Citation Nr: 20050643 Decision Date: 07/30/20 Archive Date: 07/30/20 DOCKET NO. 17-42 812 DATE: July 30, 2020 ORDER Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), as secondary to and/or aggravated by any service-connected disorder, is denied. FINDING OF FACT The objective medical evidence shows OSA is not caused by an event, injury, or illness during active service, nor is it proximately due to, the result of or made worse beyond its natural progression by any service-connected disability. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for service connection for OSA, to include as secondary to and/or aggravated by any service-connected disability, have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 5103, 5103A, 5107 (2012); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.159, 3.303, 3.310 (2019). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran had active service in the United States Navy from September 1968 to June 1972. In May 2020, the Veteran testified at a virtual Board hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge. A transcript of the hearing is of record. Service Connection Service connection will be granted if the evidence demonstrates that a current disability resulted from a disease or injury incurred in active service or that a preexisting injury or disease was aggravated by active service. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 1131 (2012); 38 C.F.R. § 3.303 (a) (2019). Establishing service connection generally requires: (1) the existence of a present disability; (2) in-service incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury; and (3) a causal relationship between the present disability and the disease or injury incurred in or aggravated during service. Shedden v. Principi, 381 F.3d 1163, 1166-67 (Fed. Cir. 2004). Additionally, service connection may be granted on a secondary basis for a disability which is proximately due to, the result of or made worse beyond its natural progression by a service-connected disease or injury. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. Moreover, service connection of a nonservice–connected disease or injury will be established if an increase in severity of the nonservice–connected disability is shown to be proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disease or injury and not due to the natural progress of the nonservice–connected disease or injury. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310 (b). The evidence must show (1) a current disability exists and (2) the current disability was the (a) proximately caused by or (b) proximately aggravated (worsened in severity beyond its natural progress) by a service-connected disability. Id.; Allen v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 439, 448-49 (1995). Service connection is in effect for chronic kidney disease, with mild renal insufficiency and hypertension, secondary to diabetes, rated 60 percent disabling; posttraumatic stress disorder, rated 50 percent disabling; and diabetes, rated 20 percent disabling. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), as secondary to and/or aggravated by any service-connected disorder. The service treatment records (STRs) show that, in the March and June 1972 parts of the separation examination, body-system and body-segment categories of mouth and throat, sinuses, nose, lungs and chest, and vascular were found to be normal. Additionally, the Veteran denied past or current frequent trouble sleeping, ear, nose and throat trouble, sinusitis, asthma, shortness of breath, pain or pressure in the chest, chronic cough, or recent weight-gain, or any other disorder which could conceivably be associated with the symptomatology of OSA. Private medical records on file reveal that the Veteran was found to have diabetes in March 2001. History at that time was that he had been obese for a long time. He was found to be 6 foot 1 inch tall and weighed 266 pounds. The post-service record shows an April 2013 VA physician’s note, in which the treatment provider discussed sequelae of sleep apnea, including “increased risk of cardiovascular problems such as high blood pressure, heart attack, abnormal heart rhythms, or stroke.” The Veteran agreed to schedule a sleep test. Between May 2014 and June 2015, VA treatment notes show, although instructed on the need for a sleep study, the Veteran repeatedly declined. In December 2015, the Veteran canceled his sleep study appointment. In this period, the Veteran was given a provisional diagnosis at VA of “R/O [rule out] sleep apnea.” In January 2016, the Veteran underwent a sleep study, which diagnosed him with severe OSA. By March 2016, his diagnosis was OSA and a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machine was recommended. An April 2016 VA examination for sleep apnea states a January 2016 diagnosis of OSA. The April 2016 VA examiner opined that the Veteran’s OSA is less likely than not (less than 50 percent probability) proximately due to or the result of the Veteran’s service-connected PTSD. She explained: Rationale: Typically, sleep apnea is a disorder of interrupted breathing during sleep due to mechanical type of obstruction secondary to obesity, environmental factors, closure of the epiglottis affecting the respiratory symptom, pathology of the mucosa or cyl[]ia. Sleep apnea occurs during the deepest stage of sleep - nightmares associated with PTSD occur after the deepest stage of sleep is reached, which is not likely to be reached or occur due to presence