Citation Nr: 24015698 Decision Date: 04/11/24 Archive Date: 04/11/24 DOCKET NO. 17-47 346 DATE: April 11, 2024 ORDER Entitlement to service connection for bilateral hearing loss is denied. Entitlement to service connection for tinnitus is denied. FINDING OF FACT The Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus did not manifest in or shortly after service, there was no continuity of symptomatology from service to diagnosis, and his conditions are otherwise unrelated to service, to include in-service noise exposure. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The criteria for service connection for bilateral hearing loss have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 1112, 1113, 1131, 1137, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.303, 3.307, 3.309. 2. 2. The criteria for service connection for tinnitus have not been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1110, 1112, 1113, 1131, 1137, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.102, 3.303, 3.307, 3.309. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSIONS The Veteran served on active duty from March 1976 to July 1996. The matter is before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a May 2016 rating decision. In February 2021, the Veteran testified at a hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge, and a hearing transcript is of record. The Board denied the Veteran's claims for service connection for bilateral hearing loss and tinnitus in June 2022, and the Veteran timely appealed the denials to the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). Both parties filed a Joint Motion for Partial Remand (Joint Motion) and moved the Court to vacate the portion of the June 2022 decision that denied service connection for bilateral hearing loss and tinnitus and remand the matter for readjudication consistent with the Joint Motion. The Court granted the Joint Motion in March 2023, and the Board remanded the matter in July 2023 for a VA medical opinion. An adequate medical opinion was obtained in September 2023, as discussed below, and another remand is unnecessary. 1. Entitlement to service connection for bilateral hearing loss is denied. 2. Entitlement to service connection for tinnitus is denied. The Veteran seeks service connection for current hearing loss and tinnitus disorders related to military noise exposure in service. Because hearing loss and tinnitus are considered "chronic diseases" under 38 C.F.R. § 3.309(a), the Board analyzed entitlement to service connection on a direct and presumptive basis. 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.303(b), 3.307, 3.309(a). The Board finds, however, that service connection is not warranted on a presumptive or direct basis. His service treatment records are associated with the claims file and appear to be complete. They do not contain complaints of hearing issues or tinnitus. In March 1977, the reference audiogram shows the following levels for the right ear, in decibels: 20 (500 Hz); 15 (1000 Hz); 15 (2000 Hz); 10 (3000 Hz); and 0 (4000 Hz). It shows the following levels for the left ear, in decibels: 10 (500 Hz); 10 (1000 Hz); 10 (2000 Hz); 10 (3000 Hz); and 10 (4000 Hz). Audiograms were also conducted at re-enlistment in July 1979, October 1984, and September 1989. Those audiograms showed normal hearing for VA purposes. While the July 1979 and September 1989 audiogram showed the threshold was 30 decibels for the right ear at 6000 Hz, VA does not consider this level for hearing loss purposes and later audiograms in service showed improved results at 6000 Hz. An audiogram from March 1995 shows the following levels for the right ear, in decibels: 10 (500 Hz); 5 (1000 Hz); 0 (2000 Hz); 0 (3000 Hz); and 10 (4000 Hz). It shows the following levels for the left ear, in decibels: 10 (500 Hz); 0 (1000 Hz); 0 (2000 Hz); 0 (3000 Hz); and 0 (4000 Hz). A second audiogram from March 1995 shows the following levels for the right ear, in decibels: 5 (500 Hz); 0 (1000 Hz); 0 (2000 Hz); 0 (3000 Hz); and 5 (4000 Hz). It shows the following levels for the left ear, in decibels: 10 (500 Hz); 0 (1000 Hz); 0 (2000 Hz); 0 (3000 Hz); and 0 (4000 Hz). While threshold shifts were noted, they were documented as "better" versus "poorer." The Veteran underwent another audiogram at separation in June 1996. It shows the following levels for the right ear, in decibels: 20 (500 Hz); 15 (1000 Hz); 15 (2000 Hz); 10 (3000 Hz); and 0 (4000 Hz). It shows the following levels for the left ear, in decibels: 10 (500 Hz); 0 (1000 Hz); 0 (2000 Hz); 0 (3000 Hz); and 0 (4000 Hz). The separation examination noted "mild hearing loss;" however, these thresholds constitute normal hearing for VA purposes. 