Citation Nr: 25008971 Decision Date: 07/09/25 Archive Date: 07/09/25 DOCKET NO. 17-44 276 DATE: July 9, 2025 ORDER Entitlement to a disability rating of 40 percent, but no higher, for lumbosacral spine disability, from October 19, 2012, is granted. FINDING OF FACT Resolving reasonable doubt in the Veteran's favor, his lumbosacral spine disability has manifested in forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine of 30 degrees or less from October 19, 2012, the date of the Veteran's non-initial increased rating claim. CONCLUSION OF LAW The criteria for a disability rating of 40 percent, but no higher, for lumbosacral spine disability have been met. 38 U.S.C. §§ 1155, 5107; 38 C.F.R. §§ 4.1, 4.3, 4.7, 4.14, 4.59, 4.71a, Diagnostic Code 5243. REASONS AND BASES FOR FINDING AND CONCLUSION The Veteran served on active duty in the United States Army from January 2006 to July 2009 and March 2010 to April 2011, with additional service in the Army Reserve. This matter is on appeal to the Board of Veterans' Appeals (Board) from a March 2015 rating decision issued by a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) agency of original jurisdiction (AOJ). This case has a long and complex procedural history. In July 2009, the Veteran was granted service connection for thoracic spondylosis and lumbar strain with an evaluation of 20 percent effective July 4, 2009. See July 2009 Rating Decision. In October 2012, the Veteran filed a supplemental claim seeking an increased disability rating, which was denied in an October 2013 provisional rating decision. See October 2012 Supplemental Claim Correspondence; October 2013 Rating Decision. However, the October 2013 rating was provisional, and in the March 2015 rating decision on appeal, issued upon receipt of new and material medical records, the Veteran was again denied an increased disability rating. See March 2015 Rating Decision. The Veteran filed a Notice of Disagreement (NOD) in February 2016. See February 2016 NOD. A Statement of Case (SOC) was issued in July 2017, the Veteran appealed the matter to the Board in August 2017, and the Board certified the appeal in November 2017. See July 2017 SOC; August 2017 Form 9; November 2017 Form 8. In February 2021, the Veteran was afforded a hearing with the undersigned Veterans Law Judge; a transcript of the hearing is associated with the claims file. See February 2021 Hearing Transcript. The Board remanded the claim in March 2021, and in July 2021 the AOJ issued a Supplemental Statement of the Case (SSOC) again denying the claim. See March 2021 Board Decision; July 2021 SSOC. The appeal was returned to the Board, which subsequently denied the claim. See December 2021 Board Decision. In March 2022, the denial was effectuated by the AOJ. See March 2022 Rating Decision. In an August 2022 Joint Motion for Partial Remand (JMPR), the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (Court) vacated and remanded the issue of entitlement to an initial rating in excess of 20 percent for lumbosacral strain disability. See August 2022 JMPR. The claim was subsequently returned to the Board. See August 2022 Board Letter. The Board remanded the claim and in a May 2023 rating decision the AOJ granted an increased disability rating of 40 percent for the Veteran's lumbosacral strain condition from January 25, 2023. See May 2023 Rating Decision. However, as the AOJ's decision represents a partial grant of the benefits sought on appeal for this issue, the claim is still considered to be in appellate status, and has returned to the Board. Thus, the Board has framed the issue on appeal as entitlement to a disability rating in excess of 20 percent for lumbosacral strain prior to January 25, 2023, and 40 percent for a lumbosacral spine disability thereafter. Entitlement to a disability rating of 40 percent, but no higher, for lumbosacral spine disability, from October 19, 2012, is granted. The Veteran contends that he is entitled to an initial disability rating in excess of 20 percent prior to January 25, 2023, and 40 percent for a lumbosacral spine disability thereafter. See June 2025 Informal Hearing Presentation. As an preliminary matter, the Board notes that the issue on appeal has been incorrectly defined as entitlement to an "initial" disability rating in past decisions, including the Court JMPR. The Board points to the procedural history, as detailed above, and finds that the issue is, instead, entitlement to a non-initial disability rating, as this appeal is not of the initial grant of service connection for a lumbosacral spine disability, but instead an appeal of a supplemental claim seeking an increased rating that was submitted after the initial grant of service connection became final. See Fenderson v. West, 12 Vet. App. 119 (1999). As such, the period on appeal does not stretch back to the initial claim filed in 2009, but instead begins with the October 2012 supplemental claim, and is subject to a one-year lookback prior to the filing of that supplemental claim. See Francisco v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 55, 58 (1994). Disability ratings are determined by evaluating the extent to which a Veteran's service-connected disability adversely affects his or her ability to function under the ordinary conditions of daily life, including employment, by comparing symptomatology with the criteria set forth in the Schedule for Rating Disabilities (Rating Schedule). 