Citation Nr: 20052767 Decision Date: 08/10/20 Archive Date: 08/10/20 DOCKET NO. 14-15 409 DATE: August 10, 2020 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty from December 1994 to December 1995. This matter comes to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) on appeal from a June 2012 rating decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). In July 2018, the Board remanded the case for further development, to include obtaining an addendum opinion as to the etiology of the Veteran’s sleep apnea. Entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded. A remand by the Board imposes upon the Secretary of VA a concomitant duty to ensure compliance with the terms of the remand. Where remand orders of the Board are not complied with, the Board errs in failing to ensure compliance. Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268 (1998). The Board’s July 2018 remand requested a medical opinion on secondary service connection; whether the Veteran’s sleep apnea is at least as likely as not (1) proximately due to his service connected PTSD, or (2) aggravated by his service connected PTSD, to include consideration of the treatise submitted by the Veteran entitled “Risk of Sleep Apnea Increases with PTSD Severity,” set forth in the June 2018 appellate brief. The July 2019 VA examiner opined it was less likely as not that the Veteran’s obstructive sleep apnea was caused or aggravated by his PTSD. She acknowledged that there is an association between obstructive sleep apnea and PTSD, and there is evidence that obstructive sleep apnea can unmask or aggravate PTSD per the study cited by the Veteran. However, she concluded there is no evidence that PTSD causes or aggravates obstructive sleep apnea. Although the July 2019 VA medical opinion was obtained, this medical opinion is inadequate as it did not fully answer the Board’s questions. First, the opinion does not clearly address aggravation. The opinion does not clearly address whether the Veteran’s sleep apnea has been aggravated beyond its natural progression by PTSD with a rationale supporting a conclusion. El Amin v. Shinseki, 26 Vet. App. 136 (2013). Second, the opinion does not include separate findings and rationales for causation and aggravation, which are independent concepts. Atencio v. O’Rourke, 30 Vet. App. 74, 90 (2018). An adequate medical opinion regarding secondary service connection must address causation and aggravation separately. See El Amin, 26 Vet. App. 136, 140 (2013) (indicating that findings of “not due to,” “not caused by,” and “not related to” a service-connected disability are insufficient to address the question of aggravation under § 3.310(b)). The examiner did not provide an adequate rationale for her opinion as “it is unclear how and why the same rationale was applied to both the causation and aggravation elements of secondary service connection.” Atencio, 30 Vet. App. 74, 90 (2018). Third, the opinion did not discuss facts specific to the Veteran; while it mentioned risk factors for obstructive sleep apnea, the examiner did not discuss the Veteran’s specific risk factors. Rather, the negative opinion was predicated on general studies without addressing any facts specific to this Veteran. See Bailey v. O’Rourke, 30 Vet. App. 54, 60 (2018) (in cases involving herbicide exposure and cancer, examiner’s rationale may not be based solely on general medical articles); Polovick v. Shinseki, 23 Vet. App. 48, 54 (2009) (although general medical research may be considered, it cannot be the sole basis for examiner’s conclusion). The VA medical opinion is inadequate because it is not supported by an analysis the Board may consider and weigh; merely generalizations about the risk factors in the general population, rather than the specifics of the Veteran’s history. See Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 102, 124-25. Finally, the medical opinion fails to contain clear conclusions. The July 2018 VA examiner reviewed the 2015 study on obstructive sleep apnea and OEF/OIF vets and stated it showed increased incidence of obstructive sleep apnea in veterans with PTSD and that increasing severity of PTSD increases the risk of testing positive for obstructive sleep apnea. She concluded there is likely an association between obstructive sleep apnea and PTSD, and there is evidence that obstructive sleep apnea can unmask or aggravate PTSD; however, there is no evidence that PTSD causes or aggravates obstructive sleep apnea. The opinion does not explain the difference between an association versus causation, which are different. A medical opinion must contain clear conclusions with supporting data and a reasoned medical explanation connecting the two. See Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295, 301 (2008). Therefore, remand is required to ensure substantial compliance with the terms of the Board’s July 2018 remand. See Dyment v. West, 13 Vet. App. 141, 146-47 (1999). The matter is REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain an addendum opinion from an appropriate clinician regarding whether the Veteran’s sleep apnea is at least as likely as not (1) proximately due to his service-connected PTSD (causation) or (2) aggravated beyond its natural progression by his service-connected PTSD. (a.) Separate findings and rationales are required to address (i) causation and (ii) aggravation because these are independent concepts. Atencio, supra. (b.) Identify and explain the relevance or significance, as appropriate, of any history, clinical findings, medical knowledge or literature, etc., relied upon in reaching the conclusions. The opinion should reflect review and a discussion of the significance, if any, of the article discussed by the Veteran’s representative in the June 2018 Appellate Brief. (c.) To clarify the record and the prior medical opinion, this opinion should indicate whether it is accurate to say that an association is not the same as causation, and that an association may arise between variables in the presence and absence of a causal relationship. If not, explain. (d.) A negative medical opinion may not be predicated solely on the absence of medical literature supporting a causal relationship without discussing facts specific to this Veteran in the context of that literature (research/studies) and explaining why in this case a causal relationship is not shown as likely as not. Baily, supra. (e.) If aggravation is found, a baseline level of severity prior to the aggravation should be identified. 2. Ensure that the VA medical opinion obtained includes a complete rationale for the conclusions reached. The medical opinion must support the conclusions reached with an analysis that is adequate for the Board to consider and weigh against other evidence of record; medical opinions must contain not only clear conclusions with supporting data, but also a reasoned medical explanation connecting the two. If an opinion cannot be expressed without resort to speculation, ensure that the clinician so indicates and discusses why an opinion is not possible, to include whether there is additional evidence that could enable an opinion to be provided, or whether the inability to provide the opinion is based on the limits of medical knowledge. C.A. SKOW Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board N. Pendleton, Associate Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.