Citation Nr: A25035305 Decision Date: 04/16/25 Archive Date: 04/16/25 DOCKET NO. 241016-483305 DATE: April 16, 2025 ORDER Readjudication of the claim for entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea is granted. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea, as secondary to service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, is granted. FINDING OF FACTS 1. New and relevant evidence has been received with respect to the claim for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea. 2. Resolving reasonable doubt in the Veteran's favor, the Veteran's obstructive sleep apnea is at least as likely as not due to his service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, with obesity as an intermediate step. CONCLUSION OF LAW 1. The criteria for readjudicating the claim for entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea are met. 38 U.S.C. § 5108; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.2500, 3.2501. 2. The criteria for entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea are met. 38?U.S.C. § 5107; 38 C.F.R. § 3.310. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from February 1973 until honorable discharge in February 1997. The Veteran first filed a claim related to obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) in August 2022, via VA Form 21-526EZ, Fully Developed Claim. In a November 2022 rating decision issued by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO), acting as the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ), the claim was denied. The Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) automatically applies to all claims for which VA issues notice of an initial decision on or after February 19, 2019. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.2400 (a)(1). The November 2022 rating decision constitutes an initial decision, and the AMA applies. Subsequently, in June 2023, the Veteran filed VA Form 20-0995, Supplemental Claim Application, requesting readjudication of the claim for service connection for OSA. In a supplemental claim decision issued October 25, 2023, the AOJ denied the claim, indicating that new and relevant evidence had not been received, and thus the claim would not be readjudicated. The AOJ continued the previous denial. On October 16, 2024, the Veteran (through counsel) filed a VA Form 10182, Decision Review Request: Board Appeal (Notice of Disagreement (NOD)). The Veteran elected to place this appeal on the Direct Review docket. As a valid and timely VA Form 10182 was received, the appeal is properly before the Board. The Board may only consider the evidence of record at the time of the October 2023 AOJ supplemental claim decision on appeal. 38 C.F.R. § 20.301. If evidence was submitted after the AOJ issued the supplemental claim decision on appeal, the Board did not consider it in its decision. 38 C.F.R. §§ 20.300, 20.301, 20.801. If the Veteran would like VA to consider any evidence that was submitted that the Board could not consider, the Veteran may file a Supplemental Claim (VA Form 20-0995) and submit or identify this evidence. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501. If the evidence is new and relevant, VA will issue another decision on the claim, considering the new evidence in addition to the evidence previously considered. Id. Specific instructions for filing a Supplemental Claim are included with this decision. New and Relevant Evidence A claimant may continuously pursue a claim or issue by filing a supplemental claim following notice of a decision by the AOJ or the Board. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2500(c). If new and relevant evidence is presented or secured with respect to the supplemental claim, the RO will readjudicate the claim, taking into consideration all of the evidence of record. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501. When determining whether new and relevant evidence has been received, "new" evidence is evidence not part of the record at the time of the last decision on the issue. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501(a)(1). In other words, potentially new and relevant evidence is limited to (i) the evidence associated with the record since the issuance of the last decision on the issue through the issuance of the supplemental claim decision on appeal, and (ii) any evidence submitted by the appellant or representative during an applicable evidentiary window on the Evidence Submission or Hearing docket, if applicable. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501 "Relevant" evidence means evidence that tends to prove or disprove a matter at issue. The "new and relevant" standard will not impose a higher evidentiary threshold than the previous "new and material" evidence standard applicable to Legacy appeals. Id. New and relevant evidence must be presented or secured with respect to a supplemental claim to warrant readjudication of the issue. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501. This holds true regardless of whether the last decision on the issue is final or whether the supplemental claim is received within one year of the last decision. See id. Service Connection Service connection may be granted for a disability resulting from disease or injury incurred in or aggravated by active service. 38?U.S.C. §§?1110, 1131, 5107; 38?C.F.R. §?3.303. The three-element test for service connection requires evidence of: (1)?a current disability; (2)?in-service incurrence or aggravation of a disease or injury; and (3) a causal relationship between the current disability and the in-service disease or injury. Shedden v. Principi, 381 F.3d 1163, 1166 -67 (Fed. Cir. 2004).??? Service connection may be established on a secondary basis for a disability that is proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disability. 38?C.F.R. §?3.310(a). To establish secondary service connection there must be evidence: (1) of a current disability (for which secondary service connection is sought); (2) of an already service-connected disability; and (3) that the current disability for which service connection is sought was either (a) caused or (b) aggravated by the service-connected disability. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310 (a); see Allen v. Brown, 7?Vet. App.?439 (1995) (en banc).??? The Federal Circuit Court has held that VA has a duty to consider all theories of entitlement when determining eligibility for compensation. Szemraj v. Principi,?357 F.3d 1370, 1373?