Citation Nr: 21068336 Decision Date: 11/10/21 Archive Date: 11/10/21 DOCKET NO. 14-18 767 DATE: November 10, 2021 ORDER A disability rating greater than 10 percent prior to June 15, 2011 for left shoulder impingement syndrome status post fractured left clavicle with acromioclavicular joint separation (left shoulder disability) is denied. A disability rating greater than 20 percent from June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019 for left shoulder disability is denied. A disability rating greater than 30 percent beginning November 12, 2019 for left shoulder disability is denied. The previously assigned 10 percent disability rating assigned under Diagnostic Code (DC) 5203 for impairment of the clavicle or scapula is protected and may not be reduced, and therefore is restored, effective June 15, 2011, the date of its erroneous reduction. REMANDED The claim of entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disability (TDIU) on an extra-schedular basis pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (b) prior to September 3, 2015 is remanded. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The Veteran is left hand dominant. 2. Prior to June 15, 2011 the Veteran's left shoulder disability was manifested by full range of motion, even in contemplation of functional loss due to pain and other factors, or as a result of repetitive motion or flare-ups. There was no evidence of ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation; malunion of the humerus, or malunion of the major clavicle or scapula or nonunion without loss movement. 3. From June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019 the Veteran's left shoulder disability was manifested by, at worst, flexion to 145 degrees, abduction to 120 degrees, external rotation to 90 degrees, and internal rotation to 90 degrees, even in contemplation of functional loss due to pain and other factors, or as a result of repetitive motion or flare-ups. There was no evidence of ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation; malunion of the humerus, or malunion of the major clavicle or scapula or nonunion without loss movement. 4. Beginning November 12, 2019, the Veteran's left shoulder disability has been manifested by, at worst, flexion to 40 degrees, abduction to 35 degrees, external rotation to 30 degrees, and internal rotation to 30 degrees, even in contemplation of functional loss due to pain and other factors, or as a result of repetitive motion or flare-ups. There was no evidence of ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation; malunion of the humerus, or malunion of the major clavicle or scapula or nonunion without loss movement. 5. In changing the diagnostic code from DC 5203 (impairment of the clavicle or scapula) to DC 5201 (limitation of motion of the arm) and assigning a 20 percent rating under the latter diagnostic code, effective June 15, 2011 in the March 2017 rating decision, the RO effectively reduced the rating under DC 5203 to 0 percent, as DCs 5203 and 5201 compensate distinct and separate manifestations of the Veteran's left shoulder disability. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. Prior to June 15, 2011, the criteria for a compensable disability rating for left shoulder disability were not met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.159, 4.1, 4.3, 4.20, 4.25, 4.40, 4.45, 4.71a, Diagnostic Code (DC) 5201. 2. From June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019, the criteria for a disability rating greater than 20 percent for left shoulder disability were not met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.159, 4.1, 4.3, 4.20, 4.25, 4.40, 4.45, 4.71a, DC 5201. 3. Beginning November 12, 2019, the criteria for a disability rating greater than 30 percent for left shoulder disability are not met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.159, 4.1, 4.3, 4.20, 4.25, 4.40, 4.45, 4.71a, DC 5201. 4. The previously assigned 10 percent rating assigned under DC 5203 for the Veteran's left shoulder disability prior to June 15, 2011 is protected and may not be reduced, and therefore is restored, effective June 15, 2011, the date of its erroneous reduction. 38 U.S.C. § 110; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.951. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from November 1967 to August 1969. These matters come before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from an April 2012 rating decision of the Department of Veterans' Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) which, in part, continued a 10 percent disability rating for the Veteran's left shoulder disability pursuant to DC 5203. The Veteran disagreed with this decision and perfected this appeal. In an August 2015 decision, the Board, in part, denied a disability rating greater than 10 percent for the Veteran's left shoulder disability. The Veteran appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) and, in May 2016, the Court granted the parties' Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMR), and vacated the Board's August 2015 decision regarding the left shoulder disability. In August 2016, the Board remanded the case for additional development and readjudication pursuant to the JMR. A subsequent March 2017 rating decision increased the evaluation for the Veteran's left shoulder disability from 10 to 20 percent disabling, effective June 15, 2011, pursuant to DC 5201, discontinuing the use of DC 5203. In a September 2017 decision, the Board, in part, denied a disability rating greater than 20 percent for the Veteran's left shoulder disability. The Veteran appealed this decision to the Court and, in September 2019, the Court granted the parties' JMR, and vacated the Board's September 2017 decision regarding the left shoulder disability. The case was remanded by the Board again in August 2019 for additional development. At that time, the Board took jurisdiction of the TDIU issue pursuant to Rice v. Shinseki, 22 Vet. App. 447, 453 (2009) (a claim for TDIU is part and parcel of a claim for an increased rating), noting a June 2014 VA treatment record showing that the Veteran will need to retire due to pain in his left shoulder. A subsequent November 2019 rating decision increased the evaluation for the Veteran's left shoulder disability from 20 to 30 percent disabling, effective November 12, 2019. The case was remanded by the Board again in February 2020 and February 2021 for additional development. Despite the higher ratings established for the left shoulder disability beginning June 15, 2011 and beginning November 12, 2019, the Veteran has not been awarded the highest possible rating. As a result, he is presumed to be seeking the maximum possible benefit during the entire appeal period and his claim remains in appellate status. A.B. v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 35 (1993). General Legal Criteria Disability ratings are determined by applying the criteria set forth in the VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities, which is based on the average impairment of earning capacity resulting from disability. Separate diagnostic codes identify the various disabilities. 