38 C.F.R. § 3.385. The Veteran also denied hearing loss and ear trouble on his July 1979 re-enlistment report of medical history, March 1995 periodic report of medical history, and June 1996 separation report of medical history. Post-service records do not show hearing loss or tinnitus complaints until his January 2016 claim. During the April 2016 VA audiological examination, which showed bilateral hearing loss and tinnitus, the Veteran reported that his tinnitus onset "a long time ago" but he could not give a specific date. He has not contended, including during the February 2021 Board hearing and in the May 2021 appellate brief, that he experienced tinnitus or hearing loss symptoms in service. After reviewing the evidence, to include the Veteran's lay statements and supporting buddy statement, the Board finds that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus are not entitled to presumptive service connection. As demonstrated by the wealth of service audiograms, he did not have chronic hearing loss in service or within one year after service. While the separation report of examination noted mild hearing loss, again, his results do not show hearing loss for VA compensation purposes and therefore do not constitute chronic manifestations of hearing loss in service. 38 C.F.R. § 3.385; Cf. McKinney v. McDonald, 28 Vet. App. 15, 23, 27-38 (2016) (finding "because hearing loss is not considered a "disability" unless the loss exceeds a certain threshold on an audiometric test, a minimum degree of hearing loss is a prerequisite for entitlement to disability compensation benefits."). In other words, "hearing loss" for VA purposes is different than the colloquial usage of the term "hearing loss," and it is even potentially different than an assessment of hearing loss as might be diagnosed by a competent health care provider. Furthermore, because the Veteran has not contended that he experienced hearing loss and tinnitus from service to diagnosis, service connection is not warranted based on a continuity of symptomatology. In short, the Board finds that the weight of the evidence shows that the conditions were not chronic in service, did not onset within one year after service, and there was no continuity of symptomatology from service to diagnosis, and presumptive service connection is not warranted. That does not end the inquiry. Service connection can still be granted on a direct basis for a disability that begins after service if it is related to an in-service disease or injury. The Board finds, however, that the evidence does not demonstrate that his hearing loss or tinnitus is related to the in-service noise exposure. In addition to the Veteran's service records, lay statements made in service and during the appeal, and the significant period between separation and diagnosis, the Board also relied on the November 2021 and September 2023 VA medical opinions. Per the Board's remand, the AOJ obtained an addendum medical opinion in November 2021. After a thorough review of the claims file, to include the attorney's arguments, service treatment records, and post-service records, the examiner concluded the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus did not begin in service and are not related to service. The examiner noted that every service audiogram showed normal hearing, except for a transient right ear threshold of 30 decibels at 6000 Hz in 1979. The examiner did not address the similar results from 1989 but, as discussed infra, this result was also transient and was improved in subsequent audiograms. In response to the questions asked by the Board in its remand, the examiner opined that "no significant or permanent hearing threshold shifts or hearing loss were noted to have occurred at any frequency in either ear during veteran's active-duty military service." The examiner cited to the normal hearing thresholds at entrance and separation and concluded "no noise induced hearing loss occurred in either ear while on active duty." The examiner specifically addressed the shifts between the March 1995 and June 1996 audiograms and stated they "are irrelevant" because the March 1995 audiogram "is not considered to be the veteran's baseline audiogram, and so comparisons between the two examinations other than for trending purposes are not reasonable or valid." The examiner further stated that "when compared to veteran's enlistment and baseline audiogram, veteran's separation audiogram is considered to be within test-retest reliability." The examiner noted the shift at 500 Hz in the right ear and stated the shift "is not considered to be significant given the length of time between 1976 and 1996 (20 years) and due ot the organization and physiology of the inner ear." Additionally, "500 Hz is not considered to be a threshold that is sensitive to the negative effects of hazardous noise exposure, and this threshold remained