Citation Nr: 22043398 Decision Date: 07/29/22 Archive Date: 07/29/22 DOCKET NO. 17-58 141 DATE: July 29, 2022 ORDER From May 31, 2016, an initial 70 percent rating, but no higher, for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), is granted. From May 31, 2016, but no earlier, a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU) due to service-connected PTSD is granted. From August 5, 2019, special monthly compensation (SMC) based on statutory housebound status under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s) is granted. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Resolving all doubt in favor of the Veteran, from May 31, 2016, his PTSD has been manifested by occupational and social impairment with deficiencies in most areas; total occupational and social impairment has not been shown. 2. Resolving all doubt in favor of the Veteran, from May 31, 2016, his service-connected PTSD rendered him unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation. 3. From August 5, 2019, in addition to TDIU resulting from his PTSD alone, the Veteran has had additional service-connected disabilities independently ratable as at least 60 percent disabling. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The criteria for an initial 70 percent rating for PTSD have been met throughout the entire appeal period. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 4.7, 4.126, 4.130, Diagnostic Code 9411. 2. From May 31, 2016, but no earlier, the criteria for a TDIU based on PTSD have been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.340, 3.341, 4.16. 3. From August 5, 2019, the criteria for SMC at the housebound rate are met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1114 (s), 5103, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.350. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran served on active duty from September 1968 to December 1969. This appeal is before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from a July 2016 rating decision of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in Jackson, Mississippi. On August 5, 2019, the Veteran testified during a Board hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge via videoconference. A transcript is included in the claims file. In February 2021, the Board (1) denied an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for an acquired psychiatric disability, to include PTSD, prior to August 5, 2019; (2) denied an evaluation in excess of 50 percent for an acquired psychiatric disability, to include PTSD, from August 5, 2019; and (3) denied a TDIU rating prior to August 5, 2019. The Board also granted an evaluation of 50 percent, but not in excess thereof, for an acquired psychiatric disability, to include PTSD, from August 5, 2019. The Veteran appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court), which vacated that part of the February 2021 Board decision that denied an initial evaluation in excess of 30 percent for an acquired psychiatric disability, to include PTSD, prior to August 5,2019; denied an evaluation in excess of 50 percent or an acquired psychiatric disability, to include PTSD, from August 5, 2019; and denied a TDIU rating, in a March 2022 Order granting a Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR). 1. Entitlement to an initial rating in excess of 30 percent prior to August 5, 2019, and in excess of 50 percent thereafter. The Veteran's PTSD is currently evaluated as 30 percent disabling prior to August 5, 2019, and 50 percent disabling thereafter, under Diagnostic Code 9411. Disability evaluations are determined by application of the criteria set forth in the VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities, which is based on average impairment in earning capacity. 38 U.S.C. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. Part 4. An evaluation of the level of disability present must also include consideration of the functional impairment of the Veteran's ability to engage in ordinary activities, including employment. 38 C.F.R. § 4.10. When a question arises as to which of two ratings apply under a particular diagnostic code, the higher evaluation is assigned if the disability more closely approximates the criteria for the higher rating. 38 C.F.R. § 4.7. After careful consideration of the evidence, any reasonable doubt remaining is resolved in favor of the Veteran. 38 C.F.R. § 4.3. The Veteran's entire history is to be considered when making disability evaluations. See generally 38 C.F.R. § 4.1; Schafrath v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 589 (1995). Diagnostic Code 9411 of 38 C.F.R. § 4.130 specifically addresses PTSD; however, all psychiatric disabilities are evaluated under a general rating formula for mental disorders. Under the general rating formula, the Veteran's current 30 percent rating is warranted for occupational and social impairment with occasional decrease in work efficiency and intermittent periods of inability to perform occupational tasks (although generally functioning satisfactorily, with routine behavior, self-care, and conversation normal), due to such symptoms as: depressed mood, anxiety, suspiciousness, panic attacks (weekly or less often), chronic sleep impairment, and mild memory loss (such as forgetting names, directions, recent events). A 50 percent rating is warranted for occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as: flattened affect; circumstantial, circumlocutory, or stereotyped speech; panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands; impairment of short- and long-term memory (e.g. retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete tasks); impaired judgment; impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of motivation and mood; and difficulty in establishing effective work and social relationships. A 70 percent rating is warranted for occupational and social impairment with deficiencies