Citation Nr: A25035607 Decision Date: 04/17/25 Archive Date: 04/17/25 DOCKET NO. 240929-477992 DATE: April 17, 2025 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea, to include as secondary to service-connected pansinusitis and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with insomnia disorder, is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty from October 2003 to March 2005, and from October 2007 to February 2009. The Rating Decision on appeal was issued in August 2024 and constitutes an initial decision; therefore, the modernized review system, also known as the Appeals Modernization Act (AMA), applies. In the September 2024 VA Form 10182, Decision Review Request: Board Appeal (Notice of Disagreement), the Veteran elected the Direct Review docket and indicated appeal of the August 2024 Rating Decision. Therefore, the Board may only consider the evidence of record at the time of the August 2024 Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) decision on appeal. 38 C.F.R. § 20.301; Terry v. McDonough, 37 Vet. App. 1, 5, 11 (2023). Any evidence submitted after the AOJ decision on appeal cannot be considered by the Board. 38 C.F.R. §§ 20.300, 20.301, 20.801. However, because the Board is remanding the claim on appeal, any evidence the Board could not consider will be considered by the AOJ in the adjudication of that claim. 38 C.F.R. § 3.103(c)(2)(ii). The Board acknowledges the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) decision in Williams v. McDonough, 37 Vet. App. 305 (2024) that found under 38 C.F.R. § 20.202 (c)(2), the Board generally may not decide an appeal before the deadline for requesting an AMA docket switch has elapsed. In this case, as the Board is remanding all claims currently on appeal for additional development, the Board finds that failure to seek waiver of the Veteran's ability to switch dockets at this juncture is harmless. Here, by way of history, the Veteran initially filed a claim of entitlement to sleep apnea as secondary to service-connected sinusitis in July 2018. He was afforded a VA Sleep Apnea examination in August 2018, and the claim was denied by the AOJ in an August 2018 Rating Decision. Thereafter, the Veteran filed another claim of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea in November 2018, this time alleging that it developed secondary to his PTSD. A VA opinion was obtained in February 2019, and the AOJ reopened but then denied the claim on the merits in a March 2019 Rating Decision. The Veteran submitted a supplemental claim in November 2022, and another VA opinion was obtained in March 2023. However, the AOJ confirmed the previous denial of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea in an April 2023 Rating Decision, finding that new and relevant evidence had not been submitted in support of the claim. In response, in August 2023, the Veteran filed a VA Form 20-0996, Decision Review Request: Higher-Level Review, seeking review of the April 2023 Rating Decision. In a December 2023 Higher-Level Review Rating Decision, the AOJ identified a duty to assist error and indicated it would conduct additional development consistent with the "Honoring our PACT Act of 2022" and obtain additional VA examinations. The Veteran submitted another supplemental claim later that month, and was afforded another VA examination in January 2024. However, in the August 2024 Rating Decision on appeal, the AOJ confirmed and continued the previous denial of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea. The Board notes that the August 2024 Rating Decision implicitly found that new and relevant evidence had been received, as it denied the claim based on the merits. As such, the Board is bound by that implicit favorable finding and will also address the claim on the merits rather than determine whether new and relevant evidence has been received. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.104 (c). Under the AMA, the Board may only remand an issue for the correction of (1) duty to assist errors occurring prior to the date of the AOJ decision on appeal (i.e., pre-decisional duty to assist errors) and (2) AOJ errors in satisfying a regulatory or statutory duty, if correction of such error would have a reasonable possibility of aiding in substantiating the appellant's claim. See 38 C.F.R. § 20.802(a). Having reviewed the evidence of record, the Board finds that remand for pre-decisional duty to assist errors is required. The Veteran was afforded VA Sleep Apnea examinations in August 2018 and December 2023, at which time he was diagnosed as having obstructive sleep apnea. In a January 2024 VA opinion to address direct service connection, a clinician opined that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was less likely than incurred in or caused by an in-service injury, event, or illness. In support of this conclusion, the clinician explained that: Rationale is There are no notes from the Veteran's time in service showing symptoms or diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea during service. The earliest medical record in the e-folder noting symptoms of obstructive sleep apnea is in 2017. Therefore, it is less likely than not that the Veteran's obstructive sleep apnea was incurred in and/or caused during service. The Board finds that this opinion is inadequate. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 311 (2007) ("Once [VA] undertakes the effort to provide an examination when developing a service-connection claim . . . [VA] must provide an adequate one"). Although the VA clinician indicated that she reviewed the Veteran's claims file, the opinion contained no mention of symptoms documented in the Veteran's service treatment records which are commonly associated with sleep apnea. For instance, a March 2005 service treatment record indicated that the Veteran was "snoring loudly." Additionally, on a December 2005 Post-Deployment Health Reassessment, the Veteran reported "problems sleeping or still feeling tired after sleeping" following his return from deployment in Iraq. This lack of clarity frustrates judicial review. Indeed, the Board must consider only independent medical evidence to support its findings rather than provide its own medical judgment. See Colvin v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 171 (1991). As such, the examiner's failure to explicitly discuss the likelihood that documented in-service symptoms such as loud snoring as well as problems sleeping and/or still feeling tired after sleeping evinced the initial onset of the Veteran's later-diagnosed sleep apnea renders the opinion inadequate. Therefore, the AOJ's reliance on this opinion in the August 2024 Rating Decision on appeal constituted a pre-decisional duty to assist error. See 38 C.F.R. § 20.802(a). On remand, an adequate medical opinion should be obtained which discusses the loud snoring and sleeping difficulties documented in the service treatment records. Additionally, the Veteran raised the theory of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea as secondary to his service-connected PTSD with insomnia disorder. In a February 2019 VA opinion, the clinician