Citation Nr: 25007345 Decision Date: 05/30/25 Archive Date: 05/30/25 DOCKET NO. 14-24 602A DATE: May 30, 2025 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for a lumbar spine disability is remanded. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from November 1994 to February 1997. These matters come before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from the August 2011 and April 2013 rating decisions of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO). In August 2017, the Veteran testified at a Board hearing before the undersigned Veterans Law Judge. A transcript of the hearing is associated with the record. In a December 2017 decision, the Board denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea, and remanded the issue of entitlement to service connection for a back disability. The Veteran appealed the denial of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC). In an October 2018 order, the CAVC granted an October 2018 Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR) filed by the parties (the Veteran and the Secretary of VA), vacated the part of the December 2017 Board decision that denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea, and remanded the matter back to the Board for additional development. In April 2019, the Board remanded the issue of entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea for additional development. Thereafter, in a December 2019 decision, the Board denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea and a lumbar spine disability. The Veteran appealed the December 2019 Board decision to the CAVC. In a November 2020 order, the CAVC granted an October 2020 Joint Motion for Remand (JMR), vacated the December 2019 Board decision that denied entitlement to service connection for a lumbar spine disability and sleep apnea, and remanded these matters back to the Board for additional development consistent with terms of the October 2020 JMR. Subsequently, the Board remanded these matters in June 2021 and June 2022 to complete additional developments. Thereafter, in a December 2022 decision, the Board denied entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea and a lumbar spine disability. The Veteran appealed the December 2022 Board decision to the CAVC. In a May 2024 memorandum decision, the CAVC reversed the Board's finding in the December 2022 decision that the March 2022 and July 2022 VA medical opinions were adequate for adjudication purposes, set aside the remainder of the December 2022 Board decision, and remanded these matters back to the Board for further development and readjudication consistent with the memorandum decision. Pursuant to the May 2024 memorandum decision, in January 2025, the Board remanded these matters for additional development. After completing the additional development, the RO issued a March 2025 Supplemental Statement of the Case (SSOC) denying entitlement to service connection for sleep apnea and a lumbar spine disability, and returned these matters to the Board for appellate review. 1. Entitlement to service connection for a lumbar spine disability is remanded. In the May 2024 memorandum decision, the CAVC found that in making its credibility finding, the Board reviewed only the Veteran's lay statements that postdated the September 2011 car accident, and failed to address earlier statements concerning reports of continuing back pain since service, and relied exclusively on the lack of corroborating treatment records between separation in 1997 and the earliest, 2008, car accident. The CAVC noted that in his February 1997 claim, the Veteran reported that his back pain began during service in July 1995, and at an April 1997 vocational evaluation, he reported lower back pain, and both of these statements predate the 2008 car accident. Similarly, the CAVC found that in the March 2022 VA medical opinion, the examiner failed to consider the Veteran's statements, which undermines her opinion finding no link between service and lumbar spine degenerative joint disease. The CAVC noted that the examiner found the Veteran's lay statements as to chronic back pain since active duty to be unsupported by the evidence because he did not complain of back pain until after the post-service car accidents. The CAVC noted that a medical opinion that fails to consider a veteran's lay statements and relies solely on the absence of contemporaneous medical evidence to conclude that there is no link between a veteran's in-service injury and current disability is inadequate. Thus, the CAVC found that the March 2022 VA medical opinion on the Veteran's back condition is inadequate. Regarding secondary service connection for the Veteran's back condition, the CAVC noted that the March 2022 VA examiner did not address the May 2011 VA orthopedic examination report noting an antalgic gait, the December 2016, March 2017, and April 2017 VA physical therapy records noting decreased velocity of gait, and the January, March, and May 2018 VA physical therapy records from a different therapist noting gait abnormality. The CAVC found that the March 2022 VA medical opinion is inadequate because examiner determined that the Veteran's condition did not result in an altered gait as severe as an obvious Trendelenburg and opined that "the postural theory