within normal limits (20dB)." The examiner explained that "the generally accepted mechanism of inner hair cell damage from acoustic trauma finds a sound wave would have to pass areas of higher frequency hearing to reach 500 Hz and if damage did not occur at higher frequencies affected earlier by the sound wave, it would stand to reason damage would not occur at the lower frequencies affected later by the soundwave." Finally, the examiner noted that the Veteran had normal hearing at 500 Hz in the right ear at the 2016 VA examination, 40 years after separation from service. The examiner also addressed the notation of "mild hearing loss" at separation and opined that it was "in error" as all thresholds documented on his separation physical are well within all accepted definitions of "normal hearing." She stated that "a mild hearing loss is defined as a threshold range equal from 26dB to 44dB," and the Veteran's thresholds at separation were documented as 20dB and lower. The examiner cited to the Institute of Medicine (2006) study that there was insufficient scientific basis to conclude that permanent hearing loss directly attributable to noise exposure will develop long after noise exposure but that the panel concluded a delayed onset of noise-induced hearing loss was "unlikely." Thus, the examiner concluded that, based on the objective evidence and cited literature, there was no evidence to conclude that the Veteran's current hearing loss is related to service. The Board also notes that the Veteran denied hearing loss symptoms in service and at separation; thus, the lay evidence weighs against service connection as well. Regarding tinnitus, the examiner noted that there were no complaints of tinnitus or ringing in service, and the Veteran did not state his tinnitus onset in service. She stated that without evidence of an objectively verifiable noise injury, like hearing loss, significant hearing threshold shift, or other objective evidence of acoustic trauma, "the association between tinnitus and noise exposure does not exist." Because there is no such evidence to support an association, the examiner concluded the Veteran's tinnitus was less likely than not related to his noise exposure in service. Following the Joint Motion, the Board remanded the matter for the November 2021 VA examiner to address the March 1995 service audiogram remarks that a baseline was reestablished after the negative threshold shift. In September 2023, the examiner reiterated that, in her previous opinion, she determined there were no significant hearing loss or permanent hearing threshold shifts at any frequency in either ear for the entire service period. The examiner considered the March 1995 notation that a baseline was reestablished after the negative threshold shift but opined that it is irrelevant because the improved results were clearly transient in nature and possibly due to equipment recalibration or tester error. The examiner concluded that the Veteran's results show normal hearing at entrance, a temporary improvement during service, and a return to his (still normal) entrance levels. She emphasized that his hearing thresholds at separation were the same as his hearing thresholds at entrance, a key factor in the analysis, and the evidence simply does not show that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus are related to in-service noise exposure. In short, the June 1996 results are not evidence of a noise injury. The Board finds that the medical opinions, together, are highly probative and very persuasive. The examiner thoroughly reviewed the records, including the audiograms, and addressed the Veteran's arguments and favorable evidence. The examiner supported her conclusions with a detailed rationale grounded in current science and medical literature. Her conclusions are also supported by the Veteran's similar hearing thresholds at service entrance and separation despite twenty years between the evaluations, which in turn weighs against evidence of a noise injury in service. Although there is no requirement hearing loss be demonstrated during service, the examiner also addressed whether the post-service diagnosis was related to service. After reviewing the persuasive lay and medical evidence, the Board finds that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus are not related to his in-service noise exposure. In particular, the Board found his service treatment records and statements made therein, and VA medical opinions, to be especially probative. Accordingly, the Board finds that the Veteran's hearing loss and tinnitus are not related to service and the claims for service connection are denied. MICHELLE L. KANE Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board M. Lavan The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.