38 U.S.C. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. § 4.1. If two ratings are potentially applicable, the higher rating will be assigned if the disability picture more nearly approximates the criteria for the higher rating. Otherwise, the lower rating will be assigned. 38 C.F.R. § 4.7. Any reasonable doubt regarding the degree of disability will be resolved in favor of the Veteran. 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. A veteran's entire history is to be considered when assigning disability ratings. 38 C.F.R. § 4.1; Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1995). The Board will consider entitlement to staged ratings to compensate for times since filing the claim when the disability may have been more severe than at other times during the course of the claim on appeal. Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119 (1999); Hart v. Mansfield, 21 Vet. App. 505 (2007). 38 C.F.R. § 4.40 notes that disability of the musculoskeletal system is primarily the inability, due to damage or infection of parts of the system, to perform the normal working movements of the body with normal excursion, strength, speed, coordination, and endurance. Functional loss may be due to the absence of part or all of the necessary bones, joints, and muscles, or associated structures, or to deformity, adhesions, defective innervation, or other pathology, or may be due to pain, supported by adequate pathology and evidenced by the visible behavior of the claimant undertaking the motion. 38 C.F.R. § 4.40. 38 C.F.R. § 4.45 provides that factors of disability involving a joint reside in reductions of its normal excursion of movements in different planes of motion and therefore, inquiry will be directed to such considerations as weakened movement (due to muscle injury, disease or injury of peripheral nerves, divided or lengthened tendons, etc.); excess fatigability; and incoordination (impaired ability to execute skilled movements smoothly). 38 C.F.R. § 4.45. The United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has held that when a diagnostic code provides for compensation based upon limitation of motion, the provisions of 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.40 and 4.45 must also be considered, and that examinations upon which the rating decisions are based must adequately portray the extent of functional loss due to pain "on use or due to flare-ups." DeLuca v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 202, 206 (1995). Also, the Court has held that "to be adequate, a VA examination of the joints must, wherever possible, include the results of the range of motion testing described in the final sentence of" 38 C.F.R. § 4.59. See Correia v. McDonald, 28 Vet. App. 158 (2016). 38 C.F.R. § 4.59 states that "[t]he joints involved should be tested for pain on both active and passive motion, in weight-bearing and nonweight-bearing and, if possible, with the range of the opposite undamaged joint." As such, pursuant to Correia, an adequate VA joints examination must, wherever possible, include range of motion testing on active and passive motion and in weight-bearing and nonweight-bearing conditions. Effective February 7, 2021, several changes to the diagnostic codes used for rating musculoskeletal disabilities were made. See Schedule for Rating Disabilities: Musculoskeletal System and Muscle Injuries, 85 Fed. Reg. 76453, 76463 (Nov. 30, 2020). When a law or regulation changes after a claim has been filed or reopened, but before the administrative or judicial appeals process has been concluded, the version of the law or regulation most favorable to the appellant generally applies. Only the former criteria can be applied for the period prior to the effective date of the new criteria. However, both the old and new criteria can be applied as of that date. See VAOPGCPREC 7-2003 (Nov. 19, 2003); see also 38 U.S.C. § 5110 (g); 38 C.F.R. § 3.114. While the Veteran has not yet been notified of all applicable regulatory changes and considered his claim under such regulations, the Board notes that the rating criteria prior to February 7, 2021 pertaining to the shoulders are significantly more favorable to the Veteran. As such, there is no prejudice to the Veteran in the Board considering the claims at this time. 1. Disability ratings greater than 10 percent prior to June 15, 2011, greater than 20 percent from June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019, and greater than 30 percent beginning November 11, 2019 for left shoulder disability are denied; however, the previously assigned 10 percent disability rating assigned under DC 5203 for impairment of the clavicle or scapula is protected and may not be reduced, and therefore is restored, effective June 15, 2011, the date of its erroneous reduction. The Veteran seeks higher disability ratings for his service-connected left shoulder disability. By way of history, the Veteran's service treatment records show that he fractured his left clavicle in July 1968. He submitted an initial claim for service connection for a left shoulder disability in August 1969 and, by rating decision dated in January 1970, the RO granted service connection for fracture left clavicle with acromioclavicular separation, assigning a 10 percent disability rating effective August 14, 1969 pursuant to DC 5203. Subsequently, by rating decision dated in August 1970, the RO temporarily increased the Veteran's disability rating for the left shoulder from 10 to 20 percent disabling, effective February 4, 1970 but then, in an August 1975 rating decision, decreased it from 20 to 10 percent, effective November 1, 1975. The Veteran submitted the current claim for an increased for the right shoulder in December 1992. However, as noted in the February 2020 Board remand, this claim appears to have been ignored until a subsequent June 15, 2011 claim for an increased rating and, as above, by rating decision dated in April 