38 U.S.C. § 1155; 38 C.F.R. § 4.1. The Veteran is currently rated under Diagnostic Code 5243, after previous staged ratings under Diagnostic Code 5237 and 5242-5243. However, these diagnostic codes utilize the General Rating Formula for Diseases and Injuries of the Spine, which provides that a 10 percent rating is warranted when there is forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine greater than 60 degrees but not greater than 85 degrees; or forward flexion of the cervical spine greater than 30 degrees but not greater than 40 degrees; or combined range of motion of the thoracolumbar spine greater than 120 degrees but not greater than 235 degrees; or combined range of motion of the cervical spine greater than 170 degrees but not greater than 335 degrees; or muscle spasm, guarding, or localized tenderness not resulting in abnormal gait or abnormal spinal contour; or vertebral body fracture with loss of 50 percent or more of the height. 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a. A 20 percent rating is warranted when there is forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine greater than 30 degrees but not greater than 60 degrees; or combined range of motion of the thoracolumbar spine not greater than 120 degrees; or muscle spasm or guarding severe enough to result in an abnormal gait or abnormal spinal contour such as scoliosis, reversed lordosis, or abnormal kyphosis. Id. A 40 percent evaluation is warranted for forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine 30 degrees or less; or favorable ankylosis of the entire thoracolumbar spine. Id. A 50 percent evaluation is warranted when there is unfavorable ankylosis of the entire thoracolumbar spine; and a 100 percent evaluation is warranted when there is unfavorable ankylosis of the entire spine. Id. For VA purposes, normal forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine is 0 to 90 degrees, extension is 0 to 30 degrees, left and right lateral flexion are 0 to 30 degrees, and left and right lateral rotation are 0 to 30 degrees. Id. Additionally, the normal combined range of motion of the thoracolumbar spine is 240 degrees. 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, Diagnostic Code 5242 Note (2). Further, unfavorable ankylosis is a condition in which the entire cervical spine, the entire thoracolumbar spine, or the entire spine is fixed in flexion or extension, and the ankylosis results in one or more of the following: difficulty walking because of a limited line of vision; restricted opening of the mouth and chewing; breathing limited to diaphragmatic respiration; gastrointestinal symptoms due to pressure of the costal margin on the abdomen; dyspnea or dysphagia; atlantoaxial or cervical subluxation or dislocation; or neurologic symptoms due to nerve root stretching. Fixation of a spinal segment in neutral position (zero degrees) always represents favorable ankylosis. See 38 C.F.R. § 4.71a, General Rating Formula, Note (5). Lastly, the Board notes that while portions of the Rating Schedule addressing the musculoskeletal system were revised effective February 7, 2021, the changes to Diagnostic Code 5243 are not relevant as they do not apply to facts of the current matter. The Board turns now to an examination of the evidence. In evaluating that evidence, the Board has been charged with the duty to assess its credibility and weight. Davidson v. Shinseki, 581 F. 3d 1313 (Fed. Cir. 2009); Jandreau v. Nicholson, 492 F. 3d 1372 (Fed. Cir. 2007). Indeed, the Court has declared that in adjudicating a claim, the Board has the responsibility to do so. Bryan v. West, 13 Vet. App. 482, 488-89 (2000). The probative value of medical opinion evidence is based on the medical expert's personal examination of the patient, the physician's knowledge and skill in analyzing the data, and the medical conclusion that the physician reaches. Guerrieri v. Brown, 4 Vet. App. 467, 470-71 (1993). Whether a physician provides a basis for a medical opinion goes to the weight or credibility of the evidence in the adjudication of the merits. See Hernandez-Toyens v. West, 11 Vet. App. 379, 382 (1998). Other factors for assessing the probative value of a medical opinion are the physician's access to the claims folder and the thoroughness and detail of the opinion. See Prejean v. West, 13 Vet. App. 444, 448-49 (2000); Nieves-Rodriguez, 22 Vet. App. 295 (2008). Within the period on appeal, the Veteran has been afforded multiple VA examinations, however, both the Board and the Court have deemed all but one of these examinations, in whole or in part, as insufficient for adjudication purposes. Of note, most recently, the Board notes that in the August 2022 JMPR, the Court vacated and remanded the issue of entitlement to a disability rating in excess of 20 percent for lumbosacral strain to the Board. See August 2022 Court JMPR. The parties to the JMPR agreed that the Board erred in its December 2021 decision when it relied upon inadequate VA examinations from May 2017 and June 2021. See id. On remand, the Board was ordered to ensure than an adequate examination was provided "in satisfaction of the duty to assist, to include range of motion with and without weightbearing, determining at what point during range of motion pain results in functional loss," as well as in accordance with 38 C.F.R. § 4.59 and rulings in Mitchell, Sharp, and Correia. See id.; see also Mitchell v. Shinseki, 25 Vet. App. 32 (2011); Sharp v. Shulkin, 29 Vet. App. 26 (2017); Correia v. McDonald, 28 Vet. App. 158 (2016). The Board notes that, as evidenced below, there has been substantial compliance with the Court's remand directives. See Stegall v. West, 11 Vet. App. 268, 271 (1998). Following the Court remand, the Veteran was