Citation Nr: 21042839 Decision Date: 07/14/21 Archive Date: 07/14/21 DOCKET NO. 16-45 458 DATE: July 14, 2021 ORDER Entitlement to an effective date prior to April 24, 2014 for the grant of a total disability evaluation for individual unemployability (TDIU) is denied. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The Veteran's claim of entitlement to a TDIU was previously denied pursuant to an October 2011 rating decision. He failed to appeal, and the decision became final. 2. The most probative evidence of record fails to show that it is factually ascertainable that the Veteran was unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation due to his service-connected disabilities in the one-year period prior to the April 24, 2014 claim to reopen the previously denied claim for a TDIU. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for establishing entitlement to an effective date prior to April 24, 2014 for the grant of a total disability evaluation for individual unemployability have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 5110, 7105; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.3, 3.151, 3.342, 3.400, 4.17. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty from May 1970 to May 1972. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from an August 2016 decision of a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO), which granted entitlement to a TDIU, effective from April 24, 2014. The Veteran timely perfected an appeal as to the effective date assigned. See October 2016 Notice of Disagreement; February 2018 Statement of the Case; March 2018 VA Form 9. In February 2020, the Veteran testified at a hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge, a transcript of which is associated with the claims file. In an April 2020 decision, the Board, in pertinent part, denied entitlement to an effective date earlier than April 24, 2014 for the grant of entitlement to a TDIU. The Veteran appealed the denial to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). In a March 2021 order, the Court granted a March 2021 Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMR) and remanded only that part of the Board's decision that denied entitlement to an earlier effective date for the grant of a TDIU for action consistent with the terms of the joint motion. In the April 2020 decision, the Board also remanded the issue of entitlement to increased ratings for bilateral lower extremity peripheral neuropathy for additional development. The Board notes that the RO is still developing those issues, so they are not before the Board at this time. Those issues will be addressed in a later decision. Earlier Effective Date for TDIU The Veteran contends that he is entitled to an earlier effective date for the grant of a TDIU, specifically, dating back to May 2009. In general, the effective date of an award of compensation and rating based on an original claim, a claim reopened after final disallowance, or a claim for increase will be the date of receipt of the claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is the later. 38 U.S.C. § 5110 (a); 38 C.F.R. § 3.400. When evidence demonstrates that a factually ascertainable increase in disability occurred within the one-year period preceding the date of receipt of a claim for increased compensation, the effective date of the award shall be the earliest date as of which it is ascertainable that an increase in disability had occurred, if application is received within one year from that date. 38 U.S.C. § 5110 (b)(2) (2014); 38 C.F.R. § 3.400 (o)(2) (2018); Harper v. Brown, 10 Vet. App. 125 (1997). The law provides that a TDIU may be granted upon a showing that the veteran is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation due solely to impairment resulting from his service-connected disabilities. 38 U.S.C. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16. Consideration may be given to a Veteran's level of education, special training, and previous work experience in arriving at a conclusion, but not to his or his age or the impairment caused by non-service-connected disabilities. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.341, 4.16, 4.19. To qualify for a total rating for compensation purposes, the evidence must show (1) a single disability rated as 100 percent disabling; or (2) that the disabled person is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of his or his service-connected disabilities, with one disability ratable at 60 percent or more, or, for more than one disability, at least one disability ratable at 40 percent or more and a combined disability rating of 70 percent or more. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (a). Here, the Veteran is service-connected for the following disabilities: diabetic kidney disease (claimed as decreased kidney function) associated with diabetes mellitus type II (60 percent disabling from February 25, 2009), posttraumatic stress disorder (30 percent disabling from July 3, 2013), diabetes mellitus type II (20 percent disabling from February 25, 2009), peripheral neuropathy right lower extremity associated with diabetes mellitus type II (20 percent disabling from December 15, 2014), peripheral neuropathy left lower extremity associated with diabetes mellitus type II (20 percent disabling from December 15, 2014), tinnitus (10 percent disabling March 31, 2008), bilateral hearing loss (noncompensable from March 31, 2008), peripheral neuropathy right median nerve associated with diabetes mellitus type II (10 percent disabling from October 09, 2015), and peripheral neuropathy left median nerve associated with diabetes mellitus type II (10 percent disabling from October 09, 2015). Thus, the Veteran's combined disability rating is as follows: 10 percent from March 31, 2008; 70 percent from February 25, 2009; and 90 percent from July 3, 2015. As such, the Veteran met the schedular criteria for a TDIU beginning on February 25, 2009. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 (a). The question that remains is whether the Veteran's service-connected disabilities precluded him from obtaining or engaging in substantially gainful employment prior to April 24, 2014. Review of the record shows that the Veteran's formal TDIU application was received by VA on March 28, 2011. Therein, he credibly reported that he had last worked full-time in May 2007, after which his service-connected disabilities prevented him from working full-time. An August 2011 VA examination report does not reflect that the Veteran was rendered unemployable as a result of his service-connected disabilities. The examiner indicated that an NCV study revealed normal findings. Therefore, no current diagnosis of peripheral neuropathy was rendered. As to the Veteran's current diagnosis of diabetes mellitus, the examiner indicated that his current symptoms - including chronic fatigue, weakness and lack of stamina - would likely prevent him from performing manual labor. However, the Veteran would not be incapable of performing minimal physical labor. Other conditions to include degenerative joint disease of the bilateral shoulders and benign right colon mass, were also deemed unlikely to impair the Veteran's ability to perform or maintain non-physical activities. In the March 2021 JMR, the parties agreed that the Board failed to fully address another August 2011 examination report. Specifically, the parties noted that during