Citation Nr: 25007484 Decision Date: 06/04/25 Archive Date: 06/04/25 DOCKET NO. 12-00 496 DATE: June 4, 2025 REMANDED Entitlement to a rating in excess of 20 percent for service-connected degenerative joint disease (DJD) and degenerative disc disease (DDD) of the lumbosacral spine (lumbar spine disability), prior to October 28, 2020, is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from July 1990 to June 1994 and from March 2003 to September 2003. This matter comes before the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) on appeal from a June 2010 rating decision of a regional office (RO) of the Department of Veterans Affairs. In March 2017, the Veteran testified at a Board hearing before a Veterans Law Judge (VLJ) who has since retired. The Veteran was informed he could request another hearing with a different VLJ in May 2022 and January 2025. The Veteran has not requested another Board hearing. The Board remanded this appeal for additional development in September 2017, October 2019, June 2020, and September 2020. In April 2021, the Board denied a rating in excess of 10 percent prior to December 17, 2019, a rating in excess of 20 percent from December 17, 2019, to October 27, 2020, and a rating in excess of 40 percent since October 27, 2020, for his service-connected lumbar spine disability. The Veteran appealed the April 2021 Board decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans' Claims (Court). Pursuant to a February 2022 order granting a Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR), the Court vacated the Board's decision and remanded the increased rating claim for his lumbar spine disability. See February 2022 JMPR. In the JMPR, the parties agreed that the Board had not provided an adequate statement of reasons or bases for denying the Veteran's increased ratings claims. Id. Subsequently, the matter was remanded for additional development in September 2022, February 2023, and October 2023. In June 2024, the Board issued a decision granting entitlement to a 20 percent rating prior to December 17, 2019; denying entitlement to a rating in excess of 20 percent from December 17, 2019; to October 27, 2020, and denying a rating in excess of 40 percent from October 28, 2020. See June 2024 Board Decision. The Veteran appealed this decision to the Court. In a January 2025 JMPR, the parties agreed that the Board had not provided an adequate statement of reasons and bases for denying a rating in excess of 20 percent prior to October 28, 2020. See January 2025 JMPR. A Court order granted the motion and remanded the matter to the Board for action consistent with the JMPR. See January 2025 Court Order. 1. Entitlement to a rating in excess of 20 percent for service-connected lumbar spine disability, prior to October 28, 2020, is remanded. In the January 2025 JMPR, the parties agreed that the Board had not adequately addressed whether VA medical opinions obtained since the Board's September 2022 remand substantially complied with that remand order. See January 2025 JMPR. Specifically, the parties noted that the May 2023 and November 2023 VA examiners declined to provide the requested retrospective opinions regarding the Veteran's reduced range of motion during flare-ups. Id. Thus, the question presently before the Board is whether the VA medical opinions obtained since September 2022 have substantially complied with the remand order as it pertains to retrospective opinions. In relevant part, the September 2022 remand directives read as follows: The examiner should also review the prior medical evidence and examinations in October 2009, October 2011 and September 2018 and provide a retrospective opinion of any additional estimated degrees of limited motion caused by functional loss during a flare-up or after repeated use over time, to include whether the functional loss is the functional equivalent of ankylosis. If the examiner determines that he or she cannot provide this retrospective testing/opinion, the examiner must state why and provide a reasoned explanation for the determination. See September 2022 Board Decision. In May 2023, a VA medical opinion was obtained in which the examiner stated that he could not provide a retrospective opinion as it would be "inappropriate to provide an opinion or any clinical judgement on an examination at which [he] was not present." See May 2023 VES Addendum. The Board finds the May 2023 VA opinion conclusory insofar as the examiner did not provide a reasoned explanation as to why it would be inappropriate to comment on previous examinations. The examiner did not address the lay statements of the Veteran or any contemporaneous evidence, rather he made a vague assertion that it would be unethical to even attempt to do so. As such, the Board finds that the May 2023 medical opinion is conclusory, and therefore inadequate for adjudication purposes. See Stefl v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 120 (2007); Nieves-Rodriguez v. Peake, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008). Accordingly, the May 2023 medical opinion did not substantially comply with the September 2022 remand order. