Citation Nr: 25005585 Decision Date: 04/24/25 Archive Date: 04/24/25 DOCKET NO. 19-12 118 DATE: April 24, 2025 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran has active service from May 1968 to April 1970. This matter is before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from a December 2018 rating decision issued by a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). In December 2012, the Veteran testified at a hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge; the transcript is of record. This matter was remanded in July 2022. In January 2023, the Board denied the claim. The Veteran appealed the denial to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). Per a January 2024 Joint Motion for Remand (JMR) and Court Order, the Board's decision was vacated and remanded for action consistent with the JMR. Per the January 2024 JMR, the August 2022 examiner failed to address the Veteran's reports of snoring in service, noting only in-service difficulty sleeping. The matter was again remanded in May 2024 for an addendum opinion that addressed the lay statements by the Veteran and whether his sleep apnea is due to his PTSD medications. Although additional medical opinions were obtained, for reasons set forth below, the medical evidence of record is not sufficient for the Board to make a decision as to this appeal. Additional remand is required. Service Connection for Sleep Apnea. The Veteran has claimed entitlement to service connection for his diagnosed sleep apnea, claiming it is secondary to his PTSD (02/26/2019 NOD). His testimony suggests that his PTSD symptoms contribute to his sleep apnea, to include nightmares and fighting in his sleep (12/07/2021 Hearing Transcript, pg. 5). He also testified that his sleep apnea began during service, citing to in-service complaints that he snored loudly (12/07/2021 Hearing Transcript, pg. 4). Additionally, the record confirms the Veteran's in-service exposure to TERA, to include herbicide agent exposure (06/17/2021 VA Memo). Thus, the record has suggested a theory of entitlement for sleep apnea associated with herbicide agent exposure. Medical evidence of record includes a number of VA examinations with accompanying opinions, as well as record review and addendum opinions as to the nature and etiology of the Veteran's sleep apnea. As outlined in the January 2024 JMR and Board remands, medical evidence of record prior to May 2024 was inadequate for the Board to render a decision on this appeal. A June 2024 record review was conducted. It is noted that an attempt had been made to contact the Veteran but he was not available (06/30/2024 C&P Exam). As such, the June 2024 opinions were based on a record review, without patient interview or in-person examination. After a review of the record, the June 2024 VA examiner provided a negative nexus opinion as to direct service connection. The examiner explained that the reported symptoms of trouble sleeping, not getting enough sleep, snoring, tiredness, and nonspecific symptoms could be attributed to multiple medical diagnoses. The examiner concluded the reported cluster of symptoms are not diagnostic of obstructive sleep apnea, emphasizing that there is no mention in service treatment record of reported apnea during sleep. The examiner explained that sleep apnea is due to dynamic narrowing of the upper airway such as the closure of the oral pharynx during sleep. Risk factors noted were excess weight, neck circumference, being male, being older, having a family history, use of alcohol, sedatives, or tranquilizers, and smoking. The examiner emphasized the Veteran's service treatment records do not include complaints, treatment, or diagnosis for sleep apnea, and the absence of a longitudinal relationship between military service and his current sleep apnea. Further, the Veteran's sleep apnea diagnosis occurred more than 45 years after release from active duty. VA also obtained an opinion as to whether the Veteran's sleep apnea was related to conceded herbicide agent exposure (06/30/2024 C&P Exam). The examiner provided a negative nexus opinion. After reviewing all medical evidence, and citing to a number of articles, the examiner opined it is less likely than not (likelihood is less than approximately balanced or nearly equal) that sleep apnea proximately due to or the indicated toxic exposure risk activity, after considering the total potential exposure through all applicable military deployments of the Veteran and the synergistic combined effect of all toxic exposure risk activities. The examiner stated that it is not possible to attribute sleep apnea to any one or group of different risk factors without completely speculating, relying on the absence of medical records attributing his sleep apnea to TERA. The examiner did not explain what additional information or knowledge is necessary to overcome the need to speculate. The examiner also considered whether the Veteran's PTSD medications caused sleep apnea. After reviewing all medical evidence, the examiner provided a negative nexus opinion that sleep apnea is proximately due to or caused by medications taken for Veteran's service-connected PTSD. It was explained that it is not possible to attribute sleep apnea to any one or group of different risk factors without completely speculating. At no point in the Veteran's entire e-file was sleep apnea attributed to medications taken for PTSD. The examiner concluded that based on the lack of evidence to support the claim, the Veteran's sleep apnea, is less likely than not that proximately due to or caused by medications taken for PTSD. The examiner relied primarily on a lack of medical evidence within the record as the rationale for the negative nexus opinions as to TERA and PTSD medication, and did not