of sleep apnea. Sleep apnea and PTSD can certainly co-exist but one is not a cause of the other. A study done in 2011: “Our results indicate that PTSD is not necessarily associated with a higher prevalence of OSA. However, PTSD severity was related to OSA, which may possibly mean that comorbid OSA leads to an increase in PTSD complaints. However, future research should indicate whether OSA exerts a negative influence on PTSD, and treatment of OSA alleviates PTSD symptoms.” Eur J Psychotraumatol. [European Journal of Psychotraumatology] 2011; 2: 10.3402[.] Therefore, it is the opinion of this examiner that the veteran’s obstructive sleep apnea is not caused by or aggravated by his PTSD, in fact it appears that the inverse is the case, the veteran’s non-service connected OSA can be an aggravant to his PTSD if not well controlled with CPAP. The April 2016 VA examiner further opined that OSA is less likely than not (less than 50 percent probability) proximately due to or the result of the Veteran’s service-connected diabetes mellitus, type II. She explained: Rationale: The veteran has physiological risk factors for the development of diabetes. This include obesity and large neck circumference. In reviewing a study from 2012-Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Type 2 Diabetes: Is There a Link? Published in Frontiers in Neurology, the study supports a link between the two conditions but not what the veteran is claiming. “...the current evidence from cross-sectional analyses suggest that type 2 diabetes is more prevalent among patients with OSA compared to those without OSA, independent of shared risk factors. However, it is still unclear whether OSA may lead to the development of diabetes over time. More data from large-scale longitudinal studies with rigorous assessments of diabetes and OSA are needed.” In this case, the veteran’s diabetes preceded his diagnosis of OSA. “Overall, there is evidence to suggest that the presence and severity of untreated OSA may be associated with poor glucose control in type 2 diabetic patients. These findings may have important clinical implications in the management and care of type 2 diabetes as they support the hypothesis that reducing the severity of OSA may be an adjunct therapeutic strategy to optimize glucose control.” The study support[s] that uncontrolled OSA is an aggravant to the veteran’s diabetes. It is less likely as not that the veteran’s sleep apnea is secondary to his service connected diabetes mellitus. This premise is not supported by medical literature. A November 2016 nexus opinion letter by the Veteran’s private treatment provider, Dr. D.F.T., states the Veteran did not begin to experience sleep problems, to include stopped-breathing apneas, until many years after first being diagnosed with diabetes mellitus, type II. Dr. D.F.T. noted that there is much medical literature associating both diabetes mellitus, type II and hypertension with OSA. He stated: “From my professional career, training and medical literature, I have concluded that it is more likely than not, given the normal epidemiology of DM2, that [the Veteran] has OSA secondary to his service-connected DM2 which had been service-connected since 2001.” The Veteran’s November 2016 Notice of Disagreement (NOD) states that the nexus opinion letter of Dr. D.F.T. and five Internet articles the Veteran submitted with the NOD on the relationship of OSA and diabetes mellitus, type II, bring the evidence into relevant equipoise, thereby rendering to the Veteran the benefit of all reasonable doubt in his favor on the claim. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.102. Two of the articles are undated, with the other three dated February 2008, August 2010 and June 2013. Dr. D.F.T.’s opinion and the articles are discussed more thoroughly in the July 2017 VA opinion which follows and by the Board farther below. In a July 2017 VA opinion, to the question is it at least as likely as not (50 percent or greater probability) that OSA is proximately due to or the result of the Veteran’s service connected Diabetes mellitus type 2, Kidney disease, and/or hypertension, the VA examiner opined OSA is less likely than not (less than 50 percent probability) proximately due to or the result of the Veteran’s service-connected condition. She explained: Rationale: An opinion regarding the veteran’s sleep apnea being due to his service connected diabetes was provided with exam done 4/7/2016. The lay statement by an individual that apparently has known him for many years and sleeps with him has been reviewed and taken into context of the requested opinion. A letter written by [Dr. D.F.T.], an[] ENT [ear, nose and throat] specialist has been reviewed and taken into consideration as well. The specialist has provided no rationale for his opinion supported by medical literature or research. He defers to articles submitted by the veteran. Notably missing in this letter is the veterans physiological risk factors for developing obstructive sleep apnea. Veteran is morbidly obese and has a large neck circumference, major risk factors for developing OSA. The veteran has provide[d] internet articles to attempt to support his claim. OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP APNEA AND TYPE 2 DIABETES: IS THERE A LINK? This article actually proposes that “OSA may lead to the development of diabetes over time.” It proposes that people with Type 2 diabetes suffer from unrecognized OSA and that severity of OSA is associated with worsening