2012, the RO continued a 10 percent disability rating for the Veteran's left shoulder disability under DC 5203. The Veteran disagreed with this decision and perfected this appeal. During the course of this appeal, a March 2017 rating decision increased the evaluation for the Veteran's left shoulder disability from 10 to 20 percent disabling, effective June 15, 2011, pursuant to DC 5201, discontinuing the use of DC 5203. Thereafter, a November 2019 rating decision increased the evaluation for the Veteran's left shoulder disability from 20 to 30 percent disabling, effective November 12, 2019. The case was remanded by the Board again in February 2020 and February 2021 for additional development. Rating criteria The Veteran's left shoulder disability is currently rated under 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, DC 5201. Prior to February 7, 2021, under DC 5201 (pertaining to limitation of motion of the arm), limitation of motion at shoulder level warrants a 20 percent rating for both the major and minor arms. With limitation of the arm midway between side and shoulder level, a 30 percent rating is warranted for the major arm and a 20 percent rating is warranted for the minor arm. With limitation of the arm to 25 degrees from the side a 40 percent rating is warranted for the major arm and a 30 percent rating is warranted for the minor arm. Beginning February 7, 2021, under DC 5201, limitation of motion at shoulder level (flexion and/or abduction limited to 90 degrees) warrants a 20 percent for both the major and minor arms. With limitation of the arm midway between side and shoulder level (flexion and/or abduction limited to 45 degrees) a 30 percent rating is warranted for the major arm and a 20 percent rating is warranted for the minor arm. With limitation of the arm to 25 degrees from the side a 40 percent rating is warranted for the major arm and a 30 percent rating is warranted for the minor arm. Other DCs that evaluate impairment resulting from disorders of the shoulder and arm include DC 5200 (ankylosis of scapulohumeral articulation), DC 5202 (impairment of the humerus), and DC 5203 (impairment of the clavicle or scapula.) DC 5200 provides that ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation (the scapula and humerus move as one piece) of the major upper extremity is rated 30 percent when it is favorable, with abduction to 60 degrees and able to reach mouth and head. A 40 percent rating is assigned with intermediate ankylosis (between favorable and unfavorable); and it is rated 50 percent when unfavorable, with abduction limited to 25 degrees from side. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, DC 5200 and Note. DC 5202 provides a 20 percent evaluation for malunion of the major humerus with a moderate deformity, and a 30 percent evaluation with a marked deformity. A 20 percent evaluation is also warranted for recurrent dislocation of the major humerus at the scapulohumeral joint with infrequent episodes and guarding of movement only at the shoulder level, and a 30 percent rating is warranted for frequent episodes and guarding of all arm movements. Impairment of the major humerus is rated at 50 percent if there is a fibrous union, 60 percent if there is nonunion or false flail joint, and 80 percent if there is loss the head of humerus, with flail shoulder. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, DC 5202. DC 5203 provides a 10 percent evaluation for malunion of the clavicle or scapula or nonunion without loose movement. A 20 percent evaluation is warranted for nonunion of the clavicle or scapula with loose movement or dislocation of the clavicle or scapula. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, DC 5203. For VA purposes, normal range of shoulder motion is: forward elevation (flexion) 0 to 180 degrees; shoulder abduction 0 to 180 degrees; internal rotation 0 to 90 degrees; and external rotation 0 to 90 degrees. Lifting the arm to shoulder level is lifting it to 90 degrees. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.71, Plate I. Relevant Evidence Evidence relevant to the level of severity of the Veteran's left shoulder disability during the appeal period beginning December 1992 includes VA shoulder examinations dated in April 1993, March 2012, October 2016, November 2019, October 2020, and August 2021. Significantly, each of these examination reports show that the Veteran is left hand dominant. During the April 1993 VA examination, the Veteran reported that he fractured his left clavicle in 1969 when he jumped out of the second floor of a building. He currently worked in construction and his shoulder would hurt in cold weather as well as when he over worked his shoulder. Physical examination of the left shoulder revealed a surgical scar but no muscle atrophy. Significantly, the Veteran reportedly had full range of motion in the left shoulder. The impression was status post fracture plus open reduction surgery (times two), left shoulder. During the March 2012 VA examination, the examiner noted diagnoses of pain in left shoulder as well as left rotator cuff syndrome. The Veteran reported that, following his in-service left shoulder injury and subsequent surgeries, the shoulder did fairly well for a period of time but that now his shoulder was very painful and caused him limitations at work. Specifically, he could no longer work with concrete due to shoulder pain. The Veteran also reported experiencing flare-ups that impact the function of the shoulder, specifically, when the shoulder is bad, he cannot lay on the shoulder as his arm goes numb. He does not sleep well due to the pain and cannot work with concrete as he had in the past. Range of motion testing revealed left shoulder flexion to 145 degrees, with pain beginning at 145 degrees; left shoulder abduction to 120 degrees, with pain beginning at 120 degrees; external rotation to 36 degrees, with pain beginning at 36 degrees; and internal rotation to 50 degrees, with pain beginning at 50 degrees. The Veteran was unable to perform repetitive use testing, due to pain from work the previous day. With regard to functional loss, the examiner noted that the Veteran had less movement than normal, weakened movement, excess fatigability, and pain on movement of his left shoulder. There was also localized tenderness or pain on palpation of joints/soft tissue/biceps tendon as well as guarding of the left shoulder. Muscle strength testing was slightly abnormal for the left shoulder, described as 4/5, active movement against some resistance. There was no ankylosis. Tests