Citation Nr: 25004732 Decision Date: 04/08/25 Archive Date: 04/08/25 DOCKET NO. 16-46 024 DATE: April 8, 2025 ORDER Entitlement to a total disability rating based on individual unemployability (TDIU) from January 14, 2017 on an extraschedular basis due to service-connected sleep apnea is denied. FINDING OF FACT From January 14, 2017, the Veteran's service-connected sleep apnea alone does not prevent him from obtaining or retaining substantially gainful employment. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for TDIU from January 14, 2017 are not met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5102, 5103, 5103A, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.340, 3.341, 4.16, 4.18, 4.19. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from November 1982 to November 1997. This matter comes to the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a July 2012 rating decision and an August 2016 Decision Review Officer decision. In a January 2019 decision, the Board determined that the issue of entitlement to a TDIU rating had been raised in an October 2016 notice of disagreement (NOD) in connection with claims previously on appeal at the time pursuant to Rice v Shinseki, 22, Vet. App. 447 (2009), and the Board remanded the issue of TDIU, as well as the Veteran's service-connection claim for sleep apnea, to the RO for additional development. In a May 2020 decision, the Board denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea and entitlement to a TDIU rating prior to April 2, 2013. The Veteran appealed the May 2020 decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). In a May 2021 Order, the Court vacated the portion of the Board's decision that denied entitlement to a TDIU rating prior to April 2, 2013; found that the issue of entitlement to a TDIU from April 2, 2013 was moot; and denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea as secondary to the Veteran's service-connected back disability and remanded the matter to the Board for development consistent with the parties' Joint Motion for Partial Remand. In May 2022, the Board remanded the issues of entitlement to a TDIU and secondary service connection for sleep apnea. In December 2022, the Decision Review Operations Center (DROC) granted service connection for sleep apnea. In a February 2023 decision and remand, the Board denied entitlement to a TDIU prior to January 14, 2017, and remanded the issue of entitlement to a TDIU on an extraschedular basis from January 14, 2017, to be referred to the Director of the Compensation and Pension Service for consideration of an extraschedular TDIU award based solely on the Veteran's service-connected sleep apnea from January 14, 2017, in accordance with 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b). In June 2023, the Board again remanded the Veteran's claim of TDIU from January 14, 2017 on an extraschedular basis for evidentiary development. The Veteran's claims folder returned to the Board, and in October 2024, the Board again remanded the claim for compliance with the prior remand instructions, in particular for the AOJ to issue a supplemental statement of the case (SSOC) adjudicating entitlement to TDIU from January 14, 2017. The Board notes that such was accomplished by the AOJ and there has been compliance with the prior remand instructions. Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998). The Veteran's claims folder has returned to the Board for further appellate consideration. TDIU from January 14, 2017 The Veteran contends that he is entitled to TDIU from January 14, 2017 on an extraschedular basis due solely to his service-connected sleep apnea. Under the applicable criteria, total disability ratings for compensation based upon individual unemployability may be assigned where the schedular rating is less than total, when it is found that the disabled person is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of a single service-connected disability ratable at 60 percent or more, or as a result of two or more disabilities, provided at least one disability is ratable at 40 percent or more and there is sufficient additional service-connected disability to bring the combined rating to 70 percent or more. See 38?C.F.R. §§?3.340, 3.341, 4.16(a). It is the established policy of VA that all Veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled. The central inquiry is "whether a Veteran's service- connected disabilities alone are of sufficient severity to produce unemployability." See Hatlestad v. Brown, 5?Vet. App.?524, 529 (1993). Also, in?Ray?v. Wilkie,?31?Vet. App.?58,66?(2019), the Court interpreted and defined the phrase "unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation" in § 4.16 to encompass two components: one economic and one noneconomic. See?31?Vet. App.?58, 72?(2019). The Court held the economic component "simply means an occupation earning more than marginal income (outside of a protected environment) as determined by the U.S. Department of Commerce as the poverty threshold for one person."