Citation Nr: 22045673 Decision Date: 08/11/22 Archive Date: 08/11/22 DOCKET NO. 17-22 918 DATE: August 11, 2022 ORDER Entitlement to an effective date of September 1, 2011, but no earlier, for the award of entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU) is granted. Entitlement to an effective date of September 1, 2011, but no earlier, for the establishment of basic eligibility to Dependents' Educational Assistance (DEA) benefits is granted. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The evidence shows that from September 1, 2011, the Veteran's PTSD precluded him from obtaining and maintaining substantially gainful employment. 2. On September 1, 2011, the Veteran met the criteria for the establishment of basic eligibility to DEA benefits. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The criteria for entitlement to an effective date of September 2, 2011, for the award of entitlement to a TDIU rating have been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107, 5110 (2018); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 3.400, 4.16, 4.19 (2022). 2. The criteria for entitlement to an effective date of September 1, 2011, for basic eligibility to DEA benefits have been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107, 5110 (2018); 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 3.400, 4.16, 4.19 (2022). REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran served on active duty from September 1969 to June 1971. This appeal to the Board of Veteran's Appeals (Board) arose from an April 2017 rating decision by the Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). In March 2019, the Board denied entitlement to earlier effective dates for the award of TDIU rating and DEA eligibility. The Veteran appealed the Board decision to the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC or Court), which vacated the decision in part and remanded it back to the Board for further development in a March 2019 Memorandum Decision. In May 2021, the Board denied entitlement to an earlier effective date for TDIU award, and awarded an earlier effective date of September 2, 2015, for DEA eligibility. The Veteran appealed the decision to the Court, which vacated the decision pertaining to these two issues and remanded it back to the Board for further development in March 2022, pursuant to a Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR). The issue was originally characterized as entitlement to an effective date prior to December 17, 2015, for the award of entitlement to a TDIU rating. The basis for the TDIU award was due to the Veteran's service-connected PTSD precluding him from obtaining and maintaining substantially gainful employment. In an October 2017 rating decision, the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) awarded entitlement to a 100 percent rating for PTSD from September 2, 2015. The TDIU rating was based solely on the Veteran's PTSD. From September 2, 2015, he is rated at 100 percent disabling for his PTSD. For the period from September 2, 2015, the Board notes that the receipt of a 100 percent schedular disability rating for a service-connected disability does not necessarily always moot the issue of entitlement to a TDIU, however, because a TDIU rating may still form the basis for the assignment of special monthly compensation (SMC) under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s) (2012). See Bradley v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 280 (2008). However, the Veteran did not have additional service-connected disabilities independently rated at 60 percent or more until March 31, 2016. Therefore, Bradley would not be applicable for any time period subject to this appeal. Accordingly, the Board has recharacterized the time period on appeal to be prior to September 2, 2015. 1. Entitlement to an effective date prior to September 2, 2015, for the award of entitlement to a TDIU. TDIU may be assigned where the schedular rating is less than total, when it is found that the disabled person is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of a single service-connected disability ratable at 60 percent or more, or as a result of two or more service-connected disabilities, provided at least one disability is ratable at 40 percent or more, and there is sufficient additional service-connected disability to bring the combined rating to 70 percent or more. 38 U.S.C. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16(a). In this matter, prior to September 2, 2015, the Veteran met the schedular criteria. Except as otherwise provided, the effective date of an evaluation and award of compensation based on an original claim, a claim reopened after final disallowance, or a claim for increase will be the date of receipt of the claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is the later. 38 U.S.C. § 5110; 38 C.F.R. § 3.400. When evidence of unemployability is submitted during an appeal from an assigned disability rating, a claim for entitlement to a TDIU will be considered to have been raised by the record as "part and parcel" of the underlying claim. Rice v. Shinseki, 22 Vet. App. 447, 45354 (2009). In this current matter, the Veteran formally filed his TDIU claim in January 2009, claiming that his PTSD prevented him from obtaining and maintaining substantially gainful employment. See January 2009 VA Form 21-8940 (Veterans Application for Increased Compensation based on Unemployability). However, in March 2009, the Veteran requested to withdraw his TDIU claim, due to accepting an offer for gainful employment. See March 2009 Correspondence. In September 2011, the Veteran formally filed his claim for TDIU again. He shared that he last worked full-time on August 31, 2011, as an energy auditor and inspector. See September 2011 VA Form 21-8940. The Veteran shared that he was placed on sick leave until further notice to see if he could maintain his job. See September 2011 VA Form 21-4138 (Statement in Support of Claim). In the September 2011 VA Form 21-4192 (Request for Employment Information in Connection with Claim for Disability Benefits), the Veteran's employer stated that he began his job in March 2009. Although indicating that he was still employed, the employer noted