for rotator cuff conditions were all positive. There was no history of mechanical symptoms (clicking, catching, etc.) and no history of recurrent dislocation (subluxation) of the glenohumeral (scapulohumeral) joint but Crank apprehension and relocation testing regarding instability was positive. There was a history of separation or sternoclavicular dislocation as well as tenderness on palpation of the acromioclavicular (AC) joint. Cross-body abduction test was positive. There was no history of joint replacement but the Veteran did have a history of two prior arthroscopic surgeries in 1969 and 1970 resulting in pain and slightly decreased motion. There were no other pertinent findings other than scars. Significantly, the examiner noted that there was no functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remained other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis. Diagnostic testing revealed degenerative or traumatic arthritis. The examiner noted that the Veteran's shoulder condition impacted his ability to work in concrete construction. During the October 2016 VA examination, the examiner noted a diagnosis of left clavicular fracture status post ORIF (open reduction and internal rotation) and subsequent hardware. The Veteran reported that, since his last VA examination, the left shoulder continued to be chronically painful. He reported constant pain 5/10, daily, of the entire shoulder, resulting in less strength, less mobility, and less durability in activities. He also experienced daily flares of 10/10 with motion in most planes and worse with weight. This severe pain limited multiple activities. The Veteran treats the pain with anti-inflammatories and requires a period of rest. Range of motion testing revealed flexion to 170 degrees, abduction to 160 degrees, and internal and external rotation to 90 degrees each. Pain was noted on examination but did not cause functional loss. There was no evidence of pain with weightbearing and no objective evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the joint or associated soft tissue. There was, however, objective evidence of crepitus. The Veteran was able to perform repetitive use testing with at least three repetitions and there was no additional functional loss or range of motion after three repetitions. Weightbearing limitation of motion was limited to 100 degrees of forward flexion and abduction, with approximately five to ten points of pressure applied, due to pain and weakness. The Veteran's left shoulder was not examined immediately after repetitive use over time and/or during a flare-up and the examiner noted that the examination is medically consistent with the Veteran's statements describing functional loss with repetitive use over time and/or flare-ups. Pain significantly limited functional ability with repeated use over a period of time and with flare-ups but the examiner was unable to describe this in terms of range of motion. There were no additional factors contributing to disability. Muscle strength testing was normal for forward flexion but slightly abnormal, described as 4/5 (active movement against some resistance) for abduction. There was a reduction in muscle strength but there was no muscle atrophy. There was no ankylosis. A rotator cuff condition was suspected, as Empty-Can testing as well as external rotation/infraspinatus strength testing were positive. Neither instability, dislocation, nor labral pathology were suspected. There was an AC joint condition but this did not affect the Veteran's range of motion of the left shoulder and did not result in tenderness on palpation of the AC joint. Cross-body adduction testing was negative. There were no impairments of the humerus. Regarding surgeries, it was noted that the Veteran had two arthroscopic surgeries in 1969 and 1970 resulting in a well-healed and nontender surgical scar with no residual hardware. Other pertinent physical findings included no focal tenderness to palpation, normal shoulders to inspection except for surgical scars, palpable induration at site of prior fracture after healing, and no DME (durable medical equipment) apparent for shoulder. Both passive range of motion as well as active range of motion values were noted to be charted as above. There was pain with terminal abduction, mild weakness without significant pain demonstrated with supraspinatus, and infraspinatus isolated testing. Mild weakness was noted in left shoulder abduction compared with right. There was no AC joint pain, no clavicular pain, and no pain with crossed adduction or crepitus at the glenohumeral joint. There was one scar measuring 4.0 centimeters x 0.3 centimeters but it was neither painful nor unstable. The Veteran did not use an assistive device. There was no functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remained, other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis. The examiner noted that the Veteran's left shoulder disorder impacted the Veteran's ability to work in that he was ill suited for jobs requiring repetitive overhead work or repetitive heavy lifting. During the November 2019 VA examination, the examiner noted diagnoses of left shoulder impingement syndrome and status post fractured left clavicle with AC joint separation. At that time, the Veteran reported that he experienced constant left shoulder pain with daily flares and was unable to do anything overhead. He felt that his condition had gotten worse. With regard to the claimed flare-ups, the Veteran reported that these occurred daily and were moderate to severe in severity. They lasted from a couple minutes to a couple hours. He was unsure what precipitated the flare-ups but noted that they are alleviated by time. The Veteran also reported experiencing any functional loss or functional impairment due to his left shoulder disability, specifically that he was unable to do anything overhead. On range of motion testing of the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 80 degrees, abduction to 75 degrees, external rotation to 60 degrees, and internal rotation to 65 degrees. The examiner noted that this loss of motion contributed to a functional loss, specifically an inability to perform any overhead work. There was no evidence of pain with weight bearing but there was evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the joints or associated soft tissue on the top/anterior area which was of a mild to moderate severity. There was no objective evidence of crepitus. The Veteran was able to perform repetitive use testing with at least three repetitions