in most areas such as work, school, family relations, judgment, or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation; obsessional rituals which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near continuous panic or depression affecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; impaired impulse control (such an unprovoked irritability with periods of violence); spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances (including work or a work like setting); and inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. A total schedular rating of 100 percent is warranted for total occupational and social impairment, due to such symptoms as: gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior; persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living (including maintenance of mental and personal hygiene); disorientation to time or place; memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own name. The list of symptoms under the rating criteria are meant to be examples of symptoms that would warrant the rating, but are not meant to be exhaustive, and the Board need not find all or even some of the symptoms to award a specific rating. Mauerhan v. Principi, 16 Vet. App. 436, 442-43 (2002). If the evidence shows that the Veteran suffers symptoms or effects that cause occupational or social impairment equivalent to what would be caused by the symptoms listed in the criteria for a particular rating, the appropriate equivalent rating will be assigned. Id. at 443. Furthermore, the rating code requires not only the presence of certain symptoms but also that those symptoms have caused occupational and social impairment at a level consistent with the assigned rating. Vazquez-Claudio v. Shinseki, 713 F.3d 112, 116-17 (Fed. Cir. 2013). Factual Background and Analysis The Veteran underwent a VA examination in June 2016. He reported that he lives with his son and daughter. He reported that his daughter had a bad temper. He reported that he keeps game chickens as a hobby. He reported that he was easily fatigued and did not do much as his children help him. He stated that he visits his sister who lives several hours away. He reported problems with anxiety from driving. He also had problems with loud noises but said he was okay if he stays busy. He reported sleep problems 2-3 nights per week. He stated that he has a couple of friends who also deal with chickens but otherwise does not associate with others. He did not work and relied on social security. In terms of PTSD diagnostic criteria, the examiner noted dissociative reactions (e.g., flashbacks) in which the individual feels or acts as if the traumatic event(s) were recurring; peristent negative emotional state; markedly diminished interest or participation in activities; feelings of detachment or estrangement from others; and problems with concentration. The examiner indicated that the foregoing disturbances caused clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning. The examiner noted PTSD symptoms of anxiety, chronic sleep impairment, and mild memory loss. He was diagnosed with PTSD productive of occupational and social impairment due to mild or transient symptoms which decrease work efficiency and ability to perform occupational tasks only during periods of significant stress, or symptoms controlled by medication. VA treatment records reflect that in December 2016 the Veteran requested a mental health consultation. He reported bad dreams, road rage, forgetfulness, and difficulty with crowds. He reported being easily distracted. At a January 2017 mental health consultation, he reported sporadically struggling with intrusive thoughts and memories. He reported that he stays engaged with family, friends, and community. He stated that he keeps himself busy at home with his animals and enjoys this. In July 2019 he reported intrusive thoughts and memories but stated that he feels that he is coping fairly well. He stated that he finds it difficult to be around children, often isolating himself from his family. He reported staying busy with the animals he cared for. He stated that he was told that he needed to see his doctor for PTSD but declined further mental health treatment at this time. At his August 5, 2019, hearing, the Veteran reported that he was aggravated by his depression associated with his PTSD. He reported thoughts of suicide. He reported memory problems. He reported that he had no social life outside of his family and two or three guys he knows. He stated that he had a hard time getting along with his family members. His son reported that he exhibited trouble with forgetfulness, difficulty completing tasks, and irritability. His son further stated that he did not socialize and kept to himself when visiting family. His attorney argued that a 70 percent rating was warranted. The Veteran underwent a private psychological disability examination in August 2019. The clinical interview and mental status examination was conducted by Dr. J.R., Ph.D. The Veteran described a longstanding history of adjustment difficulties. He reported that persisting memories have taken a gradually increasing toll on him, eroding his ability to function in everyday life. He reported a loss of interest and pleasure in activities, social withdrawal, and unstable mood swings. Mental status exam revealed poorly articulated speech; there was no evidence of hallucinations or delusions; his thought process was tangential; his insight was poor; and his overall mental status was significant for constricted affect, disorganized concentration and attention with flight of ideas. His mood reflected significant tension and irritability. Dr. J.R. noted that the Veteran endorsed general nervousness, tension, anxiety/fear, excessive watchfulness and caution, nightmares, sleep disturbance, sexual problems, fatigue, headaches/dizziness, concentration problems, forgetfulness, irritability, isolation, family