that he last worked on August 31, 2011, just as the Veteran reported. On the September 2011 VA Examination for PTSD, the Veteran explained that he was initially on medical leave due to recovering from surgery. When he returned to work, he was accused of file theft and asked not to return to work and remain on leave until the company decided on future employment. At the time, while waiting, he continued to work as a self-employed real estate broker and appraiser. The Veteran was officially fired in November 2011. He continued to hold a real estate license so that he could perform appraisals. However, he indicated that he only had one paying contract last year. He shared that his real estate business had lost money the past three years. He saw himself as retired and was not searching for additional work. The Veteran may spend an entire day in his office but felt that he worked on real estate for only about 3 hours a day. He reported preferring to do appraisals only as he did not like interacting with customers for home sales. See March 2014 CAPRI (VA Examination for PTSD). The Veteran shared his difficulties maintaining his work in real estate and appraisals. He started work around 11am, then would break for lunch at 1pm. He stated that he would end the day around 2:30pm. He expressed being difficult to work with, such being argumentative, irritable, isolative, and having panic attacks as a result of some interactions. See April 2021 Correspondence. In September 2017, Social Security Administration (SSA) determined that the Veteran had been under disability as defined by the SSA Act since October 1, 2014. It was determined that there were no jobs that exist that the Veteran could perform, considering his age, education, work experience and residual functional capacity. See March 2018 SSA/SSI Letter. Although it is probative in determining unemployability, it is not determinative or binding on the Board. See Collier v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 413, 417 (1991) (observing that while SSA decisions are relevant, there are significant differences between SSA and VA recognition of disabilities and SSA decisions are not binding on VA). The Board wants to note that there is no dispute that the evidence shows that the Veteran's PTSD precludes his ability to perform the physical and mental acts required by employment. In this matter, the main issue in dispute is whether the Veteran's self-employment prior to September 2, 2015 was considered marginal employment. The Board finds that the Veteran's reported "self-employment" constitutes marginal employment. Marginal employment can be deemed to exist when a veteran's earned annual income does not exceed the poverty threshold for one person or "on a facts found basis (includes but is not limited to employment in a protected environment such as a family business or sheltered workshop), when earned annual income exceeds the poverty threshold." 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). In Faust v. W., 13 Vet. App. 342 (Feb. 2000), the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court), found that 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) "does not define what 'substantially gainful employment' is;' [however], it does provide that 'marginal employment' is not substantially gainful employment. See also Moore (Robert) v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 356, 358 ("the ability to work only a few hours a day or only sporadically is not the ability to engage in substantially gainful employment."). The Board acknowledges that the Veteran's income exceeded poverty thresholds. However, as explained previously, marginal employment can be determined on a facts found basis when the income exceeds the threshold. Here, the Veteran's reported self-employment is not characteristic of substantially gainful employment. His work schedule was sporadic, ending the workday when he began to feel overwhelmed due to his psychiatric symptoms. Accordingly, the Board finds that the Veteran was unable to obtain and maintain substantially gainful employment due to his PTSD from September 1, 2011, the date after his last day of full-time work. Although he was technically on leave before being fired in November 2011, his last day of work was August 31, 2011, as evidenced by the Veteran's employer. Therefore, resolving reasonable doubt, the Board finds that September 1, 2011 is the earliest effective date allowed for the award of a TDIU rating in this matter. As shown, prior to that time, the evidence shows that the Veteran was employed full-time. Regarding if the Veteran's claim for TDIU was pending as part and parcel of his increased rating claim for PTSD, as stated above, in March 2009, the Veteran withdrew his claim for TDIU. When a claim is withdrawn, it ceases to exist. See Crosby v. West, 17 Vet. App. 356 (2000) (citing Hanson v. Brown, 9 Vet. App. 29, 32 (1996). As a result of that withdrawal, his claim for TDIU would not have been pending with his PTSD claim at the time. 2. Entitlement to an effective date prior to September 2, 2015, for basic eligibility to DEA benefits. Basic eligibility for DEA exists if a Veteran has a permanent, total service-connected disability. 38 U.S.C. §§ 3500, 3501. A total disability may be assigned where the Veteran's service-connected disabilities are rated 100 percent disabling under the rating schedule, or if the veteran is unemployable due to service-connected disabilities. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341. Permanence of total disability will be taken to exist when such impairment is reasonably certain to continue throughout the life of the disabled person. 38 C.F.R. § 3.340 (b). (Continued on next page) As extensively explained previously, the Board has awarded an earlier effective date of September 1, 2011, for the award of TDIU rating. As a result, the basic eligibility of DEA benefits has now been established as of September 1, 2011. Therefore, the Veteran is entitled to an earlier effective date of September 1, 2011, for the establishment of basic eligibility of DEA benefits. E. I. VELEZ Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Middleton, Syesa T. The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.