glucose control. A major risk factor for both these conditions is the veteran’s morbid obesity. This is the same article I reviewed for my previous opinion that supported that OSA is a strong risk factor of developing diabetes Type 2 and that individuals with Type 2 diabetes may have unrecognized OSA. There is no article found that supports a causative factor supporting that Type 2 diabetes causes or has OSA as a residual of the condition. The veteran also submitted a VA appeal from a decision in 2010 with the issue being “Entitlement to obstructive sleep apnea claimed as secondary to service-connected diabetes mellitus, type II” The final ruling of this article [sic] from 7 years ago is that the veteran’s sleep apnea was aggravated by his diabetes mellitus thus giving service connection for sleep apnea. This is not supported in the articles reviewed. The adverse [sic] is supported in that sleep apnea is an aggravant of diabetes mellitus and particularly in uncontrolled diabetes, obstructive sleep apnea should be a consideration and testing should take place. There is substantial medical literature supporting that diabetes and sleep apnea often coexist and one or the other should be considered a diagnosis in the presence of either. It remains to be supported by medical literature that sleep apnea is caused primarily by physiological factors that are present in this veteran and he would have likely developed sleep apnea whether or not his had diabetes mellitus. Discussion The Board has considered the Veteran’s May 2020 Board hearing testimony, in which he states was informed by a “private doctor” that his service-connected disabilities made OSA worse. Looking first to November 2016 nexus opinion letter, set forth above, in which Dr. D.F.T., after noting there is medical literature associating both diabetes mellitus, type II and hypertension with OSA, stated, “From my professional career, training and medical literature, I have concluded that it is more likely than not, given the normal epidemiology of DM2, that [the Veteran] has OSA secondary to his service-connected DM2 which had been service-connected since 2001.” As first noted by the April 2016 VA examiner, the medical consensus is that OSA develops primarily as a result of obesity or sometimes due to the shape of the cranium. In her subsequent July 2017 VA opinion, she directly states the Veteran is morbidly obese, therefore having an enlarged neck circumference. In regard to Dr. D.F.T.’s opinion, she adds, “The specialist has provided no rationale for his opinion supported by medical literature or research. He defers to articles submitted by the veteran. Notably missing in this letter is the veterans physiological risk factors for developing obstructive sleep apnea.” The Board agrees. There is nothing in Dr. D.F.T.’s opinion which informs the Board on what medical evidence of record or by what clinical reasoning he reached his conclusion. As it is, the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has determined that a medical opinion need not be accepted by the Board if it materially relies on a lay person’s otherwise uncorroborated history as the premise for that opinion. See Wood v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 190, 192 (1991) Therefore, as Dr. D.F.T.’s opinion is based on the Veteran’s unsupported history and not substantiated by the evidence of record, the Board finds there is no probative value in it. The Board does not have the medical expertise with which it can accept this conclusory opinion simply as self-evident; it needs to be informed why. Here the Board notes that the contention that the Veteran gained weight secondary to the diabetes, causing the OSA is not supported by the record. Significantly, the Veteran was noted to have been obese for a long time when the diabetes was found in 2001. As stated above, the Veteran contends that the five Internet articles he submitted are probative of his claim. The “articles” are in fact abstracts or digests of larger, published articles or of study reports. The first article, summarized in the July 2017 opinion, above, is, “Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Type 2 Diabetes: Is There a Link?” The article asserts that evidence shows “OSA is associated with insulin resistance, glucose intolerance and type 2 diabetes, independent of obesity.” It further states research shows “how OSA may alter glucose metabolism.” Indeed, the April 2016 VA examiner quoted directly from the full and published version of the article itself, which states the clinical findings during research “support the hypothesis that reducing the severity of OSA may be an adjunct therapeutic strategy to optimize glucose control.” From her review of the article, she concluded, “The study support[s] that uncontrolled OSA is an aggravant to the veteran’s diabetes.” However, this is not the basis of an argument which supports the Veteran’s claim, as the “link” between the disorders appears to be the effects of OSA upon diabetes mellitus, type II, not the other way around. The second article has the heading, “Patients with Type 2 Diabetes or Hypertension Must Be Evaluated for Sleep Apnea.” The article first asserts that patients with diabetes mellitus, type II, and hypertension are at much higher risk for OSA. It adds that “[t]reating sleep apnea in diabetics improves glucose levels and insulin sensitivity,” CPAP use for OSA “may have as much of an effect as prescribed oral diabetes medications” and studies have shown “one week of