issues, depression, crying spells, sensitivity to noise, ruminations, avoidance, distraction, unstable moods, hopelessness, worrying, panic attacks, loss of interest, apathy, and paranoia. Dr. J.R. stated that the Veteran endorsed only 25 of the 32 symptoms on the checklist, which was supportive of the position that he was not arbitrary in checking off symptoms. Such discretion on his part mitigated against malingering. The diagnostic impression was that the Veteran was significantly anxious and depressed and that he meet the diagnostic criteria for PTSD. Dr. J.R. noted the following positive clinical findings that supported the diagnosis: deficiencies in family relations; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living; deficiencies in mood; difficult adapting to stressful circumstances; intrusive recollections of traumatic experiences; speech intermittently illogical obscure or irrelevant; unprovoked hostility/irritability; inability to establish and maintain effective relationships; deficiencies in judgment; and neglect of personal appearance and hygiene. Dr. J.R. also noted that the Veteran was angry and tense. Dr. J.R. noted that the Veteran's ability to maintain concentration and attention for extended periods; ability to work in coordination with or in proximity to others without being distracted by them; ability to interact appropriately with the general public; ability to accept instructions and respond appropriately to criticism from supervisors; ability to get along with co-workers; and ability to maintain socially appropriate behavior was markedly limited. The psychologist opined that his symptoms prevented him from functioning in a competitive working environment and was thus incapable of sustained employment. Dr. J.R. stated that the currently assigned rating was an "under-estimate of the true level of psychological disability and does not correspond to the full extent of symptoms nor the degree of symptomatic interference" in the Veteran's life. He stated, "Based on his history, my examination, and a review of the historical records, he has posttraumatic stress disorder, and his functioning has been impaired for an indefinite period by anxiety, depression, and maladaptive social behaviors." Dr. J.R. opined that the earliest date that the description of symptoms and limitations applied was from 1967. The Veteran underwent another VA examination in September 2019. The examiner noted symptoms of depressed mood, anxiety, suspiciousness, chronic sleep impairment, memory impairment, difficulty with complex commands, and disturbances of motivation and mood. He was diagnosed with PTSD and an unrelated major neurocognitive disorder. The examiner explained that it was not possible to differentiate the symptoms of his two diagnoses. Together, the examiner stated that they were productive of occupational and social impairment with occasional decrease in work efficiency and intermittent periods of inability to perform occupational tasks, although generally functioning satisfactorily with normal routine behavior, self-care, and conversation. The Veteran argues that his PTSD warrants at least a 70 percent rating throughout the entire initial appeal period, i.e., from May 31, 2016. After consideration of the aforementioned medical and lay evidence, and in resolving any remaining reasonable doubt in the Veteran's favor, the Board finds that an initial 70 percent rating, but no higher, for PTSD is warranted throughout the entire appeal period. The August 2019 private examination report, as well as the Veteran's Board hearing testimony, confirms the following PTSD symptoms consistent with the 70 percent rating criteria: speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant ("poorly articulated speech"); near continuous depression; impaired impulse control; neglect of personal appearance and hygiene; difficulty in adapting to stressful circumstances; and inability to establish and maintain effective relationships. While the symptoms outlined by the 2016 examination report are not as severe as those noted by Dr. J.R. and the Veteran in 2019, Dr. J.R. expressly indicated that the significant "symptoms and limitations" found on examination had been present for many years (i.e., since before the May 2016 claim for service connection). Moreover, it is unlikely that the Veteran's PTSD symptoms suddenly worsened on August 5, 2019; based on the Dr. J.R.'s interview and evaluation with the Veteran, these symptoms had been present for quite some time. The Board will thus resolve doubt in the Veteran's favor and find that the frequency, severity, and duration of the aforementioned PTSD symptoms warrant a 70 percent rating from the date of the claim for service connection, May 31, 2016. The Board does not find, however, that the Veteran's PTSD symptoms approximate total social and occupational impairment so as to warrant a 100 percent rating for any portion of the appeal period. The Board acknowledges the singular finding of "dissociative reactions (e.g., flashbacks)" in the June 2016 VA examination report. While this symptom could be tantamount to "disorientation to time or place" contemplated under the 100 percent rating criteria, the Board does not find that the frequency, severity, or duration of this symptom (or any of the additional symptoms noted below) results in the level of impairment required for a 100 percent rating. Indeed, the record does not contain any other findings of "dissociative reactions" and no mental health examiner (VA or private) has ever found the Veteran to be disoriented to time or place. The Veteran has timely reported to two VA examinations in association with his claim, one in 2016 and one in 2019, and was noted as being alert and oriented x4 (i.e., the Veteran knew his name, location, and time, as well as why he was currently being treated). To the extent that memory problems have been endorsed