and no additional loss of motion. The Veteran was not examined immediately after repetitive use over time and/or during a flare-up and the examiner noted that the examination was medically consistent with the Veteran's statements describing functional loss with repetitive use over time and/or during a flare-up. Pain, fatigue, weakness, and lack of endurance significantly limited functional ability with repeated use over a period of time. During flare-ups, this resulted in additional loss of motion, specifically: for the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 45 degrees, abduction to 35 degrees, external rotation to 30 degrees, and internal rotation to 30 degrees. There were no additional factors contributing to disability. Muscle strength testing was slightly abnormal for the left shoulder, 4/5 (active movement against some resistance), and there was no muscle atrophy. There was no ankylosis. A rotator cuff condition was suspected, as external rotation/infraspinatus strength test as well as lift-off subscapularis test were positive. Instability, dislocation, and labral pathology were suspected and there was a history of mechanical symptoms but no history of recurrent dislocation. Crank apprehension and relocation test was negative. While there was an AC joint condition which resulted in tenderness on palpation of the AC joint, this did not affect the Veteran's range of motion of the left shoulder. Cross-body adduction testing was negative. There were no impairments of the humerus. There were no other pertinent physical findings other than a scar which was neither painful, unstable, nor larger than 39 square centimeters. The Veteran did not use an assistive device. There was no functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remained, other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis. Diagnostic testing was not performed. The examiner noted that the Veteran's left shoulder disorder impacted the Veteran's ability to work in that he was unable to do any overhead work and was also unable to push/pull/lift anything above shoulder level. With regard to Correia, the examiner wrote that there was objective evidence of pain on passive range of motion testing but no evidence of pain when the joint is used in non-weight bearing. During the October 2020 VA examination, the examiner continued diagnoses of left shoulder degenerative arthritis with impingement syndrome status post fractured left clavicle with acromioclavicular joint separation. At that time, the Veteran reiterated that, due to his left shoulder disability, he was unable to perform overhead activities and/or lift heavy objects. The Veteran reported experiencing flare-ups of the left shoulder, which occur daily and are severe. The flare-ups last 30 minutes, are precipitated by sleeping on his side and are alleviated by time. The Veteran also reported experiencing functional loss/impairment in that he was unable to lift more than 20 pounds and could not do overhead work. On range of motion testing of the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 80 degrees, abduction to 100 degrees, external rotation to 70 degrees, and internal rotation to 70 degrees. The examiner noted that this loss of motion contributed to a functional loss, described as an ability to perform overhead work. There was evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the joints or associated soft tissue, described as anterosuperior tenderness of a mild severity. There was no evidence of pain with weight bearing and no objective evidence of crepitus. The Veteran was able to perform repetitive-use testing with at least three repetitions with no additional loss of motion. The Veteran was not examined immediately after repetitive use over time and the examiner noted that the examination was medically consistent with the Veteran's statements describing functional loss with repetitive use over time. Pain and weakness significantly limited functional ability with repeated use over a period of time. However, this did not result in additional loss of motion. Similarly, the Veteran was not examined during a flare-up, but the examiner noted that the examination was medically consistent with the Veteran's statements describing functional loss during a flare-up. Pain, weakness, and lack of endurance significantly limited functional ability with flare-ups that resulted in additional loss of motion, specifically: for the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 40 degrees, abduction to 50 degrees, external rotation to 30 degrees, and internal rotation to 30 degrees. There were no additional factors contributing to disability. Muscle strength testing was slightly abnormal for the left shoulder, 4/5 (active movement against some resistance), and, while there was a reduction in muscle strength, there was no muscle atrophy. There was no ankylosis. A rotator cuff condition was suspected, as Empty-can test, external rotation/infraspinatus strength test, as well as lift-off subscapularis test were positive. Instability, dislocation, and labral pathology were suspected and there was a history of mechanical symptoms but no history of recurrent dislocation. Crank apprehension and relocation test was negative. While there was an AC joint condition which resulted in tenderness on palpation of the AC joint, this did not affect the Veteran's range of motion of the left shoulder. Cross-body adduction testing was negative. There was no impairment of the humerus and there were no other pertinent physical findings other than scars, which were neither painful nor unstable and did not have a total area greater than 39 square centimeters. The Veteran did not use an assistive device. There was no functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remained, other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis. Diagnostic testing revealed arthritis. The examiner noted that the Veteran's left shoulder disorder impacted the Veteran's ability to work as he was unable to lift more than 20 pounds and could not perform overhead work. With regard to Correia, the examiner wrote that there was objective evidence of pain on passive range of motion testing but no evidence of pain when the joint is used in non-weight bearing. With regard to the Board's February 2020 request for a retrospective opinion concerning the Veteran's left shoulder disability throughout the entire appeal period beginning December 16, 1991, it was noted that the Veteran's left shoulder pain as well as loss of motion would interfere with lifting, pushing, pulling, and