is not supported by validated literature and treatment notes i.e. gait," without citing or discussing the foregoing evidence of gait abnormality in the treatment notes or explaining the significance of any potential distinction between the Veteran's abnormal gait and a Trendelenburg gait. Thus, the CAVC found that the March 2022 examiner's failure to address the evidence of an altered gait in the record or to explain why this evidence was insufficient to demonstrate a causal or aggravative relationship between the Veteran's service-connected knee disability and the claimed back disability deprives the Board of the information it needed to resolve that dispositive medical question. Regarding obesity as an intermediate step between a service-connected condition and non-service-connected back disability, the CAVC found that despite the June 2022 Board remand for consideration of aggravation of obesity by the service-connected disabilities, the July 2022 examiner merely stated that the service-connected disabilities did not aggravate the Veteran's obesity, but did not adequately address aggravation of obesity in the supporting rationale. Pursuant to the CAVC order, in January 2025, the Board remanded this matter to obtain a new medical opinion on the Veteran's lumbar spine disability, in which the examiner addresses the evidence of record prior to the 2008 automobile accident that noted the Veteran's lower back pain, and the Veteran's assertion of continuity of lower back pain since active service. Furthermore, the Board directed the examiner to address as to whether the Veteran's service-connected disabilities caused or aggravated his lower back disability, including the altered gait due to bilateral knee condition, and obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and lumbar spine disability. Specifically, regarding the obesity, the Board directed the examiner to provide an opinion as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability and the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity; (ii) if so, whether the obesity or aggravation of obesity resulted from the service-connected disabilities was a substantial factor in causing a lumbar spine disability; and (iii) whether the current lumbar spine disability would not have occurred but for the obesity caused or aggravated by the service-connected disabilities. Pursuant to the January 2025 Board remand, the RO obtained a medical opinion in January 2025 on the direct and secondary service connection for a lumbar spine disability. However, the RO found that the January 2025 VA medical opinion on direct and secondary service connection for a lumbar spine disability, including obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and the claimed back disability, was inadequate. Therefore, the RO requested an addendum medical opinion in March 2025 from the same examiner who rendered the January 2025 VA opinion. Specifically, regarding the question as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability and the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity, in the March 2025 VA addendum medical opinion, the examiner stated that impaired mobility, including gait abnormality, or antalgic gait, does not cause obesity. The antalgic gait is most likely related to [the Veteran's] knee condition, as medical records consistently note knee pain; however last two most recent PCP encounter records in 2024 were silent for complaint, specific back diagnosis. There was a diagnosis of osteoarthritis (degenerative arthritis) that likely included his knee condition. While an antalgic gait related to bilateral knee conditions is unlikely to directly cause obesity, it could potentially contribute to reduced physical activity. However, medical literature generally attributes obesity to factors such as excessive caloric intake, rather than mobility issues alone. The Board finds that the above described part of the March 2025 VA medical opinion on obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and the claimed back disability is inadequate because in the supporting rationale, the examiner focused only on the claimed causation of obesity by the service-connected disabilities, but did not explain as to whether the Veteran's obesity was aggravated by the service-connected disabilities, including the antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability. Furthermore, the examiner stated that there was no documentation of any diagnosed back issues between 1996 and the 2011 car accident. The examiner explained that based on the available records, the lumbar spine condition is more likely a result of age-related degenerative changes rather than a direct consequence of either the Veteran's service or the automobile accident. Prior to the 2011 accident, the Veteran's low back pain was described as intermittent and related to activity levels, not a progressive or chronic condition. Furthermore, the X-ray findings in 2015 suggest degenerative changes consistent with aging, not trauma from the accident. The assertion that the automobile accident aggravated a pre-existing lumbar spine condition is unsupported by medical evidence because there was no evaluated and diagnosed condition to aggravate in the first place. Additionally, the Veteran's complaints