Citation Nr: A25035774 Decision Date: 04/17/25 Archive Date: 04/17/25 DOCKET NO. 240925-478457 DATE: April 17, 2025 ORDER An earlier effective date of August 19, 2021, for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea, is granted. FINDING OF FACT The Veteran's August 19, 2021, supplemental claim of entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea has been continuously pursued from the date of claim (August 19, 2021). CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for an earlier effective date of August 19, 2021, but no earlier, for the grant of service connection for obstructive sleep apnea, have been met. 38 U.S.C. § 5110; 38 C.F.R. § 3.400. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty from September 1989 to September 2009. This case is before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from an October 2023 Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) higher-level review rating decision. In that decision, the RO denied an earlier effective date for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea. In September 2024, VA received the Veteran's 10182 Notice of Disagreement (NOD). The Veteran elected the Direct Review docket. The Direct Review docket does not allow submission of any additional evidence in support of an appeal. Therefore, the Board may only consider the evidence of record at the time of the agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ) decision on appeal. 38 C.F.R. § 20.301. The October 2023 higher-level review rating decision was based on the evidence of record at the time of the underlying April 2023 rating decision for which the higher-level review was requested. Thus, as this is a Direct Review appeal, the record closed as of the April 2023 rating decision. Evidence added during an ineligible period will not be considered. Should the Veteran want VA to consider evidence submitted outside the eligible period, the Veteran should submit a VA Form 20-0995, Supplemental Claim, identifying such evidence. Earlier Effective Date An effective date for a reopened claim of entitlement to service connection can be no earlier than the date the request to reopen the claim was filed. See 38 U.S.C. § 5110; 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(r). There is no provision in either the statute or the regulations that allows for an earlier effective date based on a reopened claim unless a clear and unmistakable error was committed in a prior decision, or additional relevant service department records were received. See 38 U.S.C. § 5110; 38 C.F.R. §§ 3.105, 3.156(c). Pursuant to 38 U.S.C. § 5110(a)(1), the effective date of an award based on an initial claim, or a supplemental claim of compensation shall be fixed in accordance with the facts found but shall not be earlier than the date of receipt of application thereof. For purposes of determining the effective date of an award under this section, the date of application shall be considered the date of the filing of the initial application for a benefit if the claim is continuously pursued by filing a Supplemental Claim under section 5108 of this title on or before the date that is one year after the date on which the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims issues a decision. 38 U.S.C. § 5110(b); 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(1). 1. Entitlement to an effective date earlier than August 10, 2022, for service connection for obstructive sleep apnea The Veteran contends that he is entitled to an effective date earlier than August 10, 2022, for the grant of service connection for obstructive sleep apnea. He has asserted that the correct effective date is either April 1, 2021, August 8, 2021, or August 19, 2021. See August 31, 2022, Third Party Correspondence; see also June 19, 2023, VA Form 20-0996 Request for Higher-Level Review. The Veteran, through his representative, asserts that he originally filed his claim for sleep disorder on April 1, 2009. The claim was denied in October 2009, and it was not appealed. After a July 2019 sleep study, the Veteran received an official diagnosis of sleep apnea, and on August 19, 2021, he filed a supplemental claim. His claim was denied in a September 2021 rating decision and, in response, the Veteran filed another supplemental claim on August 31, 2022. In an April 2023 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for sleep apnea, effective August 10, 2022, based on legislation regarding toxic exposure risk activities (TERA). Thus, the Veteran asserts that the proper effective date for sleep apnea is August 19, 2021, the date he began continuous pursuit of his claim of service connection for sleep apnea. See September 25, 2024, VA Form 10182 Notice of Disagreement. In this case, the Veteran filed a claim for a "possible sleep disorder" on April 1, 2009. See April 1, 2009, VA 21-526 Veterans Application for Compensation. The Veteran underwent a VA examination in April 2009 for sleep disorders at which time the Veteran reported trouble sleeping and constant feelings of fatigue, but he did not believe that he had sleep apnea. See October 16, 2009 C&P Examination. In the October 2009 rating decision, the RO denied service connection for possible sleep disorder. See October 19, 2009, Rating Decision - Narrative. The Veteran did not appeal the October 2009 rating decision and it became final. Then, on August 19, 2021, the Veteran filed a supplemental claim for a sleep disorder including sleep apnea. See August 19, 2021, VA Form 20-0995 Supplemental Claim Application. In the September 2021 rating decision, the RO denied the claim of service connection for possible sleep disorder because the evidence submitted was not new and relevant. See September 7, 2021, Rating Decision - Narrative. Within a year of the September 2021 rating decision, on August 31, 2022, the Veteran filed a supplemental claim for sleep apnea (claimed as sleep disorder). See August 31, 2022, VA Form 20-0995 Supplemental Claim Application. The January 2023 VA examiner opined that the claimed condition was at least as likely as not incurred in or caused by the claimed in-service injury, event, or illness. The examiner's rationale was that the Veteran served in the Air Force from September 1989 to September 2009 and that service records show complaints in April 2003 of always being tired and fatigued. The examiner noted that the April 2009 examination provided subjective complaints that the Veteran reported trouble sleeping. Thus, the VA examiner opined that the Veteran's diagnosed sleep apnea is at least as likely at not incurred in or caused by the sleep apnea syndromes during service. The Veteran experienced symptoms of sleep apnea in service