by the Veteran or otherwise shown by the record, such symptoms have been noted to be "mild" in nature by both VA examiners and there is otherwise no evidence of memory loss for names of close relative, own occupation, or own name. During the September 2019 VA examination, the Veteran was able to recall two out of three words in five minutes and he could remember at least one past president. Moreover, while the August 2019 private examiner noted an "intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living," the examiner did not expound on this symptom and there are no contemporaneous objective findings (e.g., inability to care for oneself) in the examination report to otherwise support this notation. Notably, the September 2019 VA examiner expressly found that the Veteran's ADLs were within normal limits; there are no other indications of the Veteran's inability to perform ADLs in the medical (or lay) record. The Board lastly notes that while the Veteran's thought process was noted be "tangential" and speech poorly articulated in August 2019, the Veteran's abstract thinking was intact; he answered questions willingly; and his level of consciousness was unimpaired. His speech was otherwise noted be at a normal speed and rhythm during the VA examinations. Thus, such symptoms simply do not rise to the level of "gross impairment in thought processes or communication" contemplated by the 100 percent rating criteria. Notably, the record does not reflect that the Veteran experiences persistent delusions or hallucinations, or that he is in persistent danger of hurting himself or others. There is otherwise no evidence of total social impairment. While there can be no doubt that the Veteran's PTSD impacts his relationships, the Veteran stays engaged with family, friends, and his community, and keeps himself busy at home with his animals. See, e.g., January 2017 VA Mental Health Consult Note. The 2019 VA examination indicates that the Veteran gets along well with his younger sister while the 2016 VA examination report noted that the Veteran had a few friends. As such, total social impairment is not demonstrated. In summary, the Board finds that while the Veteran's service-connected PTSD warrants a higher, 70 percent rating, a 100 percent rating is not warranted. 2. Entitlement to a TDIU prior to August 5, 2019. The Veteran seeks a TDIU prior to August 5, 2019. Notably, the Board granted a TDIU rating from August 5, 2019, finding that his service connected disabilities rendered him unemployable or unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation as of that date. Total disability means that there is present any impairment of mind or body sufficient to render it impossible for the average person to follow a substantially gainful occupation. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 4.15. A substantially gainful occupation has been defined as "an occupation that provides an annual income that exceeds the poverty threshold for one person, irrespective of the number of hours or days that the Veteran actually works and without regard to the Veteran's earned annual income." Faust v. West, 13 Vet. App. 342 (2000). When jobs are not realistically within his physical and mental capabilities, a veteran is determined unable to engage in a substantially gainful occupation. Moore v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 356 (1991) (citing Timmerman v. Weinberger, 510 F.2d 439 (8th Cir. 1975)). In making this determination, consideration may be given to factors such as the veteran's level of education, special training, and previous work experience, but not to age or impairment caused by non-service-connected disabilities. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.341, 4.16, 4.19; Van Hoose v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 361 (1993). A veteran is totally disabled if his service-connected disability or combination of service-connected disabilities is rated at 100 percent pursuant to the Schedule for Rating Disabilities. 38 C.F.R. § 3.340(a)(2). Even if a veteran is less than 100 percent disabled, he still is deemed totally disabled under the Schedule for Rating Disabilities if he satisfies two requirements. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a). First, the veteran must meet a minimum percent evaluation. If he has one service-connected disability, it must be evaluated at 60 percent or more. If he has two or more service-connected disabilities, at least one disability must be evaluated at 40 percent or more and the combined evaluation of all the disabilities must be 70 percent or more. Second, the veteran must be found to be unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of his service-connected disability or disabilities. Id. Prior to August 5, 2019, the Veteran is in receipt of a 70 percent rating for PTSD, effective from May 31, 2016; a 20 percent rating for bilateral hearing loss, effective from May 31, 2016; a 10 percent rating for tinnitus, effective from May 31, 2016; a 10 percent rating for coronary artery disease, effective from March 2, 2016; and a non-compensable rating for herpes, effective from July 26, 2011. He is thus in receipt of a combined schedular rating of 80 percent from May 31, 2016, to August 5, 2019. As such, as of May 31, 2016, the Veteran meets the threshold for a schedular TDIU under 38C.F.R. §4.16(a). The Board notes that the appeal period in this case dates back to March 2, 2016, the effective date of the grant of connection for coronary artery disease. This is the Veteran's only service connected disability from March 2, 2016, to May 31, 2016, and it is rated as 10 percent disabling. As the Veteran does not meet the schedular requirements for a TDIU for this period, the Board has considered whether extraschedular referral is warranted. However, the evidence of record does not substantiate a reasonable possibility that the Veteran was