an August 2011 VA audiological examination, a VA examiner found that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus, "with other medical problems may compound the difficulty in attaining viable employment." The parties agreed that the Board "should have discussed this evidence and whether it reasonably raised the issue of whether [the Veteran's] combined service-connected conditions affected his employability." The Board has reviewed the August 2011 VA audio examination. The examiner indicated that the Veteran "may experience difficulty concentrating because of his tinnitus." However, the examiner also noted that the Veteran's "hearing loss is mild and should not interfere with normal conversational speech." Regarding employability, the examiner opined that "[i]t is not likely that [the Veteran's] hearing loss and tinnitus deem him unemployable. The combination of these problems with other medical problems may compound his difficulty in attaining viable employment. The hearing loss and tinnitus would not prevent employability." Thus, despite the parties' characterization of the August 2011 VA examination report as an opinion in favor of unemployability, the opinion actually shows that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus would not prevent the Veteran from working. Although the examiner noted that the Veteran's combined medical conditions, including hearing loss and tinnitus, "may compound his difficulty in attaining viable employment," the Board notes that insofar as the Veteran's service-connected disabilities have an effect on his occupational functioning, a disability rating in itself is recognition that the ability to work is impaired. 38 C.F.R. § 4.1. The Board does not find that this opinion reflects that the Veteran was unemployable for TDIU purposes, especially when considered with the August 2011 general medical examination and opinions discussed above. Moreover, as noted in the April 2020 Board decision, the Veteran's claim of entitlement to a TDIU was denied pursuant to an October 2011 rating decision. He did not appeal that decision and the decision became final. In April 2014, the Veteran reported VA Form 21-8940, Veteran's Application for Increased Compensation Based on Unemployability Three months later, in July 2014, the Veteran filed a request for reconsideration for his previously denied claims. Therein, he indicated that his most recent nerve study was conducted in September 2009. The Veteran reported persistent symptoms including burning, numbness, and tingling in the bilateral lower extremities. He contends that his prior claim was denied without considering a VA VOC rehabilitation Assessment, dated March 2011, which indicated that the combined impact of the Veteran's service-connected conditions substantially impaired his ability to work. In reaching the stated conclusion, the assessment acknowledged that the Veteran suffers from problems with mobility due to bilateral lower extremity neuropathy secondary to DM-II. It was further noted that at the time of the prior denial, he had not been granted service connection for PTSD. In July 2014, the RO issued a rating decision which granted service connection for PTSD and assigned an evaluation of 30 percent disabling, effective July 3, 2013. The Veteran's claim for TDIU was denied. In the same month, the Veteran filed an additional statement in support requesting reconsideration of the previously denied claim for TDIU. The claim was subsequently denied in October 2014, based upon a conclusion that the evidence submitted was not new and material. In January 2015, the Veteran filed a notice of disagreement disputing the RO's determination. His TDIU claim was ultimately granted by the RO in an August 2016 rating decision. An effective date of April 24, 2014 was assigned. In his October 2016 notice of disagreement, the Veteran asserted entitlement to an earlier effective date. During a Board hearing, February 2020, the Veteran suggested that he is entitlement an earlier effective date of May 26, 2009 (the date of his original claim for service connection for right lower extremity neuropathy) for all claims, to include TDIU. He also testified to progressive worsening of his service-connected neuropathy. The Veteran reported persistent symptomology 2008 or 2009. Current symptoms included difficulty walking without a cane and an inability to stand of any significant period. Specifically, the Veteran reported an inability to able to walk further than the distance between his house and the car. The Veteran also stated that he has been unable to go to the grocery store or keep up with his young grandson. Considering the evidence noted above, the Board finds that the preponderance of evidence weights against the assignment of an effective date earlier than April 24, 2014, for the grant of TDIU. The Board recognizes that the Veteran first met the percentage requirements for a TDIU in February 2009. However, the Veteran's initial claim for a TDIU was denied in an October 2011 rating decision due to a lack of evidence of unemployability. The Veteran did not appeal that decision and the decision became final. Prior to the April 2014, there is no evidence that Veteran filed a claim to reopen nor is there any evidence that he was rendered unable to secure and maintain substantially gainful employment. In reaching the stated conclusion, the Board has fully considered the Veteran's lay assertions of record. It also observes that the Veteran's April 2014 claim included a vocational assessment. Therein, the examiner indicated that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities impair his mobility, to include prolonged walking or standing. In February 2020, a social security administration (SSA) determination letter was associated with the claims file. The correspondence indicated that the Veteran reported that he became disabled as of June 2007 due to mental and physical problems. Upon review of the medical evidence (to include a consultation exam in June 2009, July 2009, and VA Med CT report March 2009) however, the SSA determined that the Veteran became disabled as December 2008. While the Board recognizes the favorable SSA determination, it is not bound by findings rendered by other administrative agencies. In this case, the Veteran has been afforded multiple VA examinations. On VA examination in August 2011, the VA examiner opined that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities would not impair his ability to perform non-physical labor. Moreover, as discussed in detail above, the August 2011 audio examiner opined that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus would not prevent employment. The examiners' findings were used as support for the previously denied claim in October 2011. Accordingly, the Board finds that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities did not prevent the Veteran from obtaining or maintaining substantially gainful employment prior to April 24, 2014. While the Board is sympathetic to the Veteran's subjective belief that an earlier effective date is warranted, the evidence of record does not support his condition. Accordingly, the criteria for the assignment of an effective date for the grant of a TDIU prior to April 24, 2014, are not met. The claim must be denied. B. MULLINS Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board R. Kipper, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.