optimal CPAP use lowered the average 24-hour average glucose level and induced better post-breakfast glucose response in Type 2 diabetics.” Once again, contrary to what the Veteran is contending, these statements, in effect, assert that the impact of OSA on diabetes will be lessened with CPAP use. The third article is, “Sleep Apnoea and Type 2 Diabetes.” It states “[r]ecent research demonstrates the likelihood of a relationship between type 2 diabetes and OSA, the most common form of sleep disordered breathing, and adds that the International Diabetes Federation (IDF) wants to raise awareness of this association between the two disorders. It sets forth certain facts, to include that estimates suggest 40 percent of people with OSA will have diabetes; in people with diabetes, the prevalence of OSA may be up to 23 percent and up to 58 percent for some sort of sleep disordered breathing; overweight and obesity may play a role, but some recent studies show an association between the two conditions that is independent of overweight/obesity; and OSA may have effects on glycemic control in people with type 2 diabetes. It concludes by stating the “IDF calls on health decision makers to encourage further research into the links between the two conditions.” From the foregoing, the “facts” of this article do not appear to be clinically conclusive. There are no findings of cause and effect, but only an association between the disorders; the percentage stated for diabetes and some form of disordered breathing is not in fact clinical data, but “may be” as high as 58 percent, that is to say, it is conjectural; and that OSA affects glycemic control appears once again to be contrary to the Veteran’s assertion that it is diabetes which “affects” OSA. The Board simply does not have the clinical expertise to draw medical conclusions based on interpretation, probability and prognostication in this field of medicine and research. However, as a factual and therefore legal matter, the Board cannot otherwise discern anything determinative from the above. The fourth article is “Diabetes and Sleep Problems: Understanding Diabetes and Sleep Apnea.” It states having diabetes produces a higher risk of sleep apnea and other sleep difficulties. The Board has reviewed this article several times, but cannot find an explanation of this premise and, similar to a VA opinion without a rationale, this article is not persuasive for Board adjudication purposes. The fifth article is “Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Type 2 Diabetes: Interacting Epidemics.” It states data “suggest” that OSA is independently associated with alterations in glucose metabolism and places patients at an increased risk of the development of type 2 diabetes.” It further states studies have demonstrated that intermittent hypoxia [a deficiency in the amount of oxygen reaching the tissues] and reduced sleep duration due to OSA “exert adverse [e]ffects on glucose metabolism.” The article concludes there is need for “further research, using well-designed studies and long-term follow-up, to fully demonstrate a causal role for OSA in the development and severity of type 2 diabetes.” From its review of these articles, the Board concludes overall there is no evidentiary basis of service connection otherwise than grounded merely in a relationship, association, interplay, correlation, “link,” and so forth to a service-connected disorder. This is markedly less than a relationship of “proximately due to, “the result of a service-connected disease or injury” and “not due to the natural progress of the nonservice-connected disease,” as set forth in regulatory language. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.310 (a)(b) (2019). Additionally, the above abstracts of clinical studies conclude more than once that further investigations or research are required to identify more precisely how the disorders are related. This simply suggests the studies’ findings are not conclusive, certainly not determinative, regarding the issue of a correlation of PTSD to OSA. For these reasons, the Board does not recognize this as evidence from medical literature sufficient to establish service connection for OSA based on aggravation by a service-connected disorder and finds them to be of limited probative weight. The Board has closely examined the Veteran’s principal argument for aggravation, put forth in the May 2020 Board hearing. The Veteran testified to an experience of being hooded during an in-service prisoner-of-war exercise. “The idea was you were to break. I didn’t break, but from then on the hood on my face was traumatic.” The Veteran further testified, “And when the sleep apnea started to kick in after my diagnosis with diabetes, my hypertension, and everything else that goes with it. I told the VA when I tested, I said just I can’t do it. And they put a mask on me, and I went for the test.” Upon rescheduling, “I was issued the mask, and I told them, I said I just can’t do it. It’s too traumatic for me.” The Veteran presented the argument at the beginning of the hearing that service connection for OSA, based on secondary causation and/or aggravation is based on how the Veteran’s service-connected PTSD affects his ability to treat his OSA. The Board understands this to mean that the resulting anxiety and panic, when presumably using the CPAP mask, prevents the Veteran from properly treating OSA, thereby aggravating it. Yet, near the end of his testimony, the Veteran vividly recounts how he is not able to