Citation Nr: 25008740 Decision Date: 07/02/25 Archive Date: 07/02/25 DOCKET NO. 18-51 638 DATE: July 2, 2025 REMANDED Entitlement to service connection for lumbosacral strain is remanded. Entitlement to service connection for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is remanded. REASONS FOR REMAND The Veteran served on active duty from January 1978 to June 1982. The rating decision on appeal was issued by a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Regional Office (RO) in March 2017. As background, in December 1984, the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) denied the Veteran's claim for service connection for lumbosacral strain. Board decisions are generally final as of the date of their issuance. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1100. In an October 2022 decision, the Board found that new and material evidence had been received to reopen the claim. In April 2022, the Veteran testified at a Board videoconference hearing before the undersigned Veteran's Law Judge. A transcript of the hearing has been associated with the record. In an October 2022 decision, the Board remanded the claims to the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) to provide the Veteran and his representative with a Supplemental Statement of the Claim (SSOC) for these matters. In December 2022, the AOJ issued the requested SSOC. In March 2023, the Board remanded the claims in order for the AOJ to request that the Veteran identify any outstanding private or VA treatment records, to include any chiropractor records. The RO requested records for which the Veteran submitted a proper release. The Board also instructed the AOJ to obtain an addendum medical opinion for the Veteran's back disability claim, and for a full VA examination for his OSA claim. In October 2023, the AOJ obtained the requested VA examination and opinions. The appeal returned to the Board, and in a December 2023 decision, the Board found that there had been substantial compliance with the remand directives, and denied the claims. The Veteran appealed the decision to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court). On November 13, 2024 the Court issued a Memorandum Decision that set aside the Board's decision, and remanded it to the Board for further development and readjudication. Entitlement to service connection for lumbosacral strain is remanded. In the Memorandum decision, the Court agreed with the parties that the October 2023 VA spine opinion was inadequate, and the Board erred by relying on it to deny the lumbosacral strain claim. Specifically, the parties agreed that the VA examiner impermissibly based her negative etiological opinion on the absence of medical documentation and failed to consider lay evidence asserting continuity of symptoms since service. In addition, the examiner also overlooked that the Veteran reported recurrent back pain during the April 1982 service separation examination, which is documented in the service medical records. Thus, the separation examination report and contemporaneous Report of Medical History form appear to contradict the examiner's opinion that the record lacked medical documentation supporting chronicity during service. The Court set aside this decision, and held that remand of the claim is warranted to obtain a new medical opinion. VA's duty to assist includes not only obtaining examination reports or opinions when triggered by evidence but extends to ensuring that examination reports or opinions are adequate. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 311 (2007) (once VA undertakes the effort to provide an examination when developing a service-connection claim, even if not statutorily obligated to do so, it must provide an adequate one or, at a minimum, notify the claimant why one will not or cannot be provided). For the foregoing reasons, the Board finds that the October 2023 VA spine opinion is inadequate, and the appeal must be remanded to obtain a new medical opinion. VA's duty to assist includes not only obtaining examination reports or opinions when triggered by evidence but extends to ensuring that examination reports or opinions are adequate. See Barr v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 303, 311 (2007) (once VA undertakes the effort to provide an examination when developing a service-connection claim, even if not statutorily obligated to do so, it must provide an adequate one or, at a minimum, notify the claimant why one will not or cannot be provided). 2. Entitlement to service connection for OSA is remanded. In the November 2024 Memorandum Decision, the Court noted that the parties disagreed about whether the October 2023 VA sleep opinion is adequate, and, by extension, whether the Board erred by relying on it to deny the OSA claim. The Court agreed with the Veteran that the examination is inadequate because the examiner failed to address the buddy statement describing the Veteran's gasping for air while attempting to sleep. The Court noted that in one buddy statement, a servicemember who bunked with the Veteran stated that he "would be awakened by the sound of [the veteran] gasping for breath, sometimes multiple times each night, and that he also snored every night. The fellow servicemember also stated that the Veteran would complain about having dry throat and headaches upon awakening and would be irritable and fatigued during the day. The Court noted that the October 2023 VA examiner listed the buddy statement, including the reference to gasping for breath, among the evidence she reviewed. And she specifically stated in her opinion that she reviewed "a buddy statement with notes of snoring and exhibiting disturbing sleep behavior." She then continued: However, symptoms such as snoring can be caused by several factors, such as the anatomy of your mouth and sinuses, alcohol consumption, allergies, a cold, and weight. [(citation omitted)]. [OSA] is the most common sleep-related breathing disorder. It causes the veteran to [repeatedly] stop and start breathing while he sleeps.... The Veteran's [obesity] is more likely the etiology. A nexus has not been established. The examiner supported her description of the causes of snoring with a citation to a Mayo Clinic article, Entitled "Snoring-Symptoms and Causes." The parties disagreed about whether the examiner's reference to "disturbing sleep behavior" reflects that the examiner considered the description of gasping for air, when rendering her opinion. The Court agreed with the Veteran that it does not. The