, or proximately caused or aggravated by his PTSD and/or depression. At the outset, the examiner notes that the Veteran’s service treatment records (STRs) are silent for the diagnosis or treatment of OSA. The examiner explains that the STRs reflect a June 2004 note of “symptom report: sleep within normal limits” and “significant improvement over the past week with no initial, middle, or terminal insomnia; denied troublesome dreams.” A July 2004 summary report notes that “he is now sleeping well.” The following week, for the MEB (Medical Evaluation Board) examination, the Veteran checked “yes” to frequent trouble sleeping along with his explanation that “sometimes I can’t sleep,” which the examining military physician remarked as “occasional insomnia.” The STRs also indicate that the Veteran’s reported sleep problems have actually improved with insomnia medications. The MEB examination is further silent for sleep apnea or suspicion of sleep apnea. This is consistent with the Veteran’s statements, as noted by the examiner, reporting an onset of sleep trouble exacerbation in 2005. Based on this evidence, the VA examiner concludes that there is no objective evidence of sleep apnea during service or within close proximity to service. The examiner then discusses medical literature showing that, while both insomnia and sleep apnea are related to sleep, the two conditions are distinctly different and stem from the discrete pathologies. Insomnia is a condition broadly defined as a difficulty falling and/or staying asleep and does not cause the pathophysiology associated with sleep apnea. Sleep apnea is a physical respiratory disorder where breathing in the upper airways gets interrupted during sleep, which neither PTSD nor depression symptoms are known to cause or aggravate. Sleep apnea has a clear and specific pathophysiology of upper airway obstruction predominantly found in overweight individuals. Here, the examiner particularly notes that the Veteran’s OSA was diagnosed in 2009, he separated from service in 2004, and in the intervening years had onset of obesity diagnosed in 2007. Given this significant intervening cause coupled with all STRs that are silent as to any complaints, treatments, and diagnosis that may be associated with OSA, while the Veteran’s insomnia is a discrete condition with a distinct pathology, the examiner opines that current OSA could not have been directly incurred in or due to service. Upon further considering the Veteran’s contentions of proximate causation or aggravation, the examiner notes that there is no clinical research that supports the conclusion that PTSD or depression is the cause of sleep apnea. Although a possible association has been hypothesized, the current published medical studies have not found a direct causal link between the development of OSA and PTSD or depression. For example, in a widely published 2008 review of PTSD and sleep, a causal link between the emotional response in PTSD patients and sleep-stage disturbances has been hypothesized and explored by highlighting the potentially key roles of the amygdala and medial prefrontal cortex in sleep cycles. However, the investigators have only concluded that further research is needed to fully understand and define this still unexplored relationship. With that, the examiner emphasizes that the articles discussing the “associations” between psychiatric and physical disabilities must be interpreted with caution because even statistically significant “associations” do not prove the causal nature of the examined relationships and may simply represent a spurious relationship that is merely coincidental, where the two medical conditions may stem from multiple independent causes, even if resulting in the overlapping symptomatology. The symptoms of PTSD/depression and OSA are overlapping such as chronic trouble sleeping. The PTSD patients may exhibit chronic trouble sleeping due to hyperarousal symptoms of anxiety, hypervigilance, as well as disruption due to nightmares. These effects of PTSD symptoms might be aggravated by additional sleep disturbances superimposed by OSA but are clearly distinct from the OSA pathophysiological mechanism in OSA patients and do not cause any respiratory obstruction in the upper airways. At this point, the examiner notes, there are no medical studies establishing a conclusive direct causation between PTSD and OSA and thus the causal diagnoses cannot be rendered at this time. Absent a direct causation from PTSD to OSA, the examiner further opines that aggravation is also unlikely, particularly in light of several studies supporting a conclusion that there is no clear-cut evidence to support a finding that OSA is aggravated by PTSD and/or depression. The Veteran has neither challenged the adequacy of the examination report or the opinions expressed therein, nor has provided any competent evidence that might have placed into doubt the expertise and impartiality of the examiner. In reviewing medical opinions, the Board considers such factors as the accuracy and completeness of the facts upon which an opinion is formed, any supporting scientific data and the general acceptance of the cited authorities, the depth and thoroughness of the analysis, the soundness of the rationale connecting data to the conclusions, as well as the veracity and scope of the rendered conclusions. See Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008); Hernandez-Toyens v. West, 11 Vet. App. 379 (1998). Upon reviewing the October 2019 report, the Board has found that the examiner had the benefit of the most comprehensive review of the Veteran claims file and conducted a full-scope medical review, to include a study of the Veteran’s service and post-service medical history, in-person examination, and review of pertinent medical literature. As such, the Board found no apparent procedural deficiencies or flaws in the examiner’s rationale answering the Board’s ultimate questions in this appeal. It is less likely as not (meaning a probability of less than 50 percent) that the Veteran’s OSA had been incurred in or due to service, or proximately caused or aggravated by his PTSD and/or depression. This does not mean that the Veteran’s notion that PTSD and OSA can be interconnected is wrong. For example, an April 2014 VA report reflects that OSA is known to aggravate the PTSD and depression symptoms. Also, in October 2019, the VA examiner notes that both conditions do affect sleep. As such, the symptoms are overlapping and do result in sleep disturbance symptoms that the Veteran might indiscriminately perceive as interchangeably aggravating. From the legal perspective, however, establishing an entitlement to service connection for OSA requires the evidence to show that the Veteran’s psychiatric symptoms caused or aggravated any physical obstruction in his upper airways, which from a medical perspective is the key pathophysiological feature of the OSA. This requisite causal link is unidirectional and may not be assumed to exist based on the fact of an existing inverse causal link, that is, his OSA aggravating PTSD and/or depression rather than the other way around, or that both PTSD and OSA symptoms ultimately cause his sleep disturbances. Of note here, the Veteran’s chronic sleep impairment is expressly covered by the schedule for rating psychiatric disorders and among the reasons why his PTSD and depression have been rated at total for the entire rating period on appeal, whereas allocating his sleep disturbances between his service-connected PTSD and non-service-connected OSA might be impractical. However, the Veteran is already in receipt of the maximum schedular rating permissible by law for the entire rating period on appeal and thus a higher rating for PTSD may not be assigned. Nor a separate rating for his sleep impairment may be assigned because the law unequivocally prohibits compensating the same impairment twice, even if such an impairment stems from two discrete pathologies. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.14. This, however, does not preclude a separate grant of service connection for OSA. The law is rather unequivocal in that service connection will be granted for a disability proximately caused or aggravated by a service-connected disability. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. However, the fundamental legal requirement for the evidence to show with a 50-percent probability or greater that the Veteran’s OSA resulted from his service or his PTSD and/or depression has not been met. Upon considering the Veteran’s beliefs that his OSA is secondary to his PTSD against the medical opinion to the contrary, that is, it is less likely as not the Veteran’s OSA had been incurred in or due to service, or proximately caused or aggravated by his PTSD, the Board has found the medical evidence to be the most probative in this case. Accordingly, as the legal criteria for the sought benefit have not been met, service connection for obstructive sleep apnea must be denied and thus is denied. MATTHEW W. BLACKWELDER Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board Alex Bardin, Associate Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.