provide a full medically explained reason for the opinions. It is well settled that the medical examiner cannot rely on the absence of medical records corroborating that injury to conclude that there is no relationship between the Veteran's current disability and active service. See Dalton v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 23, 40 (2007). See also Horn v. Shinseki, 25 Vet. App. 231, 239 (2012) (the absence of evidence is not substantive negative evidence). Accordingly, the Board finds the medical opinions inadequate because the conclusion was not supported with an analysis that the Board can consider and weigh against contrary opinions. See Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. at 124. Further, although medical literature identifying other risk factors not related to PTSD or TERA, the examiner did not explain which of, or whether, those risk factors applied to the Veteran, resulting in his sleep apnea as opposed to other theories of entitlement. See also Bailey v. O'Rourke, 30 Vet. App. 54, 60 (2018) (an examiner cannot simply make a generic statement that medical literature does not show an association between two conditions) (a medical opinion based solely on general medical literature without discussion of the veteran's individual circumstances is inadequate). Further, the June 2024 examiner provided an opinion that the Veteran's sleep apnea clearly and unmistakably existed prior to service and was clearly and unmistakably not aggravated beyond its natural progression by an in-service injury, event or illness. The examiner's statement that the Veteran's sleep apnea existed prior to service is in conflict with other opinions, notably that there were no symptoms during service, with diagnosis being 45 years post service (06/30/2024 C&P Exam). Of specific concern in this regard is that the Veteran did not report sleep disturbance on his entrance physical (09/21/2016 STR - Medical, pg. 6). Thus, the internal, factual conflict prevents the Board from relying on these opinions, because it is not clear that the examiner formulated the opinions based upon a factually accurate assessment of the Veteran's medical history and record. Because the opinions were provided based on a record review, and without an in-person examination, it is paramount that associated opinions are grounded in an accurate review of the record. An opinion based upon an inaccurate factual premise has no probative value. Reonal v. Brown, 5 Vet. App. 458, 461 (U.S. 1993). Once VA undertakes the effort to provide an examination when developing a claim, the examination must be an adequate one. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 311 (2007). Finding the opinions obtained since the last remand are not adequate, regrettably, remand is again required. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: Schedule the Veteran for an examination by an appropriately qualified clinician to determine the nature and etiology of the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea. Following a review of the relevant evidence, to include the claims file, service treatment records, post-service treatment records, and the Veteran's testimony, the clinician should provide an opinion as to whether the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea is approximately at least as likely as not (i.e., a likelihood of at least close to 50 percent or more) related to an in-service injury, event, or disease, to include conceded exposure to TERA (herbicide agent exposure). Additionally, the clinician should address whether it is at least as likely as not that the Veteran's sleep apnea is proximately due to service-connected PTSD, or has been aggravated beyond its natural progression by service-connected PTSD, to include medication prescribed for PTSD. If aggravation is found, the examiner should estimate a baseline level of disability prior to such aggravation. The clinician should also address the Veteran's testimony as to fellow service members complaining of his snoring during service and his nightmares and fighting in his sleep. The examiner should address whether these are symptoms of sleep apnea. The examiner should clarify the June 2024 opinion that the Veteran's sleep apnea clearly and unmistakably existed prior to his service, and clearly and unmistakably was not aggravated prior to service. The examiner is reminded to consider the Veteran's lay reports, and a reason must be provided if the Veteran's lay reports are rejected. Lay statements cannot be rejected solely due to a lack of medical documentation. If there is a medical reason to accept or not accept the Veteran's contentions, to include described snoring in service, the examiner should provide them. If the absence of medical documentation is relevant, the relevance must be explained because the absence of evidence is not positive evidence of the existence or non-existence of an event. The examiner should reconcile any conflicting medical evidence of record to the extent possible. If the examiner is able to gather additional understanding or information regarding the circumstances surrounding any inservice injury or event, the examiner should include that information in his remarks. The examiner must provide all findings, along with a complete rationale for his or her opinion(s) in the examination report. If any of the above requested opinions cannot be made without resort to speculation, the examiner must state this and explain why this is so, (e.g., whether an opinion is beyond what any medical practitioner might be able to provide, based on the evidence of record and current medical knowledge). Eric S. Leboff Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Myers, Pamella The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.