post-service, including following the 2011 automobile accident, demonstrate no significant link to service or the earlier lumbar pain. The current pain is primarily due to natural degeneration, not service-related factors. The current lumbar spine pain is not related to the Veteran's active duty service. Medical records from that period indicate only intermittent, activity-related discomfort, which does not suggest a chronic or service-connected condition. The Veteran's lumbar spine issues are more consistent with age-related degenerative changes, as confirmed by X-rays in 2015, showing no evidence of injury-related trauma. Additionally, the Veteran's complaints post-service, including following the 2011 automobile accident, demonstrate no significant link to service or the earlier lumbar pain. The current pain is primarily due to natural degeneration, not service-related factors. The Board also finds the above described part of the March 2025 VA medical opinion inadequate because the supporting rationale consists of several conclusory statements, in which the examiner solely relied on the absence of contemporaneous medical evidence documenting lower back conditions prior to the 2011 automobile accident, but did not address the Veteran's lay statements, when specifically in the May 2024 memorandum decision, the CAVC noted that a medical opinion that fails to consider a veteran's lay statements and relies solely on the absence of contemporaneous medical evidence to conclude that there is no link between a veteran's in-service injury and current disability is inadequate. Furthermore, the examiner noted that there was no documentation of any diagnosed back issues between 1996 and the 2011 car accident, but did not address the February 1997 claim, in which the Veteran reported that his back pain began during service in July 1995; and the April 1997 vocational evaluation, during which the Veteran reported lower back pain. Furthermore, the examiner stated that spine issues and degenerative changes showed on 2015 X-rays are more consistent with age-related degenerative changes, but the examiner did not address the Veteran's age because in 2015, the Veteran was only 39 years old, and the May 2015 X-ray report noted "multilevel facet degenerative changes." Accordingly, the Board finds that another remand is warranted to obtain a new medical opinion on the nature and etiology of the Veteran's lumbar spine disability that addresses the above noted concerns and the Veteran's assertion of continuity of lower back pain since active service, and which is also consistent with the CAVC May 2024 memorandum decision. 2. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea is remanded. In the May 2024 memorandum decision, the CAVC found that since the Board did not find the Veteran's reports of his wife noting apnea "skipping breathing during sleep and waking up gasping for air" immediately after separation from active service not credible, the Board implicitly found them credible. Also, the March 2022 VA examiner explained that witnessed apnea during sleep is a symptom of sleep apnea, but stated that these statements of the Veteran were not supported by evidence. Thus, the CAVC found that without explanation from the examiner indicating specific review of the June 2011 examination report reflecting the lay statements by the Veteran as to sleep apnea since service, and the Veteran's spouse witnessing apnea during the Veteran's sleep immediately after separation, and without specific citation to records that contradict this, the examiner's rationale for the negative linkage opinion is inadequate. Thus, the CAVC found that the proper remedy is to obtain a new medical opinion. Regarding obesity as an intermediate step between a service-connected disability and the Veteran's sleep apnea, the CAVC found that despite the June 2022 Board remand for consideration of aggravation of obesity by the service-connected disabilities, the July 2022 examiner merely stated that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities did not aggravate his obesity, but did not adequately address aggravation of obesity in the supporting rationale. Pursuant to the CAVC order, in January 2025, the remanded this matter to obtain a new medical opinion on the Veteran's sleep apnea in which the examiner addresses the Veteran's reports of his wife witnessing apnea immediately after service. Furthermore, the Board directed the examiner to address as to whether the Veteran's service-connected disabilities caused or aggravated his sleep apnea, including the obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and sleep apnea. Specifically, regarding the obesity, the Board directed the examiner to provide an opinion as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity; (ii) if so, whether the obesity or aggravation of obesity resulted from the service-connected disabilities was a substantial factor in causing sleep apnea; and (iii) whether the current sleep apnea would not have occurred but for the obesity caused or aggravated by the service-connected disabilities. Pursuant to the January 2025 Board remand, the RO obtained a medical opinion in January 2025 on the direct and secondary service connection for a lumbar spine disability. However, the RO found that the January 2025 VA