afforded a new VA examination in which the examiner provided range of motion testing and detailed other relevant lumbosacral strain indicators. See January 2023. In the examination, the Veteran's initial range of motion measurements were noted as abnormal, with active and passive forward flexion endpoint of 30 degrees, extension endpoint of 5 degrees, right lateral flexion endpoint of 25 degrees, as well as a left lateral flexion endpoint, right lateral rotation endpoint, and left lateral rotation endpoint each of 20 degrees. See January 2023 C&P Examination. Pain was exhibited on all but right lateral flexion for both active and passive range of motion. See id. Pain was also noted on weight-bearing, nonweight-bearing, active motion, passive motion, on rest, and on non-movement, and pain was noted as causing functional loss which the examiner indicated as an inability to sit for longer than 30 minutes, lift more than 20 pounds at a time, or bend over to pick up objects. See id. Furthermore, during the examination, there was no evidence of crepitus, however there was objective evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the back deemed moderately severe. See id. The Veteran was also noted as able to perform repetitive use testing, though he was not tested directly after three repetitions. See id. However, the examiner noted no additional loss of function or range of motion after three repetitions. See id. Nevertheless, the examiner noted that procured evidence suggested functional loss due to pain, fatigability, weakness, and lack of endurance after repeated use over time, and forward flexion endpoint was estimated at 25 degrees, extension endpoint at zero, right lateral flexion endpoint at 20, as well as left lateral flexion endpoint, right lateral rotation endpoint, and left lateral rotation endpoint each at 15 degrees. See id. Moreover, while not examined during a flare-up, the examiner noted that the procured evidence indicated that the Veteran experienced functional loss caused by pain, fatigability, weakness, and lack of endurance during flare-ups and estimated the Veteran's forward flexion endpoint at 20 degrees, extension endpoint at zero, right lateral flexion endpoint at 15, as well as left lateral flexion endpoint, right lateral rotation endpoint, and left lateral rotation endpoint each at 10 degrees. See id. The Veteran was noted as evidencing muscle spasm and guarding that resulted in abnormal gait or abnormal spinal contour, however his localized tenderness did not. See id. Furthermore, while the Veteran was diagnosed with Intervertebral Disc Syndrome (IVDS), he had no episodes of acute signs and symptoms due to that IVDS that required bed rest prescribed by a physician and treatment by a physician in the past 12 months. See id. Lastly, the examiner indicated that the Veteran's spine disability did not manifest in favorable or unfavorable ankylosis of any portion of the spine, inclusive of the functional equivalent of the same. See id. The Board notes that when there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence regarding any issue material to the determination of a matter, VA shall give the benefit of the doubt to the claimant. 38 U.S.C. § 5107(b); Gilbert v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 49, 57-58 (1990); 38 C.F.R. § 3.102. Thus, taking the range of motion endpoint most favorable to the Veteran, which is the estimated 20-degree forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine, the Board finds that Veteran is entitled to a 40 percent disability rating, as his lumbosacral spine disability is evidenced by a forward flexion of 30 degrees or less. However, entitlement to a disability rating in excess of 40 percent is not warranted as the Veteran's spine disability has not manifested in unfavorable ankylosis of the entire thoracolumbar spine or unfavorable ankylosis of the entire spine. Moreover, providing the benefit of doubt to the Veteran, and in recognition that a retroactive examination to determine the Veteran's range of motion is unlikely to provide a clearer disability picture, the Board finds that the January 2023 VA examination is sufficient for analyzing the severity of the Veteran's spine disability throughout the entire period on appeal. Accordingly, as evidenced in the complete, credible, and probative January 2023 examination, the Board finds that the Veteran's lumbosacral disability has manifested in forward flexion of the thoracolumbar spine 30 degrees or less from October 19, 2012, the date of the Veteran's non-initial increased rating claim and the earliest possible date that the Board finds the record evidences an increase in severity of the Veteran's condition to warrant the award of a 40 percent disability rating under Diagnostic Code 5242. See Gaston v. Shinseki, 605 F.3d 979 (Fed. Cir. 2010). This is a finding of fact by the Board. However, the evidence persuasively weighs against a finding that the Veteran's lumbar spine condition manifested in unfavorable ankylosis of the entire spine or entire thoracolumbar spine at any point during the period on appeal. Accordingly, entitlement to a disability rating of 40 percent, but no higher, for lumbosacral spine disability, from October 19, 2012, is granted. R. FEINBERG Veterans Law Judge Board of Veterans' Appeals Attorney for the Board C.W. Hall, Associate Counsel The Board's decision in this case is binding only with respect to the instant matter decided. This decision is not precedential and does not establish VA policies or interpretations of general applicability. 38 C.F.R. § 20.1303.