and that a sleep study later confirmed a diagnosis of sleep apnea. See January 18, 2023, C&P Examination. The January 2023 VA examiner was asked to provide an additional medical opinion for clarification. In March 2023, the VA examiner opined that the claimed condition was at least as likely as not caused by the indicated TERA. The examiner determined that the Veteran originally claimed SC for sleep disorder in 2009 but that he had attributed his symptoms at that time to mental health issues and his diagnosed adjustment disorder with chronic sleep impairment. The examiner noted that the "Veteran even stated at that time that he [did not] think he had sleep apnea." The examiner noted that the Veteran also denied any significant snoring, witnessed apneas by his wife, or waking with gasping for air or choking sensation at that time. See March 28, 2023, C&P Examination. In an April 2023 addendum opinion, the VA examiner asserted that based on his review of the record, the Veteran did not have sleep apnea symptoms during active duty. He explained that the Veteran presented to the Army Medical Center in 2019 and underwent work up for sleep apnea due to symptoms including fatigue, snoring, and witnessed apnea by spouse. He was diagnosed with sleep apnea 10 years after separation from service. Therefore, the examiner opined that the Veteran's sleep apnea was less likely than not service related. See April 11, 2023, C&P Examination. In an April 2023 rating decision, the RO granted service connection for sleep apnea with an evaluation of 50 percent effective August 10, 2022. A decision on the final effective date was pending additional clarification from the examiner. See April 10, 2023, Rating Decision - Narrative. In a separate April 2023 rating decision, the RO continued the 50 percent evaluation of obstructive sleep apnea. See April 13, 2023, Rating Decision - Narrative. In response, the Veteran filed a timely HLR request for the effective date of sleep apnea. See June 19, 2023, VA Form 20-0996 Request for Higher-Level Review. In an October 2023 HLR rating decision, the RO denied an earlier effective date, confirming that the proper effective date for service connection of sleep apnea was August 10, 2022. See October 4, 2023, Rating Decision - Narrative. Considering all of the evidence of record, the Board finds that the current grant of benefits is a continuation of the Veteran's August 19, 2021, supplemental claim for a sleep disorder including sleep apnea. While the Veteran's August 2021 claim was denied in a September 2021 rating decision, the Veteran filed a timely supplemental claim on August 31, 2022. A subsequent April 2023 rating decision was timely appealed with the June 2023 HLR request, resulting in the October 2023 HLR rating decision, which was timely appealed to the Board with the September 2024 VA Form 10182 NOD. Under the AMA framework, the continuous pursuit of the August 19, 2021, claim, as evidenced by the timely appeals of each rating decision, preserved the Veteran's August 19, 2021, claim as the effective date of the claim. As such, an earlier effective date of August 19, 2021, but no earlier, is warranted. Additionally, the RO, in the April 2023 rating decision, granted service connection effective August 10, 2022, based on "the date the law changed," presumably referencing the Promise to Address Comprehensive Toxics Act (the PACT Act), signed into law on August 10, 2022. However, the Board finds that the evidence sufficiently shows that the Veteran's sleep apnea is directly related to his active service. Notably, the January 2023 VA examiner very clearly explained his opinion that the Veteran's diagnosed sleep apnea is at least as likely as not related to the Veteran's sleep apnea symptoms during his active service. The Board acknowledges that the RO obtained additional VA opinions from the same VA examiner, who then asserted otherwise and focused on a connection to the Veteran's TERA. However, the Board affords the later VA opinions lower probative value than the January 2023 VA opinion. In January 2023 the VA examiner appeared to consider the Veteran's lay assertions as credible, but then, without explanation, in April 2023, afforded no value to those same assertions. Moreover, it appears that the Veteran's previous assertion in 2009 that he did not believe that his trouble sleeping was sleep apnea would be afforded higher value than his reported symptoms, especially considering the Veteran was not afforded a sleep study until 10 years after his original claim. As such, the Board finds that direct service connection was warranted during the pendency of the claim on appeal, beginning on August 19, 2021, the date of the Veteran's supplemental claim. However, the Board finds that an even earlier effective date prior to August 19, 2021, is not warranted by the evidence or procedural history demonstrated in the claims file. Regarding the Veteran's assertion that the proper effective date is April 1, 2021, the record does not include a claim on that date. The record includes an April 1, 2021, notification letter indicating that private medical records were submitted but that if the Veteran intended to file an initial claim, he must submit an application. See April 1, 2021, Request for Application. Of note, the Veteran then filed a claim on April 30, 2021, for multiple claims but did not list sleep apnea or any other sleep disorder at that time. See April 30, 2021, VA 21-526EZ, Fully Developed Claim. Regarding the claim that the correct effective date is August 8, 2021, there is no evidence of record to support that assertion. The record is absent evidence or argument associated with the record on that date; the document closest in time to that date is the August 19, 2021, supplemental claim application. Additionally, while the Board finds that this claim, which was ultimately granted, was a continuation of the August 19, 2021, supplemental claim, such is not the case with regard to his earlier claim on April 1, 2009. The Board acknowledges that the Veteran first filed a claim seeking service connection for "possible sleep disorder" on April 1, 2009, a claim which was denied in an October 2009 rating decision. However, the Veteran did not file a notice of disagreement or otherwise appeal the October 2009 denial of his claim and, thus, that decision became final. Based on the foregoing, the Board finds that the Veteran is entitled to an earlier effective date of August 19, 2021, but no earlier, for service connection for the Veteran's obstructive sleep apnea. Frederic P. Gallun Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board A. Labi, Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.