? Id. at 73. The Court has defined "employment in a protected environment" within 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 to unambiguously mean "a lower-income position that, due to the [V]eteran's service-connected disability or disabilities, is shielded in some respect from competition in the employment market." LaBruzza v. McDonough, 37 Vet. App. 111, 123-24 (2024). The sole fact that a claimant is unemployed or has difficulty obtaining employment is not enough. A high rating in itself is recognition that the impairment makes it difficult to obtain or keep employment. The ultimate question, however, is whether a Veteran is capable of performing the physical and mental acts required by employment, not whether he or she can find employment. Van Hoose, 4?Vet. App.?at 363. The Veteran's sleep apnea is rated 50 percent disabling. He therefore does not meet the percentage requirements set forth in 38?C.F.R. §?4.16(a), for award of a schedular TDIU. However,?38?C.F.R. §?4.16(b) provides that all Veterans who do not meet the schedular criteria for?TDIU?but are otherwise unable to secure and follow substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be referred to the Director, Compensation and Pension Service, for consideration of an?extraschedular?rating of unemployability. To determine whether referral is necessary, the Board must consider whether there is sufficient evidence to substantiate a reasonable possibility that a Veteran is unemployable because of service-connected disabilities and whether?TDIU?benefits are warranted because service-connected disabilities render the Veteran unemployable. See Snider v. McDonough,?35?Vet. App.?1, 8-9?(2021).? The Board acknowledges a February 2024 Memorandum from the Director of Compensation who determined after review of the record that the evidence failed to support the contention that the Veteran's service-connected sleep apnea alone prevented gainful employment from January 14, 2017. The Board is not bound by the Director's opinion as to an extraschedular rating but, instead, must consider and weigh the evidence. As the referral has already been completed, the Board can now address the merits of the TDIU claim. The Board notes that the Veteran is 61 years old, and he reported last working full time in 2017 as a warehouse supervisor. His highest level of education is completion of high school. See, e.g., the Veteran's February 2020 TDIU claim. The Board finds that from January 14, 2017, the Veteran's service-connected sleep apnea alone does not prevent him from obtaining substantial and gainful employment. The Board acknowledges a March 2019 VA sleep apnea examination report wherein the examiner noted that the Veteran's sleep apnea would affect employment inasmuch that the Veteran would be fatigued and irritable and would not feel like working. However, while "significant" obstructive sleep apnea was initially reported during the examination, the examiner later noted review of a September 2011 CPAP study that showed an apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) of 13 which the examiner placed in a "mild" category for sleep apnea. Moreover, the examiner noted during the March 2019 VA examination that the severity of the sleep apnea was not greater than the baseline. Further, the Veteran reported during a June 2023 VA treatment evaluation that his insomnia was due to his back and neck pain rather than the sleep apnea. The remainder of VA treatment records associated with the claims folder do not indicate that the Veteran's sleep apnea affected substantial and gainful employment to the extent that he would be precluded from such. On the contrary, the VA treatment records indicate the Veteran was independent in his activities of daily living and only occasionally depends on his wife for driving. See, e.g., a VA treatment record dated November 2020. Indeed, on his February 2020 TDIU claim, he did not identify sleep apnea as a disability that precluded substantial and gainful employment. Accordingly, while the medical and lay evidence from January 14, 2017 indicates some occupational impairment, it does not indicate that the Veteran is unable to secure gainful employment due to his sleep apnea disability alone. The Board is also cognizant that the Veteran's education was limited to completion of high school. However, even with this educational background, the evidence simply does not show that the Veteran would be unable to work in any form of substantial gainful employment, to include employment as a warehouse supervisor, as a result of his sleep apnea alone. Indeed, there is no indication in the examination reports or other evidence of record that there are any restrictions on the Veteran's ability to accomplish tasks in either a physical or sedentary setting as a result of the service-connected sleep apnea such that he would not be able to maintain substantial gainful employment. (Continued on the next page) ? Accordingly, the Board finds that the evidence weighs against the Veteran's claim of entitlement to TDIU on an extraschedular basis from January 14, 2017 due to sleep apnea. The benefit sought on appeal is denied. T. Raymond Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Arif Syed, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.