Citation Nr: 22046097 Decision Date: 08/15/22 Archive Date: 08/15/22 DOCKET NO. 17-21 134 DATE: August 15, 2022 ORDER The petition to reopen the previously denied claim of entitlement to service connection claim for a psychiatric disability, claimed as posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), is denied. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. In an unappealed July 2005 rating decision, the Regional Office (RO) denied entitlement to service connection for PTSD. 2. The evidence associated with the claims file subsequent to the RO's July 2005 rating decision is new but does not raise a reasonable possibility of substantiating the Veteran's claim for entitlement to service connection for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for reopening the claim seeking service connection for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD, are not met. 38 U.S.C. § 5108; 38 C.F.R. § 3.156. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty from June 1977 to January 1978. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a May 2015 rating decision of a Regional Office (RO) of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). The Veteran testified before a Veterans Law Judge in August 2021. A transcript of this hearing is of record. The issue was previously before the Board in March 2022 when it was remanded for further development. Whether new and material evidence has been received to reopen a service connection claim for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD The Veteran seeks to reopen service connection for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD. In general, RO rating decisions that are not timely appealed are final. See 38 U.S.C. § 7105; 38 C.F.R. § 20.1103. If a claim for entitlement to service connection has been previously denied and that decision became final, the claim can be reopened only if new and material evidence is presented with respect to that claim. 38 U.S.C. § 5108; Manio v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 140, 145 (1991). New evidence means existing evidence not previously submitted to agency decision-makers. Material evidence means existing evidence that, by itself or when considered with previous evidence of record, relates to an unestablished fact necessary to substantiate the claim. New and material evidence can be neither cumulative nor redundant of the evidence of record at the time of the last prior final denial of the claim sought to be reopened and must raise a reasonable possibility of substantiating the claim. 38 C.F.R. § 3.156(a). The threshold for determining whether new and material evidence raises a reasonable possibility of substantiating a claim is a low one. Consideration is not limited to whether the newly submitted evidence relates specifically to the reason the claim was last denied, but instead should include whether the evidence could reasonably substantiate any element of the claim were the claim to be reopened, either by triggering the Secretary's duty to assist or through consideration of an alternative theory of entitlement. See Shade v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 110, 118 (2010). However, a new theory of entitlement does not automatically reopen a previously denied claim. See Bingham v. Nicholson, 421 F.3d 1346, 1348-49 (2005); see also Boggs v. Peake, 520 F.3d 1330, 1336 (Fed. Cir. 2008) (new theory of causation for same disease or injury that was subject of previously denied claim cannot be basis of new claim). For the purpose of establishing whether new and material evidence has been submitted, the credibility of the evidence is generally presumed, unless it is inherently false or untrue or, if in the nature of a statement or other assertion, it is beyond the competence of the person making the assertion. Duran v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 216, 220 (1994). The Veteran has sought service connection for PTSD on multiple occasions. His initial claim was filed in May 1993 and denied in June 1994. The RO denied subsequent claims for service connection in August 1998 and June 2002. The Veteran did not perfect an appeal of these decisions. The Veteran requested to reopen his claim for PTSD again in April 2005 which the RO denied in July 2005 because new and material evidence had not been received. The Veteran was notified of this decision and his appellate rights in a July 21, 2005 letter. A copy of this letter was also sent to his representative. The Veteran did not indicate disagreement with this decision. Moreover, no new and material evidence pertaining to the Veteran's claim was physically or constructively associated with the claims file within one year of the RO's decision. As a result, the July 2005 decision became final. When the Veteran's claim was denied in July 2005, the record contained the Veteran's service treatment records, service personnel records, post-service medical records, and lay statements. Based on this evidence, the RO denied the Veteran's claim because the evidence did not show that an in-service stressor occurred. The RO noted that the service treatment and personnel records were reviewed and there were no in-service markers indicating that the described incident occurred. The RO also denied the claim finding that although his treatment records show mental health symptoms that he relates to the event in service, the evidence was insufficient to link the Veteran's current symptoms to an event in service. Evidence associated with the claims file after the prior final denial includes the Veteran's outpatient treatment records, lay statements, and his testimony at the August 2021 Board hearing. With respect to the Veteran's recent lay statements and his testimony at the August 2021 Board hearing, these statements document his assertion that he was subjected to MST in service and that he has been having psychiatric issues since his time in service. However, these contentions are duplicative of those of record at the time of the July 2005 prior final denial and were considered by the RO at that time. For example, the Veteran submitted a statement in April 1994 noting the details of his alleged MST in service which he again described during the Board hearing. Additionally, his May 1993 claim noted that he has had psychiatric trouble since his discharge from service which he also reported during the Board hearing. The Veteran's repeated contentions are therefore not new. See Reid v. Derwinski, 2 Vet. App. 312, 315 (1992). With respect to the medical records, these records are not new and material for purposes of reopening the claim, as they do not address the question of whether an in-service stressor occurred. The fact that the Veteran had a diagnosis for PTSD based on an alleged military sexual trauma (MST) in service was known at the time of the July 2005 decision. Medical evidence which merely documents continued diagnosis and treatment of disease does not constitute new and material evidence. See Cornele v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 59, 62 (1993). The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has held that, according to the plain language of the regulation, evidence that is merely cumulative of other evidence in the record cannot be new and material even if that evidence had not been previously presented to the Board. See Anglin v. West, 203 F. 3d 1343, 1347 (Fed. Cir. 2000). The medical records are duplicative of evidence that was already considered by the RO and is not new and material evidence. The Board notes that the evidence of record indicates that the Veteran is in receipt of Social Security Administration (SSA) benefits. Although the claims file does not contain the Veteran's SSA disability records, the Board finds no duty to assist error has been committed as there is no indication that these SSA records are relevant to the Veteran's psychiatric disability claim. See Golz v. Shinseki, 590 F.3d 1317, 1323 (Fed. Cir. 2010) (holding the VA's duty to assist obligates it to obtain relevant records, and that SSA records pertaining to "a completely unrelated medical condition" are not relevant unless relevance is explained by the Veteran). Specifically, the Veteran's VA treatment records document that he stopped working due to back pain and COPD. See a June 17, 2019 VA treatment record. See also a February 27, 2013 VA examination noting that the Veteran was not able to work after injuring his back. Under these circumstances, the Board must conclude that new and material evidence to reopen the claim seeking service connection for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD, has not been received. Accordingly, the previously denied claim of entitlement to service connection for a psychiatric disability, claimed as PTSD, is not reopened. M. Donohue Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board S. Morrad, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.