medical opinion on direct and secondary service connection, including obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and the claimed sleep apnea, was inadequate. Therefore, the RO requested an addendum medical opinion in March 2025 from the same examiner who rendered the January 2025 VA opinion. Specifically, regarding the question as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability and the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity, in the March 2025 VA addendum medical opinion, the examiner stated that it was less likely than not that the Veteran's service-connected disabilities caused or aggravated his obesity. As a supporting rationale, the examiner stated that while psychiatric conditions such as panic disorder with tinnitus, and agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder can contribute to stress, and bilateral knee disabilities can affect activity levels, however, there is no sufficient evidence to suggest that these conditions directly led to significant weight gain. Obesity is not considered a secondary service-connected disability unless it results from a service-connected condition and subsequently causes or aggravates another disability. In this case, the evidence of record does not establish a clear causal relationship between the Veteran's obesity and his service-connected disabilities. Medical providers have consistently recommended diet and lifestyle changes, with evidence suggesting that the Veteran was able to adhere to these recommendations, which were not impeded by his service-connected conditions. While psychiatric disorders can influence eating habits or physical activity, there is no conclusive evidence that they resulted in significant weight gain. The bilateral knee condition may have slightly limited physical activity, but it did not prevent the Veteran from following weight management strategies. As for the onset of sleep apnea, it is notable that the Veteran's BMI was already in the obese range by 2010, and his provider recommended lifestyle changes for weight management, suggesting that weight gain was influenced by modifiable factors, not by his service-connected conditions. The Veteran has demonstrated that his weight gain is not due to his service-connected conditions because with provider recommendations, Veteran was able to bring to his BMI of 41.4, in June 2021, down to 38.2 in December 2024. The Board finds that the above described part of the March 2025 VA medical opinion on obesity as an intermediate step between the service-connected disabilities and the claimed sleep apnea is inadequate because in the supporting rationale, the examiner focused only on the claimed causation of obesity by the service-connected disabilities, but did not explain as to whether the Veteran's obesity was aggravated by the service-connected disabilities, including the antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability. Furthermore, regarding the direct service connection and the Veteran's wife observing the Veteran gasping for air after leaving service, the examiner stated that in the June 2011 VA examination, the Veteran reported that his wife observed him waking up gasping for air after leaving service. While it is acknowledged that a layperson, such as the Veteran's wife, can observe and report observable symptoms like gasping for air, this description is nonspecific and she is unlikely qualified to medically evaluate, diagnosis and form a treatment plan for a sleep apnea syndrome. Gasping for air can be caused by various factors, including nightmares, and does not necessarily point to a diagnosis of sleep apnea. The absence of records indicating consistent sleep disturbances or a treatment plan for sleep apnea between 1996 and 2010 raises questions about the onset of this condition which likely developed well after separation from service. Additionally, a January 2025 primary care visit did not note complaints of sleep issues, further suggesting a later onset of a chronic sleep disorder. The Board also finds the above described part of the March 2025 VA medical opinion inadequate because the examiner solely relied on the absence of contemporaneous medical evidence documenting sleep apnea after the Veteran's active service, but did not address the March 2022 VA examiner explanation that witnessed apnea during sleep is a symptom of sleep apnea, which the Veteran's wife noted after the Veteran's separation from active service. Moreover, in the March 2025 VA medical opinion, the examiner stated that posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a recognized risk factor for obstructive sleep apnea, it is important to understand that the mere presence of a risk factor does not establish causality. While PTSD may contribute to disturbed sleep patterns, it does not directly cause the muscle relaxation responsible for the airway blockage in obstructive sleep apnea. Psychiatric disorders may cause awakening for various reasons but they do not cause the muscle relaxation that causes airway blockage in obstructive sleep apnea. The Board finds that the above described part of the March 2025 VA medical opinion on secondary service connection for sleep apnea is also inadequate because the examiner addressed the direct causation of obstructive sleep apnea by the Veteran's service-connected psychiatric disorder, but did not address as to whether the Veteran's service-connected disabilities aggravated the existing obstructive sleep apnea, which might have been caused by factors other than the service-connected disabilities. Accordingly, the Board finds that another remand is warranted to obtain a new medical opinion on the nature and etiology of the Veteran's obstructive sleep apnea that addresses the above noted concerns and the addresses the claimed causation and aggravation of sleep apnea by the Veteran's service-connected disabilities separately with adequate explanation. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain a new medical opinion on the nature and etiology of the Veteran's diagnosed lumbar spine disability from an examiner other than the one who rendered the January and March 2025 VA medical opinions. Claims file should be available to the examiner for review. After reviewing the claims file and copies of this remand and the May 2024 CAVC memorandum decision, the examiner should address the following: (a) Provide a medical opinion as to whether it is "at least as likely as not" (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's current lumbar spine disability began during his active service or is related to an in-service injury, event, or disease, including the lower back pain noted during the Veteran's active service. The examiner should review the Veteran's competent reports of lower back pain in the evidence of record prior to the 2008 car accident. (b) Provide an opinion as to whether the Veteran's lumbar spine disability is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) (i) due to, caused by, or resulted from, or (ii) aggravated by a service-connected condition, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability, including the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability. In providing the above requested opinion on aggravation of the Veteran's lumbar spine disability, the examiner should also opine as to whether a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability and the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability, caused any "incremental increase, regardless of its permanence" in the Veteran's non-service-connected lumbar spine disability. (c) Provide an opinion as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability and the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity; (ii) if so, whether the obesity or aggravation of obesity resulted from the service-connected disabilities was a substantial factor in causing a lumbar spine disability; and (iii) whether the current lumbar spine disability would not have occurred but for the obesity caused or aggravated by the service-connected disabilities. In providing the above requested opinions, besides reviewing the claims file in general, the examiner should specifically review and address the evidence of record associated with the Veteran's claims file with entries dated: (i) 09/15/2014, titled "STR - Medical" page 4 of 75 that contains an August 1996 in-service report of medical history, in which the Veteran reported that he had lower back pain for one year; (ii) 02/24/1997, titled "VA 21-526 Veterans Application for Compensation or Pension" in which the Veteran reported that his back pain began in July 1995 during active service; (iii) 03/07/1997, titled "Education - General" page 2 of 8 that contains an April 1997 vocational evaluation, during which the Veteran reported lower back pain: (iv) 11/15/2019, titled "Appellate Brief (VSO IHP; Post remand Brief; Attorney Brief)," which includes arguments and reference to medical literature regarding lumbar spine disability; (v) 4/19/2021, titled "Appellate Brief (VSO IHP; Post remand Brief; Attorney Brief)," which also includes reference to medical literature regarding lumbar spine disability; (vi) 03/08/2012, titled "Medical Treatment Record -Government Facility," which contains treatment record for back pain and report of an automobile accident in September 2011 on page 17 of 17; (vii) 08/20/2014, titled "Form 9," in which the Veteran contended that his lumbar spine condition persisted since service, and the automobile accident aggravated the condition; (viii) 08/22/2017, titled "Hearing Transcript," in which the Veteran testified that he had to carry 80 pounds weight, while marching, which took a toll on his lower back; (ix) 05/24/2011, titled "VA Examination" that contains the May 2011 VA examination report for joints, in which the examiner noted the Veteran's antalgic gait; (x) 01/15/2019, titled "CAPRI" pages 584 and 611 of 1152, which contain the April 2017 and December 2016 VA treatment records respectively that noted decreased velocity of the Veteran's gait; pages 146, 299, and 349 of 1152, which contain the May, March, and January 2018 VA treatment records respectively that noted the Veteran's gait abnormality. 