Court found that although the examiner identified the buddy statement's reference to gasping for air in the list of evidence reviewed, and although she refers to symptoms "such as "snoring, her rationale only addresses the cause of snoring, as demonstrated by the title of the Mayo clinic article. Moreover, the Court found that the examiner's references to "disturbing sleep behavior" and "such as " were intended to address gasping, then she failed to reconcile the report of gasping for air with her discussion that the Veteran's OSA causes him to repeatedly start and stop breathing, which is essentially gasping for air or, even if different, might look and sound like gasping for air to a lay individual. The Court also noted that most evident of the reasons demonstrating that the examiner did not consider gasping (as well as the other reported symptoms) is the Mayo Clinical article she cited as support for her opinion. In addition to the causes of snoring identified by the examiner, the article provides the following: Snoring is often associated with a sleep disorder called [OSA]. Not all snorers have OSA, but if snoring is accompanied by an of the following symptoms, it may be an indication to see a doctor for further evaluation. an indication to see a doctor for further evaluation for OSA: Excessive daytime sleepiness... morning headaches... sore throat upon awakening... gasping or choking at night... The Court noted that the Mayo Clinic article referenced by the examiner specifically identifies at least 4 other symptoms mentioned in the buddy statement that the buddy witnessed the Veteran experience during service, therefore the Court found that it was clear that the examiner's rationale overlooked the Veteran's other OSA symptoms, particularly gasping. The Court held that the examination is inadequate to adjudicate the claim for service connection for OSA, and that the Board erred in relying on the opinion to deny the claim, and that the decision is set aside and the matter is remanded to obtain a new medical opinion. For the foregoing reasons, the Board finds that the October 2023 VA OSA opinion is inadequate, and the appeal must be remanded to obtain a new medical opinion. See Barr at 311. The matters are REMANDED for the following action: 1. Obtain an addendum VA medical opinion from the examiner who conducted the October 2023 VA examination for the Veteran's lumbosacral strain claim, to determine the nature and etiology of the disability. The examiner must review the entire claims file, including the body of this remand. If an opinion cannot be rendered without performing a VA examination, then a VA examination must be scheduled and completed. The VA examiner must address the following: (a.) Determine whether it is at least likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's lumbosacral strain is related to his active service. If not, the examiner may not base a negative etiological opinion on the absence of medical documentation. The examiner must consider lay evidence asserting continuity of symptoms since service. The examiner must also acknowledge that, although the April 1982 Report of Medical Examination for Separation reflects that the Veteran's back was found to be clinically normal, the Veteran reported having a back problem since mid-1981 in the Report of Medical Examination and Report of Medical History. The examiner is advised that the Veteran is competent to report symptoms, treatment, and injuries, essentially that which he can observe through his own senses, and that his reports must be taken into account in formulating the requested opinion. If the examiner discounts the Veteran's reports, the examiner must explain why, and may not rely solely on a lack of service treatment or post-service treatment medical records. The examiner must also acknowledge and consider the buddy statements that support the Veteran's reports of an in-service injury and resulting low back pain during service. If the examiner discounts any buddy statements, the examiner must also explain why. The examiner must provide a full rationale for all proffered opinions. If the examiner is unable to provide any required opinion, he or she should explain why. If the examiner cannot provide an opinion without resorting to mere speculation, he or she shall provide a complete explanation as to why this is so. If the inability to provide a more definitive opinion is the result of a need for additional information, the examiner should identify the additional information that is needed. 2. Obtain an addendum VA medical opinion from the examiner who conducted the October 2023 VA examination, to determine the nature and etiology of the Veteran's OSA. The examiner must review the entire claims file, including the body of this remand. If an opinion cannot be rendered without performing a VA examination, then a VA examination must be scheduled and completed. The VA examiner must address the following: (a.) Determine whether it is at least likely as not (likelihood is at least approximately balanced or nearly equal, if not higher) that the Veteran's OSA is related to his active service. The examiner is advised that the Veteran is competent to report symptoms, treatment, and injuries, essentially that which he can observe through his own senses, and that his reports must be taken into account in formulating the requested opinion. If the examiner discounts the Veteran's reports, the examiner must explain why, and may not rely solely on a lack of service treatment or post-service treatment medical records. The examiner must consider and address the buddy servicemember lay accounts of their observations of the Veteran during active service, including his gasping for air, repeatedly starting and stopping breathing, and hearing the Veteran's complaints of having a dry throat and headaches upon awakening, and being irritable and fatigued throughout the day. The examiner must provide a full rationale for all proffered opinions. If the examiner is unable to provide any required opinion, he or she should explain why. If the examiner cannot provide an opinion without resorting to mere speculation, he or she shall provide a complete explanation as to why this is so. If the inability to provide a more definitive opinion is the result of a need for additional information, the examiner should identify the additional information that is needed. John R. Doolittle, II Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board Susan E. Leary The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.