unemployable due to service-connected coronary artery disease prior to May 31, 2016. As noted below, the 2016 VA examiner expressly noted that the Veteran's coronary artery disease had no impact on his ability to work. Accordingly, entitlement to referral to the Director of Compensation Service for extraschedular consideration for the period prior to May 31, 2016, is not warranted. Neither the Veteran nor his representative contend otherwise. The Veteran contends that his service-connected disability/disabilities him unemployable. The issue was first raised at his August 2019 hearing, and the Board takes jurisdiction of the intertwined matter as part and parcel of his increased rating appeals. See Rice v. Shinseki, 22Vet. App.447, 453 (2009). In an August 2019 application for TDIU, the Veteran reported that he became unemployable in January 2006 due to his PTSD, heart condition, hearing loss, and tinnitus. He worked full-time as a contract chicken grower until 2005. He reported that since that time he worked intermittently part time as a seasonal beaver trapper. He indicated that he had a high school education with no special training. The Veteran underwent a VA heart examination in May 2016; the examiner indicated that the service-connected coronary artery disease did not impact his ability to work. A June 2016 VA PTSD examination noted that his PTSD caused occupational impairment due to mild or transient symptoms which decreased work efficiency and the ability to perform occupational tasks during periods of extreme stress. It was noted that he was not currently employed but previously worked taking care of chicken houses. A July 2016 VA hearing loss examination indicated that the service-connected hearing loss and tinnitus impacted the ordinary conditions of daily life, noting "some people are hard to understand," difficulty hearing with background noise, and being kept awake by the tinnitus. Although dated just after the appeal period, the August 2019 private psychological examination conducted by Dr. J.R. is relevant here, as it was the basis, in part, of the Board's grant of a 70 percent rating for PTSD herein. Dr. J.R. noted that the Veteran owned a chicken farm until 2004 and that he had been employed in that capacity for 12 to 14 years as he struggled to maintain adequate control over his psychiatric problems. Dr. J.R. opined that the Veteran was "psychologically impaired to an extent that...he cannot presently function in a competitive employment environment and is presently incapable of sustained employment." Dr. J.R. stated, "Even if he did presently seek and manage to obtain employment, in my opinion, he would not be able to sustain in a responsible and competent manner without interference from his psychological problems." Dr. J.R. noted that the Veteran's ability to maintain concentration and attention for extended periods; ability to work in coordination with or in proximity to others without being distracted by them; ability to interact appropriately with the general public; ability to accept instructions and respond appropriately to criticism from supervisors; ability to get along with co-workers; and ability to maintain socially appropriate behavior was markedly limited. Again, Dr. J.R. indicated that these symptoms and limitations had been present for many years. Given the above, the Board finds that the Veteran is entitled to a TDIU as May 31, 2016, based on his PTSD. In this regard, the record reflects that his PTSD has hindered his ability to function in a work setting and secure a substantially gainful occupation consistent with his education (i.e., high school) and work history (i.e., operating a chicken farm and beaver trapping). Notably, the Veteran's ability to work closely with others, maintain socially appropriate behavior, and accept instructions has been noted as "markedly" limited as a result of his PTSD. See Psychological Evaluation from Dr. J.R. Although service connection is also in effect for coronary artery disease (10 percent), hearing loss (20 percent), and tinnitus (10 percent) during this time period, these disabilities had a little to minimal impact, collectively, on his ability to work per the VA examination reports. Thus, resolving all doubt in the Veteran's favor, the Board finds that the requirements for a TDIU based on his PTSD are met from May 31, 2016. Lastly, the Veteran has been assigned a TDIU based solely due to his PTSD, prior to August 5, 2019, and based on multiple disabilities thereafter. The Board must still consider whether a TDIU would be warranted based on the Veteran's PTSD, alone, for the period from August 5, 2019, for purposes of SMC. When considering the above TDIU analysis, the Board finds that a TDIU based on the Veteran's PTSD alone would be warranted from August 5, 2019. VA's duty to maximize a claimant's benefits includes consideration of whether his disabilities establish entitlement to SMC under 38U.S.C. §1114. See Buie v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 242, 250 (2011); Bradley v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 280, 294 (2008). Specifically, SMC may be warranted if the Veteran has a 100 percent disability rating for a single disability. The Court has held that TDIU may satisfy the "rated as total" element of section 1114(s) where TDIU is based a single disability. Buie v. Shinseki, 24 Vet. App. 242, 250 (2010). In this case, the criteria for SMC at the (s) level has been met effective from August 5, 2019. From that date forward, in addition to TDIU based on PTSD alone, the Veteran is service connected for additional disabilities independently rated at 60 percent or higher. SMC pursuant to 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s) is therefore warranted effective August 5, 2019. JONATHAN B. KRAMER Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board H. Hoeft The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.