Citation Nr: 22047722 Decision Date: 08/22/22 Archive Date: 08/22/22 DOCKET NO. 14-12 459 DATE: August 22, 2022 ORDER An initial 70 percent rating, and no higher, for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is granted from February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017. A 100 percent rating is granted for PTSD from September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018. REMANDED Entitlement to special monthly compensation (SMC) based on the need for regular aid and attendance (A&A) is remanded. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. From February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017, the severity, frequency, and duration of the Veteran's PTSD symptoms more closely approximate occupational and social impairment with deficiencies in most areas; total occupational and social impairment is not shown or approximated. 2. From September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018, the Veteran's PTSD symptoms most nearly approximate total occupational and social impairment. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. From February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017, the criteria for a disability rating of 70 percent and no higher for PTSD have been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.1, 4.3, 4.7, 4.126, 4.130, Diagnostic Code (DC) 9411. 2. From September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018, and not prior thereto, the criteria for a disability rating of 100 percent for PTSD have been met. 38 C.F.R. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.1, 4.3, 4.7, 4.26, 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9411. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran served on active duty in the Army from May 2006 to February 2011, to include service in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Veteran served in combat and his decorations include the Combat Action Badge, the Iraq Campaign Medal and the Afghanistan Campaign Medal. This appeal comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from a July 2012 rating decision of a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO), that granted service connection and an initial rating of 30 percent for PTSD effective February 3, 2011. In a December 2017 decision, the Board denied a rating in excess of 30 percent for PTSD prior to July 31, 2017, and granted a 50 percent rating and no higher from that date. The Veteran appealed the Board's December 2017 decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court), which in a July 2018 order, granted the parties' joint motions for partial remand (JMPR), vacating the Board's December 2017 decision and remanding the claim for compliance with the terms of the JMPR with respect to the denial of an initial disability rating in excess of 30 percent for PTSD prior to July 31, 2017, and in excess of 50 percent thereafter. In a December 2018 decision, the Board denied a rating in excess of 30 percent for PTSD prior to July 31, 2017, granted a 70 percent rating from July 31, 2017, and granted a 100 percent rating from January 19, 2018. The Veteran appealed the Board's December 2018 decision to the Court, which in an August 2019 order, granted the parties July 2019 JMPR, vacating the Board's December 2018 decision and remanding the claim for compliance with the terms of the July 2019 JMPR with respect to the denial of an initial disability rating in excess of 30 percent for PTSD prior to July 31, 2017, and in excess of 70 percent from July 31, 2017, to January 18, 2018. The Veteran presented sworn testimony at a hearing before one of the undersigned Veterans Law Judges in March 2017. In March 2022, he gave testimony at a second hearing before another of the undersigned Veterans Law Judges. Transcripts of both hearings are of record. At the March 2022 hearing, the Veteran waived his right to testify before a third Veterans Law Judge pursuant to Arneson v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 379 (2011) (a veteran must be provided the opportunity to testify before all members of a Board panel deciding the case). See March 2022 Hr'g Tr. at 4. The Board notes that in a February 2020 rating decision, the AOJ granted a total disability rating based on individual unemployability due to service-connected disabilities (TDIU) effective September 6, 2017, the date the Veteran was first unable to work as a result of service-connected PTSD. Increased Rating The Veteran's ratings for PTSD throughout the appeal period are assigned under Diagnostic Code 9411. 38 C.F.R. § 4.130. PTSD is rated 30 percent from February 3, 2011, the day after service separation; 70 percent from July 31, 2017, and 100 percent from January 19, 2018. The disability is rated using the General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders (General Formula). Under that Formula: A 70 percent disability rating is warranted for occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near-continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; impaired impulse control (such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a worklike setting); inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. A 100 percent rating is assigned for total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; or memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own name. The Board notes the Court has concluded that there are no descriptors, modifiers, or indicators as to suicidal ideation in the 70 percent rating. The presence of suicidal ideation alone, that is, a Veteran's thoughts of his or her own death or thoughts of engaging in suicide-related behavior, may cause occupational and social impairment with deficiencies in most areas. Bankhead v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 10, 21 (2017). Under the General Formula for Mental Disorders, the Board must conduct a "holistic analysis" that considers all associated symptoms, regardless of whether they are listed as criteria. Bankhead, 29 Vet. App. at 22; 38 C.F.R. § 4.130. The Board must determine whether unlisted symptoms are similar in severity, frequency, and duration to the listed symptoms associated with specific disability percentages. Then, the Board must determine whether the associated symptoms, both listed and unlisted, caused the level of impairment required for a higher disability rating. Vazquez-Claudio v. Shinseki, 713 F.3d 112, 114-118 (Fed. Cir. 2013). As the evidence considered in determining the level of impairment under 38 C.F.R. § 4.130 is not restricted to the symptoms provided in the code, the Board must consider all symptoms of a claimant's condition that affect occupational and social impairment. Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436, 443 (2002). If the evidence demonstrates that a Veteran suffers symptoms or effects that cause occupational or social impairment equivalent to what would be caused by the symptoms listed in the Diagnostic Code, the appropriate, equivalent rating will be assigned. Id.; see also Sellers v. Principi, 372 F.3d 1318, 1326 (Fed. Cir. 2004). The Board finds that for the period on appeal prior to July 31, 2017, the Veteran's service-connected PTSD has been productive of occupational and social impairment in most areas due, at least in part, to suicidal ideation. Moreover, as of September 6, 2017, the PTSD manifestations more nearly approximate total occupational and social impairment also due, at least in part, to suicidal ideation as well as due to panic attacks on a near-continuous basis, day in and day out, daytime and through the night. See Bankhead, 29 Vet. App. at 21. For increased rating claims, an effective date should not be assigned mechanically based on the date of a diagnosis or a VA examination report. Rather, all of the facts should be examined to determine when an increase in a veteran's disability can be ascertained. DeLisio v. Shinseki, 25 Vet. App. 45 (2011); Swain v. McDonald, 27 Vet. App. 219, 224 (2015). The Veteran's entire history is to be considered when assigning disability ratings. 38 C.F.R. § 4.1; Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1995). A claimant may experience multiple distinct degrees of disability that may result in different levels of compensation from the time the increased rating claim was filed until a final decision is made. Hart v. Mansfield, 21 Vet. App. 505 (2007). The following analysis is undertaken with consideration of the possibility that different ratings may be warranted for different time periods. 1. An initial 70 percent rating for PTSD is granted for the period from February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017. The Veteran urges that his PTSD warrants higher ratings at all times relevant to the appeal. Upon review of the evidence, with specific emphasis on the sustained level of impairment described at the March 2022 hearing and documented in the treatment record, in conjunction with the observations made in the July 2017 PTSD VA DBQ and May 2012 VA psychiatric evaluations, the Board finds that the Veteran's disorder warrants a rating of 70 percent and no higher from February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017. The evidence is neither evenly balanced nor approximately so with regard to whether a rating in excess of 70 percent rating is warranted from February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017. Rather, the evidence persuasively weighs against so finding. While a May 2012 VA examination reflects the assessment of fairly minimal impairment overall due to PTSD, "symptoms are not severe enough either to interfere with occupational and social functioning or to require continuous medication." the examiner does note that the Veteran had recurrent distressing dream about Iraq, and that he attempts to avoid thoughts, feelings, and conversations about Iraq. He also noted that the Veteran had a depressed mood almost every day and diminished interest in activities he once enjoyed. The examiner also explained that the Veteran felt detached from others, that he was unsure about the future, and that he had difficulty falling asleep. The examiner further noted that the Veteran was irritable, angry, had difficulty concentrating, was hyper-vigilant and had diminished concentration. A July 2017 DBQ indicates PTSD results in occupational and social impairment, with deficiencies in most areas. The examiner cites to long-term panic attacks, intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living, including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene, impulse control and suicidal ideation. At the March 2022 hearing, the Veteran and his wife clarified that he has had suicidal ideation since his combat service in Iraq and Afghanistan. He described direct combat and IEDs as well as mortar and rocket attacks. They reported that he has been suffering from all of his PTSD symptoms since his discharge. He has reached out to the Veteran's crisis line because of suicidal thoughts. He has panic attacks if he hears gunshots or fireworks. They have moved out of the city he grew up in because crowds and gunshots exacerbate his PTSD. At work, he had constant conflicts with co-workers. It is urged that the January 2018 VA examination is most representative of his symptoms. His wife must do all of the chores and take care of him. She recalled that in 2012, while she was pregnant, he said it might be better if he were not alive. Based on the evidence of record, including that highlighted above, the Board finds that the evidence is approximately balanced regarding whether the Veteran's service-connected PTSD has been productive of occupational and social impairment with deficiencies in most areas from February 3, 2011, to July 31, 2017. The benefit of the doubt doctrine applies. 38 U.S.C. § 5107(b), Lynch v. McDonough, 21 F.4th 776 (Fed. Cir. 2021). However, the Board finds that the evidence is persuasively against finding that the criteria for a 100 percent rating are met during this period. Specifically, the Board notes that the January 2018 examiner found that there had been an increase in PTSD symptoms since the time of the July 2017 DBQ. The Veteran's theory that the findings from the January 2018 apply to the entire period on appeal is outweighed by the 2018 examiner's medical opinion. Records reflect that the Veteran went on medical leave related to PTSD in September 2017, and not earlier, leading the Board to conclude that the increase in PTSD symptoms dates from that point, as further explained below. 