cope with the CPAP mask, because it triggers memories of in-service PTSD stressors. This is the reverse of the above argument stated at the beginning of the hearing, to the effect that it now appears that non-service-connected OSA aggravates service-connected PTSD. In looking again to the words of the regulation, if the Veteran asserts the severity of OSA is proximately due to, a result of or made worse beyond its natural progression by PTSD, this alignment of the effects of PTSD on OSA is not persuasive, as the Veteran’s own testimony at certain points in the hearing states he does not use the CPAP mask specifically because it induces PTSD symptoms of anxiety and panic. Once again, it appears first that CPAP use for OSA will “aggravate” PTSD, with the result that, only after that, OSA can now be declared to have been increased in severity by service-connected PTSD, as a preferred second result. Moreover, at other points in the hearing, the Veteran testified that in attempts to use the CPAP mask it appeared to be defective, as he “tried it several times, and it didn’t work. It just didn’t work. I even tried sitting on my sofa, sitting up in the in the corner with it on, trying to sleep that way.” The issue of aggravation was addressed by the April 2016 VA examiner in the rationale of her first opinion, in which she quoted from a study in the European Journal of Psychotraumatology: “Our results indicate that PTSD is not necessarily associated with a higher prevalence of OSA. However, PTSD severity was related to OSA, which may possibly mean that comorbid OSA leads to an increase in PTSD complaints. However, future research should indicate whether OSA exerts a negative influence on PTSD, and treatment of OSA alleviates PTSD symptoms.” The April 2016 VA examiner concluded that, “t]herefore, it is the opinion of this examiner that the veteran’s obstructive sleep apnea is not caused by or aggravated by his PTSD, in fact it appears that the inverse is the case, the veteran’s non-service connected OSA can be an aggravant to his PTSD if not well controlled with CPAP (emphasis added).” This opinion is of high probative value, as, in effect, it confirms the Veteran’s testimony---he does not use the CPAP for fear of inducing PTSD symptoms, with the result of not controlling OSA well enough. Therefore, it further exacerbates PTSD. There is otherwise in the record no mechanism identified or pathophysiology explained for PTSD being an underlying etiology for OSA. The April 2016 VA examiner in turn addressed the issue of secondary causation, stating, “Sleep apnea occurs during the deepest stage of sleep - nightmares associated with PTSD occur after the deepest stage of sleep is reached, which is not likely to be reached or occur due to presence of sleep apnea. Sleep apnea and PTSD can certainly co-exist but one is not a cause of the other.” Therefore, as the Court has also noted that the probative value of a medical opinion primarily is based on the fully articulated and sound reasoning of its conclusion, the Board finds the April 2018 VA examiner, by a reasoned analysis, has determined the etiology of OSA as being the result of obesity and its symptomatology. See Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295, 304 (2008). As such, it follows from the April 2016 VA examiner’s opinion there is no clinical basis for consideration of the disorder as being secondary to or otherwise caused by service-connected PTSD, diabetes mellitus, type II, and kidney disease, and, as a legal determination, the Board concludes further analysis along those lines would be futile. In short, as to both secondary causation and aggravation, the Veteran’s testimony is not evidence sufficiently competent to establish OSA as proximately due to, a result of or made worse beyond its natural progression by service-connected PTSD. The Veteran did not and does not now use a CPAP mask, either because it does not work or because it induces anxiety, fear and panic, based on his own testimony. Moreover, the Board, in its role as finder of fact for adjudication purposes, has reviewed all available medical evidence regarding the severity of OSA since onset and there are no clinical findings to the effect that OSA has been made worse beyond its natural progression. Factually, it remains that the Veteran does not use the CPAP mask for either or both of his stated reasons, that is to say, in either version of his narrative, the issue of aggravation at its inception shows the Veteran not using his mask for fear of touching off PTSD symptoms or because the Veteran perceives the machine as deficient in operating. Consequently, as this evidence is the reverse of what is necessary to substantiate the claim in this case, the Board finds that it does not have any probative value related to service connection based on aggravation. For these reasons and based on the objective medical evidence, the Board finds the preponderance of the evidence does not support service connection on any basis for this claim. The Board has considered the benefit-of-the-doubt doctrine; however, the Board does not perceive an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence. As the preponderance of the evidence is against the claim, the doctrine is not applicable and the claim must be denied. 38 U.S.C. § 5107 (b); 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. MICHAEL D. LYON Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board P. Franke, Associate Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.