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998). Moreover, if this examiner refused to provide an opinion, then the RO should have assigned the claim to a different examiner who was not constrained by his personal view on providing an opinion. In October 2023, the Board noted that a retrospective opinion had not yet been obtained and remanded this matter. See October 2023 Board Decision. In November 2023, a VA examiner opined that "it is impossible to opine, beyond mere speculation, on estimates of range of motion upon review of the prior examinations dating back over a decade; the prior exams stand on their own as reported." See December 2023 Medical Opinion DBQ. In a January 2024 clarification opinion, the same examiner stated "[i]t is not possible, and I will not attempt, to assess range of motion retrospectively without mere speculation; my opinion stands as stated and the reviewer should see the past exams." See January 2024 VES Addendum. The Board finds that the November 2023 VA examiner's statements are undermined, in part, by his contemporaneous findings. Notably, the examiner relied on the Veteran's lay statements and treatment records to opine that "it would be expected that he would have experienced reductions in range of motion with at least flare-ups in pain during the duration of the flare-up throughout his lifetime experience with back conditions." See November 2023 Medical Opinion DBQ. However, the examiner did not utilize the Veteran's lay statements to provide estimates for the loss of range of motion and implied that he had doubts as to the whether the Veteran performed past examinations with full effort based on perceived inconsistencies during the November 2020 examination. Ultimately, the November 2023 VA examiner did not adequately explain why he was willing to use the Veteran's lay statements to conclude that he experiences reduction in range of motion during flare-ups but unwilling to use those same statements to determine the degree to which motion was limited. The Board further notes that the examiner performed an in-person examination of the Veteran and could have elicited information regarding the frequency, duration, and severity of past flare-ups. See Sharp v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 26 (2017). Additionally, in December 2023, a different VA examiner provided a retrospective opinion regarding the loss of motion during flare-ups and after repeated use over time. See December 2023 Medical Opinion DBQ. This opinion was requested to clarify a September 2020 medical opinion which addressed a VA examination conducted in June 2020. See September 2020 VA Medical Opinion. The December 2023 examiner provided, in terms of degrees, the estimated loss of range of motion in the Veteran's lumbar spine. Unfortunately, the scope of this retrospective opinion does not cover the entirety of the period on appeal and, as such, is insufficient to adjudicate the present matter. To conclude, the Board finds that the VA medical opinions obtained since the September 2022 Board remand do not substantially comply with that order. See Stegall v. West, supra. As such, another remand is required to obtain a retrospective opinion regarding the severity of the Veteran's lumbar disability during flare-ups to be provided by other than the examiners who rendered opinions in May 2023 and November 2023. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. THIS CASE WAS REMANDED BY THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR VETERANS CLAIMS. IN ORDER TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH ITS ORDER, obtain a RETROSPECTIVE ADVISORY OPINION FROM AN INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EXPERT pursuant to 38 U.S.C. § 5109 and 38 C.F.R. § 3.328. The opinion should address the nature and severity of the Veteran's lumbar disability from June 8, 2008, to October 28, 2020. The AOJ must follow the established procedures for requesting an advisory opinion from a medical school, university, or clinic. The entire claims file must be provided to, and reviewed by, the opining physician. 2. The examiner is asked to: (a.) Provide a RETROSPECTIVE OPINION, utilizing the Veteran's medical records and lay history, regarding the severity of Veteran's service-connected lumbar disability from June 8, 2008, to October 28, 2020. (b.) The examiner should review and specifically address the VA examination reports from October 2009, October 2011, and September 2018. The analysis should include estimates of impairment in terms of limitation to ROM during flare-ups and after repeated use over time. (c.) Opine as to whether the functional loss experienced by the Veteran during flare-ups or after repeated use over time constitutes the functional equivalent of ankylosis. (d.) The examiner should specifically address the September 2020 VA medical opinion in which the clinician opined that the Veteran would experience an additional loss of 25 degrees of range of motion after repeated use over time and 50 degrees during flare-ups. If the examiner concurs with these estimates and believes they apply to the entirety of the period on appeal, it should be reflected in the ROM estimates provided for the October 2009, October 2011, and September 2018 VA examinations. " Any opinion expressed by the physician should be accompanied by a complete rationale. If medical literature is relied upon in rendering a determination, the physician should identify and specifically cite each reference material utilized. " If the physician is unable to offer an opinion without resort to mere speculation, a thorough explanation as to why an opinion cannot be rendered should be provided. In such an explanation, the examiner should discuss why contemporaneous lay statements and treatment records are insufficient to base estimates for the loss of range of motion on. " The physician is advised that the Veteran is competent to report symptoms, treatment, and injuries, and that his reports must be taken into account in formulating the requested opinions. 2. The AOJ must review the claims file and ensure that the foregoing development actions have been completed in full. (a.) If any development action is incomplete, the appropriate corrective action must be implemented. (Continued on the next page) ? (b.) If any report or opinion does not include adequate responses to the specific opinions requested, it must be returned to the providing examiner for corrective action. YVETTE R. WHITE Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Zachary J. Ellis, Associate Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.