2. A 100 percent rating is granted for PTSD from September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018, and not prior thereto. The January 2018 VA examination report reflects the VA examiner's opinion that the Veteran's PTSD results in total occupational and social impairment, consistent with a 100 percent rating. Here, the examiner specifically observed there was an increase in the level of impairment since the July 2017 PTSD evaluation to total impairment. The January 2018 examiner cited the Veteran's report of how dramatically his symptoms, specifically his experience of near constant panic, have progressed over the past few months. There was intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living, including maintenance of minimal personal hygiene. He was not working but had been paranoid his coworkers were conspiring against him. The examiner noted panic attacks now occur on a near continuous basis, and his constant state of panic made it impossible for him to concentrate or focus on any occupational tasks, with severely impaired short-term memory, leaving him completely unaware of which occupational tasks he had completed and which he had not. He was now paralyzed by panic attacks. The record reflects that while he was employed with the Clorox Company he was granted leave under the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) for the time period from September 6, 2017 to November 13, 2017 and leave under the California Family Rights Act for the time period November 14, 2017 to August 24, 2018. VA has conceded that leave of absence during these time frames was because he was unable to work due to PTSD. The Veteran has reported that his employment with Clorox was terminated after he was unable to return to work following exhausting his leave due to PTSD. The Veteran and his wife testified that he took leave during those times because his PTSD symptoms became overwhelming. They described symptoms wholly consistent with those documented in the January 2018 VA examination. The Veteran reported he took the aforementioned leave prior to leaving work, starting September 6, 2017, to avoid being fired. The Board finds that the evidence suggests that the Veteran's PTSD manifestations did not increase simply on January 18, 2018, the day they were reported to the examiner. Rather, the record persuasively shows that the increase sufficient to cause total occupational and social impairment occurred September 6, 2017, the day he went out on medical leave due to PTSD, and not prior thereto. The Board notes that the testimony and lay statements of record provided by the Veteran and his wife regarding the Veteran's psychiatric symptoms during the relevant period on appeal are competent, credible, and probative. See Jandreau v. Nicholson, 492 F.3d 1372, 1377 (Fed. Cir. 2007). Specifically, the evidence of record established that during the relevant time period, starting September 6, 2017, and not prior thereto, the Veteran was suffering from extreme paranoia and constant panic that resulted in total occupational and social impairment. Also noted is the testamentary evidence regarding ongoing suicidal ideation, though suicidal ideation was not noted in the January 2018 examination. Resolving all reasonable doubt in the Veteran's favor, the Board finds the evidence of record most nearly approximates psychiatric symptoms that result in total occupational and social impairment from September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018, but not prior to September 6, 2017. Therefore, a rating 100 percent rating for an PTSD from September 6, 2017, to January 18, 2018, is warranted. REASONS FOR REMAND SMC based on A&A is remanded is remanded. The Veteran and his wife testified that the worsening of his symptoms associated PTSD have rendered him unable to care for himself with respect to his activities of daily living. They urged that he requires the assistance of his spouse to help him take all of his medication, make medical appointments, drive, perform any daily household activities and maintain personal hygiene. She does all the grocery shopping, laundry and picks up everything in the house as he forgets to do so. She also helps him work through his panic attacks and suicidal thoughts. They reported that they have known each other since 2008 and have been together since 2011. To the extent that the evidence suggests that the Veteran needs assistance with daily living due to manifestations of his service-connected conditions, the issue of entitlement to SMC based on the need for the aid and attendance of another person has been raised, and thus is part of the appeal. The issue of entitlement to SMC based on the need for aid and attendance must be considered when the record indicates that it may be available, even if the claimant does not place eligibility for this ancillary benefit at issue. See Akles v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 118, 121 (1991). The Court has repeatedly held that SMC benefits "are to be accorded when a veteran becomes eligible without need for a separate claim." Bradley v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 280, 286 (2008); see also Buie v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 242, 250-51 (2011); Akles v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 118, 121 (1991) (observing that entitlement to SMC is an "inferred issue" in the context of an increased rating claim). VA has adopted the Akles rule for all complete claims. 38 C.F.R. § 3.155 (d)(2) states, "VA will adjudicate as part of [a] claim entitlement to any ancillary benefits that arise as a result of the adjudication decision. The claimant may, but need not, assert entitlement to ancillary benefits at the time the complete claim is filed." As such, on remand, the RO must consider the issue of SMC based on the Veteran's need for the aid and assistance of another person. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Notify the Veteran that he may submit additional lay statements from himself and from other individuals who have first-hand knowledge of his need for aid and attendance of another person. He should be provided an appropriate amount of time to submit this lay evidence. 2. Obtain and associate with the claims file updated VA treatment records. 3. Schedule the Veteran for an appropriate VA examination (or telehealth interview, review of the record, etc. if an in-person examination is not feasible) to address his claim of entitlement to SMC based on the need for aid and attendance of another person. MARJORIE A. AUER Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals J. Nichols Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals STEVEN D. REISS Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board N. Rippel, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.