concluded that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was less likely than not proximately due to or the result of the Veteran's service-connected PTSD. In support of this opinion, the examiner simply stated that, "UP TO DATE (VA MEDICAL RESEARCH TOOL) DOES NOT LIST PTSD AS A CAUSE OR AGGREVATING FACTOR OF OSA." The Board finds that this conclusory opinion is inadequate, as it failed to discuss the causes of sleep apnea (and how they apply or do not apply to this particular Veteran) and simply cited the absence of PTSD from a list as its only rationale. See Bailey v. O'Rourke, 30 Vet. App. 54, 60 (2018) (stating that a medical rationale based solely on general medical literature without discussing the specific facts pertaining to a veteran's condition or individual circumstances is inadequate); see also Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008); Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 120, 124 (2007) ("[A] medical opinion... must support its conclusion with an analysis that the Board can consider and weigh against contrary opinions."). Another VA opinion was obtained in January 2024, at which time the VA clinician concluded that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was less likely than not proximately due to or the result of the Veteran's service-connected PTSD with insomnia disorder. In support of her conclusion, this VA clinician explained that: Rationale is Although it has been seen that many people have both PTSD and sleep apnea, association does not prove causality. PTSD is neither a cause nor risk factor for the development for sleep apnea. Sleep apnea is a condition where the airway is narrowed during sleep resulting in decreased oxygen flow to the lungs. There is no mechanism where PTSD results in this narrowing of the airway. Therefore, it is less likely than not that the Veteran's sleep apnea is proximately due to or the result of post-traumatic stress disorder. However, the January 2024 VA clinician failed to provide an opinion as to the likelihood that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was aggravated by his service-connected PTSD with insomnia disorder. VA is required to address both causation and aggravation in adjudicating claims premised on secondary service connection theories of entitlement. See 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(b); see also El-Amin v. Shinseki, 26 Vet. App. 136, 140 (2013) (indicating that findings of "not caused by," and "not related to" a service-connected disability are insufficient to address the question of aggravation under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(b)). As such, the AOJ's reliance on these opinions in the August 2024 Rating Decision on appeal constituted a pre-decisional duty to assist error. See 38 C.F.R. § 20.802(a). Finally, the Veteran also claimed his OSA is secondary to his service-connected sinusitis. An August 2018 VA examiner opined that the Veteran's OSA is less likely as not related to his sinus condition, as he has no history of nasal trauma or pathology, normal sinus xrays, and no repeated medical studies relating a cause and effect relationship between sinusitis and OSA. However, like the other opinions of record, the August 2018 VA examiner did not provide adequate rationale for this opinion, nor did the examiner opine whether the Veteran's OSA is aggravated by his sinus condition. As such, the AOJ's reliance on the August 2018 VA opinion in denying the Veteran' claim was another pre-decisional duty to assist error. See 38 C.F.R. § 20.802(a). On remand, adequate opinions should be obtained to address the likelihood that the Veteran's OSA is directly related to service or that service-connected PTSD with insomnia disorder or pansinusitis either caused or aggravated his diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea. Such opinions must discuss the risk factors for development of sleep apnea and how these factors apply or do not apply to this Veteran's unique medical history and individual circumstances. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Forward the Veteran's claims file to a qualified clinician for opinions regarding the likely etiology of his diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea. The claims file must be made available for review and the clinician should indicate that review of the claims file was conducted. The need for an additional in-person examination of the Veteran is left to the discretion of the clinician. The VA clinician should furnish opinions with respect to the following questions: (a.) Whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was incurred in or otherwise caused by his active service, to include service in Southeast Asia. In rendering this opinion, the clinician is asked to explicitly discuss the March 2005 service treatment record which indicated that the Veteran was "snoring loudly" as well as the December 2005 Post-Deployment Health Reassessment in which the Veteran reported "problems sleeping or still feeling tired after sleeping" following his return from deployment in Iraq. The clinician is asked to discuss the likelihood that these documented in-service symptoms evinced the onset of the Veteran's later-diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea. (b.) Whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was caused by his service-connected pansinusitis or PTSD with insomnia. (c.) If not, whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea was aggravated (worsened) by his service-connected pansinusitis or PTSD with insomnia. The clinician is reminded that aggravation under 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(b) does not require that there be "permanent worsening" of the nonservice-connected disability. Instead, secondary service connection is warranted for any incremental increase in disability, meaning any additional impairment of earning capacity in nonservice-connected disabilities resulting from service-connected conditions, above the degree of disability existing before the increase regardless of its permanence. If an opinion cannot be provided without resorting to mere speculation, then the clinician should identify all medical and lay evidence considered in this conclusion, fully explain why this is the case, and identify what additional evidence (if any) would allow for a more definitive opinion. Such opinions must discuss the risk factors for development of sleep apnea and how these factors apply or do not apply to this Veteran's unique medical history and individual circumstances. The clinician is advised that the Veteran is competent to report his symptoms and history, and such reports must be specifically acknowledged and considered in formulating any opinions. If the clinician rejects the Veteran's reports, then he/she must provide an explanation for such rejection. The clinician is not to improperly discount the Veteran's lay statements or mistakenly rely on an absence of medical evidence in the record to support his/her conclusions. Tiffany Dawson Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Flamini, Anthony The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.