2. Obtain a new medical opinion on the nature and etiology of the Veteran's diagnosed obstructive sleep apnea from an examiner other than the one who rendered the January and March 2025 VA medical opinions. Claims file should be available to the examiner for review. After reviewing the claims file and copies of this remand and the May 2024 CAVC memorandum decision, the examiner should address the following: (a) Provide a medical opinion as to whether it is "at least as likely as not" (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's current obstructive sleep apnea began during his active service or is related to an in-service injury, event, or disease, including sleep disturbance noted during the Veteran's active service, and the symptoms the Veteran's wife reported that she observed immediately after active service. (b) Provide an opinion as to whether the Veteran's sleep apnea is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) (i) due to, caused by, or resulted from, or (ii) aggravated by a service-connected condition, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability, including the claimed antalgic gait due to bilateral knee disability. In providing the above requested opinion on aggravation of the Veteran's sleep apnea, the examiner should also opine as to whether a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability, caused any "incremental increase, regardless of its permanence" in the Veteran's non-service-connected sleep apnea. (c) Provide an opinion as to whether it is at least as likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that (i) a service-connected disability, to include panic disorder with agoraphobia and generalized anxiety disorder, tinnitus, and bilateral knee disability, caused the Veteran to become obese or aggravated the Veteran's obesity; (ii) if so, whether the obesity or aggravation of obesity resulted from the service-connected disabilities was a substantial factor in causing sleep apnea; and (iii) whether the current sleep apnea would not have occurred but for the obesity caused or aggravated by the service-connected disabilities. In providing the above requested opinions, besides reviewing the claims file in general, the examiner should specifically review and address the evidence of record associated with the Veteran's claims file with entries dated: (i) 09/15/2014, titled "STR - Medical" page 4 of 75 that contains an August 1996 in-service report of medical history, in which the Veteran reported that he had trouble sleeping for six months; page 35 of 75 that contains an October 1995 service treatment record in which the clinician noted the Veteran's sleep disturbance; (ii) 06/08/2011, titled "VA Examination" that contains a June 2011 VA examination report in which the Veteran reported that immediately after separation from active service his wife noted that the Veteran would skip breathing during sleep and wake up gasping for air; [The examiner is advised that the Veteran's wife is competent to report observable sleep disturbances and breathing abnormalities during the Veteran's sleep]; (iii) 11/15/2019, titled "Appellate Brief (VSO IHP; Post remand Brief; Attorney Brief)," which includes arguments and reference to medical literature regarding sleep apnea; (iv) 4/19/2021, titled "Appellate Brief (VSO IHP; Post remand Brief; Attorney Brief)," which also includes reference to medical literature regarding sleep apnea; (v) 08/22/2017, titled "Hearing Transcript," in which the Veteran testified that during active service he had sleep disturbance; (vi) 03/14/2022, titled "C&P Exam" that contains the March 2022 VA medical opinion in which the examiner noted that obesity is a risk factor for obstructive sleep apnea and the Veteran was obese when he was diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea in 2010. Also, the examiner explained that witnessed apnea during sleep is a symptom of sleep apnea; [Note: The examiner should opine as to whether the Veteran's wife noting observable sleep disturbances and breathing abnormalities, including gasping for air, during the Veteran's sleep shortly after separation from active service, were early symptoms of sleep apnea that was diagnosed in November 2010]; (vii) 06/09/2021, titled "CAPRI" page 146 of 248 that contains an August 2019 VA treatment record noting the Veteran's BMI as 41.4, and page 7 of 248 that contains a May 2021 VA treatment record noting the Veteran's BMI as 40.5; (viii) 05/03/2022, titled "Appellate Brief (VSO IHP; Post remand Brief; Attorney Brief)"in which the Veteran's representative argued that the Veteran's sleep apnea and lumbar spine disability are due to obesity caused by the service-connected psychiatric disorder, bilateral knee condition, and tinnitus. Clear and separate supporting rationales for the opinions rendered, including opinions on causation and aggravation of the Veteran's lumbar spine disability and sleep apnea, must be provided. If the examiner determines that it is not possible to provide an opinion without resorting to speculation, then the examiner must provide an explanation of why that is so and state whether the need to speculate is due to a deficiency in the state of general medical knowledge, a deficiency in the record, or a deficiency in the examiner's knowledge. 3. Thereafter, readjudicate the claims on appeal. If the benefits sought remain denied, issue the Veteran and his representative an SSOC and provide a reasonable opportunity to respond before returning the matters to the Board for further appellate review. MICHAEL MARTIN Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Tariq, Nadeem The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.