overhead carrying. During the August 2021 VA examination, the examiner continued diagnoses of left shoulder impingement syndrome status post fractured left clavicle with AC joint separation. At that time, the Veteran reported that his left shoulder disability was worsening. The Veteran reported experiencing flare-ups of the left shoulder, which occur three to four times per week, each lasting between two and three hours. The flare-ups were described as sharp/achy/stabbing, are precipitated by lifting his left arm and overhead lifting, and are alleviated by rest. The Veteran also reported experiencing functional loss/impairment in that he had difficulty using his left arm and with overhead lifting. On range of motion testing of the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 140 degrees, abduction to 140 degrees, external rotation to 80 degrees, and internal rotation to 80 degrees (active as well as passive). The examiner noted that this loss of motion contributed to a functional loss, described as difficulty with lifting his left arm and lifting overhead. There was no objective evidence of crepitus but there was evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the joints or associated soft tissue, described as tenderness to the anterior aspect of the left shoulder of mild severity. The Veteran was able to perform repetitive-use testing with at least three repetitions with no additional loss of motion. Pain, fatigability, weakness, and lack of endurance significantly limited functional ability with repeated use over a period of time that resulted in additional loss of motion, specifically: for the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 130 degrees, abduction to 130 degrees, external rotation to 70 degrees, and internal rotation to 70 degrees. Similarly, the Veteran was not examined during a flare-up. Pain, fatigability, weakness, and lack of endurance significantly limited functional ability with flare-ups that resulted in additional loss of motion, specifically: for the left shoulder, the Veteran had flexion to 120 degrees, abduction to 120 degrees, external rotation to 70 degrees, and internal rotation to 70 degrees. There were no additional factors contributing to disability. There was no muscle atrophy and no ankylosis. A rotator cuff condition was suspected, as Hawkin's impingement test was positive. Crank apprehension and relocation test was negative. There was no instability, dislocation, and/or labral pathology. Crank apprehension and relocation test was negative. Cross-body adduction testing was also negative. While there was an AC joint condition which resulted in tenderness on palpation of the AC joint, this did not affect the Veteran's range of motion of the left shoulder. There was no impairment of the humerus and there were no other pertinent physical findings other than scars, which were neither painful nor unstable and did not have a total area greater than 39 square centimeters. The Veteran did not use an assistive device. There was no functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remained, other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis. Diagnostic testing was not performed. The examiner noted that the Veteran's left shoulder disorder impacted the Veteran's ability to work as he had difficulty with lifting greater than 15 pounds overhead in an occupational setting. There were no functional limitations in a sedentary employment setting. With regard to the Board's February 2021 request for a retrospective opinion concerning the Veteran's left shoulder disability throughout the entire appeal period beginning December 16, 1991, the examiner noted that all relevant records pertaining to the Veteran's left shoulder disability had been reviewed, including records dating back to 1991, April 1993, March 2012, October 2016, November 2019 and October 2020. It was noted that the Veteran was unable to give an accurate description of his left shoulder disability. He reported that it has been an issue since 1969, and that he is unsure of the severity of his left shoulder disability in 1991. The medical records do not show any additional limitation of left shoulder condition during flare-ups and repetitive use. Also, of record are VA treatment records dated through March 2021. These records show treatment for the Veteran's left shoulder disability but are negative for any range of motion findings. Analysis There are three periods of time at issue here: prior to June 15, 2011, when the Veteran's left shoulder disability was evaluated as 10 percent disabling; from June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019, when the Veteran's left shoulder disability was evaluated as 20 percent disabling; and beginning November 12, 2019 to the present, while the Veteran's left shoulder disability has been evaluated as 30 percent disabling. The Board will consider the proper evaluation to be assigned for the entire period on appeal. As for the period of time prior to June 15, 2011, the Board finds that a disability rating greater than 10 percent is not warranted for the Veteran's left shoulder disability. Significantly, the Veteran's range of motion did not meet the criteria for 20 percent ratings under DC 5201, as the Veteran had significantly more than 90 degrees of forward flexion. As above, the April 1993 VA examination report shows that he had full range of motion in his left shoulder. While the reported ranges of motion in April 1993 were not specified on active versus passive, the examination otherwise fully addresses all information required to rate the disability, to include functional loss range of motion, which is a more specific description of the Veteran's overall functional capabilities. Furthermore, the retrospective opinions of October 2020 and August 2021 regarding the Veteran's level of disability beginning December 1991 do not support a higher rating. As for the period of time from June 15, 2011 to November 11, 2019, the Board finds that a disability rating greater than 20 percent is not warranted for the Veteran's left shoulder disability. Significantly, the Veteran's range of motion did not meet the criteria for a 30 percent rating under DC 5201, as the Veteran was able to lift his arm more than midway between side and shoulder level. As above, the March 2012 VA examination report shows flexion to 145 degrees and the October 2016 VA examination report shows flexion to 170 degrees. While the reported ranges of motion in October 2016 were also not specified on active versus passive, the examination otherwise fully addresses all information required to rate the disability, to include functional loss range of motion, which is a more specific description of the Veteran's overall functional capabilities. Furthermore, the retrospective opinions of October 2020 and August 2021 regarding the Veteran's level of disability beginning December 1991 do not support a higher rating. As for the period of time beginning November 12, 2019, the Board finds that a disability rating greater than 30 percent is not warranted for the Veteran's left shoulder disability. Significantly, the Veteran's range of motion did not meet the criteria for a 40 percent rating under DC 5201, as the Veteran had more than 25 degrees of flexion. The November 2019 VA examination report shows flexion to at least 45 degrees, the October 2020 VA examination shows flexion to at least 40 degrees, and the August 2021 VA examination shows flexion to at least 140 degrees, even during flare-ups. