Citation Nr: 20055656 Decision Date: 08/24/20 Archive Date: 08/24/20 DOCKET NO. 16-15 989 DATE: August 24, 2020 REMANDED The issue of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded. The issue of entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service connected disability (TDIU), on the basis of a combination of service-connected disabilities, is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty from November 1988 to December 1998. This case comes to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board) on appeal from multiple rating decisions by a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). With regard to the claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea, the RO determined (including in the May 2018 statement of the case) that this appeal arises from a March 2016 RO rating decision. This is formally correct. However, as discussed in the Board’s prior September 2019 decision, the Board has found that new and material evidence on this issue, presented in written testimony from the Veteran in April 2016 and in June 2016, was submitted within a year of a December 2015 RO rating decision that also denied service connection for sleep apnea. Accordingly, the Board finds that the December 2015 RO rating decision remained pending at the time of the Veteran’s appeal, and the Board finds that the claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea on appeal requires appellate review of the sleep apnea claim addressed by the December 2015 RO rating decision. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(b). The issue of entitlement to a TDIU, on the basis of a combination of service-connected disabilities, is before the Board following the Veteran’s appeal of a February 2017 RO rating decision denying the claim. These matters were previously before the Board in September 2019, when the Board resolved other issues on appeal (including by granting the petition to reopen the claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea, and denying a more limited form of claim for TDIU). The sleep apnea and TDIU issues have now returned to the Board for further appellate review. Prior to certification to the Board, in July 2020 correspondence, the Veteran’s previously-appointed representative withdrew and indicated that the Veteran had been notified of this withdrawal. 1. The issue of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded. The Veteran contends that his sleep apnea has developed secondary to obesity which, in turn, he contends is etiologically linked to his service-connected depressive disorder with anxious distress. The Board observes that obesity is not considered a disease or disability for VA purposes and is not subject to service connection. See Marcelino v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 155, 156 (2018). However, obesity may be an intermediate step between a service-connected disability and a current disability that may be service-connected on a secondary basis. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310; see also Walsh v. Wilkie, 32 Vet. App. 300 (2020). The Veteran has already established entitlement to service connection for depressive disorder with anxious distress (previously characterized as adjustment disorder with mixed depression and anxiety). In a June 2016 statement, the Veteran argued: “During a compensation and pension evaluation... it was concluded that the VA diagnosed Sleep Apnea condition is/was a result of member’s obesity.... [The] belief is: member’s obesity did result from excessive eating and lethargy. This excessive eating and lethargy is/was facilitated (or caused) by member’s service connected mental health disorder/depressive behavior.” The same argument was made in an April 2016 written statement. The Veteran was referring to a December 2015 VA examination report that includes the medical opinion that the Veteran’s “sleep apnea is as likely as not caused by or a result of veteran[’]s obesity/weight gain.” In March 2019, the Veteran’s attorney argued that “VA should address whether the Veteran’s diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea [i]s secondary to his service-connected depressive disorder.” The Veteran’s attorney pointed out that the March 2019 private psychologist’s report regarding the Veteran noted that “the diagnostic criteria for persistent depressive disorder, criterion B involves either poor appetite or overeating,” and that the Veteran “reported that he eats for comfort.” The Veteran’s attorney then argued that: “If VA finds that the above-mentioned evidence on its own is not sufficient to support a grant of service connection, then an examination is needed to properly adjudicate the veteran’s appeal.” The Board has not previously, and does not now, make any findings regarding the credibility of any testimony in this case. In September 2019, the Board found that the evidence then of record did not sufficiently address the medical questions necessary to adequately inform appellate review of the Veteran’s theory of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea on a secondary basis, based upon his service-connected psychiatric disorder. The Board found that it must remand this matter for additional medical assessment with attention to the criteria noted by VAOPGCPREC 1-2017 (January 6, 2017). In accordance with the Board’s September 2019 remand directives, an opinion was obtained in May 2020 addressing the claim of entitlement to service connection for the Veteran’s sleep apnea due to the psychiatric disorder, with attention to the theory featuring obesity as an intermediate step in the asserted etiological link. Multiple versions of the requested opinion, with significant differences between each version, were added to the claims-file on the same day in May 2020. However, the Board is unable to read the opinion (in any combination of versions) as adequate to support appellate review at this time. Recently, in Walsh v. Wilkie, 32 Vet. App. 300 (2020), the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) addressed “inquiry into whether a service-connected disability aggravates a veteran’s obesity”: The Court held: “Despite the G.C. opinion’s silence regarding aggravation, the Board, in accordance with § 3.310(b), must consider aggravation in this context when the theory is explicitly raised by the veteran or reasonably raised by the record.” Walsh v. Wilkie, 32 Vet. App. 300, 307 (2020). The Board finds that the aggravation question has been raised by the Veteran’s contentions in this case. One version of the May 2020 VA medical opinion addresses the question of nexus with the statement: “The significant obesity in this claimant is self-induced and a major contributor to OSA [obstructive sleep apnea], but is not related to a service-connected condition.” In another version: “The significant weight gain is self-induced and not related to a mental health disorder.” The evidence indicates that the Veteran’s sleep apnea is etiologically linked to his obesity; however, the VA medical opinion does not include an opinion adequately addressing the significant question of whether the Veteran’s pertinent obesity may be -aggravated- by the service-connected psychiatric disorder. The Court has held that “it is a big stretch of the English language to construe the phrase ‘no etiological relationship’ as encompassing aggravation.” Allen v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 439, 449 (1995). By the Court’s standard, the VA medical opinion of record does not appear to adequately encompass consideration of aggravation. Once VA undertakes the effort to provide an examination in connection with a benefits claim, it must provide an adequate one. Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303 (2007). Accordingly, remand is necessary for an opinion addressing whether obesity, as an intermediary step for secondary service connection, was aggravated by the service-connected psychiatric disorder. Additionally, the Board observes that there is some lack of clarity, between the varying versions of the May 2020 VA medical opinion, as to whether the author prepared the opinion on the foundation of a fully accurate factual premise. It is important to note that the Veteran has already established that his psychiatric disorder is a service-connected pathology of such severity as to warrant a 70 percent rating from June 4, 2015, and a 100 percent rating from January 10, 2017. However, aspects of the May 2020 VA medical opinion appear to suggest doubt regarding this established foundation. In some versions of the opinion, the author states: “I found no evidence in the e-record for service-connected disability,” and in some versions the author presents remarks that suggest doubt as to whether the Veteran actually has an acquired psychiatric disorder connected to military service. For instance, in one version of the opinion, the author states: “The note from evaluation dated in 2011 stated the lack of achievement in the veteran as the source for his depression (this post-dates time in service). The Administrative Discharge in 1998 clearly describes an active duty with a personality disorder.” The author devotes discussion to November 1998 documentation indicating that “[T]he member is not considered mentally ill and returned to full duty” and post-service documentation that “[t]he great majority of his occupational and social impairment is attributable to his Personality Disorder, NOS.” As this issue already must be remanded for a more adequate VA medical opinion for other reasons, the forthcoming VA medical opinion shall furthermore have the opportunity to ensure that it clearly considers the established factual predicate that the Veteran certainly has a service-connected psychiatric disorder responsible for significant levels of impairment. 2. The issue of entitlement to a TDIU, on the basis of a combination of service-connected disabilities, is remanded. As discussed in the Board’s prior September 2019 remand of these matters, the pending development and adjudication of the remanded issue of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea could significantly impact a decision on the issue of entitlement to a TDIU. Accordingly, the issues are inextricably intertwined. A remand of the issue of entitlement to a TDIU is required. The Court has held that two issues are inextricably intertwined when they are so closely tied together that a final decision cannot be rendered unless both issues have been considered. Harris v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 180, 183 (1991). Thus, the Board must defer final adjudication of the claim seeking TDIU until the development concerning his requested entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea has been completed. A remand of the claim for TDIU is required. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain any outstanding records pertinent to the Veteran’s claims, to include updated VA and private treatment records. 2. After the record is determined to be complete, obtain a medical opinion from an appropriate clinician regarding the nature and etiology of the Veteran’s sleep apnea. A new direct examination of the Veteran should be scheduled only if deemed necessary to prepare the medical opinion (or telehealth interview, review of the record, etc., if an in-person examination is not feasible). To prepare the addendum opinion regarding the etiology of his sleep apnea, the clinician should review the claims file. The clinician is requested to answer the following: (a) Is it at least as likely as not (i.e., a 50 percent or greater probability) that the Veteran’s obesity has been caused by his service-connected psychiatric disability? (b) Is there any medical reason to accept or reject the proposition that, had the Veteran experienced a history of lethargy and overeating behaviors corresponding to periods of service-connected psychiatric symptomatology as he claims, such events could have caused his obesity? (c) Is it at least as likely as not (i.e., a 50 percent or greater probability) that the Veteran’s obesity has been aggravated (increased in severity) by his service-connected psychiatric disability? (d) Is there any medical reason to accept or reject the proposition that, had the Veteran experienced a history of lethargy and overeating behaviors corresponding to periods of service-connected psychiatric symptomatology as he claims, such events could have aggravated his obesity? (e) Please explain whether the Veteran’s lay statements (including his description of experiencing lethargy and overeating behaviors corresponding to periods of service-connected psychiatric symptomatology) align with how obesity is known to develop. (f) if, and only if, the Veteran’s obesity is deemed to have been caused or aggravated by his service-connected psychiatric disability, please explain whether sleep apnea would not have occurred but for obesity caused or aggravated by the service-connected psychiatric disability. The VA examiner should note that the Veteran has established VA-recognized service-connected status for depressive disorder with anxious distress, recognized by VA to have progressed to a current level of 100 percent disability. The VA examiner should note that prior medical evidence of record indicates that the Veteran’s obesity is a “major contributor” to his sleep apnea. The VA examiner should also note that the Veteran’s obesity is not a disease or disability for VA benefits purposes; however, it may act as an intermediate step between a service-connected disability and a current disability that may be service-connected on a secondary basis. To determine whether any weight gain or obesity is an intermediate step between the Veteran’s service-connected psychiatric disabilities and a sleep disorder, the examiner should fully answer the above questions. A full rationale is to be provided for all stated medical opinions. If an opinion cannot be made without resort to speculation, the examiner should provide an explanation as to why this is so and note what, if any, additional evidence would permit such an opinion to be made. 3. After the above development, and any additionally indicated development, has been completed, readjudicate the inextricably intertwined issues of (a) entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea and (b) entitlement to a TDIU. If any benefit sought on appeal is not granted to the Veteran’s satisfaction, send the Veteran and his representative a Supplemental Statement of the Case and provide an opportunity to respond. If necessary, return the case to the Board for further appellate review. M. C. GRAHAM Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans’ Appeals Attorney for the Board A. Barone, Counsel The Board’s decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.