(Fed. Cir. 2004); See also Robinson v. Shinseki,?557 F.3d 1355, 1361?(Fed. Cir. 2009) (VA is required to consider all theories of entitlement raised either by the claimant or by the evidence of record as part of the non-adversarial administrative adjudication process). Adequacy of Medical Opinions When VA undertakes to provide a medical opinion, it must be adequate. Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 312 (2007). Any medical opinion which the Board considers for adjudicative purposes must support its conclusions with an analysis that the Board can consider and weigh against contrary opinions. Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 120, 124 (2007). 1. Readjudication of the claim for entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea is granted. Along with the June 2023 Supplemental Claim form, the Veteran submitted a private medical opinion from K. M., APRN, concerning the link between the Veteran's previously service-connected disabilities of left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur. This opinion was not previously a part of the record, and it certainly tends to prove or disprove a matter at issue. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501. Additionally, while stating that it would not readjudicate the claim for a lack of new and relevant evidence, the AOJ nonetheless readjudicated the claim. The AOJ obtained new medical examinations and opinions concerning the possible link between the Veteran's participation in toxic exposure risk activities (TERAs) during service and his diagnosed OSA, as well as an opinion regarding secondary service connection for his diagnosed OSA. See VA Medical Examination, August 2023; VA Medical Opinion, rendered August 2023; VA Medical Opinion, rendered October 2023. The AOJ utilized these examinations in its October 2023 supplemental claim decision. This readjudication by the AOJ constitutes a favorable finding that new and relevant evidence was received. The Board is bound by the AOJ's favorable findings, absent clear and unmistakable error (CUE). 38 C.F.R. § 3.104(c). This finding is supported by the evidentiary record. There is no CUE present, and the Board will not upset the AOJ's findings. Thus, new and relevant evidence was received and readjudication of the claim for service connection for OSA is granted. 38 C.F.R. § 3.2501. 2. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea, as secondary to service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, is granted. The Veteran contends that he is entitled to service connection for OSA as secondary to his previously service-connected disabilities of left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur. Statement in Support of Claim, June 2023; Argument of Counsel, October 2024. Specifically, the Veteran contends that his musculoskeletal disabilities have contributed to his obesity, and that his obesity in turn has contributed to his OSA. Id. As a preliminary matter, the Board notes that the AOJ made favorable findings in the October 2023 supplemental claim decision that are relevant: the AOJ found that the Veteran has a diagnosed disability of sleep apnea, and the AOJ conceded that the Veteran's service in Southwest Asia constituted participation in a TERA. The Board is bound by the AOJ's favorable findings, absent clear and unmistakable error (CUE).?38 C.F.R. § 3.104?(c). These findings are supported by the evidentiary record. There is no CUE present, and the Board will not upset the AOJ's findings. Direct Service Connection Looking to the elements of direct service connection, the first element is met; the Veteran has a diagnosed disability of OSA. VA Treatment Record, March 2022; VA Medical Examination, August 2023; AOJ Favorable Finding, October 2023. The second element, in-service incurrence or aggravation, or an event or injury that could constitute such, is not met. The Veteran's service treatment records are silent as to the condition or to any event or injury that could give rise to the condition. Indeed, while the Veteran has stated that the condition has existed since the 1980s (which would have been during military service), the Veteran gives no indication as to an event or injury during this timeframe that caused his OSA. As stated, the Veteran contends that it is his previously service-connected musculoskeletal conditions that led to his obesity, that causes his OSA. The privat medical opinion of K. M., APRN, submitted by the Veteran, does not contend that there was an in-service incurrence or aggravation of the OSA. Thus, the evidentiary record is silent as to an in-service incurrence or aggravation of the claimed OSA, and therefore, service connection on this theory of entitlement is not warranted. Secondary Service Connection Looking to the elements of secondary service connection, the first element is met. the Veteran has a diagnosed disability of OSA. VA Treatment Record, March 2022; VA Medical Examination, August 2023; AOJ Favorable Finding, October 2023. The second element is also met; the Veteran's claimed primary disabilities of left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur both have an effective date of service connection of March 1997. The remaining question for the Board is the third element, a causal link between the Veteran's claimed OSA and his previously service-connected musculoskeletal disabilities. The Board notes that obesity may function as an "intermediate step" in establishing entitlement to secondary service connection. VAOPGCPREC 1-2017 (Jan. 6, 2017); Walsh v. Wilkie, 32?Vet. App.?300, 307 (2020) (addressing entitlement to secondary service connection for hypertension and sleep apnea with obesity serving as an "intermediate step" between those conditions and the primary service-connected condition). The record contains evidence for and against a finding that the Veteran's OSA is related to the previously service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, with obesity as an intermediary step. In a private medical opinion, dated June 2023, K. M., APRN, states: [I]t is at least as likely as not...that the veteran's weight gain and obesity is due to and/or related to his service-connected conditions to include Left Knee Arthritis Status Post Total Knee Replacement and Right Foot Bone Spur; it is at least as likely as not...that the