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the Veteran has ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation to warrant a higher rating under DC 5200 (ankylosis of the scapulohumeral articulation). Ankylosis is defined as immobility and consolidation of a joint due to disease, injury, or surgical procedure. See Lewis v. Derwinski, 3 Vet. App. 259 (1992). As above, the Veteran had at least some motion in his left shoulder during all VA examinations. Finally, a higher rating under DC 5202 requires recurrent dislocation of the scapulohumeral joint. However, there was no indication of such in any of the above VA examination reports. Moreover, while there is evidence of arthritis in the left shoulder, pursuant to DC 5010, arthritis due to trauma and substantiated by X-ray findings is to be evaluated based on the limitation of motion of the joint. There is also no evidence of malunion of the humerus, or malunion of the major clavicle or scapula or nonunion without loss movement. Therefore, there is no basis for a higher schedular rating under either DC 5201, 5202, or 5203. The Board accepts that the Veteran has functional impairment, pain, and pain on motion (see DeLuca) and finds the Veteran's own reports of symptomatology to be credible. However, neither the lay nor medical evidence reflects the functional equivalent of symptoms required for a higher rating. The more probative evidence consists of that prepared by neutral skilled professionals, and such evidence demonstrates that the currently assigned ratings for each shoulder are warranted and no more. Notably, the Veteran has reported experiencing flare-ups since at least March 2012. In Sharp v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 26 (2017), the Court stated that flare-ups must be considered in providing an estimate of additional functional loss based on range of motion. Significantly, the Veteran's 20 and 30 percent disability ratings beginning June 15, 2011 and November 12, 2019, respectively, for the left shoulder consider such flare-ups. While the March 2012 VA examination report does not provide an estimation of loss of motion during flare-ups, the October 2016 VA examination report shows that the Veteran had "motion in most planes" during flares. Furthermore, the retrospective opinions of October 2020 and August 2021 regarding the Veteran's level of disability beginning December 1991 do not support a higher rating. As such, there is no indication that any flare-ups prior to June 15, 2011 resulted in loss of motion equivalent to a disability rating higher than 10 percent. As to arguments made in the January 2019 JMR concerning whether the Veteran's previous 10 percent rating under DC 5203 is protected under 38 C.F.R. § 3.951 (b), which provides protection for disability ratings that have been in effect for 20 or more years, the Board notes that in changing the diagnostic code from DC 5203 (impairment of the clavicle or scapula) to DC 5201 (limitation of motion of the arm) and assigning a 20 percent rating under the latter diagnostic code, effective June 15, 2011 in the March 2017 rating decision, the RO effectively reduced the rating under DC 5203 to 0 percent. As such, the Board finds that the 10 percent rating previously assigned the Veteran's left shoulder disability under DC 5203 must be restored. In this regard, a disability which has continuously been rated at or above any evaluation of disability for 20 or more years for VA compensation purposes will not be reduced to less than such evaluation except upon a showing that the rating was based on fraud. 38 U.S.C. § 110; 38 C.F.R. § 3.951 (b). The Veteran's left shoulder disability had been assigned a compensable rating under DC 5203 from November 1975 through June 2011, and was not based on fraud. Therefore, that rating is subject to preservation. See id. Consequently, the change in diagnostic code from DC 5203 to DC 5201 in the March 2017 rating decision amounted to a reduction to 0 percent under DC 5203, as these DCs compensate distinct and separate manifestations of the Veteran's left shoulder disability. See Murray v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 420 (2011); see also Esteban, 6 Vet. App. at 261 - 62. Specifically, DC 5203 compensates for impairment of the clavicle or scapula, while DC 5201 compensates for limitation of motion of the arm. 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a. Such a reduction by changing the diagnostic code from DC 5203 to DC 5201, rather than assigning a separate rating under the latter diagnostic code (that is, in addition to the 10 percent rating already assigned under DC 5203), is expressly prohibited, even if the disability compensated by DC 5203 is no longer present. See Murray v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 420 (2011). Accordingly, a separate rating of 10 percent under DC 5203 is restored effective June 15, 011, the date of its erroneous reduction. In sum, the evidence of record reflects that the Veteran's symptomatology for the left shoulder disability warrants no more than the disability ratings assigned. The Board finds that no higher ratings can be assigned pursuant to any other potentially applicable diagnostic code. As such, the benefit of the doubt doctrine is inapplicable, and the claim must be denied. See 38 C.F.R. § 5107(b); Gilbert, 1 Vet. App. at 49. REASONS FOR REMAND 2. The claim of entitlement to a TDIU on an extra-schedular basis pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (b) prior to September 3, 2015 is remanded. As above, the Veteran submitted the current claim for an increased rating for his service-connected left shoulder disability in December 1992 and, in August 2019, the Board took jurisdiction of the TDIU issue pursuant to Rice, noting a June 2014 VA treatment record showing that the Veteran will need to retire due to pain in his left shoulder. A TDIU may be assigned where the combined rating for the veteran's service-connected disabilities is less than total if the disabled veteran is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities. Specifically, if there is only one such disability, this disability shall be ratable at 60 percent or more; if there are two or more disabilities, there shall be at least one ratable at 40 percent or more and sufficient additional disability to bring the combined rating to 70 percent or more. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16 (a). In this case, the Veteran is currently in receipt of a 100 percent disability rating for prostate cancer; a 70 percent disability rating for posttraumatic stress disorder; a 30 percent disability rating for left shoulder disability; and noncompensable disability ratings for tinea pedis, scars of the left shoulder, and erectile dysfunction. Pertinent to the period on appeal beginning December 1992, the Veteran has combined disability ratings of 40 percent beginning December 16, 1992 and 100 percent beginning September 3, 2015. As such, the Veteran has met the minimum schedular criteria for a TDIU since September 3, 2015 pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (a). Even though the Veteran does not qualify for a TDIU prior to September 3, 2015 pursuant to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (a), it is the established policy of VA that all veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled. Therefore, rating boards should submit to the Director, Compensation Service, for extra-schedular consideration all cases of veterans who are unemployable by reason of service-connected disabilities, but who fail to meet the percentage standards set forth in 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (a). 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (b). The Board does not have the authority to assign an extraschedular total disability rating for compensation purposes based on individual unemployability in the first instance. Bowling v. Principi, 15 Vet. App. 1 (2001). As above, a June 2014 VA treatment record shows that the Veteran will need to retire due to pain in his left shoulder. A February 2020 VA psychiatric examination shows that the Veteran previously worked in the construction industry but abruptly stopped working approximately five years earlier due to persistent difficulties with relating to his peers, supervisors, and the public because of difficulties with managing his anger towards others. Initially, the Veteran must be provided notice regarding the information and evidence necessary to substantiate a TDIU. Also, remand is necessary in order to request that the Veteran provide a VA Form 21-8940 (Veteran's Application for Increased Compensation Based on Unemployability) that includes details regarding his employment history, to include any employment since his December 1992 claim for an increased rating. Furthermore, given the fact that the claim for a TDIU has been pending since December 1992, the fact that the Veteran appears to have been neither substantially nor gainfully employed since approximately 2015, and the medical evidence suggesting that the Veteran may have been unemployable due to a combination of his service-connected disabilities prior to September 3, 2015, under the provisions of 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b), the Board finds that the TDIU claim should be submitted to the Director of Compensation Service for a determination as to whether a TDIU should be awarded on an extra-schedular rating basis prior to September 3, 2015. As for the period since September 3, 2015, notably, the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) has held that award of a 100 percent disability rating does not necessarily render moot a claim of entitlement to a TDIU. See Bradley v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 280 (2008). In Bradley, the Court determined that a separate TDIU rating predicated on one disability (although perhaps not ratable at the schedular 100 percent level), when considered together with another disability separately rated at 60 percent or more, could warrant special monthly compensation under 38 U.S.C. § 1114 (s). Thus, the Court reasoned, it might benefit the Veteran to retain or obtain the TDIU rating even where a 100 percent schedular rating has also been granted. Bradley, at 293-94. Because of this holding, VA's General Counsel withdrew VAOPGCPREC 6-99, which was contrary to the holding of Bradley. See 75 Fed. Reg. 11229-04 (March 10, 2010). Here, however, beginning September 3, 2015, the award of a 100 percent schedular rating for prostate cancer clearly renders moot any claim for a TDIU. Hence, as noted, above, the remaining matter of a TDIU is limited to the period noted above. The matter is REMANDED for the following action: 1. Provide the Veteran with proper notice regarding the evidence and information necessary to substantiate his TDIU claim. He should also be requested to complete and return a VA Form 21-8940 (Veteran's Application for Increased Compensation Based on Unemployability) that includes details regarding his employment history, to include any employment since his December 1992 claim for an increased rating. 2. Refer this case to the Under Secretary for Benefits of the Director, Compensation Service, for consideration of assignment of an extraschedular TDIU under the provisions of 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b) prior to September 3, 2015. Consideration should be given to the following: a June 2014 VA treatment record showing that the Veteran will need to retire due to pain in his left shoulder (see VBMS, document labeled CAPRI, receipt date 9/9/15, page 79) and a February 2020 VA psychiatric examination showing that the Veteran previously worked in the construction industry but abruptly stopped working approximately five years earlier due to persistent difficulties with relating to his peers, supervisors, and the public because of difficulties with managing his anger towards others (see VBMS, document labeled C&P Exam, receipt date 2/7/20, page 4). Bethany L. Buck Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board April Maddox, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.