Veteran's Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA) is secondary to, related to, and/or aggravated by the weight gain and obesity from the service-connected Left Knee Arthritis Status Post Total Knee Replacement and Right Foot Bone Spur; and it is at least as likely as not...that without the veteran's weight gain and obesity his Obstructive Sleep Apnea with Maxillofacial Prosthesis condition would not have occurred. This opinion is supported by references to the Veteran's specific medical history and reported symptomology as well as citations to medical publications that illustrate the link between pain from musculoskeletal disabilities, obesity, and OSA. Medical Opinion of K. M., APRN, June 2023. K. M., APRN, lays out the causal link from the Veteran's service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur pain, to a more sedentary lifestyle, to the Veteran's development of obesity, to the medical consensus that obesity is a high risk factor for OSA, to the conclusion that absent the Veteran's weight gain related to the service-connected musculoskeletal disabilities, the Veteran would not have developed OSA. Medical Opinion of K. M., APRN, June 2023. As this opinion cites directly to the Veteran's reported symptomology, which is consistent with the medical record before the Board, and as this opinion provides a cogent, detailed rationale, complete with citations to applicable medical literature, the Board affords this opinion significant probative weight. As to evidence against finding a causal link between the Veteran's service-connected disabilities and the claimed OSA, VA medical examiners have opined that no such causal link exists. The Veteran underwent two VA medical examinations. The first examination, in September 2022, confirmed the Veteran's diagnosis of OSA; there was no medical opinion associated with this examination. The second examination, in August 2023, also confirmed the Veteran's diagnosis of OSA. There were two medical opinions associated with the August 2023 examination. In the first opinion, rendered in August 2023, the VA examiner opined that it was less likely than not that the Veteran's OSA was a result of the claimed primary musculoskeletal disabilities. The examiner reasoned that the Veteran was obese prior to the left knee replacement surgery, and therefore the knee replacement surgery could not have caused the Veteran's weight gain. VA Medical Opinion, August 2023. The VA examiner continued, "[c]onsideration should be given to the fact that patient did have obesity issues prior to leaving service. [Patient] was also with severe knee problems proven by xrays well prior to leaving service. This would at least as likely as not have eventually caused his sleep apnea." VA Medical Opinion, August 2023. This opinion is inadequate for adjudicative purposes. First, the rationale fails to consider that it is not only the left knee replacement that is service-connected, but also the underlying factors that led to the need for a knee replacement that are service connected. i.e., the opinion does not consider that the knee pain that led to the need for the Veteran to undergo a knee replacement may have led to his obesity as well. It is not relevant that the Veteran's obesity predated the knee surgery if the same facts that led to the need for a knee replacement, which were found to be service-connected, also led to the Veteran's obesity, and subsequently his OSA. This is not considered or discussed in this opinion. Second, the VA examiner makes no mention of the Veteran's bone spur and does not appear to consider this condition at all. Finally, it is unclear from the opinion if the statement, "[t]his would at least as likely as not have eventually caused his sleep apnea," indicates a positive finding, that the Veteran's obesity during service as well as severe knee problems, would eventually have caused the Veteran's OSA, or if the examiner is trying to say that the obesity alone, incurred during service, but not necessarily service-connected, would have eventually caused the Veteran's OSA. The Board cannot determine what this statement intends to assert. For these reasons, the Board cannot consider and weigh the conclusions of the August 2023 VA Medical Opinion against contrary opinions. See Stefl supra. Accordingly, the Board finds that this opinion is inadequate for adjudicative purposes and affords it no probative weight. The second VA medical opinion, rendered in October 2023, considers only whether the Veteran's OSA is related to his conceded TERA participation. The VA examiner found that it is less likely than not that the Veteran's OSA was caused by TERA participation. VA Medical Opinion, October 2023. The examiner reasoned that there is a lack of "conclusive evidence in medical literature to suggest that the TERA would directly result in OSA." VA Medical Opinion, October 2023. The examiner notes that OSA has several clinical risk factors, including older age, male sex, being overweight or obese, and craniofacial and upper airway abnormalities. VA Medical Opinion, October 2023. The VA examiner suggests, though does not explicitly state, that it is these risk factors, rather than TERA participation, that caused the Veteran's OSA. While this opinion does not offer a robust rationale that links any of the noted risk factors to this specific Veteran, it is nonetheless internally consistent and applies rational analysis. The Board can compare this opinion against contrary opinions. The Board affords this opinion some probative weight. The probative weight of the evidence indicates that the Veteran's OSA was not caused by TERA participation, but rather, was caused, or aggravated, by his previously service-connected disabilities of left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, which led to his obesity, which in turn led to his OSA. At a minimum, the Board finds that the evidence for and against the claim is in relative equipoise, and therefore, the benefit of the doubt doctrine applies. 38 U.S.C. § 5107; Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1?Vet. App.?49, 54 (1990). Accordingly, entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea, as secondary to service-connected left total knee replacement and right foot bone spur, is granted. Danette Mincey Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board A. T. Holtsclaw The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.